DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?

Hulk Hogan vs. Vince McMahon

Match

Match Data
7​.37
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 393
Number of comments: 108
10.0 3x
9.0 52x
8.0 140x
7.0 121x
6.0 60x
5.0 10x
4.0 4x
3.0 1x
2.0 2x
1.0 0x
0.0 0x
Average rating: 7.37  [393]
Average rating in 2026: 7.39  [51]
Average rating in 2025: 7.32  [79]
Average rating in 2024: 7.26  [66]
Average rating in 2023: 7.26  [57]
Average rating in 2022: 7.73  [30]
Average rating in 2021: 7.61  [18]
Average rating in 2020: 7.24  [17]
Average rating in 2019: 7.44  [9]
Average rating in 2018: 7.33  [9]
Average rating in 2017: 8.00  [8]
Average rating in 2016: 7.00  [13]
Average rating in 2015: 7.25  [8]
Average rating in 2014: 7.00  [5]
Average rating in 2013: 7.60  [5]
Average rating in 2012: 8.00  [2]
Average rating in 2011: 7.75  [4]
Average rating in 2010: 7.17  [6]
Average rating in 2009: 8.17  [6]
Your Options:
Other:
Leo the goat wrote on 13.11.2026:
[8.0] "An absolute blast of a garbage brawl that easily earns an 8/10 for turning two men pushing 50 and 60 into pure sports entertainment gold. On paper, Hulk Hogan vs. Vince McMahon in 2003 sounded like a slog, yet they worked the Street Fight stipulation to perfection. Knowing neither man could carry a traditional wrestling match, they leaned into brutal weapon shots, heavy color, and massive theatrical storytelling. Vince McMahon took absurd punishment--getting busted wide open early, taking a sickening leg drop from Hogan off the top of a ladder straight through the Spanish announce table, and giving us that iconic, terrifying shot of his blood-drenched, devilish grin rising up over the ring apron. The surprise return of Roddy Piper cracking Hogan with a steel pipe added huge nostalgia and genuine shock value, making Hogan's final Hulk-Up and triple leg-drop finish pop Safeco Field massively. Blood, guts, and peak Attitude Era melodrama executed without a dull second."
SMSNation7 wrote on 12.11.2026:
[7.0] "(7.0/B) Vince McMahon may not have an athletic bone in his body, and the combined age of the two was 106 at the time, but dammit, this was pretty good. Hogan's infamous comeback at the end, along with the insane crowd energy, was so freakin awesome."
Jamildo2 wrote on 19.10.2026:
[6.0] "This match was WAAAAY better than I remember it being. I mean, it's a 20 minute WWE style street fight between two geriatrics, so let's not go mad here. But this was solid. Genuinely one of the better hogan mania performances so far, even is it was a little generic and going through the greatest hits."
middlerope wrote on 15.10.2026:
[6.0] "An enjoyable match purely due to how absurd it is that the boss and his once biggest star, who's arguably his biggest attraction of all time, are going to blows. In execution, this is little more than a fairly decent brawl with some furniture, but it's the fact that it's two of the biggest personalities in wrestling history colliding that makes this something worth watching. Both men bleed, Vince hits a leg drop off a ladder, a Spanish commentator becomes collateral damage and Hogan hits multiple Atomic Leg Drops in a row to win."
ReiEscobar wrote on 23.09.2026:
[9.0] "Scum find his bag, great. Jokes aside, that match mark my 2000 commented review for a wrestling match, so it clearly means something to me, or it is supposed to be. That match is better than most people would expect. The storyline around it is great, twenty years in the making, Hulk Hogan's legacy on the line against, hate or love that fact, the best hell of all time in the wrestling business. Some stuff around that match isn't good tho, I don't know why Vince tried some kind of limb work into a Street Fight match, didn't had any purpose. I do not hate "fat belly" Roddy Piper interference but it is quite forgetable, and the referee stuff was also unnecessary. Still, the bleeding from both were great, Vince's facial expression and offensive setting was great, his knowledge about what he should do was undeniable great, Hogan's performance was also great, able to generate heat whenever it was the moment, even when the hit with a chair the mexican commentarist. Vince is a better wrestler than you may believe he is. Can't went that far to say he is good, tho. Limits."
KSAHZ8 wrote on 22.09.2026:
[8.0] "A surprisingly entertaining match between these two. Usually whenever Vince works it's fun and over the top but I've never been a fan of Hogan's work. This match was stiff and brutal though and had a surprise run in from Piper which made sense story time. The leg drop off the ladder was actually insane. A good street fight that was serious but also had unoffensive comedy spots throughout. The classic picture of Vince at the end got the match an extra point."
TrailsOfPersona wrote on 29.07.2026:
[4.0] "Almost exactly what you'd expect from these two. Generic brawling for a while, some weapon shots to add color into the mix, stack the deck against Hogan, and then go home after Hulking up. It is about as painfully predictable as you can get from a street fight. The ladder leg drop is DEFINITELY a great spot, and really the only reason I'm giving this four points. Even the Piper addition really served no purpose at all. Yeah, it was a fun pop for Roddy, but it added almost nothing to the final product of the match. The bells and whistles and big spots prevent this match from being bad, but it is far from a good outing either. Even when taking the ability of the two men in the ring into account. They mask their weaknesses to give an acceptable crowd pleaser, but that is as far as this one goes."
Sadagious wrote on 10.06.2026:
[9.0] "Amazingly fun spectacle. Twenty years in the making, Satan himself vs. the Hulkster, Hogan's career on the line, and a showdown between two men who helped define WWE. Vince may not be a wrestler, but he has a surprising ability to produce entertaining matches. He targets Hogan's arm and uses power plays to dominate, while Hogan regains control with an unprotected chair shot that leaves Vince covered in blood. Even the Spanish announcer gets busted open. Vince's evil facial expressions, bloody face, and heat-generating ability are fantastic, and the ladder spot is incredible. The Grenier & Piper run-in fits the story perfectly given Piper's history with Hogan. One of the most unexpectedly great matches in WrestleMania history. ****"
moncastro wrote on 05.05.2026:
"Surprisingly brutal and entertaining match, especially considering both wrestlers' age at the time. Hogan and Vince managed to make it dynamic, intense, and full of memorable moments. It's not a technical classic, but as a violent, story-driven street fight, it really worked for me."
danzitorock wrote on 04.05.2026:
[9.0] "This match is incredible and very underrated, it's truly one of Hogan's best matches, and that's a major compliment because I'm a huge fan of Hogan's work. The concept of the match is awesome, the creator vs the creation, the two juggernauts celebrating WrestleMania, a show that they're responsible for its success, but considering the circumstances, a few bad choices and this could go very wrong, but the correct choices were made and it's spectacular, a bout that stole the show and it's a show with many notorious matches. Vince and Hogan had a bloodbath, and it's a violent and personal match, filled with hate and a great selling by both. McMahon does get a lot of control segments into this match, and I can understand why some people might think this is not the right direction, but his offense looked great so I mean, even considering he's the owner and not a wrestler, if the stuff he's doing looks realistic then I have no issue with that, and his dominance was tremendous, excellent heel work by the boss. They started the match demolishing each other, but considering it's a match with no rules, Mr. McMahon managed to severely punish Hogan with tools and dirty tricks, and that's another reason of why his dominance is believable, because a street fight match always benefit the one who's not a pure wrestler. The spots were incredible, with both Vince and Hogan busted open having a super brawl on the outside, and even Hugo from the spanish announce desk was hit by a chair and bled, an amazing moment as well. Vince's leg drop from the ladder was awesome, and after they returned to the ring, we even had an incredible Roddy Piper cameo, a guy that was in the first main event of WrestleMania, who's also very important for the event, appeared and there was this whole doubt about who he was helping, but turned out he attacked Hogan, and helped McMahon, classic Roddy, playing the heel one more time, great moment. But even with Piper's help, Hogan kicked out, and performed his thrilling comeback, which received a huge pop and the crowd was loving it, it only works when they're buying and that comeback was awesome. Hogan managed to hit McMahon with some leg drops and won the match, a big payoff from the babyface, and this match is just lovely, it's a very interesting concept that actually managed to deliver big time in the ring and that's fantastic - {****1/2}"
WhatIsLooveee wrote on 01.05.2026:
[8.0] "They loved each other, they hated each other, their lives were very intertwined, and both would not have become who they were without each other's help. Even real facts from their biographies were used in the storyline, for example, the testimony of the Hulk against Vince during the steroid scandal. Their story was really very personal, and perhaps what they showed was the best that was possible, given the age of both, and it was something in the style of Vince's match against Shawn Michaels, which took place three years later, only taking into account Hogan's more limited abilities. I can't help but admire Vince - he got himself into amazing physical shape, and looked not like an almost 60-year-old owner of the company who had never performed in the ring full-time, but like a full-fledged wrestler who was really capable of posing a threat. It was very nice to see Roddy Piper, whose biography is also very related to these two, and his appearance seemed reasonable. A brutal, uncompromising fight with really spectacular hardcore moments, an amazing fan reaction (just compare it with the previous match of the card) and good storytelling. A really bright Wrestlemania-level spectacle, 8 points."
mikewillruhl03 wrote on 30.03.2026:
[4.0] "This in-ring was fine for what it was as a street fight but on rewatch it's just pointless and honestly should be forgotten. Both of these men are vile honestly and this could not have been good for their health late in their careers. No wrestlemania pop is worth the grandpa brawl, this would be panned if it was anyone else at the time and just is not worth the rewatch. Hogan wins with three leg drops, best spot was Vince's leg drop off the ladder through the announce table. **"
WG20 wrote on 29.03.2026:
[7.0] "A surprisingly good match between these two. Some great spots especially the ladder leg drop spot. Even the Piper interference made logical sense."
CMFunk007 wrote on 27.03.2026:
[8.0] "I would find this match a lot more believable if I hadn't just watched Vince McMahon get his ass kicked for the last two years by Steve Austin. But it was still fun to see him get his ass kicked by Hogan here, who still had a little bit left in the tank. Roddy Piper's return had to be the biggest surprise of the night."
Sweet Fighter V wrote on 14.03.2026:
[8.0] "There's Hulk Hogan and his Hulkamaniacs, and behind that, a real-life maniac, and his name, is Vincent Kennedy McMahon. On paper, a 20-minute match between a 49 year-old Hogan and a 58 year-old Vince sounds like a recipe for disaster, but the story is way too perfect to pass up on the opportunity. Over twenty years of history culminating into the godlike figure meeting his maker, and it's so damn appealing! And it's a a hot mess, but the story, the violence and the drama are, as always with them, ridiculously compelling. Vince is in crazy shape, his acting and his character work are brilliant, he even pulls out a ladder and lands a leg drop on the announce table, which is a sight to behold. They blast their heads with chair shots, Roddy Piper joins the madness and hits Vince with the pipe (ironically), the crooked ref shows up, then comes an epic Hulk Up with the crowd losing his mind before Hogan lands three Atomic Leg Drops for the win. This is so much fun, and like most Vince matches, a guilty pleasure of mine. ***3/4"
JoeyBingBong wrote on 04.03.2026:
[8.0] "One of the most fascinating triumphs in WrestleMania history, as these two old men bleed their way towards something truly memorable. Somehow, it's even weirder before the insanity, with McMahon targeting Hogan's arm as they seemingly flirt with a "real" match. That portion isn't the match's enduring legacy though, with a single chair shot transforming this in an instant, sparking a pretty surreal stadium spectacle. Naturally, Hogan is the driving force, turning in his last great performance in a match that comically overachieves. ****"
cadaves92 wrote on 22.02.2026:
[6.0] "Surprisingly, this was watchable. Ignoring that both of these dudes suck (inside and outside the ring), somehow they were able to book a match that was highly watchable, even debatably entertaining at different times throughout. The ladder spots, the steel chair to the spanish announcer, etc. - examples of pretty good spots that made this worth it. The weird Rowdy Roddy Piper interference seemed disjointed, and the referee spots were unnecessary. The beginning offense was not good at all, but once the street fight began these two were able to put together a decent match."
SkyIcons wrote on 12.02.2026:
[5.0] "I know they're both old men, but holy hell the offense in this match, from both of them, looked so weak. They should've just skipped straight to the street fight portion, cause that's when this becomes fun. 20 minutes for this is insane and it dragged a lot. Shoutout to that announcer that took a chair shot to the head."
EyeBronze8388 wrote on 01.02.2026:
[5.0] "They worked hard for two guys in their 50s (Hogan turned 50 later in the year while Vince was 58 in 2003). The match was better than it had any right to be. There weren't many good bumps, but as you might expect it was well booked. The lack of transition moves between them was really obvious. The spot on the announce table was definitely the highlight. Tazz & Cole were selling it like it was the best street fight ever, but I would not go that far. Vince's facial expression as he peered up from apron was one of the funniest evil faces I've ever seen. Good job by the director of getting that visual on the show. They probably should have had a 15-minute match instead of 21 minutes because it dragged at various points."
Jonny Dubya wrote on 11.01.2026:
[8.0] "I gotta say, 57 year old Vince McMahon versus 49 year old Hogan with bad injuries and couldn't really go at a level like he used to. But all in all, it's a great match with a fantastic story behind it. Vince wanting to "Kill" Hulkamania. And Hogan fighting for all the little Hulksters. I will say, the leg drop from the ladder by McMahon to Hogan through the announce table was incredible. And that was done by a guy who's not even a wrestler! Also, the pop that Piper got for the interference towards the end was incredible too."
flydel wrote on 14.11.2025:
[7.0] "I was really surprised by how good this match was. A brawl with some impressive spots (like McMahon leg-dropping from the top of the ladder to the commentary team's table), a good nostalgia moment with Roddy Piper coming in to hit Hogan with a metal bar. The rivalry was good and natural and I'm sorry but Vince is a damn good entertainer, a street fight was the logical option for a showdown between the two. A bloody spectacle and assuredly one of the better 00s Hogan match."
Sertay5 wrote on 15.08.2025:
[8.0] "That match is the most suprisingly good match ever for me. I loved this match a lot and I don't really know why to behonest. I loved the usage of blood, I loved the spots and even Piper coming out of blue even tho I didn't understand shit. I think Vince should have go over tho."
nothingleftinside wrote on 12.08.2025:
[5.0] "I don't see the appeal of this. It's basically two old men plodding around and bleeding on each other. The leg drop from the ladder is cool and it's interesting to see Hugo Savinovich take a chair shot to the head. Piper is unexpected but kinda just drags the whole thing out, as is the stuff with the replacement referees. Ends with a hulk up and a big boot. Maybe if I was more invested in the angle I would have liked this more, but for my money it was pretty boring."
Mizzle Assault Ant wrote on 25.07.2025:
[9.0] "Despite losing respect for both these guys over the years on a personal level, I must say this match still holds up as an improbably great spectacle. Bloody and hot with the crowd, it features Vince doing a genuinely insane legdrop off a ladder through a table. That alone makes it surreal in a great way, and the stunning visuals and hot crowd only elevate it further. Weirdly I think this is one of Hogan's best matches."
Popeyeyeyeye wrote on 17.07.2025:
[9.0] "As a lot of people were, I also expected this match to stink up the card and take the place for worst match of the night, but no. This is unironically my favorite Hogan wrestlemania match and they beat the living shit out of each other which I loved watching. Very sports entertained."
notanotherone wrote on 30.05.2025:
[6.0] "I was so ready to not enjoy this, because these roided-up old perverts are two of the most heinous men in the history of wrestling, but I can't deny they put on a decent show here. After a slow start there are some crazy moments, not least that ladder leg drop and the shot of McMahon rising up from the side of the ring covered in blood, looking fittingly like evil incarnate, it's frankly poetic."
Thenxt observer wrote on 24.05.2025:
[8.0] "**** (08/10) Hogan probably would not admit this, but his street-fight against Junior at XIX was one of his best matches in his WrestleMania resume. Not from a technical standpoint, but through sheer, brutal rounds of entertainment that went violent and heavy really fast. So much story built around a feud that had been boiling over the course of 20 years. Having both covered in color was more than appropriate. That shot of Vince rising over the apron with his face dripping red was perhaps the most iconic image of this blood feud. I think if this had happened today (or back then with the knowledge of what we know today) Seattle would have booed them out of the building. But maybe it was best that nobody knew all the truths, because Safeco Field popped for every little thing the two did, with the crowd in their hands. I know Vince must've loved that. Without doubt, this was his best match, ever!"
HyperTortise wrote on 20.05.2025:
[5.0] "This match was exactly what I expected from such a match. Very slow start, but got going with some cool spots. Something about 2 old guys and a ladder fired me up. The Roddy moment was funny because Cole acted like he had no idea who it was. 3 leg drops was absurd, but this whole match was, including the crazyyyy blade job. Fine match."
KKeanel wrote on 19.04.2025:
[9.0] "Hogan's post WCW Wrestlemanias history is incredibly charismatic and electric. Vince's classic way of dealing with personal feud, here based on his own example, had an another fantastic edition. We can say maaaany negative things about the Hulkster, however his knowledge how to play with a crowd and create an in-ring psychology is incomparable."
DecentWrestling wrote on 13.04.2025:
[8.0] "Vince is not known for his technical wrestling skills, but he has perfected the art of entertainment something a lot of wrestlers can't do these days. Make the most of the little things, such as a test of strength for example. The blood here makes sense on Hogan and Vince, as this is a blood feud. I don't see why the Spanish commentator needed to be busted open though lol. We got some epic WrestleMania moment, with Vince doing a legdrop off a ladder through an announce table, and then we get the iconic shot of Vince looking above the apron into the camera with a sadisitic look on his bloody face, such an epic shot. Facial expressions, they are so important and Vince does them like no other. This was such a banger, I had a lot of fun and bought into a lot of the false finishes. Really well put together and performed match."
MeloDontMiss wrote on 09.04.2025:
[4.0] "I celebrated when this match was over. I never really got the appeal towards this match, it felt like a waste of time & it's a shame this got the most build when it's no where near the best match on the card. All the dozen run ins & weapons couldn't even save this match for me."
King of kings 17 25 wrote on 13.03.2025:
"This match started out slow and then it picked up the pace. It was an all right street fight. They didn't use weapons very much. 6.89"
Plebastian wrote on 10.03.2025:
[5.0] "This match between Hulk Hogan and Vince McMahon felt like it was 60 minutes long. Piper's interference lander flat, crooked referees, and lots of blood in place of substance. There were a couple good spots but this is what you'd expect from two men in their 50s."
fablezzzz wrote on 14.02.2025:
[7.0] "Goofy silly fun match spearheaded by the 2 most iconic people in the industries history. You won't find good workrate in this bout, but when it's over you'll sit back and say "I was sports entertained""
Brye wrote on 15.01.2025:
[6.0] "I'm not as high on this as others but I also didn't really have any emotional attachment to either Vince or Hogan when growing up. This just never had my full interest, though the action is fun enough and the crowd is very much into it. Kind of a surreal match in a lot of ways, with the Piper run-in."
uselessdollthing wrote on 24.08.2024:
[2.0] "Cut the first 10 minutes of this match and its actually not that bad. The problem with this match is that they tried to work this like a regular match which obviously did not work. McMahon's strikes look horrible and he is pretty limited in the ring and Hogan probably could not carry him even if he was still in his prime. The last 10 minutes though are good, there are some flaws but its chaotic enough to somewhat ignore them. It's just that the first 10 minutes of this match is really boring and bad."
brooksavage2004 wrote on 14.08.2024:
[9.0] "A really amazing and entertaining street fight with some insanely fun action and spots between both Hogan and Vince and very fitting for Hogan's last ever Mania match."
JacquesRougeauCanHaveMyWife wrote on 30.05.2024:
[7.0] "The story around the match was really interesting and it made you not being able to confidently predict the winner, since it would be a fitting retirement bout for Hogan. Vince's matches have always been nicely structured and well prepared and it wasn't different here, so even though they weren't at the peak of their physical abilities both these guys knew how to work with mainly their facials and timing. Random appearance from Roddy was weird but at least it made sense looking at the history of him and Hogan, plus fans were going batshit for Hulk's hulk up."
Cyclone85 wrote on 23.05.2024:
[5.0] "I thought this was just okay. The skill sets of both, uh, workers was obviously limited. If they cut this by like 5-6 minutes it would've been better. There was some good spots like the table leg drop, but this match had a capped ceiling. The interferences were just meh too"
meka3000 wrote on 04.05.2024:
[4.0] "Time has not been kind to this match, especially when it was likely that this match and being the most built up match on the card was why it did a relatively low buyrate. Both hogan & mcmahon were predicyably sluggish in their action. All the smoke and mirrors didn't do much to help. Especially when hogan & mcmahon are not looked back on fondly due to their real life scandals. ** out of 5. (4.0)"
HugoRoids wrote on 29.04.2024:
[8.0] "Like the dude below me said, this match had no business being this fire. These two relentlessly beat the shit out of one another with pipes and chairs and put each other through tables. One of them isnt even a wrestler and the other one isnt a good wrestler and yet they still put on one of the most entertaining brawls in WWE history. Vince is, like usual, playing the heel perfectly and Hogan is so over and the crowd just goes apeshit for everything he does. Roddy Piper interfering is a little odd but I liked seeing him again, and my god the stare Vince gives Hogan from the outside of the ring is terrifying. A match that should have sucked but ended up being a highlight of one of the best Wrestlemanias of all time."
Heartbreakkid2003 wrote on 30.03.2024:
[9.0] "This match had zerooooooooo business being this fucking good. This was a veryyyyy fun and ugly at times brawl but man this is so much fun to watch. These two were 100 sum years old combined yet they pulled out a classic. An insane blade job from Vince a crazy leg drop from a ladder through a table from Vince. The chair shot to the Spanish Announcer and the Awesome return of Roddy piper this match had it all. A great spectacle 4.25/5"
edgyfr wrote on 23.02.2024:
[6.0] "It was funny, Pipper appearing rnadomly, the Hogan comeback and Vince beeing the most gruesome man ever gave a fun heel work."
yamom wrote on 22.02.2024:
[10.0] "DARE TO DREAM. Maybe my most watched match in history. The best street fight/'garbage' type brawl you'll ever see. Steeped in emotion, history, and genuine intrigue that collides into the perfect match for both guys to partake in at this point in their lives. It's the little things, Shane coming out to console his dad while hes bleeded and giving the most evil middle finger of all time. A match that makes you smile."
RusherBryan29 wrote on 13.02.2024:
[8.0] "This match is very entertaining. Legit one of my favorites wwe match. I think this is Vince Mcmahon best in ring performance, and maybe one of best hogan performance. This match has fun drama, and very hot crowd."
mxkami wrote on 12.02.2024:
[6.0] "I despise both these dudes, but this match is better than it had any right to be. That's all I can say."
alfa labarca wrote on 25.01.2024:
[3.0] "OOOHHH NOOOO, LE DIERON A MI AMIGO! I'm sorry to be this guy, but apart from cool spots like the ladder leg drop, I was emotionally disconnected from this match. It wouldn't be a technical masterpiece, but I was waiting for the match to end. Every "hero's comeback" match looks the same, especially with Hogan. Not fun for me."
Kyle from TheMatchGuide wrote on 21.10.2023:
[6.0] "It's a match between Hogan and McMahon, and it's about as good as these two were ever going to get. They lived up to the stipulation, and I thought the Spanish announcer getting smacked with a chair was a cool touch. It's engaging despite being slow and sloppy, and I have to respect that. Sports entertainment at it's finest, but nowhere near a good mat match in the slightest. 3 Stars."
Ruthless Attitude wrote on 11.07.2023:
[8.0] "Obviously not a mat classic, but some storytelling fun that was much better than it had any right to be. Pretty much lived up to the street fight stipulation with lots of chairshots, gallons of blood lost and a great shot Vince McMahon looking like the devil holding a lead pipe. That poor Spanish announce guy got drilled with a chairshot and got some colour as well. There's a fun Roddy Piper appearance as he hits his arch enemy Hogan with a pipe. It's sports entertainment fun and that's exactly what it needed to be."
bigredtalk89 wrote on 06.07.2023:
[8.0] "Underrated match, sure it's not a technical masterpiece but it's pure fun. Vince with a leg drop off the ladder onto Hogan through the announcer's table, the iconic shot of Vince with his face covered in blood holding a pipe, the return of Roddy Piper, this match had so much packed into it and they were able to put enough smoke and mirrors in to cover up for the fact that these are two senior citizens in the ring. One of Hogan's better late-career performances and one of the better physical performances of Vince's in-ring career"