DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?

Shawn Michaels vs. Tatanka

Match

5.90
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 257
Number of comments: 66
10.0 2x
9.0 0x
8.0 7x
7.0 61x
6.0 105x
5.0 63x
4.0 13x
3.0 4x
2.0 2x
1.0 0x
0.0 0x
Average rating: 5.90  [257]
Average rating in 2026: 5.74  [39]
Average rating in 2025: 5.86  [50]
Average rating in 2024: 5.69  [45]
Average rating in 2023: 6.28  [29]
Average rating in 2022: 5.86  [14]
Average rating in 2021: 5.67  [15]
Average rating in 2020: 5.80  [15]
Average rating in 2019: 5.25  [8]
Average rating in 2018: 6.14  [7]
Average rating in 2017: 5.33  [3]
Average rating in 2016: 6.13  [8]
Average rating in 2015: 7.40  [5]
Average rating in 2014: 6.20  [5]
Average rating in 2013: 6.00  [6]
Average rating in 2010: 7.00  [2]
Average rating in 2009: 6.00  [1]
Average rating in 2008: 6.60  [5]
Your Options:
Other:
EmoForkliftDriver wrote on 08.07.2026:
[6.0] "A fine match but very much a one man show. I don't dislike Tatanka but I didn't really enjoy anything he brought to the table here as he very much relied on Shawn Michaels making him look good. Luckily HBK is very good at making people look good as he bumps like a boss for Tatanka, far more than I was expecting him to. Michaels has a fun moment of reaching for Tatanka's hair without the ref knowing but you kinda gotta ignore that HBK has full use of his legs in this situation. HBK gets disqualified for dragging the ref out of the ring but Howard Finkel calls it as a countout for some reason and the faces celebrate as if they didn't just get screwed out of the Intercontinental Championship so they look really stupid. The match is also far too long to not have a definitive winner if you ask me"
UltimateClaw wrote on 27.04.2026:
[7.0] "Some valid criticism the finish is wonky and the match is maybe a little long but I don't think it particularly Dragged. Some solid action throughout with Tatanka having one of his best singles performances in his career. Shawn was bumping his ass off like usual and flying all over the ring and on to the outside. On a show that has no great matches I think this one stands out as the most watchable. Bonus points for how over Sherri was and the stuff with Luna was well handled."
LuminousPink wrote on 15.04.2026:
[3.0] "Honestly, not bad considering the show it's on. Just far too long and slow without much going on to keep it interesting. Ridiculously stupid finish though, never before have I seen a count-out finish happen AFTER both wrestlers get back in the ring, a move is done, and a pinfall is attempted."
WG20 wrote on 14.03.2026:
[4.0] "This match was fine good action between the HBK and Tatanka however in my opinion it was far too long and the finish was poor to start off Wrestlemania"
SebasDiaz wrote on 18.02.2026:
[5.0] "Like every opener, but here with some more points like a longer match, and better level in ring, since here was the real begining of the New Generation Era, the match had boring moments, and I didn't feel moved at all. 5/10 [***1/4]"
Smi-48 wrote on 15.02.2026:
[5.0] "Solid craftsmanship, but rather unsatisfactory in terms of the finish, considering the consequences. Tatanka is still undefeated and will lose for the first time in the fall to Ludvig Borga, while Michaels will also lose the title late in the year. However, the feud is not continued afterwards, and the story with Sherri and Luna will not mentioned again. So why this strange ending? It keeps both of them unscathed without taking advantage of it. The match is okay, offers appealing technique as an opener, and introduces the very unique atmosphere of the event. Sherri and Luna, on the other hand, are quite annoying, so I don't have to praise the match to the skies. Five points is fair."
w1shyouthebest wrote on 07.02.2026:
[8.0] "shawn michaels is so good man. on a very mediocre show he manages to steal it in the opening match, tatanka isnt half bad here either, a really great wrestlemania opening match for a...dissapointing mania"
Itayboi wrote on 29.12.2025:
[3.0] "there are very very few things in this match that deserve praise and i will start with them, shawn bumps like a boss the whole match long, and they hit a nice powerslm couter to a cross body, and some of tatanka's move to look quite good, i also have a soft spot of his hulking up. but the match was o verry slow and boring for the most of it and when it started to look like it might get good it was over. a not small out of time in this match is spent with tatanka (the face) working on shwan's (the heel) arm wich is booring as sin. the beigest issue was that the match felt like it was just a bunch of boring spots linked toghter by rest hold with no through line, the arm work was forgotten about, sherrri and luna did nothing and it all finished in a DQ. not the worst match ever but a one that really makes me wana sleep"
RemyLeBeau wrote on 17.12.2025:
[10.0] "So I think a lot of people will think I am crazy for a rating of this match as a 10 but you first need to understand that this is the first match I ever watch. When little I was given a WrestleMania 9 VHS and I have not looked back since. Truly I think if i was unbiased I would actually give this an 8 because besides from the DQ it is an prefect example of this era of wrestling. This honestly is most likely the greatest match of Tatanka's Career. Shawn was amazing in this match. Just perfect wrestling to a little kid"
LordRhys wrote on 03.12.2025:
[5.0] "Man, that was a screwy finish. Right as I thought the match really went up a gear, we're met with a cheap DQ finish with Michaels being counted out by the ref after dragging him out the ring. Tatanka wins but no belt switch is made. The crowd got really hot towards the end, and it seemed liked it was setting up for something greater after a bit of a slow start. Shawn Michaels worked a good match out of Tatanka. I find Tatanka to be a bit lacking generally and I thought the same here. His timings were a little off, his in-ring psychology was poor, and it's crazy how weak his holds look. Nevertheless I thought Shawn's selling really built up Tatanka as a true threat throughout the match. Shawn Michael's, the bumps, his speed and in-ring psychology, all very good and a nice glimpse of the Shawn Michaels WrestleMania magic we will see get better and better in the years to come. All in all, a slow start that suddenly built into something promising, only to cut off by a poor DQ finish."
SkyIcons wrote on 22.11.2025:
[5.0] "18 minutes for an unbelievably confusing finish in the opening match of wrestlemania is just insane. Shawn's bumping is really the only highlight here."
niclaswrestling wrote on 14.04.2025:
[5.0] "A good opener that not only went on a little bit too long, but was once more heavily damaged by a bad finish. HOW MANY MORE COUNT OUTS AND DQ's IN THESE EARLY MANIAS? Match is good, and one of the few highlights of the night."
JoeyBingBong wrote on 14.04.2025:
[6.0] "Stretched noticeably thin at 18 minutes, this is a decent but uneven opener, particular considering its eventual finish. Even with the bloat, these two do some nice stuff, mostly clicking outside of some occasional clumsiness. Luna and Sherri's presence helps too, but this just too much time, actively detracting from what could've been a very strong way to start the show. **3/4"
KingsCrossing wrote on 23.02.2025:
[6.0] "The finish leaves such a sour taste in your mouth (particularly for WrestleMania) that I find it a little difficult to go any higher on my rating, but for the most part this is a pretty solid match. Shawn takes a couple of big bumps and there are a couple nice moments of creativity like the moment where Shawn slams his face in to the apron when he misses a dive. Tatanka working over the arm helped to give the body of the match some focus, but I thought he could have used a little more emotion and intensity while attacking the limb. There were periods where the match was perhaps a little on the slow side as I don't think they really needed 18 minutes here, but if you ignore the very lame finish then this isn't a bad opener at all."
fablezzzz wrote on 14.02.2025:
[2.0] "I never in my life thought I'd see the day where I watched a bad Shawn Michaels match, but here it is. Shawn seemed uninterested and almost like he didn't want to put Tatanka over on anything, which wouldn't surprise me. Why are they outside of the ring bs'ing around almost the entire match? Why is everything directionless? Very frustrating match."
CMFunk007 wrote on 26.09.2024:
[7.0] "I actually quite enjoyed this one. This may have been Tatanka's best match, but it is hard to have a bad one with Shawn Michaels, even at this stage of his career. This marked the debut of Luna Vachon as well. Sherri and Luna had a fun feud before Sherri departed the company."
dangfoolian wrote on 21.09.2024:
[4.0] "A match that had potential, but the need to protect Tatanka's winning streak (that went nowhere, thanks Ludvig Borga), and keeping the belt on Shawn made it just flat. A "meh" match that leads off a crappy PPV."
UltraMark1 wrote on 16.07.2024:
[3.0] "An ok match but between two good competitors but the ending for sure dropped it down a rating for me as they wanted to protect both tatanka unbeaten streak and didn't want Shawn michaels to lose the belt so it was a lose lose situation in the end so 3/10"
Johan wrote on 04.07.2024:
[3.0] "far too slow for your Shawn Michaels match, some fun spots , horrendous ending, I won't say psychology is anything special here and there is no crowd connection, basic match really, twenty minutes is also a bit much for Shawn at this point who is really just a very good bumper and showman but has a very weak and boring offense. Minusing some points, you can't have this match on Wrestlemania. (**)"
SethHardy8 wrote on 08.05.2024:
[2.0] "a very slow fight and even more so considering that Shawn Michaels was participating. The ending ruins the quality of the combat even more."
VileVirgil wrote on 13.02.2024:
[6.0] "A really good match that is burdened with a really bad ending. A count out at Wrestlemania is always a bad idea. Still a fun match up until the end with a lot of uncomfortable commentary sprinkled in. 6/10."
edgyfr wrote on 13.02.2024:
[4.0] "Count Out moment (we are back). A surprisingly underwhelming match between this two. It was fun wrestling wise, but eighteen minutes wasted on a count out is just waiting my time, which makes me very sad because this two could have done such a great match."
JokerDeSilva wrote on 26.12.2023:
[6.0] "A fine match with a deeply mediocre finish. This was Shawn Michaels on the come up, really starting to establish himself as a great in-ring worker, while Tatanka was, at least, a hot act with a strong undefeated gimmick coming in. He was never going to be able to stand as one of the great in-ring performers, but Shawn bumped for him nicely and made his high-impact offense look good. This was before HBK really leveled up, though, so it kind of dragged at times as it turned into rest-holds and long, drawn-out heat spots. The finish was also pretty disappointing, a way to keep Tatanka undefeated while not putting the belt on him, but as always, the question is "why book the match if you don't want either guy to lose? ""
TrailsOfPersona wrote on 17.12.2023:
[6.0] "Another very, very good match. Easily would have been 7 points for me without the subpar and sour finish. I always found this match underrated. For my money, minus the ladder match next year, this is Shawn's best Wrestlemania match of his first run. All of their movement is fluid and crisp. And Tatanka shows that he has full ability to hang with a legend like Michaels. He might have been able to be a solid IC champion if they kept some momentum on him. These guys were so in sync with each other, that they were able to turn two botched spots into salvaged and decent answers. I wish these guys had some more matches because their chemistry seemed to be really good. That being said, even taking the finish aside, this is an excellent match, but still wouldn't quite be a classic. Probably just shy of that, and then the finish knocks it down some. Very close judging the best match of this event between this match and the Steiners/Headshrinkers match that followed."
Rjepic1 wrote on 20.11.2023:
[7.0] "The opener was the match of the night here. Shawn Michaels has the performance of the night and this match and has a really good, long PPV style match with Tatanka here. The finish to this didn't seem so bad on this watch; booking wise Tatanka should've won the title but I'm kinda glad he didn't since Shawn was so good. Sherri Martel returned here to be in Tatanka's corner. This match is also notable for being the debut of Luna Vachon; which I actually really enjoyed; Luna attacking Sherri after the match."
JacquesRougeauCanHaveMyWife wrote on 28.09.2023:
[7.0] "Michaels just carried Tatanka into a great, almost 20-minute long match. The pacing was fantastic and they relied on simple spots like Tatanka cosntantly knocking Shawn off the apron, who's work as a prick heel was eye-catching and the crowd was really into it. The build to Tatanka's fun little comeback was clever and the Powerslam counter looked beautiful. Screwy finish, but I didn't mind it as it worked for Michaels' character."
GoodVsBadGuys wrote on 15.06.2023:
[4.0] "I was trying to figure out why I rated this match so low, and from memory, it seemed that it didn't have the pace or creativity you would expect from a young Shawn Michaels in the WrestleMania spotlight with this first ever singles match for a championship on the grandest stage of them all. A countout finish at WrestleMania on the main show is an awful booking decision. 18 minutes is also far too long to end with a countout finish on Pay Per View."
lukerocker9 wrote on 28.03.2023:
[6.0] "A solid opener for the most part. The match certainly picked up any time HBK was on top but Tatanka wasn't bad either. Crowd was into it a bit chanting for Sherri. Would've been better if they just had Shawn win instead of the count out"
benny5bellys wrote on 14.11.2022:
[5.0] "This was hard work to get through, every now and then Michaels would spark a bit of life into it but it is a lot of dull Tatanka work. Sherri gets a good chant from the crowd. It goes 18 minutes and just as it was getting good they have a crap finish. Post match stuff was semi fun though."
Tomas Cunha wrote on 13.11.2022:
[7.0] "Lots of believable nearfalls along with good selling and in-ring action. The finish might piss a lot of people off, but personally I didn't mind this one that much compared to the other shitty finishes on this show. Not a bad start to what many consider to be the worst WM of all time. [***1/2]"
CommisarRobe wrote on 18.10.2022:
[6.0] "A fine enough match totally ruined by a screwy DQ finish, the action in this match was really good and enjoyable for the most part with Shawn selling excellently as usual. The ending left this match on a sour note for me."
Dynamax Dawn wrote on 31.08.2022:
[6.0] "I suppose this is satisfactory, though I wouldn't blame anyone for rating it lower because of the crappy finish. They didn't want Tatanka's streak to end, but they ended up letting the streak end by garbage Ludvig Borga, so maybe Shawn Michaels should have just pinned him to be honest."
Wrestlingfan wrote on 22.08.2022:
[6.0] "It was a decent match although it was hurt going about five minutes too long. Too many rest holds. Tatanka went to the armbar far too often. The shoulder injury that was sold during the first half of the match was completely ignored by the end. Michaels' bumping in the last five minutes was pretty spectacular though. They booked the finish that way to not give Tatanka a loss since he was undefeated. (**3/4)"
weredet43 wrote on 06.08.2022:
[5.0] "Quite a good bout between Michaels and Tatanka. The first part of the match I didn't really like, the guys were moving slowly, the pauses were noticeable. But towards the end the fight began to speed up, although again, I did not feel any sparkle between them. At the beginning of the bout Tatanka focused all his attacks on Shawn's arm, because something happened to it after the tag team match, although in the previous weeks they didn't emphasize it. In the end, though, it didn't make sense, because it didn't affect the ending in any way. Luna Vashon's appearance appealed to me, but despite that, for some reason she was afraid of Sensational Sherry like fire for the whole bout, although after the match she showed that she could fight. The girls didn't add anything to the match, they didn't affect the result in any way, but what happened after the match kind of explained why we needed them. The ending is a bit unclear, and there are a lot of questions about it."
Giantfan1980 wrote on 24.04.2022:
[5.0] "This was supposed to be Michaels/Jannetty in the big payoff to THAT feud after the original plan for Mania 8 was scrapped because Jannetty got fired for being drunk/drugged up, but when he came back at the Rumble he got fired again so Tatanka gets the push here. Match was doing great until the garbage Honky Tonk Man finish to keep the belt on Michaels."
Mohamed Djebloun wrote on 28.02.2022:
"This opener was really great, a lot of back and forth action, they played into Shawn's shoulder injury in the first half of the fight, great nearfalls, nice spots like Shawn countering a Tatanka dive with a superkick. I don't really get the point of the two women in ringside thought they didn't really add anything to the match positively or negatively. Now the shoulder injury was forgotten in the second half of the fight and it ended with Shawn losing via count out after some stupid stuff with the ref, this could have been a huge moment to crown an undefeated Tatanka who was very over with the crowd but nah they went with the worst possible outcome, I'd have preferred if Shawn won clean over whatever this was.[5/10]"
rishabh wrote on 08.02.2022:
[7.0] "A very solid opener which I really enjoyed. Both men worked very hard here and it's probably Tatanka's best match at least to this point. The finish was bad and hurts the match a little though. I think they could have given the title to Tatanka as he was really over with the crowd and they were clearly high on him. Another concern I had was that while the first half of the match was centered around Shawn's injured shoulder, it was pretty much ignored in the second half and played no role in the finish whatsoever. All in all it was a great opener which gets the crowd going. [***1/2]"
TigerDiver wrote on 28.08.2021:
[8.0] "I always thought this was very underrated in quality. It was clearly the best thing on an otherwise poor show. Shawn, being Shawn, bumped all over the place for Tatanka to make him look good. The whole Luna/Sherri thing was pretty random but didn't hurt the match whatsoever. Tatanka's best match ever. His comeback was great, and had he won the title clean here with no BS finish, this could've easily been a **** great opener. [***3/4]"
Brayan wrote on 07.07.2021:
[6.0] "This match was solid. That's a big compliment given how bad this Mania was as a whole. It's hard to give it too high of a grade when it felt like every match ended the same way, but Shawn Michaels and Tatanka put together a nice bout nonetheless. HBK's influence over generations of wrestlers is clear in this one, which is a cool enough reason to go back and check it out."
cactus wrote on 18.05.2021:
[6.0] "This was worked like something you'd see at a house show until the finishing stretch kicks into gear. Michaels already looks like a pro as he controls Tatanka and leads the match. Tatanka is an average worker, with a brilliant comeback. Michaels has ditched Sherri for Luna, but Sherri decides to show up and root for anyone not named Shawn Michaels. The women don't get involved much until the post-match. The finish is designed to keep the belt on Michaels without destroying Tatanka's win record, so they come up with a bullshit ending that sees Tatanka win by count-out after some shenanigans. Crap finish aside, this was a satisfactory opener."
MagnusD wrote on 21.09.2020:
[6.0] "Not a bad opener, for this show and how terrible it gets, later on, so I'll give it a pass. Tatanka looked fine and Shawn managed to get something very watchable out of him."
Nacho Disasters wrote on 20.06.2019:
[4.0] "A pretty mediocre match. A countout finish on an 18 minute opening match at Wrestlemania is what really kills it for me."
Makai Club wrote on 20.02.2019:
[4.0] "This was pretty meh for a match. Michaels? bumping all match was pretty funny. He would flop all over the ring after hitting his arm in the ring post. Tatanka is beyond dull on offence. The one thing I took from this match is that Randy Savage is truly awful on commentary. Heenan rules though. **"
Mizzle Assault Ant wrote on 26.01.2018:
[5.0] "A passable match, no more. A long run time for a terrible ending, plus lots of Tatanka on top, which is far from interesting. Some good stuff from Michaels, but eh overall."
jackleone wrote on 30.06.2016:
[7.0] "The first match is the best one of Wrestlemania IX. I think that both wrestlers did a good work on the ring in a match that almost lasts for 20 minutes. Shawn Michaels was already great as an Intercontinental Champion. ***1/2"
bugsy mcgraw wrote on 13.04.2014:
[6.0] "A good match here with a nice back and forth. Both Tatanka and Michaels play their roles well. I'm not sure what the goal with the Luna Vachon-Sherri Martel stuff was, but it still added to the match."
TAWPTierJustin wrote on 09.06.2013:
[7.0] "In my honest opinion, Shawn Michaels vs. Tatanka was a pretty good opening match at Wrestlemania IX in Caesars Palace! It had some good storytelling with both Sensational Sherri and the debuting, Luna Vachon in their respective corners as well. That match probably would've been better if WWF at the time had gone with the original finish that was supposed to take place instead of the BS finish we ended up getting and that match probably would've been at least a bit more liked by wrestling fans. Tatanka was undefeated at the time and fans were really behind him! If WWF would've had Tatanka win the Intercontinental championship from Shawn Michaels which was originally supposed to happen, I think that would've been an awesome Wrestlemania moment for Tatanka and a career defining moment for him at that! But no, Shawn didn't want to be a company guy and he had such a big ego and was so selfish at the time that he politicked to have that match end in a slightly different way by having Tatanka win by "count out" (when it really should've been technically a DQ finish) instead. That's why I feel so bad for Tatanka in this situation cause if that match hadn't ended that way, Tatanka most likely would've gone down in history as a good Intercontinental champion as well."