[8.0] "A personal build of fury, an intriguing war of factions, and a wake-up call for one of those to bring what they lost - momentum! It's a fantastic story that took months to carve into an almost barbaric culmination. The reason for being 'almost' is because of these men and their subtlety with the weaponry as the clock ticked. It was Uno & Stu that brought the story and the match to the spotlight, where Silver/Dutch handled the crowd with witty power & Reynolds/Vincent as solid underhands. The ending wasn't the best way to close out an intense rivalry, but it was still effective. 4 out of 5 stars!"
[6.0] "Oh, it's a hardcore match. It's so brutal and engaging. Look, when it comes to anything-goes matches (outside of WWE, where it means very little these days), I'm generally more generous than most. So, when a match such as this comes up, when I say it was mediocre, that basically means to the vast majority of fans, it's probably garbage."
[8.0] "A solid hardcore trios match elevated by a personal story between Uno & Grayson. SSB were a team for so long that Stu splitting off from Uno and Dark Order is a big deal and despite the lighter tone of this match they made that out as such when those two were going at it. Vincent and Reynolds are both extremely mediocre but Uno & Stu really brought it while DUTCH & Silver rule as usual with their power moves. Legos being the level above thumb tacks was a fun moment and the finish with Stu truly being excommunicated from Dark Order by the remaining members working together was good stuff. ****"
[8.0] "They went to the plunder from the get-go & maintained a high violence ceiling throughout. This was reminiscent of the better Guerrilla Warfare matches ****"
[10.0] "Definitely the surprise hit of the night. As someone who has mostly lost interest in the ROH weekly show I was only vaguely aware of the storyline between these groups, but a mix of good talent and good reviews caused me to check this match out anyway. I'm really glad I did, because clearly they got the green light to go all out and not hold anything back in this one! Brutal right from the start, with a table spot in the first minute, it never seemed to lose steam as the stakes raised higher and higher with each weapon produced, from tacks to legos to barbed wire to ladders and more. And yet it was never a pure spotfest, there was a real feeling that there was something to prove in this match, some real animosity and hurt that had to be resolved through violence so it would no longer fester. Big hit match for me, loved it. More good stuff for everyone involved please."
[7.0] "Good brawl! Nothing bad for sure. Some huge spots that were a lot of fun. I don't watch the weekly tv so I was not really sure what the story was going into it but I enjoyed it a lot."
[5.0] "Not bad but not a match for me. This was filled with underwhelming weapon/prop spots and messy-brawling, with the end result being a completely mediocre hardcore match that offered nothing new and did very little in even a mildly exciting manner. I can't imagine still caring about the Dark Order in 2023, let alone ever, but if you did then you may've been more invested in the story of Grayson versus his old partners. For me, I didn't care going in and was relying on the wrestlers to invest me in that struggle here. The result? I probably cared even less, because there was absolutely nothing interesting in the interactions between Grayson and his old partners. It didn't help that Grayson and Uno opened the match with some weak forearms and then a lame table bump, which was immediately followed up by Dutch and Silver wielding their respective 2x4s in very hokey fashion. The streak remained for the rest of the match, since almost all their hardcore spots ended up looking pretty weak, and they definitely weren't aided by the total lack of intensity and speed with which they were performed by everyone. It was always clear that everyone was just being careful to protect each other at every step, and what was worse was that with their slightly more believable hardcore spots you could often see the wrestlers spot-calling and checking on their so-called opponents to confirm that they were okay, which further tarnished the match's illusion of competition. The only 2 spots that actually looked good were: (1) the thumbtacks, just because you can't fake the skin-piercing nature of those spots, though even they were underwhelming because tacks are so overdone at this point, even occurring the same week at AEWs Blood and Guts; and (2) the big bump off the ladder through the tables at the very end, which still isn't very creative but at least deserves props because of how spectacular and dangerous it is. If not for those few spots I would've considered this a plain bad match, since nothing else was remotely interesting. Also, being expected to buy into Uno -- perhaps the slobbiest major US wrestler on the scene right now -- is an automatic no-go. Again, not a match for me, though I at least wouldn't say it was actively bad. **1/2"
[5.0] "This match relied so heavily on the fans caring about it going in. A very bog standard six-man match with hardcore spots, but somehow minus the hectic pace that suggests which would've kept my attention better."
[7.0] "A very solid-to-good bloodfeud/hardcore blowoff match hamstrung a bit by the fact that the Dark Order guys (Stu included here) outclass the Righteous in basically every possible way, down to Stu even having to clean up a table spot that Vincent botched. Hey, at least Dutch is pretty good at getting color."
[5.0] "These types of matches aren't really my preference a lot of crazy bumps. Wasn't really into the lego spot but the rest of the crowd was. Didn't think I'd see a blackhole slam into thumbtacks again!"
[10.0] "When extreme rules is used correctly in a good storyline and not often on the shows it makes a no rules match feel so much more exciting, this was just sensational EVIL UNO outdid himself so much on this match and the storytelling was amazing a sensational match and the match of the night in my opinion simply 10/10"
[8.0] "This match went from brutal to goofy in minutes, the spotfest on the card turned out to be really fun and had good spots, some didn't work out so well but nothing that spoiled the match which was pretty cool (****1/4)"
[7.0] "I actually didn't know about the Dark Order drama beforehand so seeing them fight Stu was a surprise and probably made this the most enjoyable match of the night for me in addition to the crazy spots."
[7.0] "I think it's okay that this was a bit goofy despite the tension between Stu and Dark Order, since Dark Order are goofy by nature. They had a fun plunder match. Next PPV they could do it for the trios titles."
[9.0] "Much like the Four-Way Tag earlier, this was also an insane car crash.but in a completely different way. That was a brutal, vicious war that had all the great elements of awesome plunder and hardcore fights."
[8.0] "I am rating this without knowing the story beyond that I know Stu and Uno were career-long road buddies coming out of Quebec, and I am familiar with how Reynolds and Silver joined the Dark Order, but I was not aware of the impetus of the turn I guess. But I trust it was good. The spots were mostly brutal but made sense. A feel-good win for Dark Order. My only criticisms would be technical, but not for lack of effort. Grayson was the MVP."
[8.0] "This was really fun and also maybe the only match on the card with any real concentrated build. Probably the best thing Dark Order has been involved with in at least a year?"
"Another incredible match in this show. Both these teams put an incredible match with brutal and violent spots. The interactions between Uno and Grayson added a lot to this match specially the ladder spot and the finish. Great match (****1/4)"
[9.0] "I wasn't expecting much of this match, and boy, I was pleasantly surprised. The Righteous shone like I've never saw before. Stu had some good moments, and the Dark Order felt like a strong unit for the first time in a while. Good wrestling, with violence and some nice comedy (Uno with the legos was great). I just have picked The Righteous and Stu to won, they could use the momentum there to go after the ROH World Six Man Tag Team Title."
[8.0] "Great Fight Without Honor. Exactly as this type of match should be, no BS, high intensity, plenty of brutal spots and weapons, violent from start to finish. Very very good"
[6.0] "Stu's table bump was hilarious. The lego, and barbed wire table were cool, but overall weren't as violent as i'd expect from essentially a deathmatch."
[5.0] "Perfectly fine plunder brawl. None of the characters got me invested and it didn't seem to know if it wanted to be goofy violence with legos or the culmination of Grayson breaking the hearts of the Dark Order and that held it back"
[8.0] "Real fun plunder brawl. I don't care about any of these guys nor is this my favorite match type but they managed to have something compelling and got the crowd very involved. Good stuff."
[9.0] "Really fun Fight without Honor. They used a lot of weapons, including the thumbtacks, the legos, the barbed wire stick and a barbed wire table. The last table spot was brutal and with some minutes more I'd rated this match higher without a doubt. ****1/2"
[8.0] "Very interesting stipulation trios match right here between Dark Order and The Righteous which was a match that looked bland on paper without the stipulation but giving them these Fight Without Honor rules was surely the best thing the company could have done, as it changed everything and interest soared as soon as the bell rang, everyone went to war for fifteen minutes and it was a blast to watch. To pull off such a crazy match with so little story, I give them credit for that and also to Tony Khan because this match was finally a good idea."
[9.0] "Hot Damn! This is what Dark Order can do if you give them the build and platform. Stu is a psycho and fell off the world's tallest ladder, but that was just the peak of an insanely violent match that I hope propels Dark Order to an edgier version that is ready to take the heel position against the Hung Bucks."
[8.0] "These guys go absolutely crazy for no reason other than to remind everybody how awesome they are given time and attention. Hopefully they remain a permanent fixture on ROH programming -- as opposed to Dynamite, where they feel merely intrusive. A match with genuine sense of pure joy, story and flow. Minor complaints: pretty formless for a match, even a streetfight-style but engaging beginning to end."