DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?

Eddie Guerrero vs. John Bradshaw Layfield

Match

Match Data
Date:
16.05.2004
WON rating:
***3/4
Match type:
8.72
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 298
Number of comments: 78
10.0 83x
9.0 99x
8.0 76x
7.0 34x
6.0 5x
5.0 1x
4.0 0x
3.0 0x
2.0 0x
1.0 0x
0.0 0x
Average rating: 8.73  [298]
Average rating in 2026: 8.82  [39]
Average rating in 2025: 9.00  [65]
Average rating in 2024: 8.61  [51]
Average rating in 2023: 8.76  [37]
Average rating in 2022: 8.55  [20]
Average rating in 2021: 8.79  [19]
Average rating in 2020: 9.08  [12]
Average rating in 2019: 9.33  [9]
Average rating in 2018: 8.67  [6]
Average rating in 2017: 8.40  [5]
Average rating in 2016: 8.50  [6]
Average rating in 2015: 8.40  [5]
Average rating in 2014: 10.00  [1]
Average rating in 2012: 7.67  [3]
Average rating in 2011: 8.67  [3]
Average rating in 2010: 7.40  [5]
Average rating in 2009: 8.50  [6]
Average rating in 2008: 7.50  [6]
Your Options:
Other:
Treck wrote on 09.11.2026:
[7.0] "I think the match oversatisfied because of the drama the blood added to the battle. Overall there wasn't that much content in the match, it had a really great structure and the story told was effective, however on the in-ring side it was a little bit light in my opinion. I loved the finish which was a perfect choice considering the backstory and the violence of the match. An enjoyable match kind of hard to watch at the glance of Eddie swimming in his own blood, but it made a memorable image that is still printed in many fans' minds. Good"
BlizardDemon wrote on 17.08.2026:
[7.0] "great match on what was a pretty lackluster card. the blood spewing from Eddie's head was such a visceral sight showing what these men will out on the line to have a great match. however this match , other than the over the top violence, was not anything special to give it an eight. if the rating allowed decimals then I would give it a 7.6"
Sadagious wrote on 24.07.2026:
[10.0] "I could genuinely argue this as a candidate for the greatest match in pro wrestling history. A wild, visceral, inhuman brawl. After reinventing himself as a wealthy businessman, JBL vows to succeed in the one field where he has always failed; pro-wrestling, and sets his sights on WWE Champion Eddie Guerrero, taking things so far that he causes Eddie's mother to suffer a heart attack. Eddie wants nothing less than to kill JBL in the middle of the ring. From the moment he walks through the curtain, he never takes his eyes off him, staring at him with pure disgust before beating him senseless all around ringside. Once JBL finally seizes control, he utterly dominates Eddie, cutting off every comeback with ruthless efficiency. Then, after the referee is taken out, they're finally free to unleash their hatred without restraint, leading to one of the most unforgettable moments in wrestling history: JBL's chairshot shatters the artery above Eddie's forehead, sending blood pouring from his head like a fountain. The ring is covered in blood, and to JBL this is simply business - he just wants to finish Eddie quickly, strap the title around his waist and leave, but Eddie somehow survives with two miraculous kickouts. As blood streams down his face like a waterfall, Eddie comes to life, dancing before launching an unforgettable comeback and beating JBL all over the arena. An ostentatiously rich, racist, elite villain vs. a family man, people's champion; masterclass storytelling, all-time great performances, an unmatched level of blood, hatred and violence, epic selling and an incredible post-match where Eddie beats JBL within an inch of his life. The image of JBL dropping to his knees and begging while both men are still drenched in blood & of course, the legendary chairshot- are forever burned into wrestling history. It's a miracle Eddie didn't bleed to death. *****"
hadpeasbfo wrote on 01.07.2026:
"The match in which Eddie broke the Muta scale. An absolutely amazing babyface performance by Guerrero here. It's so good, in fact, that at the point where he starts shimmying and mounting a comeback, there is not a single person in their seat. Brian Hebner, the referee, is visibly grinning from ear to ear - minutes after looking concerned whether the match can even continue. He can't even help himself. He forgets he's IN the match for a minute. That's how good this is. Eddie lost pints of blood here. JBL was terrific, too - and there would be no match without him and his lightning heel work which took over towns in 2004 and almost started riots."
CMFunk007 wrote on 13.06.2026:
[9.0] "I remember back when this happened that everyone on the message boards and forums hailed this match like it was the best match in years. I didn't quite see it that way at the time. I just couldn't get past the slow opening. But upon this viewing, I see what they saw now. It actually built up nicely to the chair shot that busted Eddie openand caused him to bleed buckets. Watching JBL get frustrated that Eddie wouldn't quit is classic."
ReiEscobar wrote on 03.06.2026:
[9.0] "Deny that I felt quite bored with JBL headlocks would be a lie I don't wanna tell. But, I also can't deny how good Eddy Guerrero looked here, and how each one of his comebacks looked better than the other. I saw someone saying that match was basically two guys fighting an different style, with JBL fighting as a more american heelish playdirty style common for the Ruthless Agression era while Eddy played the normal role an tecnico would play in a lucha bloodbath. Well said huh? Guess what, that someone don't exist, it was me. Eddy performance here was great, he bleed BUCKETS, made me start wondering about his healthy condition, his comebacks only looked even better, the DQ finish MADE sense because the guy who is widely know for the catchphrase "I lie, I cheat, I steal" won't accept be so cheated like he was from JBL. Also, a little pause for my already over review, go watch the entire storyline before you go watch this here. Apparently, things was so kayfabe based angry between them both that Guerrero's mother suffered an heart attack due to JBL threating an agression on her. Dope."
KingKrush29 wrote on 09.01.2026:
[10.0] "Eddie Guerrero enters this match with nothing on his mind but beating the shit out of JBL. JBL enters this match with nothing on his mind but escaping with a win. He's mean and oppressive in his heat and takes no concessions. Eddie, bad back and all, manages to claw his way out of this hole, but is immediately met with the a gun blast of a chairshot. The gusher that follows is the most gruesomely beautiful stream of blood I have laid my eyes on. Eddie takes a state of groggy instinct based self-defense. But he isn't lifeless, and as long as blood is pumping through Eddie Guerrero's heart, he will use every last pinch of adrenaline remaining in his body to beat the fuck out of the wretch who laid hands on his grandmother. It is the only objective remaining in his conscious. Eddie wills himself to throw the punches that had proven to be so effective for him throughout the match. JBL squirms out of the ring, looking to connive his way to gaining the upper hand once again, using the steel chair he used to bust Guerrero's skull earlier in the match as a distraction to clock Eddie in the head with the world championship belt. Eddie didn't let it happen this time, kicking Bradshaw in the balls with the refs back turned. The ref turns his way, yet Eddie has no hesitation to nail Bradshaw with the belt. Blood continues to gush out of Eddie's head as he proceeds to cut JBL's skull open with the chair and hit the frog splash he couldn't during the match. It's a disqualification. JBL won the match, but Eddie won the issue. The shot of a bloodied Bradshaw begging off from Eddie with the chair in his hands is among the most satisfying in wrestling history. JBL had nowhere to hide."
Dsannito wrote on 17.12.2025:
[10.0] "This match is a tale of two parts. The first part is a fun little brawl at the start of Eddie just trying to kick this dudes ass, and JBL is just addicted to rest holds. All this man knows his rest holds. The crowd is crazy for this match and this first half is very good. While JBL is just doing rest holds, it gives the crowd time to breathe from the babyface shine at the start that they were going crazy for, and gives them even more reason to cheer Eddie. But no one cares about the first half. No one remembers the first half. And for good reason, because this match lives and dies on that second half. And it all starts at the chair shot. Single handely the most brutal chair shot maybe ever results wise at least. Eddie starts GUSHING right away. He was busted hard way and now, this is the match. JBL goes after it right away, he is vicsious to this cut and does everything in his power to make it worse. He hits Eddie with the steps and KILLS him with a Clothsline From Hell. Charles runs in, 2 count. Eddie is dead but these kickouts are amazing. Just rolling his shoulder off the mat, his body can't go but his brain is still fighting. JBL is getting worried but it doesn't matter, anothe ref bump, powerbomb, kickout. Now he is getting more worried. Sleeper, but Eddie gets out and is now on the offensive. But JBL is back up before Eddie and he starts attacking him, BUT EDDIE DOESN'T CARE AND HE JUST DANCES AND BEATS THE FUCK OUT OF JBL AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH. You can't see Eddies face because of the blood but it doesn't matter. The crowd is screaming for this man and so am I. He goes for the frog splash but misses. Both men are dead, JBL exhausted and Eddie bleeding to death. And JBL takes the easy way out. He looks to hit Eddie with the title but Eddie low blows him and hits him with the title for the DQ loss. A sour note but I love it. The aftermath is an all timer also. Amazing match. Must watch. ***** (5)"
TrailsOfPersona wrote on 17.12.2025:
[5.0] "I almost feel like people don't watch this full match when reviewing. They just skip the the chair shot and watch to the end. This is one of the most infamous blood bath matches in company history. But the gore here really didn't do all of that much. The first half of the match is just a simplistic brawl where they spend a ton of time just bouncing from the ring to the outside over and over with little happening between. Their timing is off, as quite a few times they look confused as to who is supposed to throw a move. Additionally, there are a good chunk of long rest holds throughout this match. Eddie is trying to establish JBL as a star here, and without the blood, I don't think JBL makes it. This bout also features too overly long and kind of unbelievable ref bumps. Yes, Eddie is literally pouring blood. Yes, it makes his comeback look superhuman when he comes back. But blood and a comeback don't make a match. Especially a nearly half hour match. If you start this match at the chair shot and watch it at 2 times speed, then it might deserve the current rating it is sitting at. But really analyze this contest and don't get lost in the swimming pool levels of blood and you'll find that there isn't much substance to it."
Heartbreakkid2003 wrote on 25.11.2025:
[9.0] "Quite possibly the most underrated Wwe match of all time. It's crazy how this is only known as the match where JBL hit Eddie with a chair and Eddie bled like crazy cause this match Is much much more than that. Starts off hot with Eddie doing a great job showing his anger and frustration with JBL because of what he did to his mother. But where it really starts to reach another level is when the ref goes down the first time and JBL hits Eddie with That infamous chair shot. An insane shot and a even more insane blade job by Eddie and JBL hits his big moves on him and when Eddie keeps kicking out the fans just get louder and louder and it keeps building and building to what shouldve been a great finish but what keeps this from being a 5 star match is the Dq finish which did make sense but unfortunately keeps it from being 5 stars imo. 4.5/5 Super underrated update 2025 still fucking incredible 4.5/5"
Sweet Fighter V wrote on 21.10.2025:
[10.0] "The greatest match to ever end by DQ in my books, and my favorite Eddie match ever! Just a sensational babyface performance from him. Here you get a laser focused and fired up Eddie coming for JBL's head and kicking his ass from the get go, being relentless, even strangling him with a cable, and it's a blast considering the heat generated by JBL's outstanding heel work in the build-up. JBL sells his ass off and does some super solid work on top as that big bad bully, slowing the pace down, hitting bombs, and of course, landing one of the damnedest chairshots ever and turning things into a damn bloodbath with Eddie bleeding buckets! This made Eddie's gusty babyface performance all the more mesmerizing! Him hitting the shimmy while harboring one of the most outrageous crimson masks ever, is one of the greatest babyface spots ever. Then there's that dubious first ref bump that goes on for way too goddamn long and kinda takes away from the match (I'm cool with the second ref bump though), but there's also some crazy nearfalls with Eddie kicking out of a Clothesline From Hell and a blistering Powerbomb. The DQ finish makes for an anticlimactic conclusion at first, but it makes all the sense in the world, and that rousing post-match beating Eddie hands JBL while turning things into an even bigger bloodbath is so damn exhilarating, it more than makes up for the DQ finish. ****3/4"
BasuraNocturna wrote on 13.10.2025:
[8.0] "Very conflicted about this one's ratings. I mostly agree with another person in that, without the insane blade job, this wouldn't be so fondly remembered. Most of the match up to that point is good but not great by any means. Eddie brawls in an exciting shine segment, JBL stooges a bit, but not that much. Then the control segment form Bradshaw is whatever. There could be more aggression form JBL given the situation. He comes off as more effective than good, but it does the job. Then the chair shot to the dome happens and Eddie gushes blood everywhere. He bleeds all over the place and has one of the most glorious comebacks I've ever seen when he dances it off. He makes JBL pay, even pray, but he gets a double dose of chair to the head. Yeah, sure, it wouldn't be as good without the blade job. But the blade job is there and it elevates this one greatly. A good match transforms into something not only iconic but actually meaningful and rewarding to watch. It is enough to upset the much worse first half? I don't fully know, but it sure does leave a mark on you."
brossfacebrippler41 wrote on 13.10.2025:
[9.0] "One of the more potent storylines about Guerrero's untimely death was that at the time the weight of the world was in his shoulders, and he basically "died trying to stay as a main eventer". That statement would be more than visible in this legendary match here. JBL surely does the in ring psychology and storytelling effectively, and has a good enough David-Goliath dynamic with him; but it's penultimately what Guerrero does that makes this match- and many others featuring him- so legendary and beloved. The absolutely destructive blade job and the remainder of it is a brilliant, if not outright terrifying, wrestling brawl performance."
Wlliamofbaskerville wrote on 17.08.2025:
[9.0] "Probably the bloodiest none gimmick or death match ever. Up there with Foley/Taker hell in a cell and Foley/Rock I quit as the most violent match in WWE/WWF history. Infamous for Eddie's botched blade job in which turns the mat into a crimson mess. In alot of ways a match of two halves. The first half is a very good hard hitting slug fest. JBL was never gonna win awards for being the cleanest or best technical wrestler but he was great at what he was. A rough and tough brawler. The type of wrestler that is rare these days outside of Moxley and Kingston. He excelled at sloppy car crash brawls. This is his best none gimmick match (The I Quit match with Cena a year later is his best match). Mostly because Eddie is able to lean into what he was good at. A hard hitting brawl. At the time I grossly underrated JBL. Mostly because he so suddenly went from lower card tag team jobber to skyrocketed to WWE Champion which mostly came about because of Brock quitting and Angle's neck injury. But looking back he was superb at what he was. A detestable heel. Smackdown in 2004 was pitiful. A truly wretched show filled with jobbers getting on PPV to dead gimmicks like Morticai to steriod filled lug heads like Luther Reigns and Heidenriech being given a lot of air time to feud with Taker. It was fucking miserable but JBL and Eddie were propping it up along with Angle and Cena. This doesn't feel like a wrestling match but a fight. Two people who hate each other. Then JBL gives Eddie a sick chairshot and then Eddie bleeds. He doesn't bleed like what usually happens in WWE when someone blades. Where they bleed enough for effect then it stops. Eddie cut a main artery in his head. And he bleeds. And bleeds and bleeds. He bleeds that much he looks like someone tried to scalp him. It goes beyond the Muta scale. Eddie bleeding as much as he did got him even more over then he already was and made him look like a bad ass. And it got JBL over as a sadistic bastard. The second half is closer to Joe/Nerco in the sense you can't believe what your watching and how much blood is coming from one man's head. Even if the DQ ending is something of a wet fart the post match brawl and beat down add to the match and how brutal and hard hitting it is with Eddie giving JBL two brutal chairshots. Their best match they had against each other. Just a total fucking bloodbath."
abbiecornett25 wrote on 20.07.2025:
"Wow. The infamous botched blade job here really makes it. I love Eddie, and after the blood starts coming in, the match really picks up. HOWEVER, before that, this match wasn't really that special. And as much as I'd love to give this a ten because of Eddie and his badassery, I'm gonna have to say 7.75, and I will come back to officially rate it, when I can. It was a well worked match, and cheers to both dudes for the absurdity they went through in it."
Algo214 wrote on 30.06.2025:
[10.0] "I have just rewatched this match for the first time since it happened and every single emotion I felt back then came back, maybe stronger. In hindsight, I wish Eddie didn't have "too much heart" as I think Taz called it. But strictly about the match, everything was as it needed to be."
DecentWrestling wrote on 25.06.2025:
[10.0] "A fantastic physical brawl, and an iconic match with a tough to watch finale due to all the blood. It actually worked in line with the story and made JBL even more evil which was one of the missions. The storytelling was superb, even post-match. JBL played his role to perfection, lots of drama and bells and whistles which added to the match. Loved the nearfalls with the Clothesline From Hell and Powerbomb. Eddie's comeback at the end while beaten and bloodied was iconic and a sight to see, adding to his do or die attitude. The ending served to continue the story so I cannot mark it down for a DQ finish. It was an effective and well done match that suited the story perfectly and each guy played their roles and it accomplished the goals it set out to achieve. Masterpiece."
GolyPCDV wrote on 14.02.2025:
[10.0] "A perfect match, the blade botch takes what was an already great match to a whole new level, just incredible."
ultravioletshiroi wrote on 09.02.2025:
"This match is extremely brutal, eerily similar to the match Eddie's father had with Cavernario Galindo. That match played out in a similar way and Eddie loved to pay tribute to his father, but I don't doubt that Eddie never intended to cut that deep. He almost lost his life to entertain the fans watching this PPV."
cactus wrote on 31.01.2025:
[10.0] "This may be mainly known for Eddie's gruesome blade job where he paints the ring canvas with his plasma, but there's a great match to be found here. We all love Eddie, but JBL was fantastic here. He did a lot here to put Eddie over. After trying to calm his opponent down by grinding him down in a methodical headlock, you can see the fear on his face as Eddie starts to make his way to his feet. The referees go down and Eddie bleeds buckets. The image of a bloody Eddie jiving around doing his trademark pose as he begins to make his comeback is peak pro wrestling. Eddie gets caught redhanded and get disqualified, but this doesn't stop him from pounding away at JBL. Wrestling would be much better if we still had finishes like the one we got here. A disqualification finish isn't always a bad thing, and it was used to leave something on the table for a rewatch."
tsukushimakino wrote on 20.10.2024:
[9.0] "If you can't stomach blood like this, I totally get it, but oh my god, Eddie puts on maybe the best baby face performance ever by bleeding literal buckets. Everything prior to the blade job is great, but when he gets hit with that chair, it hits another level, and once he's getting his comeback in, wow, he genuinely looks a super hero fighting thru it all. If he had actually gotten the pinfall, I think everyone in the area and everyone watching, would've exploded from pure elation. The DQ finish it totally fine, doesn't detract anything for the record. A must watch."
DXTF wrote on 04.09.2024:
[9.0] "This match was brutal. This is the start of JBL, having ditched the baseball cap, cards and beer for a suit, cowboy hat, and the stock exchange market. JBL is in the ring talking smack to Eddie, asking him how his mum's doing (JBL got into a confrontation on a previous show with Eddie's mum, who then had a "heart attack" when JBL put his hands on her), while Eddie is stood on the top rope, just staring daggers through JBL. The match starts off very hot, Eddie is obviously very pissed at JBL for what he did to Eddie's mum. After repeatedly punching JBL for a few minutes, JBL decides he's had enough and begins to walk off, only for Eddie to chase after him and bring him back. However, the tables turn when JBL sends Guerrero into the ring steps, this is where JBL starts to take control. A decent portion of this match takes place outside of the ring and, for the most part, referee Brian Hebner is lenient, going with slow counts and ignoring the thumb to JBL's eyes by Eddie. At one point, while on the outside, JBL hits a Fallaway Slam before proceeding to Back Body Drop Eddie onto the Spanish announce table. Brian Hebner gets taken down by Eddie when Eddie accidentally knocks into him while looking to run into the ropes, at this point the match begins to turn very nasty. While on the outside (yet again), JBL absolutely destroys Eddie with a sickening chair shot to the head, causing Eddie to be busted open. Busted open probably doesn't do this justice though as Eddie is literally gushing blood and it becomes very apparent just how much blood Eddie loses in this match when, later on, JBL gets Eddie in a Sleeper Hold and it looks like Eddie has had a bucket of red paint tipped on him. Towards the end, JBL goes back outside and grabs a steel chair along with the WWE title, he keeps the title behind his back so, when Hebner is dealing with the chair, he can hit Eddie with the belt. It doesn't go down this way though as Eddie hits JBL with a low blow (which Hebner doesn't see) before hitting JBL with the championship, which Hebner does see, causing Brian Hebner to ring for the bell, ending the match. While the match was over, with JBL being victorious via DQ, the action certainly wasn't as Eddie hit JBL a couple more times with the belt, gave JBL his receipt and then some with two chair shots to the head and then hitting the Frog Splash. You'd think this would be enough but NOPE! Multiple refs dragged JBL out of the ring and walked him up the aisle, but Eddie chased after them, continuing to beat down on JBL. Eventually, Finlay, Malenko, Arn Anderson and others dragged Eddie away from JBL and the show ends with a very, very bloody Eddie Guerrero in the ring with his WWE Championship, despite losing the match as it was a DQ. I'd give this a 9 as it is a classic match (although it's not even really a match but more of an all-out fight) however the DQ at the end stops me from giving it a 10; The DQ does make sense as obviously it wasn't JBL's title to get the gold yet but, at the same time, you couldn't have Eddie beat JBL clean either if it was going to set up another title match, however, after the brutality shown between these two here, ending the match on a DQ just didn't feel right, even if it did make sense."
jackleone wrote on 24.06.2024:
[9.0] "It's a classic, the start of the star power of John Bradshaw Layfield and one of the greatest matches of Eddie Guerrero's short reign. The intensity reaches high levels and the post-match is strong and leaves a mark. This is for sure how to create a heated match, bloody and straight to the point. This is a DQ end which does not take anything off from this great match. ****1/4"
JacquesRougeauCanHaveMyWife wrote on 16.06.2024:
[9.0] "That's how you do a grudge match! They're not there to wrestle, they're not there to do moves and fancy counters, they're there to beat the hell out of each other because the stuff got personal and both guys hate each other's guts. They do a lot of brawling outside of the ring, but it's not the Attitude Era bollocks, because here they actually have to stop the referee's count and the feud called for a brawl. Eddie was still the most over guy in the company a few months after winning the title, so it only showed what a great babyface he has been. JBL on the other hand was a breath of fresh air and his work as a bad guy has been absolutely phenomenal. The match was brutal, Eddie's crimson mask was one of the best I have ever seen and you couldn't take your eyes off it. Fantastic stuff!"
RegularGonzalez wrote on 30.04.2024:
[8.0] "JBL's best match, just ahead of the Cena I Quit match one year later. This match is infamous for Eddie's disgusting blade job, but the whole match is damn good. Eddie is just on point as he can be the most sympathetic, fighting with all of his will babyface while at the same time can be the most dastardly heel. The finish itself wasn't very good, but they wanted to keep the feud going. A must-see if you can handle A LOT of blood"
Dcarter1153 wrote on 02.04.2024:
[8.0] "This feels like a conflicted rating. And I MUST point out the finish was so piss poor to make Eddie look like a superhero just to end up DQing himself. Terribly booked finish"
LincolnAntoine4482 wrote on 19.02.2024:
[8.0] "JBLs reign on top of Smackdown was underappreciated as it occurred and is still not given the credit it should. Maybe the bloodiest match in WWE history? JBL was one of the greatest true heels and his disgust/disdain toward Eddie throughout the match was palpable."
ISimon1912 wrote on 07.02.2024:
[7.0] "For me, this match falls into the same category as Mankind vs Taker in 98, one of the most brutal matches in history, but if you take away the iconic moment there isn't much left, plus (thankfully) Eddie didn't have any problems after losing so much blood (just like Foley didn't die when he fell out of his cell). This type of match is iconic and brutal, but there are things that are best avoided for the safety of the wrestlers themselves. I still get this note due to the anti-climactic ending and the impeccable babyface performance done by the late Eddie and the respect for continuing to perform despite losing a river of blood (***1/2)"
nickarvin wrote on 19.11.2023:
[7.0] "I know this match probably deserves to surpass a 7, the cut artery on the blade spot by Eddie is absolutely iconic, but the actual match was somewhat underwhelming. I understand why they needed the DQ but it was really a let down with how good of a match it was up to that point."
Ruthless Attitude wrote on 03.10.2023:
[10.0] "Despite the DQ ending, I'm still rating this one a 10. I was really enjoying the physicality a lot in this match, but then that sickening chair shot happened and changed the match completely in to something that was hard to watch, but at the same time impossible to turn away. The heart of Eddie Guerrero fighting on with his blood turning the ring into an art canvas and staining the arena is one of the most legendary moments of his career. This had the feel of a heated rivalry from the start and while the blood certainly added to the match, the intensity Eddie shows where he dominates a large portion of the match in the early going is just excellent and it's impossible not to route for him either given the heat JBL was getting with his pre-match promo. It had the feel of a good old fashioned street fight and while Eddie's performance had to have been affected greatly by the bloodloss, it is still nonetheless inspiring to watch. JBL's offense looked stiff and really hard hitting throughout the match as well and his work is great here as well. After the DQ which disappointed the crowd a little, the post match beat down from Eddie after the match got them back on their feet again. I would have loved to have seen the rematch be a Street Fight or even a Hell in a Cell match as this feud warranted that kind of finish. Utterly insane main event!"
hieisrequiem wrote on 05.09.2023:
[10.0] "On the shortlist of the very best WWE matches ever. Eddie gives the babyface performance of the lifetime here; I dare anyone to watch him do his dance with blood absolutely caking his face and not admit to feeling a chill go down their spine. ****3/4"
Juno555 wrote on 06.08.2023:
[8.0] "A thunderous chair shot, and follows one of the largest amounts of blood Ive ever seen. An amazing match that deserves all the praise it gets. Eddie truly was something special and JBL is massively underrated, I think everyone should watch this match at least once or twice in their time. Loved the DQ finish and Eddie somehow being able to continue the attack onto JBL and somehow not passing out. Amazing match."
flightaker321 wrote on 24.07.2023:
[9.0] "Is the blood in this match awesome, and also some of the best color ever in a match? The answer would be yes, but just resorting to this match as only being great because of that would be ignorant, because the couple of times that I've watched this match it's been phenomenal. Eddie shows hatred in his eyes from the get-go and he immediately pounces on JBL when the bell rings. JBL on the offensive takes full advantage of the size mismatch he has to beat down on Eddie slowly, but he would bump greatly for him whenever Eddie was on offense. The two would get into a brawl, that would take the ref out, and be taken to the floor in which JBL gives Eddie a nasty chair shot to the face, and a couple of seconds later Eddie's whole body/face is legit covered in blood. JBL from here on out would brutalize Eddie with his big offense, but Eddie just wouldn't stay down and his selling during all of this was fantastic. Eddie's comeback at the end was great, and he had the people fully behind him when he did it. Obviously, you always prefer an actual finish, but The DQ finish actually plays into the story of the match because Eddie's main goal here was just to get back at what JBL had done to him. This is legitimately one of the best WWE title matches ever no BS. ****3/4"
GMS18 wrote on 19.07.2023:
[9.0] "A JBL match cooking like this? Perhaps I treated you too harshly. But seriously, very little to criticise from start to end here. "JBL gives Eddie's mother a heart attack then says he doesn't care if she dies" is insane and I dig it. The match itself is worked pretty much perfectly with Eddie beating the hell out of him, JBL turning the tide through sheer size and strength, the crowd willing on Eddie's comebacks, and of course the disgusting chair shot and blade job that takes things to another level in too real a fashion. Everything from that point on brings a pretty good and effective match to a really great one, a career highlight for Bradshaw and an all-time great performance from Eddie. I'm left wondering what the heat could've looked like if JBL won the title here or the pop if Eddie rallied back to win, but the DQ finish doesn't detract from it either as you get the catharsis of Eddie battering him afterwards and leaving the feud even hotter than it was going in. ****1/2"
KKeanel wrote on 18.03.2023:
[9.0] "Bloody and emotional masterpiece. If only one match could show meaning of this sort of art for this brilliant individuals, that could be a good candidate. Incredible match for whole WWE history. I'm not sure that DQ was a good decision, but showing a determination of Guerrero was more important here."
Fillosetti wrote on 14.03.2023:
[9.0] "It is by no means a match of excellent technical quality, but it is such a carnage that it must be remembered. What makes this match so "powerful" is the story of Eddie Guerrero's sacrifice, who began to bleed like a pig after one of the most violent chairshots in wrestling history. It's a damn adrenaline-pumping match with very powerful storytelling, and the abnormal amount of blood adds a lot to the story. A match that, in my opinion, would have a lot to teach to Jon Moxley, who uses the bladejob in practically every match"
zachattack2023 wrote on 15.02.2023:
[10.0] "This match is so good and is underrated and a classic I do think it should have been stop but it wasn't and eddie survived but this was a bloody match.*****"
CommisarRobe wrote on 06.10.2022:
[8.0] "The match of the night for sure, the blood spilling everywhere added a certain edge to this match for sure, but the action was still excellent. Great emoting from both Eddie and JBL really helps sell the hatred the characters had for each other. Really great match."
KingsCrossing wrote on 26.09.2022:
[10.0] "The idea that this isn't good outside of the blood loss is absurd. This was worked perfectly from start to finish. They begin exactly how a heated grudge match of this nature should - not with a hackneyed Frye-Takayama sequence, but with the babyface chasing down the reprehensible heel and beating the hell out of him as the villain makes desperate attempts to flee. JBL is clearly outclassed and Eddie is riding high on emotion. It isn't until JBL is able to use Eddie's aggression (and a foreign object) against him, by countering an Irish whip and sending Eddie crashing in to the steps, that he takes the offensive. Eddie shows heart, firing back at every available opportunity, as JBL uses his only advantage - his size - to fling Eddie in to the turnbuckle and to grind him down with basic, smothering holds that rely on size to be effective. Eddie demonstrates his technique and speed by executing some successful arm drags (meaning that JBL has to show his cowardice again, promptly escaping to the floor), but is thwarted once the size advantage comes in to play again and he is caught on a plancha and slammed on to the floor (another cheap, bullying tactic) with a fallaway slam. JBL takes too long to catch his breath and pays for it as the smaller man now is able to start firing back at him once more, until JBL back drops Eddie over the table. They have also at this point established that the hatred between the two is so out of control that they cannot be contained by the ring. The two brawl in the ring (Eddie attempting to use his speed and technique by rolling off JBL's back but getting back body dropped instead) until JBL takes over with another basic, smothering hold - a bear hug. Eddie starts with his trademark lying, cheating, and stealing to earn back control with an eye poke and another speedy, technical move (a counter dropkick) before starting with his signature offense. The two continue along these lines for a little longer until the ref is taken out. JBL uses this opening to crack Eddie with a vicious chair shot. Eddie, within seconds, is absolutely covered with insane amounts of blood. The match continues on with high impact offence from JBL, and incredible displays of heart from the vulnerable champion, against the odds now that he has sustained such a graphic injury. JBL even uses a sleeper to choke Eddie out - a perfect attack on a man who is already going out from blood loss, and a clear shift in strategy from the holds earlier that relied on JBL's size. This all builds to a very natural DQ - exactly what this match, which has always been on the fringes of what is legal, has been progressing towards. If this had any of the 'work rate', sprinting wrestling that is popular today it would have been completely out of place with the story, and undermined everything they were working towards. This match is flawless, with no wasted motion or meaningless movement. A masterpiece from two men who understood their roles and characters perfectly."
arrancar wrote on 22.05.2022:
[6.0] "Make no mistake: if Eddie didn't get an absurd amount of blood in this match then this would be forgotten about as a run-of-the-mill WWE/World Title match. It was ultimately an alright match, but there's honestly nothing remotely special about it apart from that one factor. They had an extended messy brawl to start, which wasn't too interesting but it at least fit the story of Eddie being super fired up at JBL and wanting to give him a big beating. Eddie's character work was good, with his displays of aggression and vengeful desires looking very realistic, thus making it easy to sympathise with his struggle. JBL used his size and power well during his comeback control segment, doing well too grind Eddie down and give him a daunting obstacle to overcome. His control work sadly became quite boring due to how robotically he moved between his slow and generic attacks, and I get that that was done intentionally to make Eddie's comebacks feel more exciting by contrast, but I still found it rather sleep-inducing whenever JBL was just sitting in a rest hold for ages. Just one control segment for JBL before Eddie got a proper comeback would have been good, but they instead went pretty overkill with JBL constantly cutting Eddie's comebacks off over and over again, to the point that I found it difficult to care even when Eddie finally *did* get his proper comeback. And of course a ref bump had to happen to further water down Eddie's big comeback. It was at this point that I knew the match wasn't going to be anything special, although it admittedly picked it quite a bit once JBL brutally smashed Eddie in the head with a chair, followed by Eddie getting insanely busted open and bleeding all down his face and chest. Eddie did really well selling his complete disorientation following that spot, but then they had to introduce a new ref to the match because the prior ref was still down from his earlier bump, and then they immediately did ANOTHER ref bump with the new ref, because GOD FORBID WWE ATTEMPT TO TELL THEIR STORIES WITH ANY SORT OF IMAGINATION. JBL was completely battering Eddie, which on top of the immense blood loss should have made Eddie easy pickings, but for some reason he had super plot armour that allowed him to keep kicking out of JBL's pins and even start showboating before beginning another big comeback. His charismatic energy was really entertaining during that final comeback, but it was still pretty illogical to see him able to do all that after the enormous damage he'd sustained, and it really made JBL look like a joke for still being unable to put him away. JBL being beaten at Eddie's signature "heel tactics" game at the end fit Eddie's character well, but it was still a very anticlimactic finish. They then went and did even more brawling, weapon attacks, and finally a Frog Splash in the post-match angle in order to clear away the stench of that lame DQ finish, but that didn't elevate the match in any meaningful way. ***"
Makai Club wrote on 09.02.2022:
[9.0] "I've heard stories, seen pictures and gifs but I never expected this. THIS. This is a classic. A bloody fight with fantastic brawling, great storytelling by JBL, fiery, passionate comebacks from Eddie. That chair shot by JBL was sickening. I'm not sure if Eddie's selling was just that damn good or his concussion face was legit. Either way, it added so much. The match was a great brawl that felt like a damn fight. A true WWE CLASSIC. ****1/2"
KENTAfan wrote on 05.07.2021:
[10.0] "This has to be one of the most gruesome matches in WWE history, maybe THE most brutal match, and it was amazing. It was already pretty brutal before the botched blade job, but once Eddie started bleeding, Jesus ... It was just blood everywhere. Honestly there's nothing quite like this, which is probably a good thing, but still, this match happened and I thought it was amazing. Eddie literally looked like he was about to go into shock from blood loss and sold it perfectly, which added to the urgency and intensity of the match. After that came Eddie's comeback sequence, which I can honestly say is the greatest comeback sequence of all time bar none. It was absolutely insane to see Eddie come back from the brink of defeat and start taking the fight to JBL. It's kind of a shame it ended in a DQ, but honestly, I didn't mind the finish as it really didn't hinder the match at all. This is NOT a match for the faint of heart, but if you appreciate the Ruthless Aggression era, odds are you'll love this. It also put JBL on the map as a top heel. This is as good as it gets for that time period, and in my opinion a classic. *****"
AndoCommando wrote on 10.05.2021:
[10.0] "I can't believe I'm giving something that features John Bradshaw Layfield the highest rating possible, but this might be the best match to ever take place in a WWE ring and I mean that with no hyperbole. Bradshaw had morphed into the JBL moniker just a few short months earlier and already needed security guards escorting him around this time. This man was a heat magnet, and the Donald Trump-esque promo right before the match is just the cherry on top. The staredown during Eddie's entrance sets the tone perfectly and he immediately goes after JBL once the bell rings. It took a rewatch for me to realize this, but JBL is great here specifically because he's an oversized stooge. He'll bump huge for every bit of Eddie's offense that the difference between them is massive, capped off when Bradshaw tries to leave so early after such a beating. I expected to have something to at least nitpick once JBL took control, but this is the most logically sound work in his entire career. He's nowhere close to Eddie's level in a fair exchange, so he has to use whatever standard holds he knows to wear the champion down. When a headlock is applied, he's taking Eddie down to the mat and keeping him grounded with his size advantage. Once Eddie's back is hurt on the outside, JBL eventually follows it up with a Bearhug of all things. Do note that each time either is applied, the crowd winds up chanting Eddie's name louder than before. Then blood enters the fray and we witness the most grizzly bladejob outside of Puerto Rico. Eddie's selling from this point on is fantastic and genuinely looks to be in peril. Blood is still squirting out of his head, gushing all across the canvas, and it's here where he pulls off one of the most intense comebacks I've ever seen. This was like a throwback to old school brawling done in the best way possible. I can't help but adore such a tour de force that might never be matched on WWE programming again. JBL came away a more viable contender for the title than ever before, while Eddie proved himself an all-time great babyface when needed. *****"
Garmonbozia wrote on 02.04.2021:
[8.0] "Once the blood starts flowing, this match gets GOOD. Before that it isn't so compelling or engaging."
Dragon Fighter wrote on 21.06.2020:
[9.0] "A very personal bloody feud here and it was as brutal as the match JBL had with Cena one year later. Eddie was just incredible here. His character work, crowd connection were absolutely amazing. JBL's work early on top wasn't good but once Eddie came back, it became much more energetic. The match started being brutal since then. The chair shot was really uncomfortable when looking back. But it added a lot to the feud. They just beat the shit out of each other. Blood was there. The atmosphere was great. A great main event overall and the second-best of JBL after the Cena match."
CelticChase23 wrote on 06.04.2020:
[10.0] "This is the match that made JBL a hall of famer. Incredible performances from both in particularly Eddie cause of that SICK blade job and his great storytelling. One of my favorite matches of all time. Always a great watch."
Brye wrote on 28.02.2020:
[10.0] "I never expected to rate a JBL match at 10/10 but this one is unbelievable. The pure intensity, especially in the final few minutes is unrivaled. Eddie Guerrero was a once in a lifetime performer. He could do some of the funniest segments of all time but still have an intense, breathtaking moment like the end of this match. Eddie's selling is literally perfect, though after the chairshot he was probably legit hurt anyway. I just revisited this one today and it still holds up as well as it did in 2004."
Donnie wrote on 21.11.2019:
[10.0] "DIS FUCKING MATCH! Its just a perfect storm of a wrestling match. Eddie's anger is incredible as he is seemingly happy as he drives out, but as soon as he locks eyes with JBL, he starts shaking like a nutcase on the top rope and he really looks like he might kill him. The beating he unloads is fantastic as he pinballs JBL all over, until Bradshaw is forced to grab a nasty looking headlock to finally stop the attack. The back an forth is very good, and it feels like its just going to be a really fun match right up until JBL hits the most Ungodly chair shot of them all, leading to Eddie ripping his skull open with the most fucked up blade job ever seen. Fuck the Muta scale, this is the Eddie scale. JBL then beats the shit out of Eddie like the incredible shithead bully he is as he hits some truly horrific shots, and its further amplified by the blood and Eddie's incredible selling that looks like he could die at any second. Eddie's eventual comeback is a contender for best comeback ever as he displays SO much fire and emotion, and you can't help but cheer aloud for him to kill this son of a bitch. The moment Eddie craws back in the ring COVERED in blood as JBL begs off is maybe the best "This is pro wrestling" moment. Eddie eventually snapping by bashing JBL's head in with the belt makes perfect sense for the story and puts this over the top as a Goddamn classic. Everyone watch this match!"
Mizzle Assault Ant wrote on 05.04.2019:
[10.0] "The blood is incredible, yes, but I most loved the story, the heat, the incredible passion on display, amazing performance by all."
MetaKnight wrote on 28.01.2018:
[9.0] "Awesome. A great feel good moment for Eddie And the fans and JBL gets his comeuppance. These guys were spilling gallons of blood, Guerrero especially. Both these guys risked their bodies but JBL botched some things and thank goodness that Eddie made him look good enough to cover it up. Also cameos from Dean Malenko and Double A Arn Anderson are pretty cool as well. Overall, this is a prime example of an incredible match from the Ruthless Aggression era and SmackDown during that time. The finish was bollocks, but it doesn? t take away from the greatness that was displayed in this matchup. ****1/2"