DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?

Chris Benoit vs. Randy Orton

Match

Match Data
Date:
15.08.2004
WON rating:
****1/4
Match type:
7.88
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 220
Number of comments: 44
10.0 8x
9.0 46x
8.0 105x
7.0 47x
6.0 10x
5.0 2x
4.0 0x
3.0 0x
2.0 0x
1.0 2x
0.0 0x
Average rating: 7.89  [220]
Average rating in 2026: 7.62  [21]
Average rating in 2025: 7.70  [30]
Average rating in 2024: 7.74  [39]
Average rating in 2023: 8.16  [31]
Average rating in 2022: 7.88  [16]
Average rating in 2021: 7.92  [12]
Average rating in 2020: 8.06  [18]
Average rating in 2019: 8.00  [8]
Average rating in 2018: 8.50  [12]
Average rating in 2017: 5.67  [6]
Average rating in 2016: 8.67  [3]
Average rating in 2015: 7.75  [4]
Average rating in 2014: 8.00  [3]
Average rating in 2012: 7.00  [1]
Average rating in 2011: 9.00  [1]
Average rating in 2010: 9.00  [2]
Average rating in 2009: 8.67  [6]
Average rating in 2008: 8.00  [7]
Your Options:
Other:
Sadagious wrote on 29.08.2026:
[9.0] "I disliked this match the first time I watched it, but now I realize the real problem was the crowd. Toronto is so quiet, it genuinely feels like an empty arena match. Still, it's a wonderful experienced champion vs. young superstar story. Orton cleverly weaponizes Benoit's own offense against him, and Benoit's brutal collision with the barricade gives Orton the perfect excuse to dissect his neck. Extremely psychological, with a beautiful ending to the greatest World Heavyweight Championship reign in WWE history. ****"
CMFunk007 wrote on 03.07.2026:
[6.0] "I was a huge Benoit fan before the tragic end of his life. So when they had him drop the title to a green Randy Orton, I felt he was disrespected and the booking was questionable. I still do find the booking questionable. Orton was too young and green to be champ so soon. This match was fine, but it never felt like it got out of third gear."
TrailsOfPersona wrote on 13.01.2026:
[6.0] "This is another really, really hard match for me to rate, bouncing between 6 and 7 points. It really puts Orton over well and the closing few minutes are very, very good. Benoit also takes so fantastic bumps and sells Orton's offense well. It is a very good wrestling match. Mat work, submissions, selling...it looks and feels like a fight. Just like it is supposed to. On the flip side, it is extremely slow and the pace never varies, which hurts it some. There are a lot of minor submissions that are borderline rest holds. Far too many for my taste. And it just never takes it up a notch. There are a few moments that get the crowd into it, but they are pretty quiet most of the time. Although hindsight is really the final reason I chose a 6 point score over 7. Orton was given the title at this point in time solely to stick it to Lesnar, who left 6 months before. Lesnar was the youngest world champion until Orton won this match. Orton was only a year younger, so they had to pull the trigger this year to do it. Of course, Orton would just drop it back to Triple H on the next Raw PPV, making it even more obvious and making the Reign of Terror continue. Match of the night and a superb contest, but nothing I'd consider legendary. I can see myself coming back to this and upping the score sometime, though."
Brye wrote on 01.08.2025:
[8.0] "Very good match and I remember being absolutely shocked when this happened in real-time. I didn't really think Orton had a shot but he showed out in this match and looked great. A shame his first title reign was so short and rough around the edges, but I think this was a great moment in his career that naturally can't be shown (at least in full) anymore."
Oliver95x wrote on 21.07.2025:
[8.0] "Chris Benoit vs. Randy Orton war definitiv das beste Match des Abends. Beide sind sehr systematisch vorgegangen mit viel Mattenwrestling. Es gab dann den ein oder anderen größeren Spot, wie der dive nach draußen. Das Ende kam Recht abrupt mit dem rko, es hätte gerne noch einen kickout geben können um nochmal das nächste Level an Qualität zu erreichen (****)."
DecentWrestling wrote on 20.07.2025:
[8.0] "This was a fantastic main event, both men delivered big time. Again crowd sucked, but the work was superb. I liked the out of nowhere ending, the RKO outta nowhere for the win. 0 finisher kickouts in the main event. Didn't hinder the match at all."
uselessdollthing wrote on 14.01.2025:
[5.0] "Honestly, that ending is fucking awesome, and really sells the RKO as a finisher, maybe this is the match where this finisher was truly made. But this match has too much excess to it as it has greatness to it, and its really frustrating because I know it could be better."
ShaliK wrote on 15.08.2024:
[8.0] "I had never seen this match before, I am watching it for its twentieth anniversary. A very good match with a crowd going all out behind the local Chris Benoit. Good spots during this match as well as good holds well applied. I liked it. (4*)"
Heartbreakkid2003 wrote on 20.07.2024:
[8.0] "Very good match really the only match worth coming back too watch on this show. Again a bad crowd as was the case for like the whole night no clue why but that didnt stop these two especially Benoit from putting on a show. Benoit did everything he could to make orton and the match come off as good as possible. Orton did well and the finish is one of my favorite rkos ever. 4/5"
JacquesRougeauCanHaveMyWife wrote on 19.06.2024:
[7.0] "At first I though that it would be a similar situation as in the JBL and Taker match, because the crowd didn't care much in the beginning, but a good work from both Benoit and Orton got them invested and they were giving them the standing ovation near the finish. Randy looked great, he delivered a fantastic performance that gave him a babyface aura and Benoit led him like a veteran that he was. I also loved the aftermath with Chris showing respect and how prowd he was of Orton."
imeddik wrote on 22.11.2023:
[8.0] "Very good match, high impact and smart body work. They didn't give Orton the ball until 2007 but I think he was ready right there."
Ruthless Attitude wrote on 18.10.2023:
[9.0] "Excellent match. While I have seen people say Orton won the title when he wasn't ready, I personally think he wrestled at this time like a veteran beyond his years! It was a really competitive match throughout and Benoit's intensity was always great to watch here and I just liked how smart Orton was throughout the match where Benoit misses the Tope and hits his head off the barrier and Orton does some tremendous neck work throughout the whole match! He survived several submission holds and the 6 German Suplexes was also a fantastic spot. I loved how Orton's work on the neck ultimately played to the finish of the match too where he counters the Diving Headbutt and soon after hits a sudden RKO to win. It was a hard hitting, gruelling match and the intense staredown where Benoit shows Orton respect was well earned."
flightaker321 wrote on 01.09.2023:
[8.0] "This was a great match that stayed competitive until the very end. I enjoyed their opening wrestling exchanges a lot, neither guy was really able to get the better of each other during it but their aggressiveness behind each hold was nice to see. Orton's control work was good here outside of him doing some arm work that doesn't go anywhere really. Benoit bumped his ass off to make Orton good, and that bump he took off the tope into the barricade just looked nasty. Benoit's comeback consisted of a ton of German suplexes, and submission holds but Orton was just able to survive during this. The RKO at the end genuinely came out of nowhere due to how smooth the counter was to hit it.****"
Fillosetti wrote on 20.07.2023:
[8.0] "I was expecting a good but overrated match because of the good final moment, and instead it was a very good match, very technical and full of impactful maneuvers, which to be honest are quite disturbing to see knowing what would happen to Chris Benoit 3 years later"
GMS18 wrote on 19.07.2023:
[6.0] "A good match that takes its time to put over a young star, if not a whole lot more. Benoit, as per, does some rough looking shit in this. Orton winning by himself and shaking hands with Benoit after is a nice moment. ***"
violet011 wrote on 19.07.2023:
[6.0] "Benoit takes some brutal bumps in this like the dive into the barricade and the feet up on the headbutt. Mostly though this is pretty slow and the finish is pretty anticlimactic - ***"
KH21 wrote on 01.04.2023:
[6.0] "It was a decent match but nothing worth rewatching. I thought Benoit carried it, which is understandable as Randy was only 24. The ending was abit anti climactic for me in ending benoits reign."
arrancar wrote on 25.06.2022:
[6.0] "Nothing great, especially as the match that ends Benoit's reign and begins Orton's, but still a good match. It was very methodical for the first 1/3rd, with both engaging in a lot of technical exchanges that were quite slow but still pretty entertaining because of the clean technique and aggression that both men put behind them. Orton did well showing his viciousness once he gained control, and Benoit naturally sold very well to put his work over. The final 1/3rd saw them go through some decent power moves and big-move trades. None of it was too creative, and it ultimately ended pretty anti-climactically as Benoit dominated heavily but then Orton still managed to hit the RKO ("oUt Of NoWHerE") for the win, but they both still showed solid technique and sold well as they went through those exchanges. I probably won't remember anything from this match in a month's time, but I moderately enjoyed it in real-time, at least. ***1/4"
Geo93 wrote on 02.02.2022:
[8.0] "Randy Orton earns his first World Title victory against Chris Benoit. Not as much of a star-making performance as Orton vs Foley at Backlash, but still this is a very big moment in his career. Orton keeps up with Benoit really well here and they both have great chemistry. The, "RKO OUTTA NOWHERE" was a great ending to the match, as well. It's just a shame that this title run was so short-lived."
TigerDiver wrote on 02.11.2021:
[8.0] "A great match that put Orton over big time. All the props in the world to Benoit for making young Randall look so good. Orton to his credit, stepped up his game here, finding every opportunity, every loophole to outwit Benoit. I don't think it ever got into classic territory or so, but they maintained quality actions throughout and it was never boring. The post-match where Benoit forced Orton to 'be a man' and shake his hand was awesome stuff, putting Orton over even more. [****]"
KENTAfan wrote on 11.07.2021:
[8.0] "Yeah this was a great match no doubt. Randy went in as a huge underdog and, despite being a heel, brought the fight to Benoit in a way that no one had before since Chris became champion. Benoit was forced to pull out all the stops, tossing Randy around the ring with German Suplex after German Suplex, but Orton doggedly held on and continued to kick out. Towards the end, Benoit locked in the crossface but Randy managed to escape and eventually nail Benoit with one of the smoothest transitions I've ever seen into an RKO for the win. Not a perfect match, as there were some portions of it that were unnecessarily slow, but overall this was damn good. Huge win for Orton, and the best match of the card. ****"
kcharles520 wrote on 10.12.2020:
[7.0] "You can tell Benoit went all out and gave everything he had here--but Orton's boring offense *really* dragged this match down. Benoit was taking crazy bumps and working his tail off when he was on the offense--yet Orton contributed almost nothing exciting to the match himself. The crowd was also very lukewarm for this, which didn't help matters. A good match thanks to Benoit carrying it, but nowhere near a classic."
PuroresuLover wrote on 04.06.2020:
[6.0] "Welp, that was a nice match, I must way, but I don't know, it felt like something was missing. Still, is a nice match with a good closing stretch that shocked everyone. Also, Randy started the match doing an arm work, but it didn't lead to anything. It could be a better match, but that's ok, like I said, still is a nice match. ***1/2"
Makai Club wrote on 03.12.2018:
[8.0] "The middle was a bit dull and Orton's initial arm work didn't lead to anything but these two had yet another good match, showing off their great chemistry. A highly competitive back and forth match were momentum changed back and forth, with some awesome counters and a sudden ending. A sudden ending can be bad for some but I do like a quick win every now and again; adds realism to the matches. ****"
Mizzle Assault Ant wrote on 19.06.2018:
[9.0] "Man, Orton's career is so backwards. So many of his great performances are in the early days of his career. He did very well here, but Benoit drove the match to be great."
NastyYaffa wrote on 21.01.2017:
[1.0] "This definitely didn't hold up on a re-watch - it was a total bore. Watching Orton work the heat on Benoit was incredibly boring, it was too long & sucked the life out of the match, and honestly, Benoit's shine later on wasn't any better either, it was very boring, too. All in all, a very bad, dull match. *"
jackleone wrote on 18.08.2015:
[7.0] "Slow start and a bunch of mat Wrestling, but most of the time it was a good match. The RKO 'out of nowhere' was anticlimatic. Benoit did well for the entire competition, but in the end Orton proved to be the new main star of Raw. The post-match is better than the match itself, a really great scene like the one who opened Benoit title reign. ***3/4"
yanus wrote on 14.11.2014:
[7.0] "The first half of the match is rather average, but the second half is really good. The match has overall plenty positives (hard-hitting action, good reversals, a fantastic looking missed suicide dive), but also some negatives (dead crowd, weird and abrupt finish). *** 3/4"