[5.0] "Monster's Ball matches tend to be slow-moving and spot-oriented, with this being no exception. It wasn't the worst hardcore garbage match I've ever seen, but RVD was phoning it in and Abyss had lost a step along the way despite not having been that great in the first place"
[6.0] "A fairly good hardcore match. The high spots are at least meaningful here though Abyss's attempt at creepy talk with the bat was silly and made it seem like a joke. "Time to go to work again my darling! " Come on. There isn't much connective tissue here, just spot to spot but it was enjoyable enough once through. Three and a quarter."
[5.0] "Slow hardcore match that did have some brutal moments, but didnt hold my attention. The 2x4 with nails on it and the barbed wire on the wood looked painful. However, The match just wasnt real interesting to me and felt short."
[7.0] "A lot of fun stuff right here, a match that was really in the right place and at the right time on this card that needed it at this point of the show, a big intense hardcore match absolutely perfect to end their rivalry in a show like they knew how to do together at that time. Not as good as their Stairway To Janice match they'd had on television for the title a few weeks earlier, but a very good stipulation bout in Abyss' favorite setting with a lot of great spots. RVD's Rolling Thunder through the table was my favorite."
[7.0] "Pretty dang nice hardcore brawl, fittingly from an ECW Original and a man who's willing to do the most ridiculous deathmatch stuff you can get on TV. Only real problem is it made me yearn for a match between the 2006 selves of these two workers, when they were closer to their prime. Particularly, RVD being more mobile would have pushed this match up even higher."
[7.0] "There's not much that separates this from your usual Abyss Monster's Ball match, but both guys put a fine effort in and RVD's bump from the top rope onto a barbed wire board looked impressive. There's also a nice Van Daminator that didn't look overly contrived."