DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?

A-Train & The Big Show vs. The Undertaker

Match

3.6​9
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 268
Number of comments: 71
10.0 0x
9.0 0x
8.0 1x
7.0 6x
6.0 13x
5.0 58x
4.0 54x
3.0 85x
2.0 47x
1.0 3x
0.0 1x
Average rating: 3.68  [268]
Average rating in 2026: 3.55  [53]
Average rating in 2025: 3.79  [62]
Average rating in 2024: 3.72  [61]
Average rating in 2023: 4.04  [48]
Average rating in 2022: 3.32  [25]
Average rating in 2021: 3.24  [17]
Average rating in 2020: 2.00  [2]
Your Options:
Other:
Leo the goat wrote on 13.11.2026:
[6.0] "A decent, totally watchable big-man showcase that earns a fair 6/10--and holds up better than its reputation suggests. Originally slated to be a tag team match with Nathan Jones before Jones was pulled for being too green, this turned into a straightforward handicap brawl designed to make The Undertaker look like an unstoppable force. Big Show and A-Train worked a snug, heavy-hitting beatdown segment, utilizing their massive size advantage effectively while Undertaker bumped well for two giants. The crowd inside Safeco Field popped huge for Undertaker's comebacks, Nathan Jones running down late to take out A-Train with a spin kick, and Undertaker hitting a crisp Tombstone Piledriver on A-Train to move to 11-0. It wasn't a technical clinic, and the pacing was deliberately methodical, but as a midcard spectacle on a stacked show, it did its job cleanly."
PaoloReaper wrote on 07.11.2026:
[8.0] "Far better that I ever thought this would be. Taker is on top, top shape in this, connecting heavy but moving light as a wild hog. Everything feels big, like an ancient gods showdown"
Kugenesan1 wrote on 18.10.2026:
[6.0] "This is the first time I have actually watched the entire match and I have to say, this was way better than I expected it to be. Taker was so agile, he was running and leaping like a cruiserweight here. Not like he has never been agile, lol. Always love the presentation of Taker, especially when it comes to Manias. This was no exception, Limp Bizkit performing and Taker riding was an incredible sight. Yes, people may argue, this should have been a singles match instead, with Big Show, maybe it might be a solid match, but I don't think it would have been any better. Making it a handicap match and having Taker overcoming two giants made more sense. And not having Nathan Jones in the match made ultimately paid off for me cause he simply wasn't in that level. But still having him get his Mania moment was a solid call too. All that said, especially after last year, where Taker literally acknowledged his undefeated Mania streak, the least this company could do is give Taker someone worthy to work with. Benoit was literally right there and so was a young Cena."
middlerope wrote on 14.10.2026:
[3.0] "One of the weaker Undertaker WrestleMania streak matches. This does no favours for Big Show or Albert, making them look pretty weak as one man was able to take them both to the limit. Nathan Jones interferes, throws a spin kick and enters the ring directly under the referees nose and this somehow doesn't lead to a DQ. Still somewhat entertaining - it was interesting seeing Undertaker pull out armbar variations and his big moves always get a pop."
Jamildo2 wrote on 09.10.2026:
[2.0] "As a kid, my favourite wrestler was the undertaker. For the life of me, I can't figure out why. His entire legend is tied to Wrestlemania and frankly, almost every appearance that he made at the PPV up to this point had been awful. This match, was no exception. Poorly worked, poorly structured and clearly a box ticking exercise bought about due to Nathan Jones's lack of ability. Horrible match."
KSAHZ8 wrote on 22.09.2026:
[1.0] "One of the bad Taker Mania matches. Crowd didn't really seem to care either, the premise of Taker in a handicap match at Mania is cool but A-Train just doesn't fit as a good competitor, I think a singles match between Taker and Show would have worked better, I think it should have been a little shorter and the time given to the opening match instead. Nathan Jones being taken out for being terrible may have tainted this match for being pretty terrible."
danzitorock wrote on 05.08.2026:
[3.0] "That was a very lame match, and a super weird booking decision to have Undertaker, who already had an established WrestleMania record at this point, facing A-Train and Big Show, in a very pointless match. The original plan was to have Nathan Jones, a guy nobody has ever heard of, teaming up with Undertaker, but he was pulled out of the match, and it became a 2-on-1 handicap, which says it all about the experience. The action had some standard power moves, considering that everyone involved are powerhouses, but the dynamic wasn't necessarily interesting, it was a short and filler match. Jones appeared at the end to help Taker win the match and extended his WM record to 11-0 - {*1/4}"
TrailsOfPersona wrote on 31.07.2026:
[5.0] "Of Biker Taker's three Wrestlemania matches, this is definitely the worst. And it is also certainly a weaker Streak match as well, but I don't think it's a bad match. It's alright for what it is. Just really generic. Nathan Jones was supposed to be with Taker, but I'm assuming because he was greener than grass and not ready for this spot, they took him out and just had him interfere at the end. You also might forget that Big Show is just a few months out of being WWE champion because he they are so low on the card. They do an alright job having the two on one game slowly wear Taker down before he mounts a come back. It's a perfectly watchable match but really uninteresting."
Wlliamofbaskerville wrote on 14.04.2026:
[3.0] "This match pretty much shows how much Taker's stock had plummeted in 03. Tossed into a tag team with greener then goat shit Nathan Jones (Who would go on to be terrific in two Mad Max movies) against career mid carder A-Train and an unmotivated Big Show. Infamously Jones was pulled from this match at the last minute because everyone realised how terrible he was and instead Taker went at it alone. If this had been on a random episode of smackdown, this may have been somewhat passable. But for a Undertaker wrestlemania match. This is a dull nothing burger. Its not as terrible as say Gonzalez or Bundy but its so thoroughly forgettable I am struggling to say anything about it at all. If Kane had been in this instead of Taker this would be long forgotten. The only memorable thing about this is Michael Cole calls a side suplex a gut wretch suplex. Says it all really. Probably a bottom five streak match."
NewToAllOfThis wrote on 13.04.2026:
[4.0] "It feels more like a standard TV match you'd see today rather than an Undertaker WrestleMania match. All three men work well, and it's clear they went full hoss for the match, nothing too special, but it just feels like they're hitting hard and trying to put on the best show they can. With guys this big, it was never going to be an athletic, cruiserweight-style match-up, but for what it is, it's fine. **1/4"
mikewillruhl03 wrote on 30.03.2026:
[3.0] "This was really boring in the ring with Taker and Show/Albert going very slow and for some reason Takers partner was taken out then showed up early. Obviously they had nothing going for Undertaker at this point in 2003 but they could have done literally anything other than this and it likely would've been better. One of Undertakers worst wrestlemania matches for sure. **"
WhatIsLooveee wrote on 29.03.2026:
[3.0] "The weakest match on the show, the main problem of which was the lack of any intrigue. The Heels had previously attacked Nathan, securing an advantage for themselves. The Undertaker continued his impressive streak, defeating two massive rivals at once, and that's all that can be said about this match."
WG20 wrote on 29.03.2026:
[3.0] "A boring match which felt like a TV match not worthy for Wrestlemania. Undertaker did his best against the opposition he was against."
ReiEscobar wrote on 25.03.2026:
[5.0] "I can be the one running against the will here, but man, that was so fucking funny lmao. In storyline terms, is stupid that two big guys can't defeat one, I don't care if that was supposed to be an tag team match, that decision was stupid. Big Show's selling was also inconstant but I had fun here, a lot of fun. Can't say that is a bad match, it is worth an watch."
CMFunk007 wrote on 15.03.2026:
[3.0] "Nathan Jones was supposed to be Undertaker's partner for this match, but for some reason, they removed Jones from the match. Honestly, though, Undertaker moved quite well for a big guy during this one. But A-Train and Big Show seemed determined to make this one suck. Nathan Jones runs out secure the victory for Taker and everyone goes home happy and undefeated."
Sweet Fighter V wrote on 14.03.2026:
[4.0] "For Taker to be handed such a piss-poor match-up as The Streak was becoming a thing is disgraceful. And well, it's not good, which does not come as a surprise... it's freakin' A-Train and The Big Show after all, and it's so underwhelming. It's not that bad though. It being an handicap match adds some tension at the very least, but Nathan Jones coming in, hitting a Big Boot on A-Train in front of the ref and the ref not doing shit makes for a weird finish. It's under 10 minutes si it's alright, Taker gets the win and Limp Bizkit put on a show for his entrance at least. Still the weakest match of an all-time great WrestleMania. These guys had no business sharing the ring with Taker on his stage. **1/2"
cadaves92 wrote on 22.02.2026:
[4.0] "Not good. Nathan Jones was clearly not ready for a big match, so it was probably a good idea to boot him from the match, but instead we got a spot fest. A couple chokeslams, a bomb by A-Train, interference, finish. Not impressed. Was shocked to see Undertaker attempt a couple arm bars and other mat wrestling techniques."
EyeBronze8388 wrote on 01.02.2026:
[2.0] "Boring match. Vince sure loves his big guys huh? My question to WWE is if you knew Jones sucked so much why was he in a match at WrestleMania while other talented individuals are off the show? Weak! Undertaker had some worse WrestleMania matches, but this may have been the most forgettable one. He deserved a bigger role at this show. It was the last time he would be at a WrestleMania without a "Dead Man" gimmick too."
Jonny Dubya wrote on 11.01.2026:
[3.0] "Perhaps the weakest match overall on this show, I think it should've been the tag team match with Taker & Jones against Show and Albert. Because all three could've carried Nathan Jones and he would've had the benefit of three of the safest and most reliable workers in the company in that match with him."
thenumbersdontlie wrote on 07.11.2025:
"This is not a bad match at all. Nothing spectacular, but I had fun watching it. I would even argue that it's one of the better WrestleMania Undertaker matches before 2005. I didn't like the ending with the Nathan Jones interference though."
nothingleftinside wrote on 12.08.2025:
[5.0] "This isn't actually too bad, the pace is pretty good for the kind of match that it is and considering who's in it. Some very weak selling from big show in this. Undertaker looks like quite the athlete though. Nathan Jones then interferes and somehow this isn't a DQ? I guess because he was "supposed to be in the match"? Am I the only one who gives a shit about the rules here? Passable filler on a card like this, but maybe a bit of a waste of the undertaker, knowing what he's (sometimes) capable of? Extra point for Limp Bizkit playing taker out to the ring."
notanotherone wrote on 29.05.2025:
[6.0] "Didn't mind this at all. It's not exactly dynamic but it's three massive dudes beating each other up, and I don't have any complaints there. Having Limp Bizkit play Undertaker to the ring is also a nice bit of nostalgia. I also feel like A-Train/Albert never gets his dues. He was such a solid and reliable worker throughout the early-2000s"
Thenxt observer wrote on 24.05.2025:
[7.0] "***1/4 (6.5/10) Could you imagine how inferior the 11th match of the Streak would have turned out if they had given Nathan Jones the greenlight? We'd probably be talking about the worst match of the Streak. Instead, we were treated to a kick-a** performance by WWE's favorite band (sure, Vince) that was followed by a decent, passable Handicap match that seemed more suited for RAW. In his career, the Undertaker performed in 27 different Showcase of the Immortals, with many top-tier bangers, plenty of terrible encounters, and everything else in between. This was part of everything else."
HyperTortise wrote on 14.05.2025:
[3.0] "Alright normally musical bits stink in these shows, but this pre-match music was hype. I wish it could have helped the match lmao. Just a slow, not fun match. Much like MOST of Taker's WM matches. This was boring and I didn't enjoy it. Also if I had to hear "big dog" one more time I was gonna lose it. I'm legitimately curious how bad Nathan Jones must have been to get removed for this."
KKeanel wrote on 19.04.2025:
[5.0] "Probably the weirdest match of Undertaker's streak, however it's not as bad as some infamous matches from the decade before."
thesilverman wrote on 18.04.2025:
[6.0] "Not as bad as people make it out to be. Undertaker was moving in this one, and while it's obviously going to be overshadowed (and rightfully so) by his crazy Wrestlemania run of classics after this, this is still a solid outing. Probably would have preferred just Big Show vs Undertaker."
DecentWrestling wrote on 13.04.2025:
[6.0] "The match was decent enough. There was a couple of nice moments including Undertakers' leapfrog and some cool power moves but overall it just felt like nothing special. The crowd was pretty into it, popping for Taker's big shots and that leapfrog so that did help a bit. A-Train and Big Show worked solidly as a heel team. Undertaker tried to take it up a level but it just never reached there. On the weaker end of Undertaker Wrestlelamania matches."
Jordan wrote on 26.03.2025:
[5.0] "This does not come close to Undertakers best wrestlemania matches but it also doesn't deserve the low rating it has. Wasn't the best or most exciting match you'll watch but the crowd was hot and Undertakers entrance gave it a big feel"
Brye wrote on 15.01.2025:
[3.0] "Big Show was on a great run in 2003 but even he couldn't save this match. Very much a vibe-killer on this show, though thankfully pretty much everything else on the card is great."
CoRdel wrote on 04.01.2025:
[6.0] "Fun match, don't deserve that low of a rating. It's obviously not worthy of a Undertaker's match at Wrestlemania, but I've seen far far worse than that. It wasn't actually bad, they really handled well the 2v1. Action in the ring was alright, Taker looked strong, just not a great match to book in the first place."
Moranjeboom wrote on 04.01.2025:
[7.0] "Not The Undertaker's greatest WrestleMania outing by any stretch, however it was still a decent fun encounter. Limp Bizkit probably raises the rating for me, hilarious to watch this back. In ring stuff was a bit slow but crowd was well into it and there were no serious botches"
conker8 wrote on 27.11.2024:
[7.0] "I thought it was a fun match. The Undertaker has Limp bizkit do his entrance. Undertaker did all of his trademarks moves. Taker has to make his own comeback and Nathan Jones did his high kick well. Big Show and A-Train did their job well. Crowd was happy."
Cal1641 wrote on 04.11.2024:
[2.0] "A slow plodding affair that's a complete waste of time and would fit better on an episode of smackdown. This was certainly not Wrestlemania worthy. Amazing that a 10 min match can still feel like it overstayed it's welcome."
tlaugh08 wrote on 11.10.2024:
[3.0] "Complete waste of Undertakers time & talents. I believe, if Im not mistaken, they had other plans here that fell through so they went with this, but it doesnt matter having Taker in this much of a low profile match was sad *.75"
FelipeTalksGraps wrote on 10.10.2024:
[3.0] "[1.5*] A match where its best thing is surely the phenomenal entrance of The Undertaker at his last Mania appearance as the American Badass. It was just amazing. The match itself was super dull and it had no place at a WrestleMania, specially with a strange 2-1 handicap match between three pretty big guys. Nathan Jones returned at the ending to save Taker. The crowd was popping for everything and it was very physical so I guess it was watchable. Definitely bad tho."
brooksavage2004 wrote on 14.08.2024:
[2.0] "This is Undertaker's last Mania match as "The American Badass". The match itself just wasn't for me, nothing stood out well and it's another one of Undertaker's weakest Mania matches."
JCC001 wrote on 01.07.2024:
[4.0] "The Undertaker celebrated his win here by waving his big American flag with his AUSTRALIAN tag partner. Goated entrance though"
uselessdollthing wrote on 16.06.2024:
[1.0] "I mean, this match was pretty much what I expected. The stipulation is kind of interesting and the crowd is hot too so it doesn't feel totally dead. Theres nothing very bad in this its just full of big guys being really slow. Probably one of Taker's weirdest streak matches."
JacquesRougeauCanHaveMyWife wrote on 29.05.2024:
[5.0] "Once again I probably would have hated it if it happened a few years back, but Taker really reinvented himself in my eyes - he's in a fantastic shape, he doesn't get gassed a few minutes in and he cares about his facial expressions. Still, nothing out of ordinary, but A-Train and Show were fine as heels and Taker looked really explosive."
Cyclone85 wrote on 02.05.2024:
[3.0] "This didn't really have anything for me. I don't like handicap matches and general and this was no different. Taker honestly looked good here and showed some freak athleticism but he's the only one. big show was on autopilot mode and the Nathan Jones run in was, well, you know"
yamom wrote on 15.04.2024:
[6.0] "This is my favourite WrestleMania but I haven't watched it since I was probably in grade school - so I was fully expecting to hate this. But this was FANTASTIC. Okay maybe not fantastic, but expecting a horrible match made me look way more fondly upon this. Taker is carrying like a maniac here. Big Show is far from either side of his two primes and A-Train doesn't get much shine, but that doesn't stop Taker from bumping and selling like a total boss and making this match a totally servicable handicap. Fun finish and the crowd loved it all. Seriously how does this average a 3/10? Plus Takers entrance has to be Top 3 live wrestling performances. ***1/4"
diamondtaker324 wrote on 12.04.2024:
[6.0] "Honestly not sure why this match is disliked so much. I guess it has its downs but overall I actually really enjoyed it. Will admit the ending was a little meh but the rest was fun. I came in with low expectations and ended up coming out of it with mainly only positive things to say."
jjcharg77 wrote on 12.04.2024:
[5.0] "would have liked it more if it wasnt for the finish. if youre gonna keep jones off the card, keep him off the card lol"
Pantaman wrote on 29.03.2024:
[3.0] "Such an Undertaker thing to have an amazing entrance featuring Limp Bizkit and proceed to have easily the shittiest match on the card."
Aliiadwana wrote on 02.03.2024:
[6.0] "That was so fun I really enjoyed that big show and his partner did some decent things but I liked that undertaker fight them alone. It just was fun , But in the same time it is gonna be better if undertaker fights big show in a single match one on one but instead they put a handicap which is fine to me ."
theelevatedone wrote on 24.02.2024:
[2.0] "I still find it so funny that they had to change the match last minute because Nathan Jones was so shit. Everything else was just subpar big man wrestling, but Taker's entrance here is so cool, so it has that going for it"
edgyfr wrote on 20.02.2024:
[1.0] "Absolutely awful, just so boring, and so dumb, the stipulation is absurd, and the finish is the most random thing i have ever seen in wwe so far. What were they thinking."
MMGoose wrote on 16.11.2023:
[6.0] "Arguably should have just been the Undertaker-Big Show singles match here instead of the last minute correction. BUT - I think this is a satisfactory match. It's held together by Undertaker staying on his feet as much as possible, moving a bit quicker, so it's more believable that he is surviving. The Nathan Jones interference at the end is whatever. I think this match was a mistake to book but ultimately not bad."
Ruthless Attitude wrote on 11.07.2023:
[5.0] "Not as awful as I expected it to be because Undertaker, Big Show and A-Train give a solid performance for what they are given, but Undertaker definitely should have had better than a handicap match thrown together at the last minute to continue his streak. Fairly average match with some good power moves in there. A bad ending with Nathan Jones interfering in full view of the referee with terrible looking offense to give Undertaker the win."
bigredtalk89 wrote on 06.07.2023:
[6.0] "Kinda surprised by the match ratings for this match, but then I remembered a couple of things. #1: Nathan Jones was advertised for the match and then taken out in a Sunday Night Heat segment(this should add to the match not take away from it) #2: Fred Durst took up way too much time, and any given to him is too much. Other than that, it's a fine match between big men. Taker and Show fought 1 on 1 at the previous PPV No Way Out, and that probably should have been the Mania match. A-Train was a talented big guy but his inclusion made it even more obvious that Taker was going to win."