DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?

Shawn Michaels vs. Vince McMahon

Match

Match Data
7.45
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 334
Number of comments: 67
10.0 3x
9.0 49x
8.0 106x
7.0 127x
6.0 43x
5.0 4x
4.0 0x
3.0 0x
2.0 1x
1.0 1x
0.0 0x
Average rating: 7.45  [334]
Average rating in 2026: 7.41  [49]
Average rating in 2025: 7.51  [51]
Average rating in 2024: 7.56  [52]
Average rating in 2023: 7.36  [47]
Average rating in 2022: 7.69  [29]
Average rating in 2021: 6.80  [15]
Average rating in 2020: 7.29  [14]
Average rating in 2019: 7.00  [7]
Average rating in 2018: 7.25  [8]
Average rating in 2017: 7.17  [6]
Average rating in 2016: 7.69  [13]
Average rating in 2015: 7.11  [9]
Average rating in 2014: 7.50  [4]
Average rating in 2013: 6.00  [1]
Average rating in 2012: 6.00  [1]
Average rating in 2011: 8.00  [2]
Average rating in 2010: 8.00  [3]
Average rating in 2009: 8.00  [7]
Average rating in 2008: 7.81  [16]
Your Options:
Other:
Leo the goat wrote on 13.11.2026:
[7.0] "A thoroughly entertaining, cathartic 7/10 sports-entertainment spectacle that turned a simple grudge brawl into pure Attitude Era theatre. Stepping into Chicago's Allstate Arena after months of Vince McMahon tormenting him--including forcing him to kiss his ass and firing Marty Jannetty--Shawn Michaels delivered a masterclass in babyface showmanship and brutal plunder pacing. Clocking in at over 18 minutes, it never dragged despite McMahon's obvious physical limitations at 60 years old. Vince bumped like a maniac, bladed deeply, and survived interference from both the Spirit Squad and Shane McMahon (who ate a wicked chair shot and a coast-to-coast dropkick/trash can spot of his own), before Michaels pulled out a towering ladder, draped a trash can over Vince's head, and hit an iconic diving elbow drop straight through a table--punctuated by a crotch chop before drilling Vince with Sweet Chin Music for the clean pinfall. Ridiculous, violent, and wildly fun."
KSAHZ8 wrote on 04.10.2026:
[8.0] "A fun match, definitely better than Hogan vs. McMahon at Mania 19. Michaels obviously carries McMahon through the entire match. Some stiff spots throughout, Michaels jumping off the ladder through the table to finish the match was a picture perfect finish. Lost a point for the Spirit Squad spot as it wasn't really needed. The classic middle finger spot from McMahon as he was stretchered out was great too."
BradJohnson34 wrote on 17.09.2026:
[8.0] "Tons of fun. Incredible how hard Shawn hits Vince with the steel chair (in the head) and with Vince's own belt. And what a high spot for the finish. Hard to drag anything out that long without any kind of hope spot but it works here and the crowd is hot for it."
Raditz Flair wrote on 08.04.2026:
[6.0] "Shawn Michaels does a lot of physical things, Vince does nothing and it's actually watchable. The build up to this was shitty but this match is fun."
mikewillruhl03 wrote on 03.04.2026:
[6.0] "This was pretty ridiculous. I don't really enjoy the Vince McMahon Mania matches but this was definitely better than most of them. Shawn Michaels could wrestle a mop and have a great match in 2006 so it's not surprising Vince can take a beating and just corpse throughout this match. The higher score is really only for the giant ladder elbow drop by HBK, Mr. Mania beat the Chairman. ***"
WG20 wrote on 31.03.2026:
[7.0] "A fun match. Shawn carries the match whilst Vince gets help from Shane and the Spirit Squad. The elbow drop off the ladder through the table will always be iconic."
DecentWrestling wrote on 19.03.2026:
[9.0] "This match is extremely entertaining start to finish. From Shawn smashing the poster over Vince's head to Spirit Squad's fun cameo, Mikey's dancing sent me lol, Shane getting his face shoved in Vince's ass, All the way to the incredible Elbow Drop off the ladder through the table with Vince in a trash can. Vince, ever the entertainer was cartoonishly over the top making this so fun. He was so giddy mocking Bret and then trying to do the Sweet Chin Music. Lots of good revenge with Shawn whipping Vine with a belt and also handcuffing Shane to the ropes and doing the Shane shuffle lmao before beating him with a kendo stick, good stuff. The chairshot to Vince's head was BRUTAL. Even the post-match was entertaining with Vince giving an iconic middle finger while just a pool of blood on a stretcher. This is what you call Sports Entertainment and I loved it. Far better than Edge vs Foley."
Sweet Fighter V wrote on 15.03.2026:
[8.0] "Another one of those batshit crazy WrestleMania matches from Vince. It's a glorified squash with Vince receiving the ass-whooping of his life, and it's awesome! This is comedy gold. From Vince's entrance and JR hilariously hating on him, Vince showing off a picture of himself, getting blasted with it, him being a troll, Spirit Squad getting single-handedly kicked out by Shawn, Shane joining the "kiss my ass club", getting handcuffed and watching his father bleed buckets, get his head blasted by a home run of a chair shot and by a ladder, Shawn teasing the crowd before finally delivering that stupendous final spot, Vince getting stretched out and giving Shawn the middle finger... Damn, this is so much fun! Call me crazy, but this is even more brutal than that Hardcore match between Edge and Foley earlier. ****"
SkyIcons wrote on 03.03.2026:
[7.0] "Shawn being able to have a good match with Vince solidifies his spot as Mr Wrestlemania. Lot of bullshit in here, but it works."
Keithnelson18 wrote on 31.12.2025:
[7.0] "This was an entertaining match to watch. Shawn just beat the shit outta Vince here. Probably one of Vince's best matches ever. It was mostly Michaels throughout this whole match and Vince only got his comebacks when Shane and Spirit Squad help him. The two highlights was that chair shot to Vince and the elbow drop from the top of a ladder through tables."
Brye wrote on 22.11.2025:
[9.0] "Shawn Michaels is a miracle worker. Getting this good of a match out of Vince, especially at that age, is downright insane. He is the GOAT seller in my eyes and really made Vince and all his underhanded tactics look good. And the elbow drop through the table is one of the most iconic spots of the 2000s."
Porcelain8 wrote on 12.07.2025:
[10.0] "Straight up one of my favourite Mania matches. Highly cathartic, regularly funny, and full credit for some of the gnarly stuff Vince took here. You'd think this wasn't the best use of Michaels at Wrestlemania, but I can't agree with that since I'm here giving it a 10 regardless. It's the ultimate match that is really a segment. As usual with the McMahons in this era, the only problem is that it is merely the beginning of a storyline it ought to have ended perfectly, but that doesn't detract from this night."
KKeanel wrote on 25.04.2025:
[9.0] "Quintessence of 2003-2007 Vince's pure evil character. Shawn as a great performer helped to handle this match from in-ring quality. Additionally, Spirit Squad and Shane as a Vince's saviours combined with his classic stuff and whole "Mcmahonism" background delivered good enterteiment. This middle finger after the match with Michaels' music and JR's commentary really hit. Minus for boring fragments and dumb logic with Shane's handcuffs."
TrailsOfPersona wrote on 03.04.2025:
[5.0] "These Vince beatdown matches just can only be so good. And while this is one of the better versions of that match, or maybe even the best, it still has an upper limit. It's exactly what you saw from Austin around the time of WM15, Hogan at WM19, and Undertaker at Survivor Series before WM20. It goes on too long. They took match time away from matches that could have used it better. Namely the triple threat for the World Heavyweight title. It's not bad at all, and seeing Shawn get this intense again was cool, but if you've seen it once, you've seen them all."
Wrestlingfan0808 wrote on 01.04.2025:
[9.0] "The similarities to when Vince faced Steve Austin during the cage match back in 99 I believe during the Valentines Day massacre and to this, with two of the biggest stars in the companys history just getting ample time to beat the hell out of Vince. This ruled. Jr mentioning how Shawn turned to a place he hasnt been since like 97 was a nice touch during this match. The little things jr would say on commentary would add so much to a match. Hes the best for a reason. The closing shot of Vince get stretchered away sticking up the middle finger was hilarious. ****1/4"
urrklz878 wrote on 29.03.2025:
[5.0] "It's not a match, it's just a beatdown and eighteen minutes is way too long for that. There was some good stuff, Shawn blasting Vince in the head with the picture was funny and the elbow drop off the bigger ladder is a great finish but there wasn't a whole lot else to it."
Jman7 wrote on 16.03.2025:
[7.0] "This match is pretty much just Vince getting beat up by Shawn for 20 minutes, and it was so much fun. The set-up for the big elbow drop off the ladder felt like it took a little too long, but the actual spot was incredible. ***3/4"
bigredtalk89 wrote on 14.03.2025:
[7.0] "I don't know about this match, it's fun for what it is, but doesn't feel like much of a match, just a prolonged ass kicking. Vince is more of a prop than an opponent. It's also disturbing that the man who books the shows agreed to having his sons face shoved into his ass, but given what we know about Vince...maybe I shouldn't be surprised."
charlierosegold wrote on 11.03.2025:
[8.0] "A beautiful mess. Shawn Michaels was my second ever favourite wrestler, and shit like this was why. Vince Mcmahon absolutely loves getting killed by his children, as he thinks it's the natural way of the world. He screamed at Shane to stab him and take the company, he wrote himself getting increasingly owned by Paul for most of 1999, and now he's here to get smeared into the dirt by his oldest and favouritest son Shawn Michaels. I bet he felt so proud of his boy."
lonecub101 wrote on 14.11.2024:
[9.0] "20 minutes of Vince getting the hell beat out of him and Shawn jumping off a giant ladder, what else can you ask for. This was near perfection."
brooksavage2004 wrote on 13.10.2024:
[9.0] "An amazing and insanely entertaining match between both men with really amazing action and psychology between both men and it was ever so satisfying seeing Michaels give Vince what he deserved."
JacquesRougeauCanHaveMyWife wrote on 08.07.2024:
[8.0] "That's exactly how you use Mr. McMahon's character. For some reason they failed to understand that since Austin in 1999 and all these years either Vince was dominating or the matches were competitive. Here Michaels beat McMahon down, humiliated him and didn't give him the slightest chances and the crowd loved it, because they wanted to see that - who would have thought? Shawn was great here, he was oozing with charisma and the Elbow Drop from the ladder looked phenomenal, plus Shane watching all of that was a nice touch."
RealGrapsThomsen wrote on 20.05.2024:
[7.0] "This was. Pretty fun match but not much more than that. It was most a really long and overbooked brawl with weapons. Shawn was able to win with a elbow drop off the ladder onto Vince in a trash can."
HardcoreRobbo2k97 wrote on 23.02.2024:
[5.0] "Not the best match in Wrestlemania history as it was more of a fight/brawl than telling a story because Heel Vince in 2006 was embarrassing and not entertaining what so ever this match proved that and also proved that the Spirit Squad weren't good enough to be a main feature on WWE programming before the end of 2006."
Heartbreakkid2003 wrote on 13.09.2023:
[7.0] "One of the better Vince McMahon matches and its not surprise given who he was wrestling on this night. Shawn carried Vince to a solid street fight with some smoke and mirrors thrown in. Shawn did a great job showing intensity and anger which given the build up made sense I got a soft spot for this match given that this is one of the first manias I ever saw as a kid and for that Ill give it 3.75/5"
jlkclxrke wrote on 16.05.2023:
[10.0] "One of my favorite matches of ALL-TIME. If you were a 6 year old wrestling fan (HBK was my guy) watching this you'd understand why it was a 10. Absolute masterpiece from Shawn Michaels"
zachattack2023 wrote on 03.02.2023:
[8.0] "This match is so fun to watch not a classic by any means but it has so many fun moments and it is just fun to watch. ****"
eBento wrote on 08.11.2022:
[8.0] "Pure popcorn entertainment from beginning to end. Shawn Michaels absolutely goes wild towards the end of this match and Vince's selling is at its best here."
TigerDiver wrote on 09.05.2022:
[7.0] "Seeing Vince McMahon getting beaten up will always guarantee entertainment. But seeing him get beat up for over 75% of the match? That's even more entertaining! Though you could paint this as being an alleged handicap match and you wouldn't be wrong, Shawn having to overcome all the odds made for a textbook wrestling story to follow. Vince took all of HBK's moves like a boss (no pun intended), and this might be his best performance ever. Shawn taking his long-ass time setting up all the furniture in the final minutes might be too long for some, but that giant elbow drop off the ladder made it all worth it. Overall, a very good brawl with tons of entertaining spots that will keep you engaged throughout. [***1/2]"
Makoto92 wrote on 06.04.2022:
[10.0] "I absolutely love this match. This is freaking entertainment. Shawn, who beats the ass of The Chairman Himself, is absolute hero of this story. All the people played their roles perfectly. Overbooking things with Shane and Spirit Squad were very logic. I was "spoertsentertained" for sure."
4outof5 wrote on 25.02.2022:
[7.0] "A fun and funny match that probably wasn't the best use of HBK at the biggest show of the year, but still one of the better matches on the show."
KingofKings5632 wrote on 02.07.2021:
[9.0] "This WrestleMania was, in my opinion, highlighted by the two "garbage" matches of the show. This was the weaker of the two, but it was still a lot of fun. This felt very much in the style of McMahon, with a lot of interference and gimmicks thrown around to hide his lack of actual skill. It worked really well, especially considering he was in the ring with Michaels, who can make anybody look great. To his credit though, McMahon took some insane bumps and it was very cathartic to see the evil McMahon character be destroyed like this. The Trash can / Table spot is legendary and isn't talked about enough IMO."
cactus wrote on 19.05.2021:
[8.0] "Never before had I seen a villain getting their comeuppances to be as satisfying as Shawn Michaels humiliating and destroying Vince McMahon here, Vince isn't afraid to take some stiff shots and bleed buckets. That violent ladder shot to the head almost made me feel bad for batshit billionaire! The Spirit Squad rushes the ring to save Vince, but HBK is able to eventually fight them all off. Although it's total McMahon low-brow humor, I popped huge for Shawn shoving Shane's face right into his father's exposed arse. Talk about commitment to the role. Shawn takes forever building up to the grand finale, but the big elbow drop from the top of the 20-foot ladder through the table made it worthwhile."
NastyYaffa wrote on 10.04.2021:
[1.0] "Man I just didn't care at all for this. The Spirit Squad interference leading to Michaels getting beaten down & then the looooong segment before the finish where Michaels gets his revenge on Vince.. It just wasn't interesting at all. Really the best thing about it all was Vince getting carried out on a stretcher, but still showing HBK the finger on his way out. Great final image 'twas, good match this was not."
kcharles520 wrote on 17.01.2021:
[7.0] "Hogan's Wrestlemania match with Vince was way better than HBK's. Go figure. Even so, this was a pretty entertaining 'massacre' of McMahon. Less of a match and more HBK just beating the hell out of Vince. Parts of the match are hilarious too as McMahon was almost more cartoonish than evil here at times."
KENTAfan wrote on 30.01.2020:
[7.0] "This actually won a match of the year award, which I horrendously disagree with, but it was alright. It was basically HBK beating the shit out of Vince for a good 80% of the match, Which actually wasn't half bad to watch. Additionally, they accomplished exactly what they needed to for the storyline. Appreciated it for what it was. ***1/4"
Makai Club wrote on 13.03.2019:
[2.0] "I get why people may like this match but this wasn't for me. But I absolutely don't care about HBK at all and Vince is borderline parody which sucks. Tons of shitty plunder wrestling that wasn't interesting to watch and was over booked to death. Yet another unimpressive match for Mr WrestleMania. How ironic. *1/2"
owenc510 wrote on 10.10.2018:
[9.0] "This match was big fun and was poetic justice to Mr McMahon. Michaels starts right off beating down McMahon before the match started. McMahon, in a way, got some leverage after The Spirit Squad came out and attacked Michaels. Their dancing was stupid but kinda funny. Kenny Dykstra went up top for the Guillotine Leg drop but Michaels moved and got momentum again. There was a really cool spot when Michaels threw Kenny over the top rope making him do a Tope onto the rest of the Spirit Squad. Michaels was building up to a Sweet Chin Music but McMahon's second wave of defense in Shane McMahon came out and hit Michaels with a kendo stick. Another great spot was when Michaels was about to have to kiss Mr McMahon's ass but instead he stuck Shane's face in. Mr McMahon was quite funny the way he was playing it up. Michaels really just beat down McMahon for the last few minutes before dealing the final blows. He got a massive ladder and put McMahon with a trashcan on his head onto a table and hit an elbow drop from the top of the ladder to a huge pop. He finally finished by Knocking McMahon's teeth down his throat with a Sweet Chin Music."
SrHunter wrote on 19.04.2017:
[7.0] "Michaels doing his Wrestlemania magic, this obviously wasn't a great match in terms of wrestling, but damn sure was entertaining, also the Elbow drop spot deverves to be mentioned, it was great . I liked the Michaels/Vince feud, and later on the DX/McMahon's, entertaining as fuck, i settle this one with ***1/2."
blackgoku wrote on 13.03.2017:
[8.0] "Man can Mr. McMahon take a beating. The elbow drop at the end was incredible. The stuff with Shane was a little messed up."
jackleone wrote on 17.09.2016:
[8.0] "I'd never believe to give 4 stars to a McMahon match (remembering how much I hate that much versus Hulk Hogan) but this is good stuff, it's pure storytelling and Shawn Michaels is perfect as the 'hero' of the match. There are hints about the return of the D-X here. ****"
Mizzle Assault Ant wrote on 27.03.2016:
[5.0] "This didn't hold up nearly as well as I hoped it would, there is definitely some good stuff in there, especially Vince's pompous posturing and subsuquent willingness to take a beating, but so much of this match is Michaels just slowly wandering around looking for various weapons, I mean it's really excessive at some points. I could have also done without seeing Vince rub his nearly bare ass into his own son's face, story or not that's pretty messed up when you think about it. I'm generally a fan of Vince matches but I can't help but think on the rewatch that this is somewhat overrated."
TrevPuroFan wrote on 25.03.2016:
[8.0] "This was a fun little hardcore brawl. Shawn Michaels brought an awesome match out of Vince, and Vince is just awesome at taking a beating. Great match with HBK unleashing his emotions. ***3/4"