[0.0] "After a match of women's to simply please the dudes in crowd, this match keeps stretching the gum of Kane vs Undertaker, a match that felt boring and ended with something interesting at least that was Kane losing his mask. 0/10 [DUD]"
[2.0] "A deeply boring match between two wrestlers who have never had a good in ring match together. All of the convoluted nonsense with Undertaker taking Kane's mask just bored me. Even beyond breaking rules, they're breaking rules to do something that's boring. Unfortunate."
[5.0] "Not really a match. It's a lot more watchable than the Judgment Day or Survivor Series 98 eyesores due to the angle with Undertaker going after Kane's mask the whole match and ending the match unmasking him and this was also the first time Kane was ever busted up like this in a match and the shot with the steps in particular looked good. It was just a straight up fight where the rules didn't really come into play and they sort of explain it in commentary where the ref was scared and didn't want to interject and they don't think it ever really started. It was an alright match and I kinda liked all the chaos with it, but it felt more like something you'd see on Raw or SmackDown."
[6.0] "This isn't bad, it's just bad for a Summerslam match, comes off as more of an angle than a match. I don't get the people calling it a "glorified squash" as no wrestler really gets put over, Kane leaves after his mask is taken off? Man he was really buried there..."
[5.0] "While this really isn't a match, and essentially just a hardcore brawl, it's fairly enjoyable for what it is. Undertaker and Kane go back and forth, Kane gets busted open with the steps after ramming them into the turnbuckle and Taker ends the match by ripping Kane's mask off for the first time."
[2.0] "This was literally just a glorified squash. The action was very bad, the ending was worse and even the commentary team didn't have a clue on what even happened."
[6.0] "Honestly, this wasn't really a match, as even the commentators were unsure whether or not it officially got underway as there was no bell. It was more of an angle than a match and I thought it told a good story of The Undertaker trying to rip Kane's mask off. It wasn't the best thing ever but I thought it added to the event all told."
[2.0] "What was that? The commentators didn't know whether the match even started, nobody said that it was a No DQ Match but they were using stairs and hitting low blows anyway and the match ends suddenly because why not. It was a confusing disaster and for now biker Taker just looks like a poor man's Crush."
[7.0] "I genuinely enjoy this match as a sub-10 minute hardcore brawl between 2 big dudes, with a crowd that enjoyed getting to see some serious violence. I may be in the minority, but I enjoy the match, even with the non-match non-finish (not sure if that's a double negative? ), because it's believable for these 2 mythical beings are just lighting each other up with weapons and exposing weaknesses, with the angle of Taker going for Kane's mask, it's a question the vast majority of fans probably wanted to know."
[4.0] "Hardcore slugfest between the two titans. Very little here, aside from some spots with weapons. Too much attention put on the mask gimmick, and indeed it ends as soon as Kane's mask is removed, with JR repeating that the bell never rang. Silly way to go about a rivalry which had decent heat."
[2.0] "Barely even a match, just a short brawl without an actual ending, with Taker ripping Kane's mask off and Kane just heading to the back. A complete waste of something that should have been a big deal."
[2.0] "I've hardly ever liked Undertaker vs. Kane matches, and at this point, the rivalry has already been overused during the Attitude Era, with the two facing off multiple times in 1998 in particular, but also 1999. So with Taker now out of his Deadman phase and into his Biker phase, they tried something different. No longer were they supernatural creatures engaged in a mystical battle for supremacy, they were two heavyweights looking to tear each other apart with Taker's quest to unmask Kane looking to add intrigue. Alas, I just saw a basic brawl. Going around the ring, throwing a few punches and one or two holds during the whole match. Typical for the fights of the time, but damn, it's so outdated. Add a really bad ending, and you have a match to forget"
[3.0] "Whole lotta brawling. Just another in the Taker/Kane saga. Kane is sporting his new sleeveless outfit that he would wear until his return in mid 2002. Kane tries using the steps but hits the post and bangs his head pretty good on them. Taker goes for the mask and rips it partially and Kane is busted from the failed steps shot. Kane fights back, Taker spears him and rips off the mask the rest of the way and Kane flees as Taker's music plays. I guess it's a no contest as no ref's even wanted to officiate. Definition of the cool down/piss break match between TLC and the main event."
[2.0] "This match was a basic brawl, but at least Undertaker tries his hardest to rip off Kane's mask throughout the match. Taker pulling off the mask is cool but why was this on SummerSlam exactly? *"
[2.0] "This match is more of a disappointment I think it could have been so much better and probably their worst match they had together the only cool thing is we get to see kane's face for the first time . *"
[6.0] "A pretty decent walk and brawl. I liked how chaotic it was with all the confusion over whether the match had even started or not. It actually felt like there was some real animosity between them."
[5.0] "A cool match, not perfect, but still there is something in it. Of course, we could expect both more and less, but we got something in between. The main point of the match is that we almost saw Kane's face. And it's worth a lot! **1/2"
[6.0] "Really' A low rating for this! Oh well everyone is entitled to their own viewpoint. In my eyes this was a fun brawl, and Taker removing Kane's mask was cool yet Kane was protected in the match. Nothing too spectacular about the match, but it lifted the crowd up in order for them to get hyped for the main event."
[3.0] "Pretty bad match, but it's typical the kind of brawl WWF produce around this periode. Going around the ring, throwing somes punches and one or two wrestling moves during the enire match. The finish really sucked."
[2.0] "A very bad match, not worthy of this level of show. The logic was badly broken here. This is an ordinary match, but in front of the judge, the Undertaker hits his brother in the groin, tries to pull off his mask more than once, although for this the referee can award Kane a victory by disqualification, but the scriptwriters definitely did not care, because the conditions that are needed to win to pull off the mask was not. Complete absurdity and stupid chapter in the long confrontation between the brothers."
[2.0] "This was not good at all, a basical brawl without any interest and a really bad finish. This is a match to forget, I don't know why they didn't do that in a weekly show. Sloppy match from the beginning to the end. *1/4"