Eddie Guerrero vs. Edge

[6.0] "Not as good as their Summerslam match, but still excellent. This didn't have the same kind of storytelling and relies more so on explosive moves then the prior match. Still wonderful. Just not as memorable. The final spot before the finish was awesome regardless. It is an exciting, well performed match, but not one that really leaves a lasting impression in my opinion."

[7.0] "Edge and Eddie Guerrero were a good duo to have a match against each other. They worked well together and always gave as good as they got. They would have an even better match 4 days later on Smackdown in a no DQ match."

[8.0] "Eddie's awesome character work makes this such a fun match. His cockiness, his work on top, and he does a great job at making an otherwise bland Edge look good. Solid action, nice finish, I dig this. ***3/4"

[8.0] "I thought this was fantastic and I really liked the way Edge sold the concussion. It's actually kind of crazy to see WWE openly saying 'concussion' during a match here, considering they generally would steer clear of that these days. I thought the finishing stretch and the finish itself to be especially good. The 2nd best match these two guys had, with the #1 being the one on Smackdown."

[6.0] "It was once again carried by Eddie who was the only one showing any personality and caring about working the crowd. Edge was bland, but the match itself wasn't bad. They were smooth, hit some nice moves and creative counters, but nothing more than that."

[8.0] "This is my favorite match of theirs in this program. The intensity from the very start is just right, with Eddie doing an elite job for the crowd. Some really top notch sequences and moves from both over the course of the match and a creative and effective ending. Good ass match"

[8.0] "A really good match here, with Eddie especially doing the sneaky cheating heel work well. Edge was a great foil for him here, selling everything well without ever looking dumb for falling for it. This was in-ring psychology and storytelling without having to be slow and relying on restholds."

[9.0] "A superb match. High intensity and work rate. Eddie really finds that extra gear and I loved how he removes the turnbuckle pad without the referee spotting it so you don't see a lull in the action and how it also plays into the finish of the match. Edge also looks good and sells the offense and the head injury well. Eddie was always a great heel, but he takes it to another level with his mannerisms and his facial expressions to the point where he is over with the fans and the sunset flip finish looked amazing."

[8.0] "This was an excellent performance from Eddie Guerrero. He shows fantastic range as a heel here. Whether it's cowardice, crafty resourcefulness, or cocky swagger, he does it all so naturally. I really liked his creative submission on Edge's neck, too. The finish was perfect and I appreciated that it didn't involve anybody needing to hit their finisher. Great match."

[8.0] "Really liked this one it feels as if the more matches they had against each other the better the matches got Their worse but not still not bad first match at summerslam their very good 2nd match here at Unforgiven and their classic blowoff match On Smackdown. Great feud and great matches between 2 greats This match gets a 4/5"

[6.0] "It was a good match, Eddie is a fantastic wrestler and carried it pretty much the whole match. Edge is not a bad wrestler but Eddie is on a completely different level and much better than Edge. The match started well, i thought it got a bit boring during the middle but towards the end, they picked up the pace a bit and i really liked the way it ended with a powerbomb from the top corner."

[7.0] "This was a really good match with a great performance from Eddie. Edge's head was focused on throughout the match and he sold it well. The sunset flip powerbomb looked great and was a good finish. ***3/4"

[8.0] "Eddie was great in this his character work, facial expressions and work over Edge was great. Edge was coming off a concussion heding into this match so Eddie targeted it throughout this match and as stated earlier his work was strong, Edge had nice moments of acting dazed due to this. I loved the sunset flip powerbomb ending because it played into what Eddie worked on throughout this the neck/head. Good match slightly better than the SummerSlam match***3/4"

[9.0] "Eddie Guerrero's character work & facial expressions in this match while portraying a sinister heel are fantastic. The action is great too, and I pooped big for the finish."

[8.0] "Marginally better than their SummerSlam encounter. Nothing amazing but another good stuff from these two. They did a good job building up the match, and I liked the exposed turnbuckle bit at the end. The ladder war on SD would soon follow this and would way surpass the two PPV bouts these two had. [***3/4]"

[7.0] "Really fun little match right here. Not a classic by any means, but a good back and forth matchup with an invested crowd that flowed fairly well. I found Eddie to be the MVP here, his character work, offence and selling were great, especially when he sold that punch from Edge as though it knocked him out. That was funny as hell lol. All in all a pretty great match with a good ending that had Eddie bashing Edge's head off the turnbuckle and hitting him with a sunset flip powerbomb off the top rope. This is a hidden gem. ***1/2"

[6.0] "Satisfactory match. Two of SmackDown' finest going at it, with a pretty good finish, and a little final visual that I personally loved. Eddie's cockiness. That's what made him shine. And what still makes him shine today in the memory of all of us."

[5.0] "Decent match. Eddie was fantastic. Did all the work to make Edge look good, got all the heat and had all the exciting offence. Edge was meh and did nothing. **3/4"

[7.0] "Good match between the two. Eddie's charisma and heel work shines in this match and the finish was pretty good too. Not as good as their Summerslam match though."

[7.0] "Another very good match from these 2. Felt like a really good tv match. Nothing crazy but a very good match. ***1/2"