DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?
4.48
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 208
Number of comments: 33
10.0 0x
9.0 0x
8.0 0x
7.0 1x
6.0 28x
5.0 74x
4.0 71x
3.0 34x
2.0 0x
1.0 0x
0.0 0x
Average rating: 4.48  [208]
Average rating in 2026: 4.24  [37]
Average rating in 2025: 4.31  [51]
Average rating in 2024: 4.50  [42]
Average rating in 2023: 4.70  [43]
Average rating in 2022: 4.48  [21]
Average rating in 2021: 4.85  [13]
Average rating in 2020: 6.00  [1]
Your Options:
Other:
Leo the goat wrote on 13.11.2026:
[6.0] "A solid, above-average 6/10 heavyweight sprint carried by two explosive athletes who knew how to lay their strikes in snug. At just over seven minutes, it never dragged for a single second--letting Umaga showcase his scary agility for a 350-pounder while Batista absorbed punishment and fired back with sheer power. The only real drawback was the suddenness of the finish, as the Batista Bomb came out of nowhere before the Orlando crowd had a chance to bite on any major near-falls. Clean, physical, and a respectable midcard buffer on a stacked card."
DecentWrestling wrote on 09.11.2026:
[5.0] "Solid but nothing spectacular. It started well and Batista took a big bump off the apron that looked nasty. The Batista Bomb while he was falling over made the finish look even more wild, which helped. Fine for what it was. These two are capable of much more."
BilboBaggins wrote on 05.09.2026:
[3.0] "Homeboy grabbed a fucking nerve-hold in the year of our lord, 2008... TWICE! Shame, as the opening was fine, but the thrown-together nature of this match and general sluggishness really bogged it down. Also, oof, that closing Batista Bomb. They tried, A minus for effort."
WG20 wrote on 01.04.2026:
[4.0] "It was alright. This match was put together so that both men were on the show. This was pretty much a filler match"
SkyIcons wrote on 14.03.2026:
[4.0] "Not bad by any means, but slow and never really ups the pace. A fine match, nothing else, could've been better."
Smi-48 wrote on 19.02.2026:
[4.0] "Too little time for such a polished and promising match. Umaga has long since lost his aura of near invincibility, and the signs clearly point to victory for Batista. And then the match has little to offer in terms of content that goes beyond a casual training session."
EyeBronze8388 wrote on 01.02.2026:
[3.0] "Boring match. I like both guys, but the chemistry wasn't there. The Batista Bomb was impressive at the end. Otherwise, Batista didn't do much on offense. Batista won for Smackdown, which meant absolutely nothing. Batista was fighting for Smackdown, yet he got drafted to Raw soon after this."
Hitman26 wrote on 29.01.2026:
[5.0] "I was excited for this match I thought it would be a very cool brawl between them, instead it's just a short filler match. I really wanted Umaga to win this one but Batista got the win with the Batista Bomb on Umaga."
WhatIsLooveee wrote on 18.01.2026:
[4.0] "A fairly short slow average match, which allowed fans to relax a little after the non-stop action. The wrestlers didn't show anything beyond their base, 4 points."
sdenapoli wrote on 26.08.2025:
[5.0] "While this was a heatless match with no stakes except "brand supremacy", it was better than Batista just doing nothing at Wrestlemania."
Thenxt observer wrote on 24.05.2025:
[4.0] "** (04/10) Instead of permitting two big main-roster stars a reasonable 10 minutes at the company's biggest show of the year, Mr. McMahon forced us to have to watch a seemingly endless celebration of the 2008 Hall of Fame inductions, which filled up a thick portion of Mania 24's first hour. We had reached barely past 60 minutes on the runtime when the bell had finally rung for Baptista and U-manga. These two were meant to have a power matchup, not a quickie. My head still shakes at the thought of one Batista Bomb!"
Cyclone85 wrote on 18.04.2025:
[3.0] "Wow. I thought this was going to slap. It is slow paced with Umaga on offense for most of it, with far too many rest holds for what should be a titan vs. titan match. Very meh"
bigredtalk89 wrote on 16.04.2025:
[6.0] "Decent big man match, though all anyone remembers is an impressive Batista Bomb and Umaga being introduced by Regal as "YOU MANGA! ""
Ajay00329 wrote on 02.04.2025:
[5.0] "Kinda sad Batista was given nothing here as this match means nothing even for "interpromotional match" for "brand supremacy" which means nothing after this match. An average filler match despite containing great workers"
Erdrick wrote on 31.03.2025:
[4.0] "Slightly below average television match just there to kill time on the show. (Wait, what do you mean it's happening at WrestleMania? )"
brooksavage2004 wrote on 12.09.2024:
[3.0] "This was literally a filler match, the in ring work is far below what both men are truly capable of and the ending was bad with that botched Batista Bomb."
12psi wrote on 21.08.2024:
[5.0] "Honestly a fantastic filler match. Very engaging to pay 75% attention to, with a well-paced, deliberate, and very brutal bout that Umaga shines in. Battista falls a little short, looking somewhat clunky and slow, and offers up a very silly finish one that actually works quite well."
JacquesRougeauCanHaveMyWife wrote on 27.07.2024:
[5.0] "It was alright, but I don't see the point of doing rest holds in a 7 minute match, especially since Batista was getting a mixed reaction here. It was okay when things were moving and Umaga was fascinating to watch as always, plus the Batista Bomb looked impressive, but it's not a wrestling classic."
WU20 wrote on 13.03.2024:
[5.0] "Ok match. It was actually entertaining. Seeing great. Batista wasnt so good here. Happy to see late umaga. (**1/2)"
TrailsOfPersona wrote on 20.01.2024:
[3.0] "Wow. Shockingly worse than expected. This match was so clearly a thrown-together match between two stars that they had no other Wrestlemania plans for, but wanted them on the card, so they threw them together, and tried to make some nonsense 'brand supremacy' excuse to get them together in an otherwise cold as ice match. And neither man was working hard to try and make the company eat their decision. Besides one hard bump to the outside by Batista, this match was dull and by-the-book. It's a short match, and they still threw in around a one minute nerve hold. Umaga essentially dominates the entire match, and then Batista essentially hits his two move combo for the win. A year before this match, Umaga was in a high profile match and Batista was in a world title match. Now, they're both lucky they got on the card. The magic of Umaga was officially dead, and I think fans were starting to get tired of Batista too. They went through the motions here, and really came close to embarrassing themselves. This should have been better. This is Wrestlemania. Not a random Raw or Smackdown."
face painted legend wrote on 24.11.2023:
[6.0] "I don't think WWE expected what happened to happen with this. They tried to piece this thing together the best they could in the build up to make Batista and Teddy Long aka Smack Down the babyfaces and Regal and Umaga aka RAW the heels, but it ended up not working out. That stadium was as much, if not more for Umaga than they were Batista, and that showed during the match. Batista overpowered Umaga in the start, but once the thing really got going, and Umaga started working on Batista's back the crowd ate that up. When Batista would fire back up from underneath the crowd would boo and when Umaga would take back over control they would cheer. I'm not sure if Dave was selling the back (which is what i'm going with) or he just couldn't get Umaga positioned properly, but I love how the back work Umaga done played in to the Batista Bomb at the end."
zachattack2023 wrote on 12.03.2023:
[6.0] "This is a fun little match it felt like they force this match because it really didn't have a build but it was still a solid match. ***"
Outbackjames wrote on 10.08.2022:
[7.0] "I like Batista, I like Umaga, I like haymaker exchanges, I like the GM intros, and I like this match. Super fun, midcard attraction match."
eltetechori wrote on 19.05.2022:
[4.0] "As expected from both of them, a not very technical fight, slow and that only hard blows would be seen due to the physicality of both, in general, not at all enjoyable."
flightaker321 wrote on 20.03.2022:
[4.0] "This match was placed on the crowd probably since they didn't have anything for them to do, so the storyline was Brand supremacy. Umaga controls most of the match but is really boring as he locks in a hold that sucks the life out of the crowd. They had some nice struggle moments in this with their strength I will say that.**"
Garmonbozia wrote on 07.03.2022:
[4.0] "They went back and forth, then Umaga got the control. This had some basic brawling. It was adequate."
Mizzle Assault Ant wrote on 31.12.2021:
[3.0] "A disappointing match from two guys I like. There just didn't seem to be much to this sadly, and then the ending was badly botched."
cactus wrote on 19.05.2021:
[3.0] "A basic power match that hid behind the useless Brand Supremacy gimmick to disguised the fact that this program had nothing going for it. It wasn't rotten per se, just rudimental and something that you would see on a house show. Umaga slaps on a nerve hold that sucks the life out of the crowd, who entertain themselves by chanting Umaga's name over and over again. Both guys do their usual schtick with no added flare before Batista puts Umaga away with a botched Batista Bomb. A total waste of one of their most over babyfaces at the time."
texasyosh wrote on 27.03.2021:
[5.0] "If it had a better build aside from Smackdown versus RAW, I think this would've been a much more memorable match. Two big dudes slugging it out, and its a good follow up after Money In The Bank."
chilewrestlingfan wrote on 20.03.2021:
[6.0] "Not an epic match, but it wasn't bad. It was nice to see a monster vs monster match in the middle of another kind of matches."
HC7 wrote on 11.09.2020:
[6.0] "Raw monster vs Smackdown monster. For a match that seemed to be put together to just give these guys time on a Wrestlemania and to fill show time, this wasn't that bad. Probably the two best big monster guys besides Undertaker on the WWE roster at the time."