[2.0] "The real problem here was that we have two babyfaces (Angelina & Velvet) who clearly worked and ironed things out, recently taking on two heels (Madison & Tara) that were basically BFF's as a tight-knitted group. It didn't help that Angelina and Velvet came down the entrance aisle together and Madison & Tara did as well. So basically, we had a no thrills 4-way match that might as well be a tag match instead. There is just nothing of note to talk about. Even having Mickie as the ref, didn't even add much to the match at all. Nothing here is interesting to even worth warranting about, apart from the roll-up finish."
[4.0] "The format hurt this with two hostile teams involved and the need for tagging, but with all four women technically for themselves.Would've worked better if it was under elimination rules and not one fall. The action was basically acceptable women's fare for the time."
[3.0] "Not a good showing for the KOs division on what is normally TNAs biggest stage. Tara winning was a saving grace of sorts even if it wasnt in the most impressive fashion."
[3.0] "Its a uh, match I guess? Nothing really happened that I can remember and I just watched it not even 10 minutes ago. Not like bad sloppy just bad boring. 2.5/10"
[2.0] "This was a really bad showing for the Knockouts division. Pretty much every move was either botched or looked really weak. Tara was okay, though that awful looking roll-up she won with kinda overshadowed her passable performance. Mickie was a decent enough ref at least."
[2.0] "Loses a point instantly for being a tag-type four-way, a rule type that I feel breaks the flow of a match too often. This is a tale of two pairs of workers. Tara and Angelina are good. Madison isn't. Velvet... really, really isn't. Every spot seems to be botched when Velvet is in town. Fittingly, she's in for the weird finish. The standard four-way finisher chain ends with Tara notably not hitting Widow's Peak on Velvet (which would make sense), but winning with a roll-up. Only two problems there. First, she's got a handful of tights in FULL VIEW of babyface guest referee Mickie James, and Mickie still counts the pin. Second, Tara visibly applies barely any pressure so Velvet could kick out easily. Worst part? This match was invalidated on the NEXT IMPACT where Madison coerced Tara into a Fingerpoke of Doom."