DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?

Mankind vs. Paul Wight

Match

Match Data
Fixture:
Date:
28.03.1999
WON rating:
3/4*
Match type:
2.76
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 143
Number of comments: 38
10.0 0x
9.0 0x
8.0 0x
7.0 0x
6.0 3x
5.0 6x
4.0 21x
3.0 54x
2.0 40x
1.0 18x
0.0 1x
Average rating: 2.74  [143]
Average rating in 2026: 2.81  [36]
Average rating in 2025: 2.63  [30]
Average rating in 2024: 2.97  [35]
Average rating in 2023: 2.95  [22]
Average rating in 2022: 2.11  [9]
Average rating in 2021: 2.20  [10]
Average rating in 2020: 2.00  [1]
Your Options:
Other:
ReeBoyJenkings wrote on 24.10.2026:
[5.0] "I thought this was a fun cute little match man idk what to say. Show and commentary selled really hard for Socko and i liked the referee giving a little bit of lee way with the chairshots. Nowadays you so much as do a hulk hogan boop with a chair in WWE and the match is thrown out. Post Match was good but show really shouldve just chokeslammed him idk why they did a gakeout just to have him turn anyway;"
BarneyJune wrote on 19.09.2026:
[6.0] "6/10. The wrestling itself is nothing special, but the angle elevates it considerably. With the winner getting the referee spot for Rock/Austin, everything Show does has consequences. Him completely losing control and chokeslamming Mankind through the chairs, getting DQ'd, then knocking Vince out after being berated is great Attitude Era storytelling. Mankind being stretchered out also adds another wrinkle to the main event later. Average match, very effective piece of the larger story."
SebasDiaz wrote on 22.07.2026:
[1.0] "The debut on PPV of The Big Show when he used his real name, the match itself unfortunately was disappointing, a finish in DQ, and the most of it being boring, to be the referee of the Main Event here. 1/10 [1/2*]"
Ruthless Attitude wrote on 31.05.2026:
[3.0] "One of the more hyped matches on the card, but this was a major disappointment. Big Show does some impressive things here like how he breaks the Mandible Claw and Foley once again goes above and beyond to put his freakish size and strength over, but it's really cheap to see Foley go the things he does like that chokeslam through the chairs when you end up with a really bad DQ finish that doesn't really make sense and Big Show's volatile relationship with Vince and The Rock actually could have made him a more interesting referee than Mankind here as well. There was potential for a much better match than what we got as we would see at Backlash the following month, but it fell apart because it was rushed, was badly written and had another swerve for the sake of a swerve!"
Imperador wrote on 18.05.2026:
[0.0] "It's a match that goes around in circles a bit, not good enough for a WrestleMania match more suited for a live event. But the worst part is when Big Show and Mankind use illegal moves, like Mankind kicking him in the balls and Big Show hitting him with chairs, and Earl Hebner says nothing. Yet when Big Show chokeslams Mankind through chairs, suddenly there's a disqualification. Makes no sense."
Amaury08 wrote on 07.05.2026:
[3.0] "A bad Wrestling match, with a bad decision of booking, the match itself has not purpose, it's just a way to let Mick Foley be the referee in the Main Event and protect Big show as much as possible. One of the first match of Show in WWF."
w1shyouthebest wrote on 07.02.2026:
[5.0] "this isnt good in any form but it is also isnt, ...as bad as others say it is, its perfectly fine, the dq ending is a dissapointment but wight clearing mcmahon after the match is very entertaining indeed"
Jonny Dubya wrote on 20.01.2026:
[3.0] "I'm giving it three points, and that may be generous. But it's only because Mick Foley is in it. This match was a so-so match that had a screwy DQ finish."
SkyIcons wrote on 19.01.2026:
[2.0] "Yeah, this was pretty bad. Big Show was slow and sloppy, Foley bumped well, but he could only do so much."
JokerDeSilva wrote on 06.09.2025:
[2.0] "Yeah, just not a very good match I fear. Foley was really physically struggling at this point if I remember correctly, and it sure looks like it, and it led to another slow, plodding walk-and-brawl kind of match with object shots and mediocre action. Throw in a dumb DQ finish and it's just a disappointing nothing."
CMFunk007 wrote on 27.08.2025:
[4.0] "They brought the Giant in with a ton of hype behind him, and this is what they did with him? Vince really had a hard-on for WCW and took out his frustrations on their incoming talent for nothing but petty reasons."
brooksavage2004 wrote on 27.04.2025:
[1.0] "Such an awful and pointless match between both men with awful in ring work and chemistry between each other, the ending was flat out stupid and that spot where Paul flattens Mankind was pure gross looking."
niclaswrestling wrote on 17.04.2025:
[3.0] "Short and rather poor match with a bad finish but fun post match angle. It's not pointless as it features Main Event implications, but the entire match is honestly just below average and not good at all (3/10)."
CAMERONQPR93 wrote on 30.03.2025:
[3.0] "Sigh. The problems here are more in agenting than execution. This really should have had more smoke and mirrors. Sending these two out to have a poor 7 minute wrestling match when it is one of the more hyped matches on the card was a bad choice. Illogical DQ finish considering earlier chair shots were allowed. These two deserved better."
bigredtalk89 wrote on 21.03.2025:
[4.0] "Nothing of a match, Big Show beats him up for a while then gets himself disqualified. Main event didn't need a special ref, this felt more like something that should have happened on Raw"
SalvatoreVitale wrote on 11.08.2024:
[1.0] "[1/4*] This is a slow, plodding match with many logical issues. Foley and Wight have no chemistry, and this is not a good first showing for Wight at all. The ending is awful and makes absolutely no sense. Why would Wight get himself disqualified and willingly give the win to Foley? What a way to make your new big signing look like a total fool in his first PPV match. Not to mention that the entire storyline and stipulation with Mick Foley wanting to referee the main event is so stupid and pointless, particularly since Foley was the WWF champion just a few weeks before. It seems like such a waste of time. Overall, it's an awful match."
HV85106 wrote on 22.07.2024:
[4.0] "This could've been way better. The Big Show kept trying to get DQ'd over and over, and finally did when he threw Mankind through two steel chairs. I know referee's discretion and all, but Mankind hit a low blow on Big Show and didn't get DQ'd, so this was a strangely booked match."
BigDave123 wrote on 14.06.2024:
[5.0] "The match was fine and Big Show getting disqualified was the right call as it protected him from losing but the issue was that in the Russo era, far too many matches ended with stupid disqualifications so it was something that really got overdone to death"
DestructiveDanyah wrote on 02.06.2024:
[5.0] "The rating for this is people just clinging to the worst wrestlemania ever chat and going mad with the votes. Its a fine match, not great but not under 3 out of 10. Was a standard brawl with Mankind playing the brave babyface role well as he usually did and big show looking fine in defeat"
BoltsFan2132 wrote on 10.04.2024:
[4.0] "Sub par match that could have definitely been better. The fact that after the main event this is one of the most hyped matches on the card and it goes less than eight minutes and ends in disqualification kind of sucks. My personal favorite bump is when Mankind gets sent into the ring steps backwards, that looked brutal. Big Show looked really good here, in storyline even knocking out Vince in the ring after the match. 2.5 stars at most."
edgyfr wrote on 14.02.2024:
[1.0] "Not was this absolutely dull, boring and meaningless but the ending is one of the dumbest things i have seen, it deletes all meaning of DQ, as the whole match is full of DQ worthy moments."
JacquesRougeauCanHaveMyWife wrote on 14.02.2024:
[2.0] "What? They've been fighting all around the floor for ages with Hebner not counting them out once and Mankind hit a low blow clearly in front of the referee and he decided to disqualify one of them only after a Chokeslam onto the chairs. What a bollocks of a match with Foley's worst instincts and absolute burial of Paul who should have been booked like a monster instead of a dumbass who doesn't understand the rules."
OnlyHalfTheEffinShow wrote on 05.01.2024:
[5.0] "So far into what has been a pretty disappointing Wrestlemania, this is the only match that actually feels of a caliber deserving of the occasion. ONLY by virtue of the workers involved. And even then it still only barely scraps by as a passable Mania match. The stipulation is for the referee spot in the main event of all things, and Big Shows continued mismatched booking continues to do him no favors. The only thing worth seeing this match for if youre not on a Mick Foley or Big Show Mania marathon is the bodydrop Show gives Mick while the mandible claw is locked in as Mick climbs up the giants back. All 400lbs of Shows mass crashes down square on Micks chest with absolutely no give, its a brutal spot and this matchs only real saving grace."
formen wrote on 08.12.2023:
[4.0] "Decent match, but not great. I thought they worked okay together. Does not make sense why the end is a DQ, when Big show used a chair earlier with no DQ."
JakWhit wrote on 01.09.2023:
[5.0] "Im not sure what this match does to justify such a low rating. This is a pretty dam solid match with a crazy bump taken by Foley, dont get confused its not a show stealer or even an underrated gem for that matter but its a lot better than a 2 Average that it seems to be getting"
NickJammer2221 wrote on 16.07.2023:
[6.0] "The ranking for this is way too low, this was a classic plucky effort from Mankind against a monster opponent and it gave Big Show a defeat without making him look weak as he got disqualified. Standards were different back in 1999 I guess."
GoodVsBadGuys wrote on 15.06.2023:
[6.0] "It is wild to me what a low rating this match has. It is less surprising when I see that this match had not rating until 2020. If you were following the product in 1998-1999, this was a very creative and ultimately satisfying way to show off Mankind's incredible courage and toughness and give him access to playing a major part in taking down The Rock and the Corporation in the main event. Big Show falling backwards as a counter to the Mandible Claw is a spot I can still picture in my head to this day 24 years later, and the Chokeslam through 2 steel chairs is another major moment."
nyavaeh wrote on 25.03.2023:
[2.0] "Yet another match on this show that I felt should have been way more than it ended up being. Very disappointing."
benny5bellys wrote on 19.11.2022:
[2.0] "A slow meandering bore that made me beg for the finish. Show looks absolutely ripped and the spot to get out of the mandible claw was good, the rest was not."
Giantfan1980 wrote on 04.09.2022:
[3.0] "Winner becomes the special ref for the world title match. Both guys are fighting on the outside, Mankind tries for a ddt but Big Show pushes him backwards into the steps. Show throws him back into the ring and starts attacking. Show uses a Russian leg sweep. Mankind pulls out socko and puts the mandible claw on Big Show. Show is barely hanging on. Mankind gives him a low blow, but Show won't go down. Mankind has the hold and is riding piggy back. Show falls backwards and squashes Foley good. Show takes Mankind outside the ring and hits him with some chair shots. He's tosses a chair into the ring then chokeslams Foley onto a folding chair drawing a DQ. Mankind becomes the special referee. Big Show starts hitting Mankind again with the chair. Vince McMahon comes down to ringside and gets in Shows face. Show gets mad and goes to chokeslam Vince, but has second thoughts so the retard McMahon slaps Show in the face and gets himself punched out. Everybody loves it. Mankind leaves on a stretcher."
Derek Joists wrote on 07.07.2022:
[3.0] "Big Show threw Foley around the ring, a lot, and did the very occasional wrestling move. That's about it. Dull."
MilkDDT wrote on 18.01.2022:
[3.0] "Decently fun match with some good bumps from Foley, but it's quite forgettable, especially due to the DQ finish."
cactus wrote on 18.05.2021:
[1.0] "The winner of this goes onto referee the main event. Paul Wight really had a disastrous first year with the WWE. He's used as an enforcer to the Corporation and he's made to look like a complete idiot who can't get the job done. Mankind is way too beaten-up to get anything good out of Show. After some soulless brawling, the best part of this match was when Show gets out of a Mandible Claw by jumping backward and squashing Foley like a bug. Even though Show uses a steel chair twice in front of the referee, he's finally disqualified when Show chokeslams Mankind onto two standing chairs in a gruesome spot."
lutherreignsfan wrote on 11.05.2021:
[3.0] "Below average match. Foleys bump over the ring steps wasn't nice to look at. Shame it ended the way it did."
texasyosh wrote on 04.02.2021:
[2.0] "Wasn't good by any means! Mankind did most of the work and took a ton of bumps but it still lacked a lot."
Bigdawgwrestlerbaby wrote on 18.09.2020:
[2.0] "This was bad even with Foley busting his ass throughout the match. It's amazing how many crazy bumps Foley was willing to do even in a match so short. It didn't result in a very good match, though. Bad stuff (*)"