[4.0] "I don't think it's necessarily a stinker. But it went on a lot longer than it should've. I don't care at all for either wrestler in this match so I couldn't really get invested into it. When you include that, and the fact that Corbin looked as bland as ever here it's just not going to produce anything of good quality here."
[6.0] "A solid stipulation match between these two, which surprised me. Moss has managed to join the elite class of wrestlers to give Corbin a good singles match. I wish Moss would swap Madcap with Riddick and get a touch of personality in his gear, but I also dont care that much about him to get that upset about it. Overall, this was an entertaining match that did good in showcasing the more aggressive side of Moss."
[7.0] "I don't get the low score here. Their characters might haven't been the most interesting but has the tools to entertain the crowd and get a decent reaction. That's what happened here when the match started but moving on, the action got nastier and rapid which was a pleasant surprise for the crowd. The crowd was into the finishing stretch as Moss silenced his final rust and served revenge. 3.5 out of 5 stars!"
[2.0] "God, this was trash. Went on for wayyyy too long. Madcap would've been better served had he come in and just annihilated Corbin in 5 minutes or less. Much like Lashley leaving Omos in the dust, I'm hoping Moss can finally move onto a program that isn't complete ass."
[6.0] "Corbin's matches are always so bland and usually just the same wandering around the ring throwing punches and occasionally hitting big moves. This was no exception except Madcap is starting to come into his own. ***"
[7.0] "No idea why this is rated so low, this was pretty fun! Sure, both characters are on life support, but this seemed exactly like the type of match that needed to happen to turn Madcap around. Moss brought a lot of fire and intensity and showed a bit of an edge that will help him grow from his jokester character. He destroyed Corbin and Corbin was there for it. Hopefully, they use this to build on both characters (away from each other0, but this was a good chapter in the story and a solid PPV match."
[6.0] "Kept my interest. Didn? t overstay it? s welcome, really cool ending with moss mauling corbin. These 2 aren? t bad in ring by any stretch they just have the worst characters. Would love to see both of them get a reset, and hopefully do better things. ***1/4"
[7.0] "Forget the dumb gimmicks these guys have, this was a really good match. Riddick Moss showed some unreal intensity here and Baron Corbin was there to get obliterated, which is great!"
[7.0] "That's what I expected in my best fantasies, a fast and fun hardcore match. That's just how it should be as a result of such a confrontation. Very pleasantly surprised. Happy Corbin looked quite harmonious and did not spoil the overall impression at all. Madcap Moss, as I have written repeatedly, can potentially be a big star and he proves that he can work seriously and at the same time in different roles. A good ending to the feud."
[5.0] "The problem with this isn't the work these guys can do, or the match type. The problem is that both of them have terrible gimmicks, and it makes it difficult to care very much who wins or how they do it. If you can overlook the gimmicks, it was an okay enough match."
[7.0] "Brutal match, but the low rating is because people don't care about the performers. If you replace Madcap with Jon Moxley people would give this match a 9"
[3.0] "A terminally boring affair. Madcap Moss, without the gimmick look and Robin Williams suspenders is now all in black. He's just a guy now. I'm not saying I was the biggest fan of the gimmick, but it was something different at least... Baron Corbin really isn't all that interesting, either, but at least he has a unique look. The match was the typical boring WWE TV match. At least there was a clean finish."
[8.0] "Un combat bo, a seques, en què Corbin va ser fantàstic com sempre i que va servir per demostrar el gran poderío que posseeix Moss; totalment decebedor que la rematada de Corbin s'hagi tornat inútil"
[5.0] "A decent match even though I expected to see more, like every time there is a No Holds Barred or no disqualification match in general in WWE right now. Madcap Moss is finally rid of Happy Corbin, and he can finally be taken seriously. [**3/4]"
[8.0] "They put on a good match. The story for Moss' redemption was there, the use of chairs also fit their program. Corbin plays the crowd incredibly well, Madcap also starts to grow into his face character."
[8.0] "Another good match for this great event. Corbin has been consistently giving good matches at PPV's, and Madcap Moss looked great with this stipulation, it's good to see new stars in the near horizon of WWE. Good match. [****1/4]"
[6.0] "Good thing they gave Madcap the win, I just hope they know how to take him down a safe path where he gets away from the ''ridiculousness'' of WWE when he does those joke segments and such."
[8.0] "The match itself was very good. Brutal as it should be with a variety of spots and objects used. I think Moss didn't use a table because it was saved for the Main Event. Overall, it reached up to a 7. However, Moss really got his new gimmick over as a fiery babyface while supporting the fact that this was personal to him. That last part gace the match another +1."
[4.0] "Well, Moss looked better without the gimmick, but that's about it for positives from this match. It was the usual sanitised WWE attempt at a no-DQ match, something they're better off not doing at all if they can't do them properly. There was little actual wrestling and none of the blood and weapons that this sort of match needs. Both men did what they could within the limitations, but it still wasn't worth watching."
[6.0] "Another just good match on this show. The most basic No Holds Barred match you can put on but everything was executed as it should be and it had a finish that worked with the story they had."
[7.0] "I find that Madcap and Corbin have done a good job. It wasn't beautiful, but a good match certainly. They used the weapons well and perfect ending, good job."
[5.0] "Shows you how bad SmackDown has been lately that this was the only match from the show that got on this card. Hopefully Moss goes on to develop his own personality and more importantly changes his name."
[6.0] "Again, a hot crowd elevated this a bit more, but they did solid work in the ring too. Legit put over Moss in a good way. Not as bad as you'd think."
[6.0] "This exceeded my meager expectations. It was a fun little brawl that was centered around chairs. They did some basic but effective spots with them, and Corbin denying the crowd a table was a great way to get him heat. The finish is a great way to hopefully conclude this feud, with Moss crushing Corbin's neck with the stairs in a similar vein to how Corbin did to Moss earlier in the feud. Decent enough. [***]"
[4.0] "An under average match, why this match happing again, the only good thing was that they put Moss over, this feud should have ended in any Smackdown after Backlash"