DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?

Ashley & Maria vs. Beth Phoenix & Melina

Match

2.15
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 162
Number of comments: 28
10.0 0x
9.0 0x
8.0 0x
7.0 0x
6.0 0x
5.0 0x
4.0 22x
3.0 28x
2.0 67x
1.0 39x
0.0 6x
Average rating: 2.13  [162]
Average rating in 2026: 2.48  [27]
Average rating in 2025: 1.87  [45]
Average rating in 2024: 2.03  [34]
Average rating in 2023: 2.09  [32]
Average rating in 2022: 2.27  [15]
Average rating in 2021: 2.67  [9]
Your Options:
Other:
EvieSonicFan124 wrote on 03.08.2026:
[0.0] "[DUD] This Is The Rightful Place On The Card Due To The Overwhelming Emotion In The Last Match, I Liked The Ladies In The Match. I Think The Divas Year In WWE Was Perfect, But This was A Bad Start And One Of The Worst Matches Of WWE? No, I Don't Considered It Being Bad, But There Was No Reason To Name The Match A Playboy Tag Match If One Of The Wrestlers Isn't in Playboy! {i think} And, I Loved Santino Marella In The End Segment. SNOOP DOGG CAN THROW HANDS! But Hey, At Least It made Me Jump More Than The Boring Sloppy Spots The Divas Did, Not Saying That Beth, Melina, Ashley & Maria Did Bad, But They Could've Did Better. Love Their Match Quality, But This Was Horrid."
PWC wrote on 29.03.2026:
[4.0] "I will say that all four ladies in this match, really tried here but, alas this was just not that great at all. The only highlights of the match came with Melina and Beth doing the double team electric chair slingshot spot and the nice bulldog by Maria from the top rope. There was nothing really at stake here in this match. Just Santino getting jealous of Ashley getting Maria to pose nude in Playboy...that was the whole story to the match. I would give this a lower score if wasn't for the lights going out, Maria kissing Snoop afterwards and Lawler sucker punching Santino was a little fun to watch."
Raditz Flair wrote on 14.03.2026:
[0.0] "Beth Phoenix is the only one who has real talent and can actually wrestle. I almost gave a 1 for her but this fiasco isn't worth any score. Sometimes I wish we could get into negative numbers here because this would be one match that's worthy of a -2."
SkyIcons wrote on 14.03.2026:
[2.0] "They set this match up for disaster. Dumb gimmick, right after flair's retirement. Work-rate wise, it's a 2008 divas match... then the lights in the arena go out."
Smi-48 wrote on 20.02.2026:
[2.0] "This isn't a match, it's a meat market, Vince McMahon style. Accordingly, this junk has aged badly, at least since the 'Me Too' movement. We mustn't forget that Ashley Massaro's tragic fate is also linked to crap like this. Santino Marella and a few halfway decent moves from the heels bring in just under two points."
EyeBronze8388 wrote on 01.02.2026:
[3.0] "Bad match. It should have been three minutes with these competitors. Beth tried to carry it, but Ashley & Maria were not the right team. The crowd didn't care. Neither did the light crew. At least they used a spotlight to focus on the action in the ring. The clothesline by Snoop after it was over was a good way to get the heat back for the babyfaces."
sdenapoli wrote on 26.08.2025:
[3.0] "I don't really know what to say here. All I will say is that at least the right team won and at least we don't ever have to see this dumb crap at Mania, or in WWE anymore."
Thenxt observer wrote on 24.05.2025:
[1.0] "1/2* (01/10) (shake my head). (shake my motherf****ng head). WWE was not there, yet, with ways a ways a ways to go! What I actually hate most about the Lumberjill affair is that since it hit the five minute mark, I have to add it's rating to the shows final score. Thanks, Vince. Thanks a lot! Not even the f****ng lights wanted to stay on for this."
KKeanel wrote on 25.04.2025:
[3.0] "Women's wanna be entertainment piss breaks during a dark days of their division were a regular part of Wrestlemanias back in the day and this match fortunately wasn't worst of them. Snoop added some value."
popsi netn wrote on 20.04.2025:
[0.0] "WWE is capable (WM22). But this is rock bottom. All the women are dressed in short skirts, dancing behind a pimp. It's not even hidden that they are eye candy. The match isn't even worth mentioning, Maria and Ashley do what they can but only have the basics. Disgusting and embarrassing."
Ajay00329 wrote on 02.04.2025:
[0.0] "You know it's bad when the floodlights of the stadium also refused to look at this match. Honeslty this was a bathroom break match for the worse. Happening just after the heart wrenching match between flair and Michaels. Snoop dog and santina marella and the entire women's roster being involved didn't helped either. If this match was cut the show wouldn't be affected. A terrible match overall"
Erdrick wrote on 31.03.2025:
[3.0] "The best that the Divas of the era could do in a throwaway tag match, though it's unfortunate that this was in the place of a Divas title match. The lights cut out mid-match, resulting in a scramble to get spotlights on the ring, which probably didn't help the quality. The Playboy branding made no sense and I have no idea why Snoop Dogg was involved, with the very awkward kiss from the rapper to Maria at the end getting downright creepy."
brooksavage2004 wrote on 12.09.2024:
[0.0] "I really couldn't actually care about this match whatsoever. The whole Playboy aspect wasn't needed, the in ring work was bad so was all the shenanigans by Santino, Snoop and Lawler and the bad production and lighting made this match worse too. Horrible."
JacquesRougeauCanHaveMyWife wrote on 28.07.2024:
[2.0] "At least it wasn't some another Bra and Panties Match, so I guess that's a progress? Phoenix and Melina looked good here, they were connecting with their stuff and had a good timing, but Jesus Christ there's nothing you can do when you're put against Ashley and Maria. Two eye candies that can't bump, can't throw a punch and probably would get broken in half if you touch them too hard, so the lighting issues actually did them a favor."
TrailsOfPersona wrote on 20.01.2024:
[3.0] "It is a really bad match, but I've seen worse. The major problem to me is, the baby face team are just wrestling with pillow-like softness. Don't get me wrong, I'm not the type that needs to brutal hard-hitting matches that leave the participants bruised by any means, but these women weren't even throwing remotely believable shots in. It's hard to have any immersion and suspend any disbelief like that. Also...I don't understand King's spot? Santino had one interference, and Jerry decides he needs to leave the announce position and hit him? Was this just supposed to be a favor to him to try and get him a pop at Wrestlemania? Because no one cared. Then there's the disrespect aspect of this match that this was a lumberjack for the sole purpose of getting the other women a small pay off. Overall, while I wouldn't quite call this match bowling shoe ugly due to the efforts of Beth and Melina, it's close, and undoubtably a bad match. Not one you'll want to watch again."
violet011 wrote on 20.03.2023:
[2.0] "This could not have gone any worse for the women involved. Playing second fiddle to Santino and Snoop was bad enough but the production issues and feminist Jerry Lawler getting involved killed any hope it had - *"
Cal1641 wrote on 15.03.2023:
[2.0] "Even the production team wanted this one to end. I do feel bad for the women involved in this 1. Because its awful 2. Because they have to wrestle in the dark. Really this should have been melina vs beth phoenix if you wanted a decent match."
TheOneAndOnlyCactus wrote on 14.03.2023:
[2.0] "I legit forgot that this match was promoted by Playboy, as this match doesn't feature the usual sexual themes of prior Playboy matches. I did remember Snoop Dogg taking part in the action at ringside and he was the highlight of the match as aside from that, there's nothing notable to mention. It was an inoffensive match, basically."
PLRadek wrote on 21.02.2023:
[3.0] "Least eventful match on the card had one or two good spots including Beth's spear to Melina. 1.5 stars"
eltetechori wrote on 26.05.2022:
[2.0] "Undoubtedly, the worst of the event, no chemistry, uninteresting fight and on top of that put it in a gap of great intensity in an event like this."
EliasAC wrote on 04.04.2022:
[1.0] "Ashley & Maria vs. Beth Phoenix & Melina is horrible, nothing happened, The only point that I put is for Snoop Dogg."
flightaker321 wrote on 20.03.2022:
[1.0] "As expected when looking at the time period this took place this wasn't very good. Probably meant to be a cooldown match for the show.*"
cactus wrote on 19.05.2021:
[2.0] "This is promoted by Playboy and hosted by Snoop Dogg, but the T&A aspects are thankfully nowhere to be found. Beth uses her size to hit some power moves and Maria's attempts at doing hurricanranas and other athletic stuff weren't good, but I appreciate the effort. Santino gets involved, which causes Jerry Lawler to leave the commentary table and knock him out. Snoop Dogg hits Santino with a surprisingly decent clothesline after the match. Better than I expected, but it's still bad."
Sky23 wrote on 01.05.2021:
[2.0] "The year is 2008. Gail Kim and Awesome Kong are having bangers over in TNA. What does WWE counter this with? Playboy bunnies! Beth Phoenix and Melina (two actual wrestlers) must have hated every minute of this, being relegated to a cooldown match for the sole purpose of tittilation. They don't even half-ass it. No one does, not even Ashley (reminder: Ashley wanted to actually be trained to wrestle but WWE ignored her). It's just... the premise of this match doesn't allow for any sort of quality. They didn't even let the women be the focus, with Snoop Dogg hosting and Santino Marella being the difference maker for the heels."
texasyosh wrote on 27.03.2021:
[2.0] "This match has aged considerably poorly, Ashley and Maria's gimmicks were being... playboy bunnies. The entire presentation of this is offputting. We get some shenanigans with Santino Marella. Beth is obviously the star of this match, but there really isn't anything meaningful here, this match can be skipped."
Mizzle Assault Ant wrote on 05.01.2021:
[4.0] "Obviously this has some weaknesses, I don't think it's that bad but it's just sort of there in a perfunctory way. Phoenix is fun to watch, and Maria and Melina had their moments. Poor Ashley never had a chance to get very good but she really tried at least."