[6.0] "By performance, it wasn't the best outing, but it was the character-oriented work that entertained the fans. It's pretty much what has to be expected from Castle who's a solid in-ring hand with lots of charisma and he did his job as the challenger very well. Joe's antics with Stokely were nicely covered up to bring a dirty win in his books, but if we look through the caliber, he doesn't even need it in the first place. 3 out of 5 stars!"
[7.0] "I enjoyed this plenty enough. You know what you are getting with Dalton Castle in 2023 which is plenty of shtick. I enjoyed my time with it and the crowd were well up for it. It is not a work rate classic by any stretch of the imagination but I had a fun time"
[7.0] "This match was mostly shtick which is an unfortunate reality for post-back injury Dalton, but his charisma (and Joe's) can carry a pretty standard match. When there is some wrestling the power moves are always good, and what shtick there was just works because that's how good Castle's gimmick is; The Boys deserve a lot of credit for how much they add to Castle's matches as well. Very enjoyable if not all that memorable; there's a version of this match that is excellent if the stars align. ***1/4"
[6.0] "Kind of a by the numbers match between Joe and Castle, but both guys are so good that their baseline is still worth your time, but it is not worth going out of your way to see it. Highlight for me was Castle's apronrana to Joe. Stokely-Joe connection is an interesting development. I'm curious to see who is going to get the big rub from beating Samoa Joe for this ROH TV Title, and whether it will happen on ROH TV, ROH PPV, or AEW Collision."
[8.0] "This is just plain fun, Dalton has never felt more over as a solo competitor but they also make sure to get in all those Boys spots that audiences love. Joe is brutal, Stokely remains the best non-wrestling talent in AEW-ROH, and the story told is a blast."
[3.0] "It was just disgusting. Nothing happened during the whole match. We just watch Samoa Joe doing something once a minute, and he was exhausted already on the third, and there was literally one Dalton comeback, although its hard to call it a comeback. Also, the ending is the worst. Worst match on the show, even with zero hour."
[6.0] "A good match, not as the rating says. Joe did his monster's job at the beginning, then Dalton got the upper hand and did some very impressive suplexes. The finishing sequence was good, bringing forward the story between Joe and Hathaway. So yeah, I'd say promoted."
[7.0] "Way better than the rating. Dalton and Joe "work around each other" given the miles and injuries but you really wouldn't notice it unless you were looking for it. Masterful character work from both guys, doing it in totally different ways. An acceptable time for a fuck finish as this card wasn't really full of them."
[4.0] "I would've liked to have seen Dalton Castle win the title here because I think he's the only one that could actually make it standout. That's nothing against Joe but he seems above it and like it's a just a token prize. The match itself didn't really offer much."
[5.0] "DC didn't stand a chance but he's a fun character for Joe to run through till they find someone to take the title off of him. I'm pretty sure both guys are permanently banged up at this point, so this was fine considering that."
[5.0] "I love both Joe and Dalton but this was just ok. Joe's title reign has been dominant and Dalton's probably not the one you want see end it, even though he should be holding some gold sooner rather than later."
[5.0] "I found this fight entertaining but not as good as I thought it would be, obviously Joe was going to win so they had to do something flashy or interesting, but it's not that big of a deal either."
[7.0] "I enjoyed the match. Castle is great on the ring and have a gigantic charisma. Joe always look like a menace in the ring. They chemistry could be bigger, but still was very entertaining."
"Even though this match started slow, it started to get better over time, but it never did it for me. The finish made sense as they want to develop more the Stoke and Joe relationship (***)"
[7.0] "I loved this brawl between Joe and Castle, it was very very cool. The spots with the Tate Boys were funny and the finish very clever with the Hattaway angle advancing."
[5.0] "Joe is still great but this match just never really clicked. The suplex spots from Dalton to Joe were great but overall the match was just super slow and never flowed well, and all the stuff with The Boys was really unnecessary and distracting."
[6.0] "Despite the lack of buildup for this bout, Castle felt like a legitimate threat to the title and they told a solid story. The wrestling was perfectly fine here, but the finish was.meh. This is a TV show finishing angle. The finish could have been more decisive."