[0.0] "When fans want to throw around trailblazer for Stacy Keibler and Trish, it includes garbage like this. Now, to be fair, it's not their fault. They're doing what they're told because there was nowhere else to work for women in 2004. Unfortunately, that's just the way it is. Jazz, Molly, and Victoria were always good and yet I rarely see their names get the credit they deserve."
[0.0] "For most of these matches ill give a 0 there was some actual good moves here but its just disgusting to watch i feel bad for all the women here as their all very talented sad to see."
[4.0] "In all kidding aside, this battle royal here wasn't all that endearing. I didn't like how Nidia, Jazz and Gail Kim were eliminated within the first minute of this. And I laugh in retrospect because less than 2 weeks later, all three of them were fired as this was Nidia's last match if I recall. Not much to say here. Highlight was probably the double team slingshot spot on Victoria from Molly and Trish. Picked up a tad bit with Molly, Trish and Stacy at the end but, again it was rushed very quickly with a bleh ending."
[2.0] "I mean...this was bad, but it was typical bad stuff that you'd expect of this era. Yeah, the fetish stuff was very awkward and unneeded. Yes there is a lot of sloppiness here. Yes, Stacy looked out of her depth. But it wasn't ungodly long and there was some semblance of action. It's really bad for sure, but not worse than you should expect it to be going into it."
[4.0] "Honestly not the worst battle royal ever. It's rough around the edges but I think this is probably the closest Stacy Keibler ever came to winning the title and tbh, maybe they should've given her a quick run for 1-2 weeks. The booking sucks and whatnot but you can't say that the women don't work their asses off in these matches."
[8.0] "Do we really care about the wrestling here? No. But do I like seeing a bunch of beautiful women in sexy outfits? Hell Yes. Everyone looked beautiful, hard to pick a favorite but I guess Trish. Highlights included Nidia's top being ripped off, Stacy doing her foot choke on Trish, Jazz on the apron and then Trish's post match celebration topped it all off. As JR said I was mesmerized watching this one."
[2.0] "Whatever anyone says about the current WWE product, women's matches really have come a long way from this. Trish does actually get a decent spot here where she saves herself from elimination towards the end and the women in this match are talented and try their best out of what they was given and are not to blame at all for the quality of it and sadly it's another example of really bad T and A stipulation matches we often got at the time. Jerry Lawler is as perverted on commentary as you would expect!"
[2.0] "Was genuinely terrible the fact it is just out the ring and not over the top for elimination is whack. Jerry Lawler on commentary is one horny bastard. But can still appreciate the talent of the women wrestlers just a really fucking weird concept of match."
[2.0] "It was what it was and it was just sad watching some talented women having to put up with that. I can't completely shit on it because some decent workers were involved and their stuff wasn't bad, plus they got the reaction from the virgins in the crowd, but the fact that it actually took place is just insulting to the intelligence."
[5.0] "I actually thought the action in this match was pretty good especially near the final sections (Stacy's hope spot, Trish's elimination save). Helps that the women in the ring have genuine talent and we aren't yet in the period where these battle royals would contain women who'd never wrestled before. Of course the stipulation and the commentary holds it back but if this had been a regular battle royal for the championship this could have been a genuinely good match. There aren't even any huge botches."
[1.0] "I'm not categorically against titillation in wresting but good lord if I had to listen to one more second of Jerry Lawler filling his pants over this match I might have vomited. The women did what they could in this "match"."
[0.0] "a poor taste attempt at soft porn and it being for the title makes it much worst. There is nothing that redeems this in any way. everyone is dressed in school girl outfits and Jerry Lawler does kindergarden joked."
[1.0] "A lot of talent in the ring but unfortunately this was the Ruthless Aggression era so they did not get the opportunity to show it. Commentary was abysmal.."
[1.0] "Shameless sex appeal, and as was usual for women's battle royals at the time, they didn't trust the women to throw each other over the top rope so you could be eliminated if you went through the ropes. I'm shocked Gail Kin didn't just eliminate herself like she did in 2011. Though, she and Victoria threw in the only actual wrestling moves all match, so I have to give them credit for that. Dragged too long at the end."