DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?

Battle Royal Match 2009

Match

0.​29
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 255
Number of comments: 44
10.0 1x
9.0 0x
8.0 0x
7.0 0x
6.0 1x
5.0 0x
4.0 0x
3.0 0x
2.0 9x
1.0 35x
0.0 209x
Average rating: 0.27  [255]
Average rating in 2026: 0.41  [34]
Average rating in 2025: 0.35  [57]
Average rating in 2024: 0.24  [67]
Average rating in 2023: 0.22  [49]
Average rating in 2022: 0.24  [21]
Average rating in 2021: 0.09  [22]
Average rating in 2020: 0.20  [5]
Your Options:
Other:
Raditz Flair wrote on 25.10.2026:
[0.0] "Take a good look. Here's some of the trailblazers with ratings higher than 5 in this piece of shit. You may think, "but it's not their fault they had to work with what they had". You're right. I have to look at what is put on my tv screen or in front of my eyes at the arena and go with that and this match fucking blows."
KSAHZ8 wrote on 24.09.2026:
[0.0] "Yeah this is just offensive, even back then. Clustering all the women together to come out and dance around Kid Rock while he finished his concert that nobody cared for to then give them little to no time, heat, spots and have a man in drag win. I felt bad for the women who returned for one night only; Joy Giovanni, Miss Jackie, Molly Holly, Sunny, Torrie Wilson and Victoria who deserved entrances. I mean at least have Vickie Guerrero be in the match and win it, you can go somewhere with that and have her carry the heat."
TrailsOfPersona wrote on 16.09.2026:
[0.0] "It has to get 0 points for the absolute disgrace that it is. Before the bell even rings, this is the only match the women get on Wrestlemania. Not even ONE of the champions has a match. Instead, everyone is crammed into this battle royal. What, we couldn't shave off time from Triple H and Orton's bloated mess to get a women's title match in? The ladies don't get an intro. They start fighting before the rules are even finished being read. Instead a long Kid Rock segment eats their time. They barely acknowledge some of the returning legends that were in this match, even though they should have been a big deal. If you were at the arena this night, you probably didn't even NOTICE Mae Young or some of the returning legends, considering even the PPV commentators barely even gave them a mention. The 'action' is nothing but punches and bodies flying everywhere. And then the ultimate slap in the face of Santino winning it. It wasn't funny. It wasn't surprising. It was a disgrace from even before the start until after the finish. One of the most disgusting and insulting 'matches' in the history of the company without a doubt."
PWC wrote on 29.03.2026:
[1.0] "I'm a big advocate and fan of the Divas Era but, even I can't vouch for this. The Kid Rock entrance crap actually took away some of the potential fun of the match and didn't even give the girls proper introductions for being gone for so long. 1 star for the Divas looking great as usual. And hey Mickie, Michelle, Beth and Melina had a mildly enjoyable Final Four spot before it was ruined for reasons why, that are better left unsaid."
SkyIcons wrote on 26.03.2026:
[0.0] "A stain on the sport. The women are sung out by known predator Kid Rock, and then they are all beaten by Santino."
Kugenesan1 wrote on 27.02.2026:
[6.0] "Santina is the greatest Diva ever. The only reason I am not giving this match a 10 out of 10 is that Mae Young not participating in this match. She should have. The commentary was great fun. Yeah this was definitely stupid but very funny at the same time."
JokerDeSilva wrote on 16.09.2025:
[0.0] "Yeah, it's very on brand for WWE to only ever hold a "Miss Wrestlemania" crowning match once in their history, and give it to Santino in a dress. This is embarrassing for everyone involved. I'm so beyond glad that things have improved for women's wrestling since this."
sdenapoli wrote on 01.09.2025:
[0.0] "This was totally pointless. From the loooong Kid Rock concert, to the match itself, to all the "comedy" with Santino at the end, this match sums up what WWE thought of their women from this time, as a joke."
Hippykillerz wrote on 14.08.2025:
[0.0] "First off, Kid Rock's mini concert lasted DOUBLE the length of the match, that's ridiculous. Very brave to put a piss-brake after the opening match. That aside, this just embarrassing to call a match. I love battle royals and this has to be in the running for the worst one ever. I had no idea who have the people were due to Kid Rock and the pace of the match being way to quick. Sloppy action, even Gail Kim struggled here. The one good point I will say it that took about half the match to realize 'Santina' was in the match so they hid 'her' well. That said, it's a huge slap to all the women for a man to win this one. Santino was super over at the time, I get it, but if this happened today, WWE would have major heat. Beyond awful segment."
Draftonism wrote on 10.07.2025:
[0.0] "If there was ever a definition of "a waste of time", it's this match. This was unnecessary and a Kid Rock segment at the start definitely did not help this match at all. Within the 5 minutes and 33 seconds of this match, some renowned names were not brought up at all. Not only was this an absolute disaster of a match but it also had a nonsensical ending by having Santina win over one of their top female stars at the time. This match defined what Vince's dreams likely are, a convoluted mess."
RemyLeBeau wrote on 26.05.2025:
[0.0] "I am just really not sure how in lords name that this was how they wanted to do this match. Also just to point out the story after is just as bad and still mostly offensive"
Thenxt observer wrote on 22.05.2025:
[0.0] "0 (0.0/10) Kid Rock must've been WWE's favorite artist in the world (at least, back in 2009). Or maybe he was Vince's. Or maybe he was whom Vince thought was our favorite artist. Or maybe it was Vince telling us that he was our favorite artist. Whatever the reason might've been, this is the part of the show you wanna get up and use the bathroom, and you might wanna grab a snack once you're done, because you're not going to want to see Santino Marella dressed in drag and being crowned the first ever Miss WrestleMania. Unless you enjoy seeing the Women's division being humiliated in front of the whole world. "Kid Rock is my hero, " said King. You think he meant that, or could that have been Junior in his ear?"
KKeanel wrote on 26.04.2025:
[1.0] "It wasn't entirely bad, however this whole idea on Santina's creation was a huge disaster. Piss break by any definition."
Banderas wrote on 27.03.2025:
[10.0] "Hell Yea. Santina Marella wins, that's it! She deserves to a title push for Divas Championship. Best match, and best women performer. Wait for more."
Ddamnpeggy wrote on 02.09.2024:
[0.0] "Seriously fuck this match dude. Santino Marella? Fuck that shit. Kid Rock? What a joke! Barely acknowledging some of the greatest divas of all time, instead talking about how hot they are all match? Why even have this on the fucking card dude."
brooksavage2004 wrote on 19.08.2024:
[0.0] "This whole battle royal was way to rushed, just about all the women involved hardly get seen or mentioned by name and having a man in Santino Marella win the whole thing is such a slap in the face to the WWE women's division."
Giulia Benity wrote on 10.08.2024:
[1.0] "A bunch of talented divas throwed in a small damn ring, let's also count this as the debut of Joy Giovanni, the return of Sunny, Molly Holly after 4 years in retirement, I barely think the commentators even recognized they're was in there, since there isn't even A ENTRANCE, just a random floppy singer singing in the stage, since this was like a mid- kickoff match the crowd was not even caring at all, let's not forget that Victoria, Torrie Wilson were also making their return after a couple of months or even years without having an TV match, honestly, I can consider this, as the worst match in the women's wrestling era, not because of the divas, because all of they were talented AS HELL, but the matter of sense of placing legends among with they, and burying they in a random FIVE minutes battle royal, I don't think there was A SINGLE move in this ugly match."
JacquesRougeauCanHaveMyWife wrote on 03.08.2024:
[1.0] "I mean obviously this is awful and insulting to have Santino win it and it's the biggest problem with this match, but it's also so boring and uneventful. They start without anybody noticing, people get thrown out randomly and the crowd just kinda sits there staring, occasionaly chanting for Marella. A waste of time, but I'm sure Vince enjoyed it."
VileVirgil wrote on 25.04.2024:
[0.0] "I think one person found this match enjoyable and his name is Vince. You know a match is bad when the commentary team can't think of shit to say. Completely disrespectful to the entire women's division when the boring ass match is won by a man and Kid Rock of all people gets more time and care then they did. 0/10"
TripleCrown wrote on 24.04.2024:
[0.0] "25th Anniversary of WrestleMania and they did this to "celebrate" women in the WWE. Absolutely disgraceful having Santino win it. Wasn't even "funny" nor was it worth the time and effort to put him in that gear and wig. Should've had an actual respected women's wrestler in it. I will say, despite the absolute disgrace of the finish, it was at least kind of cool to see so many women featured at WM. Sunny, Torrie Wilson, Molly Holly, kind of a shame we didn't get Lita or Trish Stratus but what can you do. I think if they had been in the match, then yeah... one of them would've won it for sure. I just don't understand why Santino had to win, such a disgusting thing to do. As Bryan Alvarez would say... MINUS 5 STARS."
DammitChrist wrote on 18.04.2024:
[0.0] "Overall, this shitty Battle Royal is a 1 out of 10. I will happily acknowledge the efforts of Mickie James, Michelle McCool, Beth Phoenix, Melina, Victoria, and Gail Kim (briefly) in this match despite the atrocious booking to this whole contest that had very little wrestling. I also will not ignore Molly Holly for staying as long as she could while trying to make the best out of a terrible match. With that being said, that is where the few positives end. As previously mentioned, this Battle Royal was mostly devoid of good wrestling; which is NOT the fault of the women here because this was back when WWE cared very little about women's wrestling. Additionally, they made SUCH a big deal about the winner of this match being the 1st ever "Miss Wrestlemania" only to have Santino Marella be the one victorious in the end despite being a man. Santino is not even transgender (like Nyla Rose) by the way, which would have been completely fine and acceptable. This was just Vince making a mockery out of women's wrestling; especially since he had none of the women come out individually, and since none of them were even trusted to go over the top rope in this Battle Royal for a legitimate elimination. It is also a disgrace that legends like Molly Holly, Victoria, and Torrie Wilson were brought back without a solo entrance just to be wasted in this shitty Battle Royal that BARELY gave any of them spotlight (although Victoria at least got SOME spotlight here). Sunny, Miss Jackie, and Joy Giovanni were apparently in this Battle Royal too; but you most likely would have never known while watching this entire segment. Hell, even the COMMENTATORS had trouble distinguishing the legends in this match. Aside from Victoria & Sunny, the commentators only distinguished Molly Holly, Torrie Wilson, and Miss Jackie AFTER they got eliminated. I don't even think they noticed Joy Giovanni being there at all. Maybe this is why you give these women a solo entrance going into this match, or AT LEAST introduce all of them individually in order to avoid this issue? Lastly, Trish Stratus and Lita dodged a major bullet by not being part of this terrible Battle Royal because they would have 100% been wasted here on Wrestlemania 25 of all ppvs. Santino Marella being the winner after doing almost NO offense in this match was just the ultimate slap to the face of EVERY woman that was brought in to compete in this Battle Royal. Maryse was the reigning Diva's Champion at the time of this Battle Royal; but you would have never guessed it since she was unceremoniously eliminated within the middle portions of this match. Melina was the reigning Women's Champion, and she was in the final 2 here; so I guess that counts for something in her behalf. Anyway, yea, this was an ABSYMAL way to showcase the women's division on their biggest ppv of the year, and an AWFUL way of spotlighting the female legends/veterans at Wrestlemania 25. It's a shame too because the 2009 women's division looks good on paper; especially since the likes of Mickie James, Melina, Maryse, Michelle McCool, and Beth Phoenix were the top women that year. It also had Gail Kim that received the occasional push in 2009-2010, but ended up being underutilized despite being a great talent. The division also had Eve Torres, the Bella Twins (especially Nikki Bella), and Layla who ended up growing to be decent performers in the end. WWE has come a long way in properly showcasing women's wrestling with GOOD booking over a decade later. Unfortunately, this Battle Royal is the epitome of WWE disrespecting the women during a time where they did not value them highly at all (especially since the male winner was just used as comic-relief at their expense at Wrestlemania 25; aka the biggest ppv of the year). As previously mentioned, this match is objectively a 1 out of 10 quality-wise; but this deserves another point taken off on this site because I STRONGLY dislike what they did to the women over a decade ago here. This gets a warranted 0 from me here on Cagematch. What a COMPLETE waste of Mickie James, Melina, Beth Phoenix, Michelle McCool, Maryse, Victoria, Molly Holly, Torrie Wilson, Gail Kim, Eve Torres, Natalya, Layla, and even the Bella Twins."
JoLUVmania wrote on 15.04.2024:
[0.0] "So disrespectful to the womens division, to have a Freaking Man win this match. and burying the already buried womens divison"
BoltsFan2132 wrote on 09.04.2024:
[1.0] "This was a throwaway that added nothing to the show and should have been on the pre show to make room on the main card for the Miz & Morrison match. The segment started with a mini Kid Rock concert and ends with Santino Marella winning a woman's battle royal, and to be honest if Santino wasn't so good as a comedy act this would have been even worse. It was cool having some of the legends back for this match but they didn't necessarily need to considering no one really was able to shine except for Beth Phoenix."
KingsCrossing wrote on 05.04.2024:
[1.0] "What an absolute mess... The booking of this match really shows the lack of respect the women's division received at this time. The fact that they brought back several women from the past and barely even featured them on camera shows how little they really cared about this. The match is a very standard women's battle royal for this period, and has nothing much of interest take place. I suppose I'll give it a point because the action itself was at least passable (no major botches and the offence was so simple that nothing looked all that bad) and thankfully very short, but from a booking standpoint this was a joke."
ShaliK wrote on 10.02.2024:
[0.0] "Probably the worst Battle Royal I've seen, the few spots there are are blocked. I'm wasting my time watching this. Even the public did not react more than that to Marella's victory. (0*)"
Madlad wrote on 24.12.2023:
[0.0] "This match SUCKS. one of those things that make you question watching wrestling. What the hell is this? So we start things with a shitty kid rock concert and then nothing happens and then Santiono won lol. You know what is the title for this battle royal? Yes the Miss Wrestlemania battle royal and Santiono Marella wins it LMAO"
lukerocker9 wrote on 31.08.2023:
[0.0] "An absolutely nothing battle royale where nothing interesting happens and no one got to shine. To make it worse Santino in drag wins, and to make it even worse Kid Rock took up 15 minutes of screen time before, don't particularly hate his songs, but a pre match concert shouldn't take more space than the match is introducing. And that also robbed us of getting Miz & Morrison on the card."
GMS18 wrote on 21.03.2023:
[0.0] "You'd think a 0 might be reserved for something that drags forever and takes years off your life but this very efficiently offers nothing of value. A shitty Kid Rock concert kicks us off with all the women coming out at once, commentary couldn't give a damn about the match except cracking horny jokes, not even for names like Sunny and Molly Holly making their first appearances in years, the actual match doesn't have a single good or memorable moment, and it's won by a man in a dress. Bravo."
TheOneAndOnlyCactus wrote on 14.03.2023:
[1.0] "An actual Women's match that was given more than 5 minutes for once... doesnt mean it was good. Props to Beth, Mickie and Michelle who did their best but dear lord, this mess of a match sums up the history of Womens wrestling in WWE until then. It was sloppy, poorly thought of, and had the worst possible winner. To think that the Kid Rock concert, in which the Divas made their way to the ring, lasted longer than the actual match, surely is insanity."
Sky23 wrote on 09.06.2022:
[0.0] "This was the state of women's wrestling in WWE in 2009. Essentially the backdrop to a performance by white-trash anthem master Kid Rock, featuring very little actual in-ring action to speak of, and ending in a man in a dress winning a women's accolade. Anyone who was willing to defend this at the time, let alone 13 years later, is someone to be distrusted heavily."
Leo 4 King wrote on 12.02.2022:
[2.0] "Certainly not a good match, but there are some cool spots, Beth Phoenix is very impressive as usal, Mickie gieves a good performance, especially the confrontatin with Michelle McCool."
The Joseph wrote on 10.02.2022:
[0.0] "Kid Rock. Santina Marella. No one gets a single moment but them. That should be all I need to say to give this match a 0."
cactus wrote on 14.05.2021:
[0.0] "Before the match starts we are 'treated' to a nearly 15 minute Kid Rock concert. The participants of this battle royal are robbed of getting individual entrances as they all enter together during the last song. We've got returning stars like Sunny, Victoria, and Molly Holly making their return, but you wouldn't have noticed that as they aren't introduced and are lost in the sea of blonde women in the ring. Santina (Santino in drag) wins this car wreck of a battle royal. This entire segment made all the women feel like afterthoughts and its sole purpose was to build up to a joke that went over like a fart in church? ."
Argylex wrote on 13.12.2020:
[0.0] "Maybe the lowest point in the history of WWE's women's division. Both the match itself and the subsequent angle of "Santina"."
WhatIsLooveee wrote on 08.11.2020:
[0.0] "Probably the worst battle royale in the company's history, the worst contender to win this battle royale, and the worst decision to put it on the card of the biggest stage of them all. It was terrible from start to finish, including the idea, the consequences, and the match itself, if you can call it that at all"
HC7 wrote on 25.08.2020:
[0.0] "As a kid I thought this was pretty funny and entertaining and I still think the Santina thing is okay but really did not help the already pretty bad and boring womens roster at the time. Yes someone should have won this other than Marella and been pushed but the fact this happened at that time is not shocking at all considering how much WWE gave a shit about the Divas division"
guysquiterio wrote on 02.08.2020:
[1.0] "Bad, bad, bad! i feel bad for each Woman that was in this very ring.... yes even Rosa Mendes, this was very bad and no fluence in the moves smeh, shame on Santino and the bookers"