[7.0] "A very enjoyable encounter between two talented young wrestlers who complement each other particularly well. The pace is excellent throughout, with both men showcasing their athleticism and creativity through some impressive sequences. Marcus Mathers is especially impressive, bringing an unpredictable quality to his offence and making a very strong case for himself in from of an AEW audience. Nick Wayne, meanwhile, continues to show cinsiderable improvement, displaying confidence and a more convincing heel personality that adds some welcome character to the match. His interactions with the cowd are particularly entertaining, and he seems increasingly comfortable in this role. Mathers also deserves credit for his selling and for making Wayne's offence look convincing without sacrificing his own strengths. The match perhaps lacks the depth and complexity to reach another level, but its relatively short duration works in its favour, keeping the action focused and preventing anything from overstaying its welcome."
[3.0] "[1.5*] Wasn't the biggest fan. I think this did more harm than good for Nick Wayne's awesome new character. I know tony really loves this type of young, super indy high-flyer like Mathers but he's a nobody for AEW's audience and he shouldn't have worked a 50/50 match against the kid they're pushing hard after he beat Chris Jericho (twice). Too many big moves, not a lot of selling, exaggerated facial expressions by Mathers who had Speedball's gear and a move-set that's a fucking mix of Ace Austin and all these guys. Match lacked personality and felt like a bad DEFY Main Event. I support the talent but this made no sense."
[6.0] "A fun 8-minute TV match with plenty of energy. Both guys kept things moving well, Mathers brought the explosiveness, and Wayne was a good fit for that kind of pace. It is not something I would call must-see, but it did exactly what a match in this spot should do. Solid television wrestling that served its purpose and moved on."
[4.0] "Mathers is like a worse version of Speedball, Ace Austin and Dragunov rolled into one, I don't get the appeal. Wayne looked great as per usual, this guy is gonna be AEW world champion one day for sure. 4"
[3.0] "A good showcase for Matthers, whom I wasn't familiar with. Wayne won, as expected, but at least it served to introduce a wrestler to the audience, despite the limited time. In-ring quality: 1.25/5. Stakes: 0.5/2. Justification: 0.25/1. Placement on the card: 0.75/1. Suspense: 0/1. Bonus/penalty: none. Total: 2.75/10. Match watched on MyAEW."
[4.0] "Not a type of match that I'm a big fan of, but it had some thrill without a doubt, with Marcus Mathers making another big appearance, after leaving WWE ID, I've read these days that he made his ROH debut, and now he's on Collision, so Tony must really like him. The bout was pretty much a fast paced spotfest, with a very lackluster selling and the sequence at the end with the destroyers and all of that was super lame, but in terms of athleticism it was an interesting one - {**}"
[9.0] "This was a lot of fun honestly. Nick Wayne has really hit on something lately, he's clicking in a great way. Mathers is a guy I know a little from the indie scene and I thought he put on a really great effort here, looked better than certain regular roster folks I could name. This was a really good time."
[8.0] "A fast paced match between two young high fliers. Mathers moves in unexpected ways around the ring and it's fascinating to watch. Wayne was full of confidence and playing to the very pro-Jericho crowd, but none of those losers in the crowd beat Jericho twice, so he kept going. Just a very fun match from start to finish."
[7.0] "Was actually pretty entertaining. When Nick Wayne is given the right opponent, he looks great. Mathers sold well, got in some impressive offense, and overall lead to a good match."
[4.0] "This match wasn't good but this new character for Wayne might go somewhere if they do anything substantial with it but irrelevant collison undercard matches aren't gonna take him further. He should be in the mix for some midcard titles if they wanna capitilize on his recent success."
[6.0] "Honestly when this was announced i thought this would be sub 5 minutes and a way to put Nick over even more. But i was positively surprised to see it go close to 10 minutes with some nice back and fourth action. I think i have seen Mathers wrestle once before tagging with Price and Olivier vs Bayne, Yamashita and Starkz which was a really fucking good mixed 6 tag (must watch). He impressed me with that and he did that again here with some solid offence throughout i assume he will be getting a deal in the same way as Zayda soon. Nick was once again good with everything from his offence to his crowd work and it is great to see how over he has gotten. First person to benefit from a Jericho feud in donkeys years. Finish with the Wayne's world was pretty good as normal. Nick's post match promo was also pretty good and the ships horn replacing the pyro for him beating Jericho was so bloody good. So yeah overall a good match that suprised me with the fact it got time to be a good match. (***1/4)"
[10.0] "Come on man this is the debut of Marcus Mathers being able to perform now in the AEW landscape environment for his professional wrestling career and it just goes to show what a future for him holds, but I believe that he may be able to sign a deal with that company potentially. He and Nick Wayne had a tremendous matchup and just have always been high level players when it comes to pro wrestling matches. Great work from both the young stars man, future is so damn bright."
[7.0] "Nick Wayne's heel work, from the expressions, to the crowd work, to the bumping, made this match what it was. Mathers did well with this opportunity."
[7.0] "This match was so fast paced and fun, they packed so much in to 8 minutes. I had never seen Marcus Mathers before this match but am now a fan of his. I started to believe he might actually get an upset win, the commentary team helped with this. Nick Wayne's promo with the ship horn instead of pyro was awesome."
[6.0] "(3.25 stars) I thought it would last two minutes, but in the end they gave Marcus Mathers a chance to shine a bit, and Wayne's little promo at the end was fun"