[8.0] "Another very strong encounter between two of the best tag teams in the world, further demonstrating just how well these four work together. The chemistry remains excellent, with crisp combinations, clever counters and increasingly compelling near-falls throughout. What makes this particular instalment especially enjoyable is the added sense of urgency, as FTR find themselves in a position where another defeat could effectively end their chances of winning the series. That desperation translates nicely into the performances, giving the match a more heated atmosphere and allowing both teams to bring a little more emotion to their work. The action itself is perhaps not paticularly different from what we've seen in their previous encounters, and a few sequences do feel somewhat repetitive, but the execution remains consistently impressive. The unique setting aboard the Jericho Cruise also adds some character to the match, while the crowd provided an excellent atmosphere. The finish is particularly well handled, with FTR resorting to some opportunistic tactics to secure the victory and level the series. My on real criticsm is the somwhat unnecessary referee spot, which feels out of place amid anotherwise well-constructed encounter. Nevertheless, this is another excellent chapter in what has become a very enjoyabe series. I'm increasingly looking forward to seeing how they bring it all to a conclusion."
[7.0] "All their matches so far has been really that level, not that great for what you expect from two of the best tag teams of all time but understandable specially when you think about it. It is five matches, if they perform their best at first the ceiling will be gigantic. So I kinda respect the way they made their performance overtime. Anyway, this match had a pretty similar ringwork compared with the Fright Night one with the huge difference that the crowd was better, Paul Wight added a lot of good qualities with his on point commentaries and we got a shift here because that could mean the series was over for FTR if they lose, so their urgency was higher than ever. They played better the emotions here, and the ending here was actually good."
[7.0] "[3.5*] I've rated 3 of their 4 matches together 3.5-Stars. Before the 5th match (which I loved) I honestly thought this was their ceiling and it was fine, despite a bit disappointing. I still don't think this is a legendary Series but it's been pretty fun TV. This was great, they had great chemistry and the crowd was pretty hot. Some repetitive spots but also some great character development too. This was a bit more heated (thankfully) and crisp, with FTR stealing the win to tie the series. Very good stuff."
[8.0] "I really enjoyed this again. You can genuinely feel the continuity between these matches. The near falls were well constructed, the combinations were sharp, there were plenty of small counters, and the pace kept increasing naturally as the match went on. Obviously, the series was always heading toward a fifth match, but because the journey there has been so consistently strong, the finale actually feels important rather than inevitable. The referee spot caught me off guard, but it didn't bother me. I even laughed."
[6.0] "Not bad but a little disappointing for me. I couldn't tell you why they gave the fucking referee a leapfrog/drop down spot. This may surprise some people but I've never bought a ticket to see what the ref might do. It was completely out of place and took me out of the match."
[8.0] "Really good match, probably the second best they've had behind their WrestleDream instant classic. The referee doing athletics was a bit stupid though I'll admit, that was a bit too much even for me. Great tag match.. 8"
[10.0] "I still think their first match was their best so far but only by a little bit. The unique setting on the boat gave this one some specific flavor, especially being forced to fight multiple times in the tiny space between the ring and the fans. FTR did an awesome job busting up Shelley's leg out there, giving a strong story to the match."
[4.0] "Predictable winners, a rather lame finish, and wrestling devoid of any major highlights. The fact that the most notable spot involved the referee says a lot about this match; it was given plenty of time, yet it never managed to draw me in. In-ring quality: 1.5/5. Stakes: 0.5/2. Justification: 1/1. Placement on the card: 1/1. Suspense: 0/1. Bonus/penalty: none. Total: 4/10. Match watched on MyAEW."
[7.0] "[*** 3/4] These four legends keep delivering masterclass after masterclass of tag team wrestling on every show. It has been an awesome series of matches, all really great at around 15 minutes each, just awesome. I really liked how in this one FTR failed to cut the ring in half early on, allowing MCMG to take a much more prominent role. The venue also gave it a niche indie atmosphere that really elevated the visuals, and that ref spot was fucking NUTS."
[6.0] "Another good one between them, I think this one was the best in terms of crispiness, after three full matches against each other, the chemistry is on point as expected, and we had some nice fast paced combinations here. The thematic of the match was pretty much the same, they focused on speedy combos and frenetic tag team action, which is not my favorite angle from FTR, but it's still enjoyable in its own way. Many sequences here were great to watch, and FTR managed to win the match and tie the series, now it's 2-2, after Stokely distracted Shelley and Dax took advantage with a surprise roll-up - {***}"
[6.0] "I really liked this tag match. All of their matches have been really good tag matches, but in my opinion, they haven't topped their first one. I personally think this was their weakest tag match. As I said, this was still a really good tag match; however, it lacked something, and I don't know what it is. "
[8.0] "The in-ring quality was very high, as one might have expected, but for me, this match suffers from two issues. The outcome of a fourth match in this kind of setup is often predictable, and the way they won--involving interference from Stokely--was the same as in the second match. That's why I would have preferred for them to win on their own in the second match (even if by cheating, since that's part of their characters)."
[9.0] "An absolute tag team clinic, and one that used the limited space of this arena well. FTR focused on the leg of Shelley, leaving Sabin to fight FTR for a good chunk, really got to see some fantastic babyface and heel work in that stretch. This series has been very good, and this was the best match since the opener. Stokely helps FTR steal the win, ensuring a match #5 will happen."
[6.0] "This had heavy "we need to do this match to get to the last one" energy. I don't think these two teams can have a terrible match even if they tried, but there's clearly more in the tank. I'm sure the fifth match in the series is going to be a banger."
[8.0] "I thought this was wonderful. Tight, well worked, well structured, well paced and proper old school tag team wrestling. No insane bumps and flips required because the work could speak for itself. These matches feel like they stand alone. The last match is going to be a banger. TAG TEAM WRESTLING!"
[7.0] "Very good tag once again, continued on the attack to the leg after the third match so this one pretty much focuses on Shelley's injury for the Sabin hot tag. A nice addition to the series to give FTR a nice win and a good setup for their final match"
[4.0] "Feel like I haven't seen anything new in their matches since their first bout, it feels like they have peaked there and this has turned into a time wasting, heatless bouts between two talented tag teams. They could have these same matches with others with similar results at least those would feel less repetitive since they aren't facing each other every week."
[8.0] "Well i thought this match match was really good and of the 3 of 4 matches i have seen from this series the closest in quality to match one. Which i thought was the peak of the 5 match series so far. Thought it was wrestled with a level of intensity close to match 1 which helped it feel very important. Added to the fact it was shit or bust for FTR. Lots of good action in the match with some good counters and some good work by FTR on Shelly's leg which was the peak of the match for me. The chemistry between the teams are what makes these matches and that was on show at a good level once again the just mesh together so well. But i do agree that it feels like this has been a bit underwhelming of a series considering how excited we were all for them to finally face each other multiple times. But it will all be worth it with match 5 at full gear i think. They won't have anything to hold back and we will get a definitive finish which will add a lot to the match as i am bored considering i think all 3 tv matches have ended in roll ups to protect each team. So yeah a pretty good match but i am sure match 5 will be something special. (****)"
[10.0] "Every single one of these damn tag team professional wrestling matches from FTR and MCMG I have said it from the beginning and I will stick of it till the very end. They will all be a career highlighted performance match up every single time and they are literally doing it as we speak. This was one of the best ones yet as well, this was just perfect tag team pro wrestling. Amazing man. So good."
[7.0] "I think this was my favorite match of the series so far. Good control work from FTR that never felt dull or like it went too long. Sabin and Shelley's comebacks were welled timed and both did good jobs performance wise as well. Still, it didn't hit the level I expected from this series."
[8.0] "(4.25 stars) It was far more intense than Match 3 and therefore of a much higher standard; however, Match 5 simply has to be the classic we've been waiting for all these years, otherwise I'll consider the feud a disappointment"
[8.0] "A much better match in my opinion than the Wrestle Dream match. The way FTR worked over Shelley's leg throughout this was magnificant and honestly made me care about the Machine Guns. MCMG are a good team and have always been but something about them make me drift from their matches but this one was very grounded and a sense of desperation from FTR took this to another level. ****"
[9.0] "Excellent, just like each of the four matches they've put on so far. The in ring psychology and the chemistry, it's all there. I can't wait to see Match 5 at Full Gear, they're going to give it their all without holding back, and given what we've seen so far, it can only be legendary. Two of the best teams in the world."
[8.0] "Best match in the series since the first one at WrestleDream. Good mix of aggression and technical work, and the crowd are hot for every second of it ****"