[5.0] "I don't mind this being a technical match, since X Division should have no limits, including a limit on the amount of technical wrestling in a match. What I do mind is that it ended rather abruptly and the finish was unconvincing. Especially in the replay it looked like Doug Williams murdered Jay Lethal with a frankensteiner and then they flipped over with zero momentum into the pin."
[6.0] "A solid match even if the pairing is not one that might expect as an X Division title match. Doug was very underrated and I do wish he got to have even more of a proper singles run in TNA. A fine match in the midcard that did what it was supposed to largely even if there wasnt a lot of crowd heat at points."
[6.0] "It's a decent match, yes, but it's not an X Division match. Doug Williams was inserted into the division apparently to make it a bit slower, which kind of defeats the purpose. The tag team match was more X Division than this. Still, Lethal's over as a babyface, and you can't argue with that. Shame that immediately after the match he gets punked out by Robbie E (at the peak of his go-away heat) and made to look like just a guy. Gee, I wonder why he quit within three months after this. Can't possibly think why..."