[6.0] "One of the better Austin Theory matches I've watched. Not even anything special but Mustafa Ali makes this a watchable one. I have no interest in seeing Theory with this title but at least this was watchable. I get that Ali got this match because it's his hometown, but I honestly would've booked him to win the belt. He's long overdue one..."
[7.0] "A good match that wakes up the crowd with the local Ali. Theory attempted a Spanish Fly while sitting on the top rope and made it look great. (3*1/2)"
[6.0] "Pretty solid match that never kicked into the next gear. Whats disappointing is that I know these two are capable of a much better match. Regardless, this was still a fairly fun match and a good penultimate match before the absolutely epic main event."
[5.0] "A decent match that could have been a good or even great match if the booking hadn't made the babyface so impotent leading up to this. Both talents are great but one of them comes out of this completely and utterly worthless while the other isn't especially more over now than before."
[7.0] "This was a pretty good match that served the purpose formulated by the creative which is to push Theory as the next young prospect. I get that perspective, but I truly felt that Ali was the better person here. He talks the talk better than Theory, gives a great match against most of the current stars and fits both sides of the coin so well. He is a perfect foil for a star who can meteorically rise to the creamy top. But he doesn't get the respect he used to get during his days in 205 Live and I don't know why. The action was very good, Ali had a wonderful crowd reception & this was the perfect time to hit the trigger, but it is what it is. 3.25 out of 5 stars!"
[7.0] "Good match, but Ali should've won. Hometown crowd aside, Ali is just a tremendous talent, and it's a shame to see Theory pushed over him. Oh well. Vince gonna Vince I guess."
[7.0] "I thought the finish could have been executed a little better against Ali, but I do think the actual wrestling was really good and as much as I don't like Theory as a person he is a good wrestler and Ali was able to mesh with him really well. ***1/2"
[7.0] "Above-average match that felt like it belonged more on RAW than late into a PPV. Mustafa really brought it, probably especially due to being the hometown hero. Theory has had better outings, but he kept up and it was still solid. The finish was a little deflating but it made sense, though I hope both these guys continue to be showcased."
[6.0] "Don? t get the point of this. Ali shows out, gets a decent reaction, has his hometown inspired gear, outwrestles theory the entire match, and then loses clean. If theory really is the future like everyone says he is, I? m worried for wwe in 5 years. Ali managed to get a good match out of him here tho. Deserves better. ***"
[7.0] "How beautiful Mustafa Ali looked, I understand why fans want a more respected attitude for him and he works out every fight achieving success and respect through blood and sweat. He was close to triumph in his hometown, but all the bullying before that made itself felt and the badass Theory after The Unproven Cutter was able to win. I really love such fights with a lot of inner athleticism and the ability to show completely sharpened skills of a particular style without looking up for something superfluous. Bravo!"
[6.0] "The wrestling was fine here, if unspectacular. They're trying with Ali, he got a boost from being the hometown guy here, but I'm not sure he's ever going to really get over as a top guy. Theory did some cool stuff in the ring, but it feels like they're forcing him into a spot he doesn't really belong in yet, kind of reminiscent of the first couple years of Randy Orton's career. That said, it worked out just fine for Randy, so maybe in five or ten years we'll look back and see that it made sense."
[6.0] "Some good high spots in this match, I for one enjoy Theorys heel work, both Wrestlers put in strong amounts of effort for an entertaining but forgettable match"
[4.0] "Mustafa Ali is a very talented guy (and he's got a great backstory), so of course they go with the hyper-generic Austin Theory (I refuse to just use his last name. That's patently ridiculous) who looks like a base design in a WWE video game for a CAW. I don't get it. Theory has negative charisma and he's still kind of green (although not bad, but you can see the holes in his work), so obviously, he's the one who gets the push."
[8.0] "Una lluita regular, gens espectacular, simplement compleix la seva comesa; Theory amb un exercici fantāstic i Mustafa ho intenta, ni malament ni bé"
[9.0] "Both proving they can carry top-of-the-card match, even though Ali being from Chicago for sure helped to make the crowd invested. Smooth clean wrestling with a several cool spots."
[6.0] "This was maybe the lowest rated match of the card, but even that giving us a satisfactory match. A bit skippable, showing a surprising very strong Mustafa, with a winner Theory. Satisfactory match. [***]"
[4.0] "Stunned at the mostly positive ratings here when the booking is pathetically bad. I get that it's WWE's thing to have superstars lose in their home town, but being bad often doesn't make it any less bad. The work was soulless and pointless and didn't even particularly get Ali over as a babyface or Theory over as a heel. Ali did some decent athletic stuff as usual but nobody will remember a single thing about this match a week from now. (**)"
[6.0] "I'm no Theory hater, but I think with this loss, Ali is out of WWE's plans for a while, at least that's what I think is going to happen, hopefully I'm wrong."
[7.0] "Predictable result was predictable, but they made a good job of it, and Theory is well on his way to becoming a top star. Whether Ali gets properly rehabilitated or is just seeing out his contract remains to be seen."
[6.0] "Good match. That's the story of the entire show, mostly good matches but largely forgettable. I don't think I will remember anything from it a week from tonight. Theory defends the title, nothing suprising, I think we are in for a lenghty reign."
[7.0] "Good match. Managed well and good maneuvers. I thought Mustafa Ali won, but Theory is too important for the federation. Good match and good work by both."
[6.0] "It was Mustafa Ali challenging for a title in his home town... in WWE, so you knew what would happen. Theory isn't the guy that WWE and their co-opted writers think he is."
[6.0] "Good match, Ali should have won the match tonight, Ali winning it tonight was the perfect ending to this story, Austin is improving in-ring in every PPV, and he will have a major role in the future of WWE"
[7.0] "An enjoyable match that was amplified by the crowd being very behind Mustafa Ali throughout the match. Had some cool spots and counters, I especially liked Ali countering the A-Town-Down into an STF towards the end. Theory winning was fairly obvious but Ali looked the most credible he has since coming back. Hopefully they find something else for him after this. Good match. [***1/2]"