DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?

Randy Orton vs. Triple H

Match

3.62
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 249
Number of comments: 65
10.0 0x
9.0 1x
8.0 2x
7.0 1x
6.0 5x
5.0 65x
4.0 63x
3.0 49x
2.0 54x
1.0 5x
0.0 4x
Average rating: 3.61  [249]
Average rating in 2026: 3.80  [41]
Average rating in 2025: 3.60  [53]
Average rating in 2024: 3.62  [60]
Average rating in 2023: 3.48  [42]
Average rating in 2022: 3.69  [26]
Average rating in 2021: 3.50  [22]
Average rating in 2020: 3.20  [5]
Your Options:
Other:
Mizzle Assault Ant wrote on 11.11.2026:
[0.0] "Famously awful main event. I remember actually being somewhat into this story at the time, but watching this match live I was immediately put off by the robotic exchange of finishers in the opening stretch, and it just never got better from there. Excuses, excuses, but this was a bomb and both guys mainly have themselves to blame."
Leo the goat wrote on 09.11.2026:
[5.0] "A frustrating main event that suffered primarily from tone-deaf booking stipulations and impossible card placement. Coming off the greatest television buildup of 2009--where Orton terrorized the McMahon family and Triple H broke into his home--this needed to be an all-out, violent Texas street brawl. Instead, the stipulation that Triple H would lose the title on a DQ or countout completely neutered the feud's venom, forcing them into a cautious, collar-and-elbow wrestling match that felt completely out of place. Following the emotional and athletic masterclass of Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels meant the 70, 000 fans in Houston were already completely burned out. The actual in-ring work wasn't botchy or technically bad, and hitting their finishers in the opening minutes showed some early fire, but the rest of the 23 minutes dragged into a sluggish, sterile slog. A completely average 5/10 that never matched the heat of its build."
callmehater wrote on 02.10.2026:
[3.0] "With how incredible the build was to this match it was incredibly frustrating & disappointing that this match completely sucked. Typical Triple H fashion where he needs weapons to mask how mediocre he is in the ring & Orton is super inconsistent as well. They tried spamming finishers right as soon as the bell rang but it didn't make a lick of difference. Randy also should've won this match"
KSAHZ8 wrote on 26.09.2026:
[3.0] "Yet another extremely long Triple H match that did NOT need this much time. The storyline going in to this match was phenomenal and deserved the main event spot, the actual match... no, the story was super personal, Orton's best heel work. The actual match was just a super long, boring, dull, nothing match. The story this match had, it deserved a last man standing or a no disqualification, anything! The crowd didn't care for it either, not after the Taker and HBK match, that should've main evented this show. Triple H had so many WrestleMania main events and most of them were abysmal and were always overshined by other matches on the card because his matches were always extremely long snoozefests to boost his own personal ego."
TrailsOfPersona wrote on 16.09.2026:
[4.0] "While it isn't worthy of being a Wrestlemania main event, it was alright. The match just seemed to fundamentally not understand what it should have been. First, they built this match like it was a personal blood feud. And then they just go out there and have a standard wrestling match with each other. On top of that, both of these men are known for having overly long slogs and this was no exception at all. It ate up way too much time and there was not a single moment where it was really doing anything exciting. It was structured well in terms of the time each man had the advantage, but whenever they got the edge, they were just throwing out the same stuff you see every week on TV. They did nothing at all to make it FEEL like this big personal main event. It felt complacent to me. I see many people saying that the crowd was gassed and that detracted from this bout, but I think that only goes so far. If you listen to the introductions and the very start to the match, the crowd still had plenty of life. But after the first few minutes, when this started to shape itself into such a standard affair, I think the audience checked out. They'd just seen Taker/Shawn put on a match of a lifetime, then a fairly decent triple threat title match, and then burned MORE energy on Austin celebrating with beer for his HOF induction. They got treated to a GOAT match, an entertaining match, and then an exciting segment for a legend. Then this fairly typical slow paced title match followed. It wasn't that the crowd was out of energy. It was that their expectations were raised and this didn't live up to them. This is far from a horrible match. And if it were shorter and on a B show PPV, it would have been pretty fine. Instead, it is a footnote in Wrestlemania history on poorly booking the order of your card and nothing more."
CodyPodlaskowski wrote on 21.04.2026:
[8.0] "If the match didn't have to follow Taker vs HBK it would have been perceived better because the match itself is solid the crowd was just dead. They told a good story I just wish they did no DQ after the insanely good build it had it just unfortunate for a guy as great as Randy Orton in the end to have to get criticized for something that I believe isn't his fault THIS ONE IS GOOD! It actually started off fast with an RKO right in the beginning which was exciting the finish should have been Randy Orton for the win because this was one of his best years in the business!"
RO94 wrote on 19.04.2026:
"A very good match. Hard hitting, physical, evenly matched and told a great story. Triple H, trying to defend the WWE title but more importantly, seek revenge on Randy Orton for everything he has put his family through. The stipulation that if Triple H is DQ'd means he loses the title, adds extra drama to the occasion and turns the match into a psychological battle. In the end, good overcomes evil, a ref bump allows Triple H to give Orton his comeuppance, first with a punt kick of his own and then a sledgehammer to the face. While it's a fitting end to the story, as a wrestling match, the actual finish is a little flat so it loses half a point. Overall I would give it a 3.5/5 and certainly a match that doesn't deserve such a low rating."
Wlliamofbaskerville wrote on 14.04.2026:
[3.0] "I remember watching this at the time. Everyone was just completely wiped out by how amazing HBK/Taker was. This had big shoes to fill and Orton and Triple H put everyone to sleep. Its one of the most boring matches of all time and a shoe in for one of the worst main event matches in WM history. I remember the watch party I saw this mania with, during this match everyone just sitting around and talking because this match was so deathly dull. Incredible really because this had the best buildup of the entire show but for some reason they didn't make it a no dq, instead they had a dull as shit match in front of a crowd that were dead. Crazy how many main events Triple H had and how many of them stank. This is the second time he went on last when he really shouldn't have and a match before completely stole the show (WM X8 with Hogan and Rock) There a reason why HBK Taker has entered into the all timer matches and this one has long been forgotten because its boring as shit."
DrewVogelaar1 wrote on 09.04.2026:
[4.0] "Good lord, this shit is boring. Why this wasn't a No DQ match, I'll never know. For the second time this decade, Triple H main evented and nobody cared (Jericho match). The crowd was dead from Undertaker vs Shawn, and it killed any bit of joy from this match. Why did Randy intentionally throw Triple H into the ref and then hit a finisher, knowing damn well the ref wouldn't be able to make the count? Why does the ref just not start the count when they're on the outside multiple times during the match? I can forgive Triple H vs Jericho because the match itself wasn't terrible, the crowd was just dead. This match is boring, has a dead crowd, and has no reason to be a main event unless it were a No DQ match."
WG20 wrote on 01.04.2026:
[4.0] "Given the storyline going into this match it definitely needed a stipulation. The action throughout was alright just a tad too long. The finish was very odd."
SkyIcons wrote on 26.03.2026:
[3.0] "They did well enough for what was given. Just too long, and needed a stip. Needed to be more due to how heated the feud was."
Sweet Fighter V wrote on 19.03.2026:
[4.0] "The destination pales in comparison to the wild ride that the road was. It's the culmination of one of the most heated and most personal feuds of the decade, yet it's the worst WrestleMania main event of the decade if you ask me. I love the pre-match intensity and that boisterous staredown, it's going to be a treat! And then they both hit their finisher in under two minutes and still go on to wrestle over twenty more long and uninspired minutes. It's off-beat, dreadfully structured, melodramatic, and while the match has its moments and that emphatic finish is great, it's WrestleMania, and I don't dig the shenanigans and Triple H winning. **1/2"
Kugenesan1 wrote on 27.02.2026:
[6.0] "Randy was always great at selling it seems cause he was A+ in this match in terms of selling. Triple H never should have won and the surprise reactions of the fans tells it. And the obvious one is that they should have never gone last. Taker/Shawn should have. That said, take every underlying factor and context out of this match and look into it on paper and face value alone, this was a solidly put together and well thought out and produced match. Especially the ending."
Green Deli wrote on 26.02.2026:
[5.0] "Now, this match is too long, theres no doubt about that. But this one surprised me in how little I was bored. Sure, I was kinda bored by the middle portion, as it was quite slow, but it did pick back up enough to keep my interest. Im sure it underwhelms when viewed in context, but overall I didnt have that bad of a time with it."
w1shyouthebest wrote on 08.02.2026:
[8.0] "i really like this match, first off their feud was fantastic which aids the match, the stipulation was a bit odd, and many see this match as pretty boring but i just...dont? theres something abt this match i just love, whether it be me being an orton fanboy or what i just love it"
Notorious27 wrote on 10.01.2026:
[3.0] "These two had a fantastic feud going into this match. It's the main event of Wrestlemania, it's 2009 Randy Orton vs a Triple H that may be past his prime but he's still very much capable of putting on great matches. They've known and worked each other for years, and somehow they manage to put on this abysmal match! Given the storyline that they had and the fact that we have 2 all time greats facing off in the main event of Wrestlemania I have a hard time believing that this match is as bad as it is. But it is! Orton did a mid air drop kick that was nice, put that aside it's a 20 something minute bore fest with the most dead finish you can imagine. Awful match. *3/4"
RTruthSaidWhatsUp wrote on 04.12.2025:
[5.0] "I understand that people are bothered that the stipulation of the match doesn't have much to do with the final match, but the match itself isn't bad, so meh, it's a bit long and boring at times, but it's not bad, maybe disappointing, but I didn't think it was bad."
JokerDeSilva wrote on 17.09.2025:
[5.0] "Honestly, I do think this match gets a slightly bad wrap. Like, was booking it as a "title changes hands on DQ" stip a stupid idea given the blood feud build up? Yes, absolutely. No feud that involved home invasions and DDTing someone's wife should involve a lengthy chinlock segment. Coming after the Taker-HBK match, and even the Hardys blood feud match, does make it look worse in comparison, too. But maybe it's also because I just watched Unforgiven 2004 coincidentally enough and saw an even more boring and plodding Triple H-Randy Orton match that I'm slightly more generous to this one. They did okay. It was a dumb stip, but it was worked alright, it was just kind of boring and a let down from what it should have been. It wasn't BAD."
sdenapoli wrote on 01.09.2025:
[4.0] "This was just confusing. Why have this blood feud and then make such a stupid, pointless stipulation? And it didn't even matter because Triple H cheated and won, which he shouldn't have. Why win here?"
Raditz Flair wrote on 01.09.2025:
[0.0] "A blood feud with no blood. It was going to be impossible to follow HBK/Undie but it seems like these two didn't even try. This is the second time Triple H followed a superior match and build with his brand of inferior, slow paced, faux-epic crap. Triple H is the Ken Norton of wrestling. The boxer not his son the football player. It's also a comparison of quality. Ken Norton had too much integrity to fuck the promoter's daughter."
Hippykillerz wrote on 19.08.2025:
[2.0] "I will give credit where it's due, they did all they could to build this match into a bloodfeud. Makes sense since this should be the biggest match at the biggest show of the year. What doesn't make sense is making it a straight singles match when this feud is screaming for a no-DQ, street fight match. What instead happens is a boring, yawn inducing snooze fest...in the main event...of WrestleMania...that's the problem. Fundamentally, there is nothing wrong with this match. They are telling a story and all the moves look fine. But there is nothing here that is Mania main event worthy. Orton plays the role of a psycho heel well, but his character is slow and methodical, so he needs an opponent who can inject life into the match. Triple H is not that. Triple H is beyond overrated and cannot carry a big time main event, despite what he believes. It leads to a mirror match of boring. That combined with going on after HBK/Taker and Austin means the crowd are just waiting to go home. The finish comes out of nowhere too, really flat. If this was on any other show, it would be a below average match, but because it is the main event of WrestleMania, it is really bad."
Walker46527 wrote on 12.08.2025:
[2.0] "(**) ""The worst thing you can be is boring" should be the tagline of this match. Plodding, uncreative, and sterile, nothing about it lives up to the wonderful build that preceded it. HHH and Orton have never been the best opponents for each other--their styles are far too similar, making it feel like watching a person grapple with themselves for 30 minutes. Speaking of, this match is a HHH classic (an ode to the good old days) Broadway, but it lacks any of the fire or emotion seen in those matches and instead becomes a slog. That wouldn't be so bad if it weren't the main event of the "25th anniversary" of Mania, which makes it a disappointment, to say the least."
Thenxt observer wrote on 22.05.2025:
[7.0] "***1/2 (07/10) When the time came for the main-event's bell to ring, you could hear nothing but pins drop from how burnt out all of Reliant Stadium was. The unfortunate truth is that had they booked the HBK/Taker to be the main-event, the energy to Orton/HHH might've been higher in intensity and response, owed to the strong hold of a matchup from the two. I know. I know: Randy should have won. He didn't. He would get his win against the Game, but not tonight. That finish was more dead than the crowd that remained."
KKeanel wrote on 26.04.2025:
[4.0] "Disappointing main event. A lot of boredom - I would compare it to Mania 32 from this aspect. Such an intensive feud would be summarized better."
RPMX123 wrote on 25.03.2025:
[5.0] "not even that bad, just very mid. whose grand idea was it to have a bog standard singles match after that buildup? should've been an i quit match or something **3/4"
Gravelord wrote on 24.03.2025:
[3.0] "While there have been worse WrestleMania main events than this one, there have been few if any that so utterly failed to live up to immense hype around them going in. For what was one of the most intense feuds in WWE history, with Orton repeatedly assaulting HHH's family and wife in the lead-up, the match itself came off as relatively pedestrian, aggressively dull, and barely any different from the usual fare one would expect from those two. First and foremost, the encounter was obviously hamstrung before the bell even rung by a stipulation that forbade anything truly violet from happening and forced both men to wrestle an ordinary match. I know Vickie Guerrero was responsible for adding the stipulation, but why the McMahons--who despised Orton at this time in kayfabe and, most importantly, owned the damn company--allowed it to stand still makes absolutely no sense. They should have just let both guys rip each other apart with weapons for twenty minutes to really sell how much they were supposed to loathe one another. Instead, we were treated to slow-paced, nearly twenty-hive minute slog that centred around HHH and Orton having to deliberately restrain themselves lest they be disqualified. I admittedly did enjoy some of Orton's heel work. Him clearly trying to get under HHH's skin to force the DQ only to end-up working himself into a frenzy and costing himself the match resultantly was not a bad story on paper. But it was clearly not the match I or anyone in attendance wanted to watch given how quiet the crowd sounded and how bored it looked for most the the match. I will say, Orton hit a dropkick to HHH coming off of the top rope and it looked spectacular. Orton's dropkicks are usually on point, but this one was something else. Genuinely the highlight of the match. There's nothing much else to say about this really; it was just boring and it is obvious as to why that was. I will also add that the ending two minutes were some of the slowest and most sluggish wrestling I have ever seen. It was like they were both trying to drag it out for as long as possible. It was intolerable and I just couldn't wait for it to be over by that point. Oh, and yes, Orton should have won this. He was red hot as a heel, and beating him here really put a damper on what should have been an all-time great run for him. *3/4"
NG wrote on 11.02.2025:
[9.0] "I started watching wrestling partly thanks to this rivalry which I find incredible so on the emotional side it definitely had an impact on me, and what's more I found that the match was really cool I just think that the rivalry should have stopped after this match and not continued. Coming back to the match obviously when you come after one of the best matches of all time it's difficult to get people to react and ensure that it is still concerned, I just think that if we would have reversed the match in co main event and taker michaels in main event the match would have had a lot more positive reaction."
Essalim wrote on 30.09.2024:
"A great storyline that ended with a poor quality match. I feel sorry thats all i can say. This match could have been way better."
lgccs wrote on 27.08.2024:
[3.0] "Barely watchable; these two never had much chemistry and when paired with an utterly dead crowd, it produces a predictably dull main event."
brooksavage2004 wrote on 20.08.2024:
[1.0] "The story and build up it had was really great with peak heel Randy Orton attacking babyface Triple H and his family which led to Triple H breaking into Orton's fake house, scaring his fake wife, but then there was the added stipulation of Triple H being stripped of the title if disqualified or counted out, which led to them just having a regular match. It was slow, dull, boring, way too long, the crowd was dead and it was just typical standard wrestling between both men. Both one of the most underwhelming and worst WrestleMania main events ever."
SigmaAngeloAsteria wrote on 09.08.2024:
[1.0] "Horrible match. Slow, plodding, boring, uneventful, dead crowd....everything was horrible. The wrong person won, nothing interesting happened in the match, at least there wasn't any botch whatsoever. And the worse thing is that the feud was amazing: a good, violent, grudge feud. AVOID THIS MATCH"
HV85106 wrote on 07.08.2024:
[5.0] "Yeahhhh this had building blocks to be something more than what it was, I'm sure their other meetings are better than this. It didn't help that it had to follow up Undertaker vs. Shawn. I liked the hot start for the first 10 or so minutes, it got a bit too slow for too long towards the end, but these guys didn't fundamentally do anything too wrong. It was just a case of wrong stipulation for the most part. **3/4"
JacquesRougeauCanHaveMyWife wrote on 03.08.2024:
[4.0] "I really wanted to like this match, because the build has been fantastic and Randy's character work phenomenal, but it was just so boring. They had something there - they slowed things down, focused on telling the story with the facials, but the crowd didn't care after three hours of wrestling and Taker with Michaels stealing the show. They got barely any reaction and even though they worked the stipulation well there was no way that they would get the fans involved with limiting Triple H's offense at this point of the show. Really a shame, because the story deserved so much more."
uselessdollthing wrote on 01.08.2024:
[0.0] "I don't care about Shawn vs Taker being before this and I don't care about the build to this match. This is still an offensively boring match that also goes 20 plus minutes. Especially with these two who are well known for putting on boring matches, I wasn't sure what I was expecting but I still feel like my time was wasted. The crowd wasn't even into it, this match totally failed."
RealGrapsThomsen wrote on 14.06.2024:
[5.0] "The build up to this match was amazing, but this match was not. The match was slow, dull and boring. The only thing that could have saved this match would have been a stipulation or something."
MarkMcMarkington2 wrote on 04.05.2024:
[2.0] "A really great feud that ends with an utterly dull and heatless match. They never could have followed up on HBK vs Taker, but at least make this match a no DQ or something."
TripleCrown wrote on 24.04.2024:
[3.0] "The story leading up to this match was amazing, they really put a lot of effort into making people care about this match. The biggest issue though, is that they had to follow HBK/Taker. People knew it was going to be a great match but I don't think people quite understood how great it was going to be. Under different circumstances, this would've been a very good WM main event. The crowd was very dead at this point though, and having seen the HBK/Taker match, nothing was going to top it. Was still an ok-ish match but it was overshadowed earlier on in the night. Wouldn't really recommend people go back and watch this match because it's just very flat and doesn't have that feeling of a WM main event."
BoltsFan2132 wrote on 09.04.2024:
[6.0] "Not sure why this match gets so much flak on here as I thought it was on par with the World Heavyweight Title match on this same show not that the bar was very high, every match on this card paled in comparison to Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels. I agree with others that this match should have been a No Disqualification type of stipulation but I thought they did well with the story they had with Triple H needing to hold it together and not get disqualified and Randy trying multiple times to win by countout. Triple H being able to finally drill Orton with the sledgehammer when the ref took a bump seemed alright in terms the feud getting its blowoff but it definitely could have been more. Bump of the match had to be the hanging DDT from the announce table to the floor. At least 2.5 stars."
KingsCrossing wrote on 05.04.2024:
[4.0] "I absolutely hated this match live, but going back and watching it now, I think they were actually really close to having something that worked. The first half of the match has potential. They actually sell the hatred between the two pretty well in the early portion of the match. The early finisher exchange is a unique idea that is initially sold well and gives them something interesting to work with, however around the time that Triple H makes his comeback out of Orton's chinlock, the match starts to come across as pretty ordinary, and everything from beforehand seems like it was fairly inconsequential. It feels a lot longer than it actually is, and by the time they reach the finish (which on paper should feel very cathartic, but in execution it has come after so much tedious 'action' that it falls flat) all the heat is gone. It's a shame, because I think they had some ideas here that could have resulted in a really good match, but unfortunately the second half of the match the crowd has clearly checked out, and it comes across as boring more than anything else."
Wilks434 wrote on 16.02.2024:
[2.0] "Most underwhelming match in WWE history. For anyone reading this, go watch their No Mercy 2007 Last Man Standing match instead. Had the action, drama & result that this match should've had. Instead, we got an abortion of a WM main event that still irks me 15 years later."
ShaliK wrote on 10.02.2024:
[5.0] "The big problem with this match is its length, yet it had some good first minutes. I didn't find it bad, just too long. The finish is cool. (2*3/4)"
ryand25 wrote on 16.12.2023:
[5.0] "It wasn't a great match but it wasn't horrible. I think the low ratings are due to the expectation of the match and it not living up to that. In a vacuum the match itself was okay, nothing special. It certainly could have been much better considering the build up."
Madlad wrote on 04.12.2023:
[0.0] "One of the most disappointing matches ever. I was so much into the story of these two. It started from that betrayal in 2004 and was very deep and very personal. Orton and HHH absolutely hated each other And were ready to kill. But what happens in the end? A fucking normal match instead of hell in a cell, or at least a No DQ. Hell even they aded if triple h gets DQ he lose the title. WHAT THE HELL IS THIS? so we get a slow boring ass match with wrong winner"
Okaro143 wrote on 03.12.2023:
[4.0] "The way it started and the middle portion was okay but the ending felt so off. This was a revenge grudge match but didn't really feel like it. It was more of Orton trying to slither himself to win the WWE Championship. It was a match of poor quality and a huge disappointment. **1/4"
lukerocker9 wrote on 02.09.2023:
[4.0] "This match had the exact opposite gimmick to what it needed based on the build, hell just based on the video package it feels off to hear the "title changes on DQ" rule. There are some decent moments, specially at the beginning. but the match does become a drag . Its not the worst Mania main event (way more watchable than Hogan/Sid for example) but its still in the lower tier"
Leth99 wrote on 17.05.2023:
[1.0] "This match is so lifeless, so my review will be lifeless as well. This match meant nothing and if the show was without these two, no one would complain."
violet011 wrote on 21.03.2023:
[1.0] "You'd think they realised that Triple H can't work a good Wrestlemania main event that doesn't involve two other guys in it but nope. Did they learn here? Nope, because Wrestlemania 32 happens. The early finishers are the only highlight as they plod for 20+ minutes. This needed a no DQ stipulation but nope, we got the opposite. This fucking sucked so much holy shit - 1/2"
Dcarter1153 wrote on 26.02.2023:
[6.0] "3 stars - really so low? The crowd was dead but I still managed to find this one really enjoyable with a great story"
xnvius wrote on 14.10.2022:
[2.0] "what a disappointing finish to an all time rivalry. the man RKO'd his wife. punt kicked his father in law. KILL THE MAN. very underwhelming."
Geo93 wrote on 07.09.2022:
[6.0] "Mildly underrated, in my opinion. This was not a bad match at all, it just had to main event a show where Undertaker and Shawn Michaels tore the house down. Plus, this didn't really feel like a main event for a PPV (never mind a WrestleMania). This probably should have been No Disqualification. I guess it was pretty passable, though. Some decent character work from Randy Orton."