DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?

Jeff Hardy vs. Matt Hardy

Match

6.70
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 315
Number of comments: 70
10.0 0x
9.0 1x
8.0 60x
7.0 138x
6.0 87x
5.0 20x
4.0 8x
3.0 1x
2.0 0x
1.0 0x
0.0 0x
Average rating: 6.70  [315]
Average rating in 2026: 6.86  [36]
Average rating in 2025: 6.46  [59]
Average rating in 2024: 6.65  [54]
Average rating in 2023: 6.83  [42]
Average rating in 2022: 6.70  [20]
Average rating in 2021: 6.55  [11]
Average rating in 2020: 7.30  [10]
Average rating in 2019: 7.00  [6]
Average rating in 2018: 7.10  [10]
Average rating in 2017: 6.33  [3]
Average rating in 2016: 6.75  [8]
Average rating in 2015: 7.50  [4]
Average rating in 2014: 5.60  [5]
Average rating in 2013: 7.00  [3]
Average rating in 2012: 7.00  [2]
Average rating in 2011: 6.67  [3]
Average rating in 2010: 6.63  [8]
Average rating in 2009: 6.68  [31]
Your Options:
Other:
Leo the goat wrote on 13.11.2026:
[7.0] "A very solid, emotionally charged 7/10 Extreme Rules brawl that capitalized on deep brotherly familiarity and creative weapon spots. Stepping into Reliant Stadium after Matt's shocking Royal Rumble betrayal, both brothers worked a tight, physical 13-minute grudge match that prioritized visceral punishment over graceful high-flying. Matt played the bitter, vindictive older brother superbly--smashing Jeff with steel chairs, trash cans, and a brutal Side Effect onto the steel ring steps--while Jeff brought fearless desperation, hitting a massive Swanton Bomb off the top rope through Matt and a stacked table setup at ringside. The finish was both vicious and inventive: after Jeff tried to go one step too far with a leapfrog leg drop off the top of a tall ladder and crashed violently through a table on the mat, Matt dragged his brother's head directly inside the frame of a folding steel chair and hit a sickening Twist of Fate for the clean pinfall. Hard-hitting, personal, and well-paced."
Raditz Flair wrote on 25.10.2026:
[7.0] "I thought this was a little better than some but not the classic I think a lot of fans hope for. The best part of this feud was Matt Hardy changing his gear and his character for several months. I think they chose the right winner but because it's WWE and they love 50/50 booking they held back for the rematch a month later."
KSAHZ8 wrote on 26.09.2026:
[5.0] "This match was really disappointing, The Hardyz have had tension and matches prior but this was their first big blood feud, Matt just never had the charisma or star power that Jeff had. It had some fun weapon spots and it wasn't a bad match at all, just kind of there. I'd expect to see it on a regular PPV or maybe even a Main Event of RAW or Smackdown not on WrestleMania. Given the storyline, a lot more was expected."
TrailsOfPersona wrote on 17.09.2026:
[6.0] "I mean...it is certainly no Bret vs. Owen type of encounter, but it's still a pretty good match! I think it maybe underdelivers for a match they'd been building up for months, and that is why it has a bit of a sour reputation. WWE didn't do many feuds like this at this time. That built slowly for half a year. They were a thing of the past. And it worked so well here only for them to have a good match instead of an amazing one. The big bumps are excellent and extremely memorable, as is the finish, but there just isn't anything around those bumps to act as glue and hold them together. It's pretty standard stuff with some good big spots thrown in. It's a good addition to this card, and I definitely won't say it was a let down but...it wasn't as good as it should have been given the story and personal nature."
BilboBaggins wrote on 08.09.2026:
[4.0] "Good lord, this was dull. The general crux of this feud is a last-minute, ass-pull heel turn and Matt pulling a Blofeld and becoming the author of all Jeff's pain. Sad to say that while a Hardy vs. Hardy rivalry sounds appealing, I reject this build for how short-sighted, ill-conceived, and generally preposterous the build was. Having Matt orchestrate pyro accidents? Alright. Having him allude to potentially committing arson and killing Jeff's dog in the process? That's a confession, tacky as hell, exploitative, and it's dumb! Then we get to the actual match, and instead of it being a tense, bitter fight between two siblings who want to win while beating the piss out of the other, it's just every other mindless, PG-era garbage match. There's absolutely no heat or story to this one, so now this very personal match is missing the emotional core- the stakes that the entire bout should be centered around. They just go through the motions from spot to spot with all the usual hallmarks: egregious downtime that kills the pacing, weapons that have no place under a wrestling ring (why a poster and vacuum? ), and contrived spots that make no earthly sense (the table sandwich comes to mind), do more to harm the guy giving the move, and bring them no closer to winning the match. I really shouldn't be surprised by this outcome. I don't typically associate intense, aggressive, or logical, story-driven wrestling with Jeff Hardy, and the last blood feud Matt Hardy was involved in saw him get jobbed the fuck out. That said, I was still hoping this match would have some oomph to it, but alas, not. Despite being cut short, the match still drags and doesn't even properly build to a finish. Jeff tries to senselessly destroy his body to garner a cheap, fleeting pop by using a ladder to hop over another. Only for Matt, who got battered all throughout, to get out of dodge, because why would anyone take that dive? Then a chair-assisted Twist of Fate, heel wins, and it's so flat and deflating. This did nothing to elevate Matt, feels like a detour for Jeff, and didn't even bother to tell a story or to sell people on their alleged hatred toward one another. And worst of all? It was bog-standard and meandering as hell."
Hitman26 wrote on 24.05.2026:
[7.0] "This match was very enjoyable even though it was only 15 minutes. Many memorable weapon spots with the double table splash being definitely my favourite. The finish was surprising but I didn't have no issue with it. I wish they had more time but it was enjoyable like this too. A very good brother vs brother match with lots of weapon spots."
kirbykrackle wrote on 17.05.2026:
[7.0] "These two deserved more than 15 minutes. Still, a very serviceable match for the time allotted. Awesome finish."
WG20 wrote on 01.04.2026:
[7.0] "Nothing spectacular in this match just a lot of weapon spots. I did however like the finish of the match. I did expect more given the storyline."
SkyIcons wrote on 26.03.2026:
[7.0] "I enjoyed this. Definitely expected more considering who is in the match, but an adequate amount if extreme spots. Sick finish"
Kugenesan1 wrote on 27.02.2026:
[6.0] "I just know both the Hardys was itching to do more but unfortunately this was all they could do and we know why. Still I think they did fine especially with Matt's offenses were all extreme in terms of movesets. Jeff selling at the end was so good."
RTruthSaidWhatsUp wrote on 03.12.2025:
[6.0] "The match was okay. Given the storyline, you'd expect more, but it wasn't a bad match. I guess it works."
JokerDeSilva wrote on 16.09.2025:
[7.0] "In the long history books of brother-vs-brother matches, and "blood feuds that culminate in violent matches, " I think this ranks pretty well, actually. I was never a fan of the Hardys, Jeff especially, but both actually came to make it look like they wanted to beat the breaks off each other (something that our main event of the night could have worked on, honestly). It's kind of your standard messy hardcore brawl, but that's what you come to a Hardy vs Hardy extreme rules match for, to be honest, so I think it's well executed enough."
sdenapoli wrote on 01.09.2025:
[7.0] "A brutal match between the Hardy Boyz that, in my opinion, lived up to the build for this match. Jeff was his usual high-flying self, and it was nice to see Matt pick up a big win over his brother."
Hippykillerz wrote on 14.08.2025:
[4.0] "The big problem I have with this match is that I don't believe that these men hate each other, feels forced and the story elements are just too farfetched (killing his dog in a fire, why does that need to be include? ! ). This impacted the enjoyment of the match for me and I didn't enjoy this much. Some of the spots hit, Jeff's dive of the ladder looked nasty, but a lot of things effected this. A blood feud match and the first weapon used was a poster? ! What? ! A lot of the action felt soulless and was going through the motions. The biggest thing for me was a rope brake in an Extreme Rules match...excuse me? ! Beyond stupid! The match was just not WrestleMania worthy."
Figure4Dragon wrote on 22.06.2025:
[6.0] "It was all about plunder and producing highlights, and although it had all that, this felt hollow and heatless for much of it. I walked away feeling the same way I did when I saw this in 2009: "I had fun watching it, but it underdelivered." I still think the finish was cool. Matt was the one who attempted to have those moments where he communicated his disdain for Jeff that played out in the build, but the crowd just didn't seem to care much for it. Sometimes I love plunder matches, and other times I'm indifferent, and this one I enjoyed and thought it was good, but they certainly did not deliver for what their build called for. ***"
704eb wrote on 20.06.2025:
[4.0] "More Jimmy/Jey than Bret/Owen, for sure. They're not absolutely falling apart out there but man this was heatless and lifeless, just spots being thrown together with little rhythm or drama. The Jeff bump on his tailbone from the top of the ladder was very impressive and the match has somewhat of a novelty to it, but not much past that. I don't think it's as much of a disaster as the aforementioned WM40 brother vs brother match, but still quite uninteresting."
Thenxt observer wrote on 22.05.2025:
[9.0] "****1/2 (09/10) Sure, Owen and Bret have the best brother vs. brother match at WrestleMania, but I think I would give the next honors to the Hardyz on the 24th... oh, excuse me, I mean: the 25th anniversary of WrestleMania. Time is a factor in the overall enjoyment of this one. Kid Rock and the Divas were given 17 minutes, but the Hardyz weren't allowed fifteen? At least, we know they saved the best for their "I Quit Match, " in three weeks. Now, I'm starting to see why Backlash 2009 in considered one of the best of WWE's B-shows."
smackdownvsraw wrote on 28.04.2025:
[8.0] "A really entertaining match. Love the makeup Jeff has on. This match has some great spots, I especially loved the double table spot"
trexyyy wrote on 11.04.2025:
[7.0] "Nothing too special, was expecting Jeff to win in the end but that didn't happen. Was it a spot fest? Sure. Was it an entertaining spot fest? Yeah."
Suit Williams wrote on 09.04.2025:
[4.0] "This match wasn't bad, but it wasn't anything special. There was a lack of structure and a lack of real energy. This felt a lot like a professional version of a backyard match, where they think of some cool spots to do, but don't have anything in between to thread it together. The stunts weren't even particularly cool, with Jeff splashing though a Matt table sandwich and Jeff missing a lifting leg drop over a really big ladder. Honestly, the only thing I remember Matt doing was the finish, a Twist of Fate with Jeff's head in a chair. An unmemorable hardcore match, and a disappointing end to this era of Jeff Hardy as he's gone by next year. **"
Olympus19 wrote on 08.03.2025:
[8.0] "This was a spot fest, but it was well paced, the spots were memorable, and didn't last too long. An extreme rules match shouldn't go over 15 minutes! Matt and Jeff do a decent job selling the pain too. While I do think a rivalry match like this, with this stipulation, would have been enhanced with blood, the spots were structured in such a way that not bleeding was at least plausible. I watched this match shortly after the Owens/Zayn match at EC 2025, and I must say I enjoyed Matt/Jeff more. I found the commentary to be less distracting too, which helped. This match isn't an instant classic, but it is entertaining and does not deserve the low rating. Did it live up to the pre-match hype? No. But put expectations aside and you will enjoy it."
Gerdo wrote on 21.12.2024:
[6.0] "I don't know how to rate this match. I liked the spots, even if I still can't decide if I'm good with the Splash on the two tables. But the impression is that spots are the only thing here. No storytelling, no breaks, just spots with weapons to fill the 13 minutes. Too much. And the ending was not that brilliant too, Jeff should've won and Matt's win was soo anti-climatic, but came after a nice Twist of Fate (again, spots were very good). Good match but it should have been something else, I'm very sorry because thet put a lot of effort into this."
brooksavage2004 wrote on 19.08.2024:
[7.0] "The feud was pretty bad and the finish was anticlimactic with Matt beating Jeff, but it's still a really solid enough match despite it's structure and ending."
JacquesRougeauCanHaveMyWife wrote on 03.08.2024:
[3.0] "What a dumb spotfest. They immidiately load the ring with weapons and start randomly hitting each other without any thought put into it. All they were thinking about is how many spots they can fit in the 13-minute match, so there's no room for breathing at all, just a non-stop, brainless action. Ridiculous spot with Jeff going through two tables and no psychology at all at no point."
RealGrapsThomsen wrote on 14.06.2024:
[7.0] "This was a pretty decent match but nothing amazing. It was a long brawl with some creative spots and Jeff dominating Matt for the most part. My main complaint with this match is how good the build up to the finish was only for the finish to be very anticlimactic."
TripleCrown wrote on 24.04.2024:
[6.0] "Jeff & Matt Hardy are so good as a team, but I feel like they kind of fall pretty flat as opponents. I must say though, this is a pretty decent match. Loved the Twist of Fate onto the chair, the story up until that point was awful but luckily they managed to end it with a decent-ish match at WM. Having it be an Extreme Rules match was definitely the way to go, I think if it was a normal 1v1 then it wouldn't be nearly as praised as it is today."
BoltsFan2132 wrote on 09.04.2024:
[7.0] "A decent match that had a few memorable spots with my personal favorite being the table stacking splash by Jeff Hardy. The finish was creative but it seemed to lack intensity after the first few minutes with this being set up as a blood feud between brothers. It was said by Matt in the build up for the match that his career was somewhat mediocre in terms of success compared to Jeff so I'm glad they had him go over here as it's not as if Jeff needed this win. Solid 3 star match."
KingsCrossing wrote on 05.04.2024:
[7.0] "The feud was awful, but the match ended up being pretty good. There are a lot of cool spots here, and the finish is great. While I think they do well making sure the match feels heated, I think the biggest issue here was that things did feel pretty rushed. They had to move quite quickly from spot to spot, and it did mean that some of the storytelling suffered. I think they probably had a better match in them, but this was still a good one."
Heartbreakkid2003 wrote on 17.03.2024:
[8.0] "(8.0) Honestly one of the more underrated mania matches of the 2000s. I was invested into this feud a lot as a kid when I first watched this back in 09 and while The feud itself hasnt aged that good the match here at mania has. For the time it was given they went out and did some great spots especially the twist of fate at the end. 4 stars from me"
ShaliK wrote on 10.02.2024:
[7.0] "A good match, not very memorable despite some nice spots. I've never been a big fan of the chemistry between Jeff and Matt when they face each other in 1Vs1. Note a Rope Break from Matt when Jeff pins him while it's an Extreme Rules match. (3*1/2)"
Jman7 wrote on 18.01.2024:
[6.0] "This was a fun Extreme Rules match, but for how personal the rivalry was, the match felt a little heatless. The big spots looked good, and I liked the finish with Matt hitting a Twist of Fate on Jeff with a chair wrapped around his head. ***1/4"
zachattack2023 wrote on 23.02.2023:
[8.0] "I think this was a very good match I just wish the story line was better and they were given a little more time but it has some fun spots and is a good match . ****"
4outof5 wrote on 25.02.2022:
[6.0] "Some fun stunts here but felt a bit heatless for brother versus brother and especially for the Hardys. No matter, they made things right with The Final Deletion years later."
cactus wrote on 19.05.2021:
[6.0] "An entertaining hardcore match where the weapon spots overshadow the personal aspects of this rivalry. Although the spots were impressive, they move from them so quickly that don't have the impact that would have if they built them up better. All the attempts of story-telling are moved aside so they can all get their shit in. The brutal finish sees Jeff miss a leapfrog leg drop over the ladder and Matt capitalizing by laying Jeff out with a Twist of Fate with Jeff's neck placed in a chair. I can't call this a bad match, but it's certainly a missed opportunity given the history between these two."
Makai Club wrote on 15.03.2019:
[7.0] "Really enjoyed this match. It had a very heated feel to it. Both Hardys showed it in this faicla expression and their use of weapons. It wasn't a crazy match spots wise, it was subdued and basic. Exactly what it needed to be. ***1/2"
owenc510 wrote on 13.10.2018:
[7.0] "This was a good match. I remember the build up being very emotional as a kid, and I felt the same with this watch. The story of Matt trying to get out of the shadow of Jeff was very good. There were a lot of big moves hit and a some brutal spots. Lots of weapons used, some in creative ways. Matt was very good at showing he knew Jeff very well by knowing what he was going to do. A good example being hitting him with a chair as he came down from a Whisper In the Wind. One of the big spots of the match was Jeff putting Matt on a table and stacking another on top then jumping through both onto Matt. I remember it being much bigger before, but it was still good. The second big spot of the match was Jeff leap frogging two giant ladders to do a leg drop but crashing to the mat. The finish looked brutal to me with Matt hitting a Twist of Fate to Jeff with the chair wrapped around his head before getting the pin."
Mizzle Assault Ant wrote on 02.02.2018:
[7.0] "I have really enjoyed some of the matches between these two over the years, but I would agree with others that this was good rather than great. A bit too much time spent with Jeff constructing furniture creations, which I guess is in line with his character but was a bit tedious here. The actual action was good, I just wish it had been worked more like the grudge match it was meant to be."
HeadCheese wrote on 26.07.2016:
[8.0] "A really fun brawl style match. What you would probably expect between these two. Maybe one of the Hardy vs Hardy matches."