[9.0] "Fuck it, I loved everything about this. This has gotta be Logan's best match and he's the fucking babyface? It shouldn't work but it does. Great mix of awesome counters, soap opera bollocks and good story told with Logan stealing all of Miz's moves. Plus the frog splash through the table, fucking duh ****1/4"
[8.0] "This had ZERO reason to be as good as it ended up being. Logan ended up carrying the Miz to my surprise and I found this to be super enjoyable. The table spot was sick."
[7.0] "Logan Paul massively over-performed in his first ever singles match. A very solid match that did a great job of introducing Logan Paul to the pro wrestling world. Can't forget Miz's great performance either, walking Logan Paul through this match. Kudus to both guys. ***1/2"
[5.0] "Probably the best match Logan had in his career, which is strange because he's facing the Miz here. I don't hate the Miz or anything, I just don't thing he's nearly capable of carrying Logan to a good match. But they had something that was solid. Still don't like the outside shenanigans and its funny that they had Logan be a babyface here."
[10.0] "Logan Paul's presence and ability was enough to make this a banger the man's ability early in his career was very impressive its a pretty good sports entertainment wrestling match, don't come in expecting a technical masterpiece, it's a entertainment showcase and it's pretty great at that"
[9.0] "This was Logan Paul getting back at Miz for his betrayal at WrestleMania 38 and it's a really great match that showcased just how annoyingly amazing of a singles wrestler Logan is."
[7.0] "Wow, Logan Paul really smashed it here, what a match, and i love itttt... Logan definitely have a bright future ahead of him and i can't wait to see him again in the ring."
[8.0] "This was a really good first debut for Logan. The Miz made him look great in his first match, selling his ass off for Logan and even taking a frog splash through the table. The interferences from Ciampa and Styles were a bit unnecessary but Logan got the win."
[7.0] "Logan had a few matches before which showcased his potential, but this match really got me into him. He was working as a face which is not ideal for him, but his incredible athleticism made up for it. You just can't be not impressed with his talents and even though I could do without the table spot it was a nice match to put him over. Also kudos to The Miz who most probably led Paul here."
[8.0] "Arguably the best match of Logan Paul's rookie year in the WWE. Super entertaining from bell-to-bell with a fun narrative they told compellingly."
[6.0] "The story of this match was The Miz trying to use his veteran experience to control his inexperienced opponent, but he also relied on Ciampa to lend a hand when the ref was distracted. It is always hard to tell if a stadium crowd is into something because the noise escapes through the open roof, but it seemed like both men got some good reactions at certain spots. The fact that this is only Paul's second actual match proved he has been putting in the work to make sure he exceeded expectations. This was better than anyone expected it to be and likely changed a few opinions about Paul in the process."
[8.0] "The match in which Logan Paul proved that WrestleMania 38 was no accident. Moreover unlike many other celebrities, he can really show match 1 vs 1 at a very high level. ****1/4"
[8.0] "After the fight at WrestleMania, I was waiting for this match and I expected it to be good. But honestly, I didn't know it was going to be that good. Logan showed himself from a really good side, it was obvious that he would win, and Miz as a veteran was a suitable rival, he was a guarantee that the duel would go well, Miz fights very cautiously and safely, does not lead to injuries, and in the fight against an inexperienced rival this is especially important. We will probably see Logan only at the Royal Rumble or just before Wrestlemania, I think that Kevin Owens or Pat McAfee would be the best for him."
[8.0] "A magnificent performance from Logan Paul once again as he learnt the craft so fast and precise. The Miz worked well as Logan's first opponent taking all the moves like a champ and counter attacking in his own brash style. The swiftness & smoothness in Logan's offense felt so good to watch as not many would ace the trick this good but he did. The match wasn't impressive action wise alone, it felt great as a story of a passionate debutant defying the odds and proving his opponent wrong that he meant to be here. I'm simply into what's next for Logan as a WWE star and the future is surely bright for him. 3.75 out of 5 stars!"
[8.0] "This is a surprisingly excellent match. Logan Paul is such a fast learner in what he does and it shows in the wrestling world. The Miz puts his opponent on display perfectly and it lets Logan Paul shine as he should. However, I think Logan Paul should be heel and it would work much better. Impressive jump off the third rope through the commentary table, I didn't think Logan Paul would take that bump."
[7.0] "This was far better than I expected. Logan was really impressive despite his lack of experience and Miz did a great job selling for Logan and making him look good."
[8.0] "Fun match and better than I expected. Logan looked quite good and that splash he did from the top ropes to the table was pretty impressive and insane. I liked how the match ended with Logan getting the win over Miz by doing his own move on him. Oh yeah props to The Miz too."
[8.0] "Now this is a festive fight. I liked the attires of the fighters, they were dressed beautifully. Also, the fans were interested in the spectacle and at the same time it was very dynamic and bright. Logan Paul is probably the brightest star outside of wrestling, which shows a pleasant sight, you can see how he tried and he probably surprised everyone, I hope we will see him more often in the ring and I just became his fan. I really liked the performance and it was really hard for Miz. As a result, we saw a lot of beautiful things, including Maris and falling on the table. In general, the impression is only super positive."
[9.0] "Logan Paul est impressionnant ! c'est vraiment une superbe prestation de sa part. Le Miz fait un boulot fabuleux également c'est important de le souligner.assez intéressé par la suite pour Logan Paul."
[7.0] "Another impressive performance from Logan Paul. However the Styles interference was a bit weird. Was he even involved in this feud? And I think Logan Paul as a face does not really work. Though it did not hurt this match. The fans mostly cheered for Logan. ***1/2"
[8.0] "For this being someone's second ever wrestling match Logan Paul was amazing, although he did stiff Miz with a couple of his punches. All of his moves looked good, and impactful, he's actually a pretty solid seller. Miz was fine here and did a good job of helping Logan look good but I thought Logan was better than him in this match. That frog splash Logan hit was beautiful, his performance was so good that he managed to get the crowd on his side by the end of this.***3/4"
[8.0] "Really good. Logan Paul did a better performance than even some wrestlers with experience can't, and Miz did his job really good to push him. And there's a good story of student who tries to surpass his mentor, but with some "dirty" moves like using opponent's moves. Ironically, this was the way the end the match. ***3/4"
[3.0] "Typical Miz match where he everything he did was sloppy and didn't look like it had any impact. Logan Paul gassed out very early in the match, and they spent a lot of time resting. The frog splash will cause a lot of people to overrate this match. Paul has a lot of star potential, and is already a much better worker than Miz. He should not be a babyface, that is just ridiculous"
[7.0] "It was a great match, Logan Paul impressed me again, even though I'm far from being a fan of what he does on the internet. he must have trained very hard to reach such a level, because clearly out of all the celebrities who have been in a WWE match, he's the one who's doing the best (sorry Bad Bunny, but it's a fact). And AJ Styles' appearance made me wonder if the WWE might be setting up a rivalry between AJ Styles and Ciampa. If that's the case, it's going to be the bomb. [***3/4]"
[8.0] "What a banger. An incredible performance from Logan Paul who delivers a match worthy of Mania. The booking is huge, a super good use of the managers and AJ which gives a dynamism in addition and brings to the end is insane"
[7.0] "Very very funny that the future Styles/Ciampa feud is coming because of this match. Logan Paul sadly better at this than I? d like to admit. Dude has something to offer in ring."
[7.0] "I really don't like the fact that Logan Paul is kind of good at this but here we are... I still hope he doesn't show up in WWE anymore though the vibes are too bad"
[8.0] "I really hate to admit that Logan's performance impressed me; I really wanted to hate him. Great pacing throughout, the moonsault was awesome, his frog splash looked like an Art Barr frog splash. I'd say this is up there with the best celebrity matches."
[8.0] "I can? t deny that Logan Paul impressed the hell out of me. He definitely has a lot of potential if he kept working on it, and that? s speaking from a unbiased perspective. Although the promos before Summerslam were a bit hit or miss, the match ended up being pretty entertaining. If Logan was made a heel, he would be interesting to watch. Miz did a spectacular job making Logan look good. Although my expectations were low, they were exceeded for sure."
[7.0] "As he's done multiple times recently, the Miz carried a talented non-wrestler to a really good match. It's a big ask for anyone to have a 15 minute singles match for their second match, but Logan Paul stepped up to the plate and was hugely impressive. A few spots looked obviously choreographed, but overall it worked well, and Paul's frogsplash to the announce desk was simply epic."
[7.0] "Logan Paul impressed the hell outta me here and Miz did his usual stuff, which is usually pretty good. Great showing for Paul and I think he has a bright future in WWE."
[7.0] "A strong match here, good tempo. The mocking kicks from Miz and Paul I thought was a really nice touch to the match. Some really good high spots and some great bumps. Logan Paul is proving with matches like this that WWE were correct to give him a contract."
[10.0] "I don? t care what anyone says, this match was stupendous. Perfect first singles match for Paul and everything went perfect. The frog splash through the table was crazy aswell. Miz establishing himself as a legend."
[8.0] "I want to congratulate Logan Paul. He trained with passion and commitment and had a good match. He is not technically clean, but he has no fear and is very athletic. Very entertaining this match."
[7.0] "In my opinion, this time, all the limits of Logan Paul appeared crystal clear. Anyway, thanks to the work of the Miz, the match is more than just satisfactory and tell a decent story."
[10.0] "In my opinion, it was genuinely booked match to intriduce some new superstar, even if he is a internet mega star, to the wrestling fans. Perfect moment for AJ's interference, memorable spot and reallu good stuff to watch in general. And yeah, The Miz is a legend!"
[10.0] "I don't care, that was awesome. Aside for some greenness in basic offense from Paul, like kicks, great showing from him. Nicely booked without overdoing it."
[8.0] "Logan Paul is really good at wrestling. He might just be a babyface after all if he keeps this up. Miz has a reputation for being a poor worker but he did well here."
[7.0] "This was fun. I don't want to see Logan Paul wrestle every week, keep him to attractions like this where his weaknesses don't get exposed. He certainly springboards better than others recently."
[8.0] "I expected absolutely nothing from this match, because matches with famous personalities turn out to be very incomprehensible, but everything turned out fine here. Logan has shown himself to be a true professional who has given many years to the industry.Miz, as a true professional, worked well with Logan. I hope that Logan will continue to evolve and please us"
[9.0] "Screw it, this was incredible. I never expected to give a 9 rating to Logan Paul vs The Miz, but here we are. I knew this would be good after how well Logan did at WM, but this was above and beyond my expectations. Logan moves like a young AJ Styles. He hits all his moves remarkably well for somebody of any experience level, let alone a rookie. He is better at most of his spots than guys who have a decade plus worth of experience over him. There were some small moments of awkwardness but not enough to detract from the match. Logan Paul does have a minor issue with rushing, but that is to be expected for somebody of his experience level. The interference with Ciampa and Styles actually detracted from how well Miz and Logan were doing. If Logan Paul was a nobody debuting in NXT for the first time everybody would be praising him as a future WWE Champion, and I say that as somebody who was fully prepared to hate him prior to WM. This match was a phenomenal achievement."
[7.0] "One of the only moments when famous people have debuted on proffesional wrestling and have done such a good job. All the admiration to The Miz and Logan for putting this pretty watchable match. I have to say that Logan is still very green, he needs to keep working and improving, mainly on not damaging others with his own moves. The end of the match was great, and the crowd made a huge pop for the winner. A pretty satisfactory match. [***3/4]"
[7.0] "It legitimately annoys me how good Logan Paul is. I wanted to hate him, truly, but he's just too good. He killed his role as a heel at wrestlemania, but i believed he could never make it as a face. But damnit he killed it here again. His moves were pretty basic, but done incredibly well. His storytelling and character work were on point. Spots like the frog splash and the turnbuckle were legitimately memorable moments on the show. No doubt Miz carried him somewhat here, but he's already so good its hard to even tell. Best Celeb wrestler ever? Maybe."