[4.0] "Pretty boring match that is held together by Matt Borne's ability to get the Doink The Clown gimmick over. Borne is a solid worker but the way he plays to the camera is really what sells it. He also does a great job bumping Crush who damn well needed it because he is absolutely boring to watch. I don't like Crush, I think he looks lame and he never never improved despite having regular employment all the way through to the early 2000s. His offence is weak and has no presence and he sucks the life out of anything Doink made look semi decent"
[2.0] "The crowd were silent for this one probably wishing for it to be over. How this match got on Wrestlemania amazes me.A forgettable match and terrible in-ring work from both individuals. The finish of the match was also meh."
[4.0] "Kind of a nothing match, the pacing was really off (even slow in some points) and their chemistry in the ring was barely existing... Matt Borne's work with Doink is still incredible to watch and it's criminal how underutilized he was by the WWF! Funny ending with the double Doink' story starting, but at the end of the day this match was nowhere near a Wrestlemania worthy one, as it would fit best on an episode of RAW probably or even a smaller PPV and seeing the match record of this feud, it really makes you wonder how the managed to get that WM spot in the card..."
[2.0] "One way to describe this match is with the emoji of the clown face, a match that was more entertainment of Doink taking over Crush and I didn't feel a thing for this. 2/10 [*1/2]"
[3.0] "While this may initially seem like punishment for the nasty clown, it quickly develops into a slapstick story and completely buries the character of Crush. For me personally, this is no material for Wrestlemania."
[3.0] "the first match of this show that starts to give us a hint that we are in for a spical show. the actual match part is boring as hell but not bad, its juts that if your gona have a face dominate the match they have to be more interesting the old crush over here. the ending is really dumb but it is charming. the brain is the real hero of this match as he reacts to everything in the best way"
[3.0] "Doink's makeup was almost completely removed by the end, which was quite amusing, it's actually kind of creepy looking. Doink 2's face paint looked way better, maybe he should be Doink 1? Many interesting point to mull over huh. As for the match it wasn't very good. I don't really know what to say about it. Crush is quite boring and uninspiring, and then Doink is just Doink... Or is it Doink 2? Who knows. This one can be skipped it felt like filler."
[4.0] "The finish is cute but beyond that, this isn't much. With Crush taking most of the match, they're smart enough to keep things simple though, leaning on Doink's bumping and shtick to keep things afloat. I'm not sure that fully works, but it's enough to get this closer to serviceable than catastrophic for my money. **"
[4.0] "Pretty unremarkable. Crush has a couple of fun little power spots, but it's nothing all that noteworthy. The finish was at least amusing and is the only thing about this match that's memorable. I can understand why it would all be a bit silly for some, but personally I enjoy heel Doink, so I'd consider this at least passable - but probably nothing more than that."
[5.0] "These outfits were really colorful here. I remember as a kid thinking Kona Crush was awesome, much better than Demolition Crush. Doink was a Pennywise gimmick made for Vince to get his rocks off and laugh. But Matt Borne was great with the gimmick and the mirror image Doink was nothing of not creative, though they should have just revealed it as Steve Kerin later on down the road instead of doing nothing with it. But Crush was just too green for this to be any good."
[1.0] "this was not a good match imo very forgettable and just wasn't my type of match with a poor ending i have not enjoyed really doink the clown as a character or as a wrestler and i don't particularly care about crush aswell so i had bad thoughts from the start"
[3.0] "A pretty forgettable match with a memorable ending. There's no memorable spots and it always felt like one person was in complete control. Not my idea of a Wrestlemania match. 3/10"
[2.0] "It's awful, i don't care at all for either man, wrestling wise is painfully boring, buuut two doinks were just so fun, unexpected and actually a very smart way to make him win."
[3.0] "Honestly, love it or not the Double Doink spot at the end is one of the truly memorable moments of Wrestlemania history and I won't hear otherwise. It's kind of a silly finish, but it suits the character nicely so I don't actually hate it. The big problem is just that the match itself is pretty mediocre. The original Doink was a solid worker with good psychology, but babyface Crush is kind of just a big lug who didn't do anything noteworthy."
[4.0] "This one was a toss up for me between 3 points and 4 points. There's nothing truly wrong with this match. Even the silly finish was something I didn't mind because it fit the character of Doink. The real issue is that this match is very lumbering. It's slow paced the entire time. It never picks up steam and never picks up any momentum. The crowd cares very little as well besides when Crush goes for his finish. I'd almost dare to say this match feels more like a house show match between these two might feel. It just never feels like it has any stakes to it. I decided to go with 4 points because it was a serviceable enough match. Felt a bit long, but I don't think it hurt much either."
[4.0] "I thought this was fine. Relatively enjoyable match here. I actually have really been enjoying Doink in this era. The match itself was pretty good; Matt Borne was pretty fun to watch. I did take a point off for the stupid "two Doink's" finish which was a little too silly for me; especially with Heenan hamming it up on commentary."
[5.0] "It wasn't bad when it comes to the ring action. Borne is brilliant and he moves around the ring like an absolute pro, while Crush looks impressive when he's in there with someone smaller and more experienced. Some bollocks with two Doinks as the finish but at least it wasn't insulting to the viewers."
[3.0] "The second Doink was a memorable finish even if it was a bit silly. The rest of the match was a slog, Borne did his best and had some highlights (didn't expect a piledriver here) but Crush is not fun to watch here and this 8 minutes go by really slowly"
[3.0] "This feud was pushed quite a lot on television in early 93, but the fans just didn't care about most of this match. It wasn't technically bad, but it was just kinda there. I get what they were shooting for with the finish, but Doink pulled much better "tricks" in other matches. [*1/4]"
[5.0] "Better than some are saying but by no means a good match, this was a fairly slow clunky bout with the only notable moment being when the 2nd doink came up to cheat and win the match."
[5.0] "I'm very surprised by the low rating on this one. The finish is very silly, but I think Doink did a good job here. Crush does look very silly here though so you could rate it lower for those two things, but I enjoyed myself enough to give it a 5."
[4.0] "An ordinary bout at the time. Crush dominated most of the match, and it was monotonous. I really liked this double illusion, especially if you mentally travel back to that time, you can understand what it was like. The audience reacted vividly to the wrestlers coming out, but during the matches, they would quiet down and all you could hear was a quiet buzz. I didn't write about this flaw in the previous matches in the hope that something would change, but this is the third match. The only thing I will lower my grade for."
[3.0] "Crush kicks Doink's ass and this goes on until a ref bump lets another Doink (Skinner) run in and clobber Crush so Doink 1 can get the pin. Whatever."
"Started with a brawl with Crush attacking Doink before the bell, Crush dominated most of the fight until a ref bump happened and a second Doink appeared attacked Crush and the clown won. I didn't hate the finish it was amusing and worked with Doink's character. I thought this was fine nothing too good but nothing too bad either. [5/10]"
[2.0] "This feud was quite stupid and I didn't care about this match at all and wanted it to end quick. The match itself ended up being bad and I so much want to give this 0 points because of the retarded finishing angle. [*]"
[3.0] "Yeah, this was no good. Matt Borne was actually somewhat of an underrated worker, and his character work under the Doink gimmick was tremendous. But then again, you can only do so much working with Crush. This just wasn't meant to be good. Finish came off as silly and awkward too. [*1/4]"
[3.0] "As Crush enters the arena, he looks like the dog's bollocks and you're left scratching your head wondering how such a specimen never became a huge star. Then the bell rings and you realize why. He beats Doink all over the place and looks lost and awkward. Luckily Matt Bourne is a good hand and is able to stop Crush from completely shitting the bed on his first ever singles feud. I know it's not to everyone's tastes, but I dug the finish. After a ref bump, a second Doink appears from under the ring and lays into Crush with a prosthetic arm before returning back to his hiding spot. After the bell, a second referee comes down to argue the result with the first ref, but the second Doink had mysteriously disappeared from under the ring. It's silly and campy, but it fits the product they were putting out at the time."
[6.0] "I would say this is actually a decent match, Doink gets a bad rap now but the original heel character was very good, as was the guy portraying him in the first year."