[7.0] "This was a fun match that worked as a nice showcase for Grayson. Moxley winning was a forgone conclusion from the start, but it was nice to see Grayson get a good amount of offense in and even escape Moxley's Bulldog Choke. There were some minor things that weren't the best here, such as Grayson's feet hitting the mat when he went for the 450, but there wasn't anything that severely damaged my score of this match. Good stuff."
[7.0] "Really consistent, hard-hitting match that made Stu Grayson look really strong for this ongoing Blackpool Combat Club story. That man was determined to fight and fight, and it took an avalanche Death Rider to beat him. It was nice to see a riveting Moxley match that didn't have blood, too. Unfortunately, it is gonna be tough to get the fans to boo Moxley unless he does something truly despicable (which seems to be the build, but will they deliver is the real question)."
[7.0] "A good old brawl where Moxley looked like a fucking beast. Grayson looked well, sold the shit like a boss, even if he needed, in my opinion, more offense. The finish was pretty cool."
[5.0] "They started off weird but got better as the match went on. Would've liked this match to be a bit rougher considering the competitors in it, but it was still good tv fare."
[7.0] "I like that this match didn't come out of nowhere. He had a plot rationale, and that's cool. I wish Dynamit matches were driven more by storylines. Stu Grayson is definitely doing well since his return. He gave a good rebuff to Moxley, but it was not enough to win. ***1/2"
[2.0] "very rough match, to the point where this felt like it was something you'd see on DARK and say "well they've got time to get better". Opening sequences were very sloppy and while it improves a little bit, Grayson throwing out a 450 splash just felt like an attempt to save what was a poor match unworthy of tv"
[7.0] "I'm very impressed with Stu's return. He hasn't had a winning effort yet, but he has so many fun matches and I hope they give him a strap soon. I also loved Moxley's performance as always."
[7.0] "I was expecting a little more from this match specially after last week performance from Stu Grayson, it was not a bad match at any point but imo this could have been a lot better but at the same time I am so happy to see Stu back on tv and The Dark order in general involved in this storyline with the Elite and BCC. They deserve to be part of this and I am really interested to see how things turned out."
[8.0] "Enjoyed the hell out of this match, strong chemistry between the wrestlers, backed up by a proper storyline. I thought Stu looked really good and was I was entertained through the whole match even if the outcome was obvious."
[6.0] "Good match. Very competitive match. Grayson performed well in a losing effort. Nice somersault senton escape into the corner by Grayson out of a bulldog choke."
[5.0] "I don't understand the positive ratings. I'm wondering if fans were just happy to see Stu back, because this did not seem to click at all. The sequence where the two attempted to trade shoulder tackles near the start of the match was hilariously awkward. It improved a bit down the stretch, but not enough to make up for the first half. This was sloppy and not at all an impressive way for Grayson to underscore his return to the company."
[6.0] "Jon Moxley is too beloved and has too much of a banger entrance theme to get consistently booed. This was the definition of fine. BCC need to definitively murder Dark Order so we can move onto faction warfare with with the Elite through to the PPV."
[5.0] "Unlike previous Moxley matches, this match was wholely unmemorable. Maybe with the new officially official Moxley heel turn, there'll be a renewed tenacity. Stu really didn't spark a lot of interest unlike the previous trios match. A bit of a letdown."
[7.0] "Good match that at least allowed Stu to look competitive with one of the top names in AEW. Thats a much better usage out of him than the vast majority of his first AEW run. I think it could have been better with some more time but still a good match."