[3.0] "An angle more than a match, the action revolved around Samoa Joe fighting three men without bothering to tag out while Jeff Jarrett was rooting him on so comically aggressively that the eventual swerve was far too obvious. This is the kind of bullshit that gave TNA a bad reputation."
[2.0] "This match was garbage. This felt like a match that should be on TV, not on your biggest PPV of the year. Then Jarrett walking out made things a whole lot worse. Just a nothing match on your biggest stage of the year."
[2.0] "Such an utterly bizarre match to put two of TNA's main headliners (Sting and Joe), and then it turns out it was booked this way just to facilitate a heel turn. And if Sting & Nash were proven to be telling the good guys all along, why did they keep wrestling afterwards? ! This was a pretty clear burial of Joe and a bad use of Sting."
[2.0] "Joe losing in another notable spot under Russos bad creative for him in a largely nothing match with a bizarre dynamic even before the swerve that happened later in the show. What a last match for Kevin Nash in his run in TNA."
[4.0] "Pope and Joe do their best, but they can't save this match from mediocrity, as there are several points when the old men are just fighting in a nondescript way. You feel that this could have at least been interesting if Hulk Hogan had been the third man on the face team as planned. Ends in some story with Jeff Jarrett walking out on his partner to set up the Immortal reveal later in the night."