DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?

Eddie Guerrero vs. Rey Mysterio

Match

7.43
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 337
Number of comments: 67
10.0 2x
9.0 20x
8.0 119x
7.0 179x
6.0 16x
5.0 1x
4.0 0x
3.0 0x
2.0 0x
1.0 0x
0.0 0x
Average rating: 7.44  [337]
Average rating in 2026: 7.45  [51]
Average rating in 2025: 7.45  [67]
Average rating in 2024: 7.59  [64]
Average rating in 2023: 7.55  [55]
Average rating in 2022: 7.48  [29]
Average rating in 2021: 7.50  [16]
Average rating in 2020: 6.95  [21]
Average rating in 2019: 7.00  [7]
Average rating in 2018: 7.63  [8]
Average rating in 2017: 7.00  [13]
Average rating in 2016: 7.00  [6]
Your Options:
Other:
Leo the goat wrote on 13.11.2026:
[7.0] "A very solid, briskly paced 7/10 WrestleMania opener that delivered crisp technical and high-flying chemistry between two lifelong friends and rivals, even if it didn't quite reach the stratospheric heights of their Halloween Havoc 1997 classic. Stepping out as reigning WWE Tag Team Champions in front of a hot Staples Center crowd, Rey Mysterio and Eddie Guerrero worked a fluid, respectful 12-minute exhibition filled with slick chain counters, innovative reversals, and dynamic springboard offense. The only noticeable blemish was Rey constantly having to readjust his loose mask throughout the match, which slightly disrupted the rhythm of a few exchanges. Still, the closing stretch was sharp--culminating in Rey countering a Gory Special/powerbomb setup into a slick hurricanrana pinfall to pick up the clean win and plant the seeds for Eddie's simmering frustration and upcoming heel turn. Clean, lively, and a textbook curtain-jerker."
KSAHZ8 wrote on 24.09.2026:
[7.0] "Amazing WrestleMania opener, these two always had amazing matches together. I've always been a big fan of both guys. Fast paced match, but had a good story to it. Rey with the shock victory. I did have to deduct a point as Rey's mask kept slipping off throughout which was slightly distracting. A great final Mania match for Eddie."
Pedram 1384 wrote on 28.05.2026:
[7.0] "A great chemistry between these two great wrestlers but with a flat finish thank you Eddie thank you rey"
CodyPodlaskowski wrote on 21.04.2026:
[8.0] "Quite possibly maybe one of the best wrestlemania openers of all time two friends going at it and for the 1st time in wrestlemania history it was tag champ vs tag champ one on one! How exciting a story about who's the better man in the ring! These two showed off like only they could and it was so fun to watch the pacing and timing was unmatched, their in-ring chemistry together couldn't be touched IF YOU KNOW YOU KNOW another match I can watch over and over again and it won't get old!"
ReiEscobar wrote on 20.04.2026:
[8.0] "Eddie Guerrero and Rey Mysterio always had great chemistry and that night wasn't anything different. It was short, their purposes was to pop up the crowd to hype the shit out of them, kinda poetic that Eddie's last WrestleMania ever was against his best friend."
Cardomillo wrote on 11.04.2026:
[7.0] "Cool little match to start things up. High spots, fast action and a generally good match. The end of the match came as a surprise."
PinkMephisto wrote on 03.04.2026:
[7.0] "I'm not sure why I remember this being something like 4+ star material from my first watch a few years back but a great way to kick off this show all the same with good concise action between two perpetually over acts; like other commenters have said, the floor is just high for these two, even if this kind of feels like it *is* the floor for an Eddie/Rey PPV match. Eddie working more heelish and being gnawed by his inability to put Rey away is a nice simple story. [***1/2]"
THE BRAZILIAN PAUL HEYMAN GUY wrote on 03.04.2026:
[8.0] "That was a masterclass in flexibility. Eddie Guerrero never disappoints, in his sadly final Wrestlemania. Rey Mysterio's performance was also impeccable. Both deserve praise. What a match! (12:22)"
WG20 wrote on 31.03.2026:
[8.0] "A great opener from these two with phenomenal chemistry. The action throughout was fast paced and high impact."
SkyIcons wrote on 02.03.2026:
[8.0] "This is what I believe an opener should be. High impact, fast action. Great stuff from Rey and Eddie here."
TrailsOfPersona wrote on 09.02.2026:
[7.0] "I'm always a tiny bit conflicted when it comes to this match because it is a bit to choreographed for my taste. Even so, it still winds up being an absolutely excellent contest. They mix in a bit of everything. A bit of mat wrestling, a bit of lucha balancing moves, high flying, submissions...they just touch it all. The near falls leave you on the edge of your seat and they plant the seeds of Eddie's eventual heel turn well. While this one maybe didn't QUITE live up to the super high standards that were placed on it, it is still fantastic."
EyeBronze8388 wrote on 01.02.2026:
[7.0] "Great way to start the show although it was not the Hart/Hart match like I thought it could be. The focus of the match was Guerrero working on Mysterio's back and being frustrated because he couldn't put him away. Then Mysterio was able to pin him, which set up the feud because Eddie was mad that he couldn't beat Rey. Eddie turned heel after this and they involved Rey's son in the feud in an over the top custody storyline. I didn't love the storyline, but I loved every match these two had with eachother. Their best match ever is WCW Halloween Havoc 1997. I highly recommend that one. Sadly, this was the last WrestleMania that Eddie Guerrero would participate in because he would die later in 2005. Rest in peace, Eddie."
Jonny Dubya wrote on 24.01.2026:
[7.0] "This was a really good match. And in an unsurprising trend, a great opener. And also unsurprisingly, another great match between Rey & Eddie."
DecentWrestling wrote on 17.12.2025:
[8.0] "Eddie controls the match but Rey knows him so well and despite being overpowered, every time he manages to reverse or mount a small comeback before being cut off. Frustrating Eddie more. It really is a fantastic little match here with a great story and pace. Eddie's desperation and growing frustration plays out well and serves to plant seeds going forward as well. Perfect opening match."
Sweet Fighter V wrote on 16.10.2025:
[8.0] "For these two to have a WrestleMania match and deliver a SmackDown worthy match is certainly disappointing. It's not bad at all, it's actually good, it's just that they treated us with even better matches on SmackDown, and I thought this would deliver something more epic. Anyway, it's cool to have them on such a big stage, the action is nice as always, the storytelling is good, the crowd is into it, and Rey further cementing himself as Eddie's kryptonite is great. ***3/4"
Brye wrote on 03.10.2025:
[7.0] "A very good match but also maybe not even in the top 10 matches that Eddie and Rey have had against each other. That being said, I'm glad they got to have a match with each other at Wrestlemania and it was still a lot of fun."
sdenapoli wrote on 24.09.2025:
[8.0] "While it was no Halloween Havoc '97, this was still a really fun match that the crowd was really into. Rey and Eddie had great chemistry, even when they were both babyfaces. While this was the start of the Eddie/Rey feud, it was still great. A good way for Eddie to go out at Mania."
EmoForkliftDriver wrote on 24.08.2025:
[7.0] "Really good opener. Eddie Guerrero and Rey Mysterio are curse by their own talent so whenever they shared a ring they had a high bar to reach. As great as this is it's not even my second favorite match of theirs, they've even had better matches on an episode of Smackdown in 2002. What this match does do well is tell a story and it's nice and simple. Eddie wrestles the heel here, showing a lot more methodical groundwork than he usually would, allowing Mysterio to be the clearly more "exciting" performer. This was the build to their feud and told the story of Eddie not being able to get the better of his tag team partner down to the finish where Rey gets the upset victory. Again it's no Halloween Havoc but I don't think these two could have a bad match"
D00M DR0P wrote on 03.06.2025:
"Solid Wrestlemania opener. Both guys at their prime doing what they do best. Fairly short and to the point, and ultimately overshadowed by other matches on the card, but sets the tone for what will be a great event. (***1/4)(7.5/10)"
KKeanel wrote on 26.04.2025:
[8.0] "It couldn't be any other pick for an opener and both guys delivered a high-tier kick off. Really solid Eddie's Wrestlemania farewell."
chromehearttags wrote on 26.03.2025:
[7.0] "Really fun opener. All the counters and reversals were a surprise but made sense from tag champs and wrestlers with as much history as these two. 7.5/10"
ShaliK wrote on 19.03.2025:
[8.0] "A classic that I love to watch. Both wrestlers are at each other's throats throughout the match, and the counters are superb. I love the last two minutes. (4*)"
bigredtalk89 wrote on 17.03.2025:
[8.0] "Fun opener, one of the better one's in Mania history, though not one of the better matches between the 2, they still know how to work a great match against each other and this is a fine first match in what would become a wild program"
brooksavage2004 wrote on 11.02.2025:
[9.0] "Rey and Eddie always have incredible chemistry between themselves every time they fight against each other, even when they were tag champions together, they had a really amazing and entertaining match between each other and it will serve a purpose for their 2005 rivalry later on."
JohnAbbaRiley wrote on 01.12.2024:
[7.0] "A fun match. Eddie and Rey have really good chemistry but what hurt the match for me is the constant adjusting of the mask by Rey. Otherwise a fun Mania opener"
JoeyBingBong wrote on 26.11.2024:
[8.0] "Delightful match, even with Rey continually battling his mask. As usual, their chemistry is sparkling, producing some fabulous action over the somewhat modest runtime. Even with those limitations, it's a fitting big room opening match, finding thrills befitting the WrestleMania stage. It's certainly not their best match, basically serving as a setup for the pair's actual feud, yet the work is strong enough to make it an incredibly worthy addition to their series. ***3/4"
sverkhchelovek wrote on 18.10.2024:
[7.0] "Incredible chemistry, amazing execution of every move, fantastic speed and pace. The only flaw is the ending came out kinda nowhere. I would like watch like to watch another 10 minutes of this."
RealGrapsThomsen wrote on 02.08.2024:
[7.0] "This was a decent match that showed the respect. The two werent given a lot of time so they didnt waste a second. The counters, the action, all of it was epic. Rey won the match and they shook hands after."
JacquesRougeauCanHaveMyWife wrote on 26.06.2024:
[7.0] "Great pace, great structure and an interesting story told. They could have easily gone for some nonsensical high flying bullshit, but especially Eddie was such a pro that he knew he had to slow down and wrestle a bit more like a heel. Even though he was friends with Rey he wanted to prove that he was the better man and he showed his emotions perfectly here, while being a little more intense and less showy than usual."
mxkami wrote on 18.06.2024:
[6.0] "Eddie is my all time favorite. Rey is a god. This match doesn't hit for me like it does others. Eddie's heat spots with Rey always bore me to death."
drexeldragon1723 wrote on 08.05.2024:
[9.0] "This match made me a wrestling fan. I picked up the WrestleMania 21 DVD at Best Buy back in the day. It was on a whim and I had no idea what it even was. Luckily for me, my first experience with pro-wrestling was to watch Eddie Guerrero and Rey Mysterio work a match... could've done worse. I was immediately hooked. The rest, as they say, is history. Apart from the sentimental value here, I just tink this is an awesome match. Might be the second best Mania opener ever after Bret vs Owen."
birds123 wrote on 26.03.2024:
[10.0] "One of my favorite WrestleMania matches ever, and one of the most underrated WrestleMania matches ever. This was a sprint if Ive ever seen one. Rey and Eddie on the grand stage and they both go out there and tear the house down. Top 3 WrestleMania openers ever."
Connorstubbs12 wrote on 11.03.2024:
[8.0] "two of the best Cruiserweights opening the show with a small banger which leaves to their last big feud. Rey Mysterio was elite"
crs285 wrote on 03.12.2023:
[8.0] "Liked this match a lot. This was not Eddie's and Rey's best match against each other but any time they met it was a good match. Crowd was split between the two."
Ruthless Attitude wrote on 15.11.2023:
[8.0] "There's a few misshaps with Rey Mysterio's mask in this one which was a little bit distracting, but it's still a very high quality match. Eddie's style where he grounds his opponents and works in a lot of submissions in this match was very different to what I've been used to seeing from him, but it was very effective match to watch and it made for a good clash of styles, particularly in a back and forth contest like this where Rey's speed and offense is explosive and Eddie's countering looked great. I liked the finish as well, which was actually a call back to the ending of their Halloween Havoc 97 clash where he catches Eddie out with a Hurricanrana pin. This isn't their best clash, but I enjoyed it a lot."
Heartbreakkid2003 wrote on 14.09.2023:
[8.0] "4/5 stars Very underrated mania Opener between 2 guys who know each other so well This match served as the start of their memorable 2005 feud and is Eddies last real feud and this marks the rise of Rey mysterio as a main eventer Super fun and enjoyable match highly recommend if you havent watched it before"
eenfish69 wrote on 01.09.2023:
[8.0] "Great solid work by two of the best. Not as good as some of their previous stuff from the 90s, and Eddie in particular looks a lot slower and not quite as smooth, but his crowd work and charisma is eternal. A few minor faults here and there, but overall an extremely solid manes opener and entertaining and engaging throughout."
lukasmgc wrote on 23.05.2023:
[8.0] "How did Dave give this 3 1/4 stars. This match was great. The only thing that stops me from giving it a ten is the fact Eddie repeated the three amigos a ridiculous amount of times and some of the submissions he did looked sloppy and he botched one a few times. Other than that, this match is a really good match."
KingsCrossing wrote on 08.04.2023:
[8.0] "It definitely isn't their best match together (it's one of their weakest, in fact) but the floor is so high with these two that it is still very good. A lot of their offence looks great and there are some pretty fun sequences. The two are obviously very comfortable working with each other. Rey's mask clearly causes him issues as he can't keep it on straight and Eddie is a bit uncharacteristically flat and lacking in his usual emotion (perhaps just playing up to the story but it didn't really come across that way? ) but this was still a good match and better than I remembered. It's probably a low end 8.0 but I'd say they did just enough to edge out that rating."
GM56 Champion wrote on 20.03.2023:
[10.0] "What was Meltzer smoking when rating this match? Rey correcting his mask all the time was annoying, but the in-ring action? Man, very technical and mostly very smooth moves. Even though it has a few botches and lasts about 12 minutes, that's probably the best match of theirs I've ever watched and the most underrated match I've ever watched."
Prince Osborne wrote on 08.03.2023:
[8.0] "The reason for this match being the underrated one in their series is because of not one, but three different reasons in my opinion: lack of an intense arc, an almost good length and the finish most importantly. Nonetheless, both had the fans adrenaline pump up to an all-time high through their exhilarating action that spilled all over the ring. It was wild to see these mavericks of the high-flying genre blast the fireworks for the rest of the night. Even though there were extremely better matches after this, Im glued to this one as my personal pick for the top three listing. 3.75 out of 5 stars!"
Dcarter1153 wrote on 12.02.2023:
[7.0] "The match was going great but WHY WOULD U END A MANIA MATCH BETWEEN THESE TWO WITH A FUCKING ROLLUP? ! what a joke"
zachattack2023 wrote on 04.12.2022:
[8.0] "This is a really fun opener that was really fast pace and high flying it was a really solid start to wrestlemania.****"
GonzoAppreciator wrote on 26.09.2022:
[8.0] "One of the best Mania openers in the event's history. Mysterio and Eddie produced yet another great great match with each other and Eddie once again did a fantastic job putting Mysterio over."
TSwifty wrote on 12.07.2022:
[7.0] "This wasn't close to the best matches of Eddie/Rey. They've had amazing matches together, but this one was just good. That's all it needed to be to further their story along. Eddie worked on top for most of the match. His work over Rey's back was really good. Eddie had some of the best backbreakers in the business. Rey's comebacks had the right amount of technique and energy. Very smooth transition into the finishing pinfall as well. ***1/4"
flightaker321 wrote on 13.03.2022:
[7.0] "A perfectly fine opener between Eddie and Rey. Not these two best matches but I appreciated the back and forth action between Rey and Eddie. Of course, we got some impressive-looking spots between the two of them. Eddie's work on the back of Rey was good. An overall solid start to their story that would continue to build***1/2"
4outof5 wrote on 23.01.2022:
[7.0] "This was good but a bit disappointing given their history and the big stage it was on. Not much drama and the match is supported purely by the respect and love of the two wrestlers."
KENTAfan wrote on 06.10.2021:
[7.0] "This was a great way to open a Mania, just a fun back and forth between the always impressive Eddie and Rey. Lots of aerobic displays as you would expect, as well as some great technical wrestling at times. Crowd was super into it and in the end Rey actually managed to win with a roll up. There were a few periodic botches, but all in all good stuff. ***1/2"
Brayan wrote on 09.07.2021:
[8.0] "A blistering pace to a match that helped set the tone for a great WrestleMania. One of my personal favorites and one of the best Mania openers. Guerrero and Mysterio always found ways to reimagine past battles and enhance the overarching story. With Guerrero doubting his own ability to defeat Mysterio, his partner as Tag Team Champion, an intriguing story played out here. 4 stars, 8/10."
KingofKings5632 wrote on 02.07.2021:
[7.0] "Upon rewatching Wrestlemania 21, I forgot this match even happened. After rewatching, I can tell why. This wasn't bad per se, but it is definitely one of the weaker matches in these guy's storied rivalry. Eddie shined here in the character department and Rey brought some cool moves, but there wasn't enough time or a story to really make something great. As an initial chapter to the reigniting of the feud though, it wasn't bad. Somebody help Rey with his mask though."