DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?

Bret Hart vs. Roddy Piper

Match

Match Data
8.45
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 488
Number of comments: 123
10.0 74x
9.0 162x
8.0 180x
7.0 60x
6.0 10x
5.0 1x
4.0 1x
3.0 0x
2.0 0x
1.0 0x
0.0 0x
Average rating: 8.46  [488]
Average rating in 2026: 8.49  [78]
Average rating in 2025: 8.33  [89]
Average rating in 2024: 8.61  [85]
Average rating in 2023: 8.55  [56]
Average rating in 2022: 8.53  [34]
Average rating in 2021: 8.35  [26]
Average rating in 2020: 8.69  [26]
Average rating in 2019: 8.00  [13]
Average rating in 2018: 8.50  [18]
Average rating in 2017: 8.17  [6]
Average rating in 2016: 8.27  [15]
Average rating in 2015: 8.67  [12]
Average rating in 2014: 8.40  [5]
Average rating in 2013: 7.40  [5]
Average rating in 2012: 8.00  [1]
Average rating in 2011: 6.00  [1]
Average rating in 2010: 8.00  [2]
Average rating in 2009: 7.80  [5]
Average rating in 2008: 8.91  [11]
Your Options:
Other:
TrailsOfPersona wrote on 05.10.2026:
[9.0] "A true early masterpiece in Wrestlemania history. It is an early example of Bret Hart's technical and storytelling genius as a singles star. And that isn't to discredit Piper. His intensity adds to the weight of the match immensely. As a wrestling match, it isn't the most amazingly technical for Bret, but it is still an outstanding enough wrestling match to hold up strictly on a bell to bell sense. Then the story telling. Both men are babyfaces but were heels in the past. Both men are so hungry to win the match that they break out some heel tactics to try and score a victory, which angers the other. This culminates in Piper thinking about hitting Bret with the bell only for the crowd to beg him not too. He hesitates and gets the audience in the palm of his hand while Bret is helpless. And when he throws the bell away to try and win clean, the crowd explodes. The finish that follows is sheer brilliance. It gives the Hitman such a strong win but also elevates Piper in defeat. It is truly a match for the ages."
Jamildo2 wrote on 07.09.2026:
[8.0] "This was great. Almost felt like a trailblazing technical match. Rowdy Roddy Piper gets nowhere NEAR enough love. He was outstanding here and did everything that he could to put Bret over and make him a star. Generational performance."
Jonoabbo wrote on 09.06.2026:
[9.0] "There are a lot of very good Wrestlemania matches before this one, but this feels like the first great technical affair to take place on the showcase of the immortals. There are some great chain wrestling sequences here, and some great more modern moves. While that's what helps this match to stand out over some of it's predecessors, it's the story of this match, particularly the fluctuating heel sides of both competitors, that makes it truly great. This is present throughout the match, but most notably in the finish, with Piper opting not to use the ring bell, tossing it to the side and locking in the sleeper, only for Bret to hit a well executed reversal leading directly to the 3 count. Awesome stuff. Also, Bret gets some real nice colour in this one. Great stuff."
PaoloReaper wrote on 21.04.2026:
[10.0] "One of the classic examples of what great wrestling is, and of what does it mean to tell an in-ring story. Phenomenal work. I cried a little. [9.5]"
LuminousPink wrote on 14.04.2026:
[7.0] "A classic and great example of in-ring psychology. Bret is of course pretty great but Roddy also puts in a good showing too, especially with that finish."
UWF Rules Enthusiast wrote on 10.04.2026:
[8.0] "This is a classic. This was a big moment in Bret's career. Piper doing a clean job was unheard of. This was the Match of the Day and the best match of Piper's career."
JoeyBingBong wrote on 07.04.2026:
[9.0] "An early WrestleMania classic, as Roddy Piper makes Bret Hart in a bloody, dramatic Intercontinental clash. It's an iconic babyface match, with tempers flaring and Piper leaning heel until at the point of no return, he fully closes the door on his prior years of villainy. That's a theatrical finish to an otherwise bruising affair, a gritty thriller that doesn't waste a second of its not even 14-minute runtime. ****1/2"
EyeSocketCrunch wrote on 05.04.2026:
[10.0] "34th anniversary for this absolute classic. When I was first getting into wrestling as a late bloomer, my point of introduction was Bret Hart. He's still one of my absolute favorites, the way he moves, the control he has of his body, the way he takes punishment. He's one of my favorites of all time without a doubt. Here he's paired with Piper, I think this match was my introduction to him as a worker, and I just fell in love. This is such a brutal match, that manages to be so bite-sized and snappy. It delivers the technical prowess and the classic bloody brawling in such a small package. Adore the payoff of Roddy's prematch promo, he remembers Bret when he was just a baby in diapers, and when the time comes, he doesn't have the guts to kill him. One of my all time favorites. An ideal match."
lonecub101 wrote on 04.04.2026:
[6.0] "I will say the prematch promo from Piper was not my favorite. He could be good and I have seen great promos from him, but this was just rambling for the sake of it. In terms of the match, it is the best of the show so far, but still not my favorite. The action was solid, but not revolutionary even for the time, but the finish I think was good for both guys."
WG20 wrote on 05.03.2026:
[9.0] "A great Wrestlemania match. The story and in-ring work from these two was top notch. The finish for the match was brilliant from Roddy hesitating to hit Bret with the bell to Bret reversing the Sleeper Hold into a pin. Tremendous stuff."
Sweet Fighter V wrote on 05.03.2026:
[9.0] "This is such a delightful match-up. Two fan favorites, yet too polar opposites; Piper being that wild, brash, out-spoken veteran brawler, Bret the calm, soft-spoken technician and young rising star. Add the genuine backstory between Piper and the Hart family to the equation, and you get this brilliant piece of storytelling. The nice little pre-match promo set the tone perfectly, and I love how it all unfolds with Bret taking control, outwrestling Piper, showing he is the superior man, then Bret hurting his shoulder, going for a roll-up, getting slapped for it, the tension rising, Piper getting dirty, wanting to punish Bret, busting him open and all, building that brilliant moment of moral struggle with Piper ring bell in hand, changing his mind after having the crowd on the edge of their seats, deciding to play it clean and getting caught off guard as a result. This is Piper's finest performance ever. His character work here, as frantic as it is, is outstanding, and that post-match moment with Piper showing love and respect to Bret, handing him the belt, is a perfect final touch. ****1/4"
MondoVision wrote on 02.03.2026:
[8.0] "Such an intense match, the sort of thing that was totally anathema to the WWF product at the time. Both these dudes come out swinging and using every trick in the book, and by the time Bret springs a leak from his forehead you KNOW things are going to get as violent and hate-filled as they're gonna get in the Fed circa 1992. Roddy tosses some GNARLY looking punches and Hart ripostes with some STIFF forearm shots (long before those became cliche in wrestling, of course.) Bret keeps catching Roddy off guard by playing possum but he just can't keep Piper down with his usual five moves of doom offense. We get a ref bump spot, which leads to some brawling on the outside. Then Roddy hesitates on conking Bret with the timekeeper's bell, in a spot of melodrama that has been imitated COUNTLESS times over the last 30 years. The finish sees Bret counter a sleeperhold into a roll-up (yet ANOTHER spot that has been copied a bajillion times.) This is a hell of a bout and probably the best thing Roddy did in the '90s as a whole."
SebasDiaz wrote on 18.02.2026:
[7.0] "A great match, with both doing a great work Bret and Roddy Piper, the structure of the match with the Dynamics of everything, with Piper more brutal, attacking with the bell and then losing by roll pin, Bret bleeding adding more drama to then win with that roll pin which was okay but could've been better, but after all, the match didn't disappoint, 7/10 [****1/4]"
guycalleddonut wrote on 01.02.2026:
[10.0] "Technically brilliant, no surprise there, but also psychologically fantastic. Roddy Piper perfects the word drama, selling the struggle of trying his damnedest not to return to old heel tricks in his struggle to keep up with the much more agile, younger Bret Hart. A beautiful story told inside the realms of the squared circle."
danzitorock wrote on 30.01.2026:
[8.0] "That's an incredible match, specially if you consider how rare face vs face matches were back then, and they've managed to perform one here with excellency. Both guys are babyfaces, but when the bell rings, both want to win the title, and if they have to do a dirty tactic, they will. Bret did a dirty trick on Piper, who kept being respectful during the match, but you never knew what was next, and after extending the ropes to Bret, he punched him with a cheap shot, which ended up busting Bret open. It's a short match, but extremely frenetic and the crowd was on fire. The ending is kinda goofy, but considering the major background of Roddy Piper as a heel, it was a cool way to end the match, with him hesitating about going back to his old self, and his selling during that moment was of course incredible. Piper hesitated and fought against his nature, but Bret has nothing to do with that, and won the match right afterwards. Great WrestleMania moment, a duel between two Canadian legends - {****}"
Rhasta wrote on 29.01.2026:
[6.0] "Very solid match here. It starts with them trying to one up each other by cheating, but by the end Piper doesn't take a cheap win with the ring bell. It ends with a creative pin by Bret to win the match."
Enzokkk23 wrote on 24.01.2026:
[6.0] "the match is slow, i didn't see any thing impressed me in this match, it's like any average match today, I have no idea how this got a 8.5 ! , i think it would be good if i gave this match a 6/10 rate"
flydel wrote on 24.11.2025:
[9.0] "Simply put: EXTRAORDINARY ! The storytelling is amazing, Piper couldn't hit Bret with the bell as he knows he's soon to be departed from the company and back to Hollywood (he also knows he's come a long way since the early 80s and his now a face in the eyes of the public). Tremendous passing of the torch moment "from one Canadian to another" ! We finally got a good Piper's match at Wrestlemania too. Bret got to regain the IC title after losing it some months earlier in a house show and this (for me) is one of the matches that truly kicks off the "New Generation" era of wrestling."
SkyIcons wrote on 10.11.2025:
[8.0] "Really liked the dynamic here. Throughout the match both men were using to use cheap tactics, willing to do anything to win. But when it came down to it, Piper couldn't pull the trigger and it cost him the match. Match escalated after Bret got some color. This was also a much needed match for Piper, his history on mania outside of this is very bad. Great stuff."
Hippykillerz wrote on 02.11.2025:
[9.0] "I love the story of this one. Piper deep down knows he can't bear Bret without cheating and slowly but surely, he comes to realize that as the match goes on. Every exchange in this match feels like it adds another layer to the story. Even when the match slows down, you can tell it means something. Perfect storytelling. The match comes to a head with the ring bell spot and awesome sleeper reversal. Maybe Piper's best match and another feather in the cap for the Hitman. Would be a perfect match if the pace would be a little faster but go out of your way to watch this one."
KastGo wrote on 23.10.2025:
[6.0] "For me this match was really boring like 70% of all time.Some moments were really good but the whole match for me is little bit overrated.It has really good story, but for now it is very simple.It was not bad, but not something satisfying"
rishabh wrote on 10.10.2025:
[9.0] "My only complaint with this match is that it wasn't very long. Bret Hart and Roddy Piper were cousins, and both were babyfaces at the time which made for an interesting encounter. This match could have gone for hours and I wouldn't have complained. It was a fantastic contest with such good storytelling and drama. We also saw blood during the match, even though blood wasn't allowed in WWF then. The finish was the famous Bret Hart pinfall off the turnbuckle. This was easily the best match of Roddy Piper's entire career, and one of the best Intercontinental title matches ever. [****1/4]"
jacobmiller wrote on 08.09.2025:
"A severely underrated match. This was exactly what it was supposed to be, and the storytelling was great. It's not from left field to say this was Roddy Piper's best career match, and it also fits nicely in Bret Hart's catalog of timeless wrestling classics. For its intensity and character development, not to mention its very good in-ring work, this match still holds up as good as anything from the golden era of wrestling. 4.5 Stars."
shihab696 wrote on 24.08.2025:
[8.0] "It is a good match. Quite underrated. Piper was great in this match. They both were. Sold the story excellently."
Cinnamon16 wrote on 03.08.2025:
[9.0] "The best Piper match and an underrated WrestleMania classic. This one deserves a lot more attention and love than it gets."
BasuraNocturna wrote on 07.07.2025:
[9.0] "Great dynamic between these two. Their contrasting styles are the driving force in the beginning. Bret Hart is the more technical one, while Piper realizes he's outmatched in that regard and tries to turn the contest into a fight. Both Piper and Hart are faces coming into this match, but they have both been heels. They both display that. But the magic of it is the way they do it. Roddy does it leanning into the hair pulling and the eye gouging, while Bret is more cerebral, playing possum to gain an advantage. The action is crisp, and Piper sells Hart's technical prowess so well, hurting just by the Hitman's wrist control. He also intersects so well the sportsmanship with his cheating ways. The spot where Roddy opens the ropes for Bret to come back to the ring just to go for a cheap shot after it is a great example of it. Hart being the less popular one of the two at the time more than justifies the color to put some more sympathy in the Hitman's favor. The struggle and desperation that Piper shows while trying to block the sharpshooter explain Piper's more desperate ways in the finishing stretch, and his acting is understated and good enough to make the struggle to throw the bell away plausible. In the end, Hart's prowess is what wins him the bout. The pin out of the chokehold is consistent with his style, overall approach to wrestling, and situation in the match. And also serves Piper well for not being able to pull the trigger."
Heel Worker wrote on 10.05.2025:
[8.0] "A very well structured match with great character dynamics. Piper capitalized on Hart's weaknesses while Hart found the way in desperation. Great finish by Hart."
KKeanel wrote on 24.04.2025:
[9.0] "Incredibly bloody, vicious and intense battle. Definitely one of the Wrestlemania's classics. Alongside Flair vs. Savage, match of the night obviously."
trexyyy wrote on 17.04.2025:
[9.0] "This was yet another great Bret Hart Wrestlemania match, these two guys put on a classic. Their chemistry was great, Piper's refusal to cheat in the end which ended up costing him was a good way to end this. Yet another enjoyable match."
niclaswrestling wrote on 13.04.2025:
[8.0] "Finally, Roddy Piper got his Wrestlemania classic, and it was with none other than Bret Hart in his first singles match at the event. A very well worked contest that to this day is one of the best Intercontinental Title matches in Wrestlemania history."
ShaliK wrote on 13.04.2025:
[7.0] "A really good match to watch. Roddy Piper is mixed throughout the match, doing something unforgivable to Bret Hart while doing some pretty sneaky things. In the end, he hesitates to use the bell, only to give up and get screwed. I really loved it, it's short and the story is interesting. (3*3/4)"
Itayboi wrote on 26.03.2025:
[8.0] "maybe the best ic championship mania match to this point (yes i know what im saying by that) a very good match with a grate finish, piper plays this match so well form his dismay at some of bret's tacits at the start of the match to himself slowley turing to the dark side only to not be able to go the whole way and hit bret with the belt. bret is as always excellent in this match tho he did have a few sloppy moments but even those didnt hurt the match to much as it made it feel more real. the finsh is very well done, so well done infact that bret would use the counter agin later agins austin. also heenan is amazing in this match palying up to the face vs face dynamic of the match. i mean what more can i say just a very good story told in not alott of time"
Gerdo wrote on 10.03.2025:
[8.0] "Piper refusal to cheat in the end gave this match a plus. It was short but very good, especially under the psychology aspect. Storytelling was the main focus of the match, with the action in ring which also was excellent. Bladejob was a nice add to this match."
TonyMcTony24 wrote on 10.03.2025:
[8.0] "Very great storytelling here. Pipers reluctance for old tactics, the respect these to have. At 13 minutes it's a crisply wrestled contest. Bret hart is one of the best in the game, unless you give him 4 out of 10 ratings with poor and flat out ridiculous reasons as to why, but we're sane here. One of pipers best as well, one of the goats at storytelling."
fablezzzz wrote on 14.02.2025:
[4.0] "It's fine, nothing special, just your typical Bret Hart Match: Not selling anything, insisting upon himself, slow and repetitive tropes. Bret Hart matches swear that they have deep psychology, when in reality, they're boring and overrated. I'll never understand the praise for his work."
charlierosegold wrote on 31.01.2025:
[10.0] "Bell to bell the best Mania match up to this point. It really feels like the 90s have finally arrived, and they have come in swinging. Bret's first singles match in Mania and what a barn burner to showcase his power. I fully believe that if Roddy just worked a regular match instead of worked boxing at Mania 2 he could have dragged T to something decent, he's that good. The storytelling is absolutely phenomenal, with both wrestlers corrupting their morals a little bit at a time, getting less sportsmanlike and more brutal as time goes on. Later Bret matches portrayed him slightly more as a squeaky clean babyface, but here he is allowed to roll up Roddy and win with a surprise small package! He's allowed to play possum to catch Roddy unawares! It's a level of nuance and shades of grey not seen in most western wrestling history. Roddy's got a full character arc here too, the old heel falling back into his old ways out of fear and jealousy, catching himself before he fell too far and finally accepting his defeat. Hubris! Pathos! Acceptance! This is some mythical shit right here."
benh2 wrote on 30.11.2024:
[9.0] "Some incredible storytelling here, particularly from Piper, who fights his old urge to cheat. Bret's "accidental" juice adds another layer to the match. One of the few ref bumps there's been that actually added to the match and finally when Piper locks in the Sleeper to win the match, having played by the rules all along, he falls victim to a very cute finish. Fairly standard work but they made everything mean something and the crowd ate it up."
Thesully wrote on 12.11.2024:
[9.0] "Such a great match, particularly the storytelling at the end where Roddy Piper struggles with his morals and ultimately chooses to do the right thing. I'm also not ashamed to say that I watched this match daily for about a year. Even the commentary was amazing. Highly recommend watching this match, especially if you're looking to get into the business in any capacity."
FelipeTalksGraps wrote on 11.10.2024:
[8.0] "[4.0*] Incredible match with a beautiful storytelling. Piper knew he could not out-wrestle Bret so he tried to escape, but then he decided he was going to prove he was better inside the ring until the ref bump ocurred and he saw the perfect opportunity to hit Bret with the ring bell, win it all and retain his championship without further adversities. However, after a long thought, the crowd convinced him to try to defeat Bret in the ring, so he put the ring bell down and slapped Brets face. The problem is, 1-on-1, Piper could not beat him, so Bret out-smarted him when he was doing the Rear Naked Choke and Bret used the ropes exactly how he used against Austin at Survivor Series to win the championship. After the match, Piper (who was the heel with conflicted feelings) put the belt on Hart in a wholesome moment for a gigantic pop. Brets blade job was so great I thought he was legit busted open."
LJAwesome 03 wrote on 07.10.2024:
[8.0] "(Grade B+) This was a classic in terms of storytelling and in-ring work, I appreciate how Roddy was more of a brawler in certain aspect of the match since if he tried to go for technical like Bret he wouldn't fair well and Bret showed his heart and him bleeding caught me off guard. I liked how Roddy was trying to go for a heel way of winning. However, listening to the crowd decided to try the more honorable right which cause him to lose in the end though he showed respect to Bret!"
CMFunk007 wrote on 31.08.2024:
[9.0] "You can tell when Roddy Piper really respects someone. He's willing to do the job for them, something he rarely ever did. Rumor has it that Piper and Hart are distant cousins, but I'm not sure of that. But this was likely Piper's best singles match of his career outside of the Valentine dog-collar match, but I do think this was better than that. he chose to elevate Bret here and did a fantastic job while not losing any heat for himself."
Johan wrote on 30.06.2024:
[10.0] "[****1/2] + (1) the extra 1 for drama and storyline and while the ring work is amazing, this match is a 4 star match in ring work wise with 5 star storytelling, atmosphere and aura, and the in romg storytelling is off the charts!"
RealGrapsThomsen wrote on 24.05.2024:
[8.0] "This was an awesome match. Piper and Flair both put on a good match and told a great story. The pacing and psychology was good. Piper put Bret over and passed the torch."
KingsCrossing wrote on 11.05.2024:
[9.0] "I've always thought this match deserved more love when it comes to people talking about WrestleMania classics. There are a lot of matches these days that try to tell a similar story, but it's rare for it to be executed as well as it is here. The sense of escalating tension between the two babyfaces as they become increasing heated and determined to win is palpable, and the fans are fully invested by the climactic final minute or so of the match. The pre-match promo is an all-time, too. Terrific stuff all around."
HugoRoids wrote on 06.05.2024:
[8.0] "I dont think as a match this one held up to my memories on a rewatch, but hot damn this is still really good. Hot Rod is without a doubt one of the best character workers in wrestling history and what he lacks in ring ability, Bret makes up for. The chemistry these two had was great and the action, while slow at times, told a story. This is a match better suited to view as a story than a technical clinic. Especially the ring bell spot where Roddy cant bring himself to smash Brets head with it, which ultimately costs him the match. If you choose to watch this match, also make sure to watch the pre-match promo. Its amazing."
uselessdollthing wrote on 04.05.2024:
[6.0] "A pretty decent match. Piper isn't on the same level as Bret when it comes to in-ring skill but his strong suit is his charisma and character work which really shines through in this match. He pretty much dominates Bret for most of the match, but Bret manages to punish him for his mistakes. Towards the end he's swayed by the influence of the crowd which leds to Bret taking him down and getting the pin. Good match, good showing for both wrestlers."
ISimon1912 wrote on 16.04.2024:
[6.0] "I really wish I had liked this match more, but for me the most interesting thing is Piper's character work than the wrestling or Bret's skill, I can't take this match to that level, just an ok match, but it's still my match WretleMania VIII favorite (***)"
tlaustin wrote on 07.04.2024:
[10.0] "Piper's entire career can pretty much be summarized by charisma that always broadly avoids payoff. He's a talker. He's a personality. He's an incredible heel and, in rare moments, the fieriest of fiery babyfaces. For whatever reason, even though he gets the "psychology" part of wrestling, most (not all) of his career he just seemed allergic to having good matches. Part of that is perhaps just a symptom of the era he's from, but I think, oftentimes, the bigger issue is Piper just needs someone opposite of him that can lay the technical part of the match out. Case in point: Bret Hart. By allowing Bret Hart to pace the match and Piper to have the emotional moments--the character conflict with the bell, the losing of his mind, etc--you get the best of everything these two are capable of both in terms of ring work and storytelling. I think this is probably widely known as one of the best Wrestlemania matches of all time so I don't really want to do a heavy dissection of it, but if you somehow haven't seen it yet, it is one of the all time best builds and stories WWF ever put out."
jeremyeyork wrote on 02.04.2024:
[10.0] "This was easily the best match of WrestleMania VIII. The backstage interview the match just added so much. The spot with the bell really got the fan interaction"
Yee I watch wrestlin wrote on 30.03.2024:
[8.0] "this is such a good match such a smart match between a amazing babyface and a amazing heel its a smart old school wrestling match with moves that matter every movement in this match matters its such a good watch and then bret getting the win is awesome just personally dont like the way he won getting a quick one on the heel especially since pretty much this exact same thing happens with flair and savage later in the show. 4 stars"