[5.0] "Passable matchup, loved Hulk Hogan's heel antics and the way that he won the championship. The Giant does some cool moves too although really hated the bikes' sounds during this match. Overall a nice watch."
[6.0] "Not sure why this match is rated so low. It was a w a txhabke main event with the Giant having some cool spots, with the best ones being hik Huljing uo and also when he chokeslammed Scott Hall. And speakning of Hall, the post fight shenanigane is what shined here the most. Again not sure why i's rated so low .... it's more entertaining than 90% of the main events you see nowadays"
[4.0] "it's not bad but it's not great, it's very slow and has only a few moments that stand out (really nice backbreaker from the giant). Fine but meh, follow up promos not great. Still very much learning on the job with the nwo"
[2.0] "Stupidly slow and boring. Cliché ending and a crowd who doesn't really care ? (they would rather play with their bikes). The only novelty here is that apparently it's the first Hogan match with the "Hollywood" gimmick... What a bad first impression."
[3.0] "Debut match of Hollywood Hogan was executed in a rather dull way. 90% of Hulk's heel sticks and 10% of an actual wrestling. The Outsiders' interference could look much better. Whole thing shouldn't last nearly 30 minutes."
[4.0] "This match might have worked a lot better if it wasn't in front of this kind of crowd as they was just cheering Hogan for everything he did, which isn't good for his first proper match since turning heel. He's way over the top with the cowering and the stalling as well to the point where it's just not believable to watch and it makes the match really boring as well. I did like the moment in the match towards the end where The Giant was Hulking up routine and then had the match won with the chokeslam before Hall and Nash inevitably interfered and Hogan wins the title. It got to it's destination I suppose and the post match where Hogan spray painted the belt was iconic. The complete burial of The Booty Man was hilarious."
[3.0] "a match that clearly exists to be driven by audience reaction and storyline, except the audience doesn't give a shit about the story in any way so it kind of doesn't work as well as you'd hope it to. most of this is very long holds and Hogan running away... but the crowd cheers every time Hogan gets away, or gets the upper hand, and they pop off like crazy when he wins the belt via cheating and the Outsiders both interfering as if he heroically won it clean. without the right crowd reaction this DOES move the story along in a fun way, but is a really rough watch as a match."
[5.0] "If only The Giant was more over as a babyface it would have been much better, but I still liked what they did here. Basically Hogan was trying out his heel tricks and it was so fresh to see it from him. I loved his stalling with constantly leaving the ring and then watching him getting suprised by Wight was something new. For some people it might have been too slow, but for me it was really fascinating to watch and it only made me wish that they did it in front of the more wrestling knowledgeable crowd."
[0.0] "Hogan going from being a guy who can beat the entire roster with relative ease to cowering from The Giant makes no logical sense and the heel stalling doesn't work when the crowd have already decided that Hogan is the face here. Agonizing amounts of stalling and a test of strength that lasts an ice age. Nothing either guy does looks like it has any impact. Giant sells a belt shot like a bullet to the head and stays out in the middle of the ring for what must have been almost 10 minutes."
[3.0] "Hogan's first match as a heel was surreal to see at the time. He went from being Superman to being a cowardly heel. Bobby Heenan tried to cover for this, but I just didn't buy it. The nWo immediately target the champion of the promotion, which for some reason they didn't do during their WWF run. This match was dull and slow and tough to sit through...and this weirdo crowd is chanting for Hogan throughout the match."
[2.0] "Really dull main event, even with all the NWO window dressing, this match just doesn't work. Also doesn't help that this is the....like, 4th Giant/Hogan match in a calendar year, which really hurts the appeal."
[7.0] "Slow but I actually enjoyed the dynamic of it, watching Hogan work as a true heel for the first time on a PPV. The angle after the match was great too, lots of historical value in this match."
[3.0] "The formula for this match: Giant hit's a move, Hogan bails and jaws with the crowd. Back in, GIant hits a move, Hogan bails. Rinse and repeat until the heel run in helps Hogan win the belt. Hogans first ppv since the turn. Hogan has made a complete 180 and is now acting like a cowardly heel. Every time Giant hits something Hogan takes the low road. Hogan tries to be a bad guy and tells the crowd to shut up but they keep cheering him. After 5 or 8 minutes Hogan finally gets the upper hand. Hogan moves to polish off The Giant but the Giant starts "hulking up" and drops Hogan with the big boot. Uh oh. NWO run in! Giant fends them off but Hogan gets a hold of the world title and pops Giant with it and pins him to win the WCW world title. Bad new for WCW. Hall and Nash celebrate Hogans birthday by having the Booty Man bring out a birthday cake. What did Shiavone expect? Everyone in WCW pretty much turned on Booty and The Horsemen almost broke his leg because of his association with Hogan, so I can understand why he would join the NWO. Course it's only temporary. Hogan makes an example of him and he and the Outsiders beat the snot out of brother Bruti. The birthday present is a can of black spray paint which they use to spray NWO on the belt. Shiavone Heenan and Rhodes are disgusted. I'm usually lenient on Hogan matches because I was a mark back in the day, but this sucked!"
[3.0] "This match was harmed by the audience more than any other on the card due to them cheering for Hogan and not the Giant, probably because they knew nothing of the storyline. It was also harmed by being 15 minutes long with almost no actual wrestling, more importantly. Yes, the storyline was crucial to WCW's next few years, but unlike the formation of the NWO a few weeks prior to this it doesn't make up for the poor match."
[1.0] "As great as the storyline, so worthless match. This whole fight on the hands of someone showing their strength looked too drawn-out and tiring. Hogan was not yet so much accustomed to the role of the bad guy at that time in the ring, he felt uncomfortable in some places of the match. But the post-match segment was very good and further promoted the grouping to great heights in the industry."
[0.0] "One of the WORST matches I've ever seen in my life. It's very boring, very slow, I didn't give a damn about the match. I wanted it to end as soon as possible... -*"
[5.0] "Obviously the presentation is a problem, these bikers are clearly not invested WCW followers and more interested in seeing Hogan for his name value than following the nWo story. But I thought this was a fine match actually, Hogan leans heavily into his stooging heel act and it feels very fresh, and Giant does well enough."
[3.0] "This was a slog to get through, but in addition to that the match didn't really work because The Giant was ridiculously not over here. Crowd was going nuts for Hogan despite him being a heel and doing general heel things. Any attempt to get The Giant over as a babyface fell completely flat, which makes sense because how are you gonna root for the dude with Jimmy Hart at ringside doing his annoying whistle and megaphone shtick? Still was an important moment in the NWO storyline."