[8.0] "Excellent TV tag match here between four big names. I will watch peak Vader do literally anything and pounding the hell out of Sting and Rhodes is something he excels at. Windham is great, Dustin is great, and String gets a nice hot tag, something he excels at. The finish is messy but the crowd is definitely feeling the chaos."
[7.0] "WCW without the return of Ric Flair would have looked a lot different with these four in the main event scene. This feels like a glimpse of what that world could be like. I am a sucker for a big baddies duo like Vader and Windham, while Sting and Dustin were the perfect antithesis to them. The crowd ate every bit of Dustin's segment with a spoon, as poor Rhodes Jr. was constantly cut off in the most hapless way possible. I mean, Vader straight-up splashing his spine to stop him just summed it up perfectly. Sting's hot tag sent everyone in the building into a frenzy! It looked like he had everything in control, but after Dustin was taken out on the floor, he easily fell prey to a two-on-one assault. Vader then mercilessly whipped Sting's spine with a strap, as the babyface locker room cleared out to come to his aid. And THAT is exactly how you hype up your SuperBrawl main event! [***1/2]"
[5.0] "This had moments of good stuff. Any time Vader gets to lay out Sting or Dustin Rhodes with a lariat it looks amazing and Sting's natural babyface heat is insane to see. Overall though this is just a fine tag team match with a fucked finish to build to the PPV. To be honest the highlight of this match was the batshit insane hype promo they showed beforehand featuring Vaders mortal kombat looking castle"
[7.0] "This was low key kind of awesome. Vader and Windham were a really great team of physical heels, and they put a beating on Dustin, which Dustin sold wonderfully. He looked genuinely exhausted and desperate, writhing around on the mat in search for a way to his partner. Vader looked equally great, flying around the ring and throwing his entire body into everything he did. The crowd erupted when Dustin finally made the tag. Some fans will be disappointed by the finish, but I thought it worked and escalated things nicely leading into the big PPV bout between Vader and Sting. High energy main event that successfully built up the hype for SuperBrawl."
[7.0] "Four dons in the ring, a super hot crowd, an excited JR on commentary and the babyface locker room clearing to back up Sting as he gets whipped post match. Just brilliant TV wrestling."
[6.0] "Really enjoyed this. Great heat during the match with the crowd heavily invested throughout. Obviously it completely breaks down at the end to build towards the Superbrawl matches. Being new to WCW in 1993, I'm actually getting excited for the PPV!"
[5.0] "A standard tag team match with the DQ finish. This is as early as I've gone back in Sting's career so far and it's really noticeable how much of a star he already was."