[1.0] "A little less unwatchable than the one at the last PPV thanks to the inclusion of kendo sticks, but once again, a match that never should have been on this--or any--PPV; I'll say it again: poor Kane."
[0.0] "I'm sorry but there's nothing which can salvage this match - they had a stinker at summerslam and had a rematch with a stipulation here but it added completely nothing"
[1.0] "I'm seeing a lot of people say this is better than their previous matchups, and maybe marginally that's true, but not enough to make a difference. This match is awful, the gimmick really doesn't do much to help that either. These guys are both cooked physically and were never good wrestlers to begin with, this was an all-time disastrous pairing."
[5.0] "So like, what are we doing here? Ultimately not a very good match not very good people in the match but the cane stipulation made it watchable, if not satisfying"
[3.0] "They're still doing this stuff? Jesus Christ... Just like their SummerSlam match, though this time the gimmick made it a bit more bearable - even if the crowd couldn't have cared less. Kane working from underneath is always rough to watch, but at least he got a nice pop for the Chokeslam."
[4.0] "Mercifully, this match was significantly better than their match the previous month. It's a very simplistic match. Two big guys hitting each other with canes. They try to add a power dynamic, and Kane is trying so hard to get some selling out of Khali with the leg strikes, but it is just not happening. I give a lot of credit for the chokeslam at the end. He got Khali up higher than I thought he would have, and it at least looked big. It's certainly not a great match, but Kane is putting in effort, and it's about as good a match as you can pull out of Khali. Could have been a minute shorter comfortably. Any longer than this, and it would have started to stink the joint up."
[2.0] "I think the exact same thing can be said about almost every match of The Great Khali vs Kane. The match was uninteresting, slow and just plain boring to watch. Setting a stipulatiom for the match did not help them at all, and perhaps even harmed them."
[2.0] "It was still difficult and uninteresting to watch, but nevertheless, the extreme rules added some spectacle to their pathetic confrontation and was not as terrible as their previous fights. However, I believed that the Great Khali had to avenge Kane for his brother Ranjin Singh and win the match, and besides, alas, everything lasted quickly in time, not allowing to properly demonstrate all the extreme."
[4.0] "Pretty stiff match as it seemed. They weren't given a lot of time which made an already difficult situation even worse. Kane essentially tried to carry Khali in a decent match but he didn't really made it. One more thing was that the focused too much on the Cane."
[3.0] "Worst match on this card easily. Two men, one who can barely walk and one who is very stagnant in his career at that moment hitting each other with kendo sticks that were on the ring posts. Quite boring and these two didn't have much chemistry and this match really felt like it was put together to fill time"