"[6.0] The match itself was pretty decent, featuring some good counters and impactful moves. Liv Morgan did a great job with the ring psychology, controlling the match in a way that fit the storyline behind it. What keeps me from giving it a higher rating was the appearance of Liv's partners, which didn't really fit the situation and felt rather forced. The ending was also extremely anticlimactic. To be completely honest, the way this match ended was pretty bad. Despite having a good beginning and middle, the match maintained a decent pace, which I appreciated, as I was actually expecting it to be much slower."
[5.0] "A rather underwhelming match that never quite manages to live up to its intended underdog narrative. The dynamic between Liv Morgan's arrogance and Chelsea Green's determination is perfectly understandable, and there are few decent moments along the way, but the in-ring execution leaves a lot to be desired. The apcing is sluggish, the offence often lacks impact, and the chemistry between the two is not particularly convincing. Liv does a reasonable job of playing the dominant heel, while Chelsea has some moments that hint at a more serious side to her character, but the overall performance never really comes together. The finish is also somewhat underwhelming, and the subsequent Money in the Bank cash-in, while providing a significant title change, does little to elevate the match itself. A disappointing effort, especially considering the talent involved and the importance of the championship at stake."
[7.0] "A good and better than expected match. Probably one of Chelsea Green's best singles matches and it showed that she deserved a world title reign. Some good spots and a physical matchup. I liked the fact that Chelsea won, a mini upset."
[1.0] "All I have to say is yikes. I'm a fan of Chelsea Green, but her match with Liv wasn't very good. I'll state two positives that Morgan being heelish towards her was good alongside her beatdown (some parts of it), which gives sympathy towards Green. Some of Chelsea's offences were basic but good. The negatives stem with the match that it felt slow, some sections were choreographed between both women, they looked sloppy in the ring, and I wish at least there were more selling. If the story hinted of a slow confidants build up throughout for Chelsea that finally she just had enough of Liv talking down at her, beating her up, she then gives her a beatdown like she did to her. It would've been so awesome, it'd show a side of Chelsea we never saw. It upsets me that this is her final match as champion, the ending of the match was underwhelming and the segment afterwards was very predictable: Tiffany turning heel and cashing in. Very boring. Nonetheless, I hope all the women have better booking and become better in the ring."
[4.0] "Ass match. Chelsea can't sell for her life lmao. Liv was actually fine in this but I hated the ending. It was very bad. No selling at all. I'm happy Tiffany is champion and we don't have to see Chelsea holding captive the title. But I have to admit that she didn't need that briefcase at all. Roxanne should be miss MITB"
[2.0] "bof.. Liv Morgan est insupportable mais fait tout le match (enfin pas grand chose tout de même), heureusement, car Chelsea Green ne brille pas.. gros manque de sérieux, surtout pour une championne ! quel ennui"
[2.0] "A thoroughly poor match, with awkward pacing, unconvincing offence and little chemistry between the two. The decision to present Liv as the dominant wrestler only compounded the problems. Chelsea's victory offered no meaningful redemption for a disastrous title reign, and the subsequent cash-in reduced her supposed moment of vindication to another booking convenience. A shame how little care was afforded to any of this."
[4.0] "I was not feeling this match at all. There wasn't one part of this match were I thought that what I was seeing was interesting or compelling. I just dont get it maybe, I love both of these peformers I think there both great wrestlers in ring, I just don't think there giving us the best they can + the cash in was cool but as of right now I don't get why Tiffany (in kayfabe) would cash in on Chelsea when Liv was right there, but the story hasn't happened yet so maybe I sound like an idiot. But the cash in doesn't justify Roxxane not winning."
[3.0] "[1.5*] I mean. It wasn't good, eh? I gotta say, I do appreciate that they tried really hard to have a proper wrestling match, but Liv only works out against incredible workers and Chelsea is not a good in-ring performer at all, so this felt a little bit... amateur? Idk. I liked the storytelling and they did try hard, but it just wasn't technically good. I won't ever give a DUD to a match like that tho."
[3.0] "Technically, this was a very poor match, and it went far too long for something with no chemistry. The supposed feel-good story of Chelsea Green, who had been presented as the weaker champion, finally overcoming a much stronger champion in Liv Morgan completely failed to land for me. By the end, I wasn't invested in Chelsea proving herself. I just wanted the match to be over. The interference was unnecessary, the finish was unnecessary, and honestly the entire feud felt unnecessary. The whole thing just felt exhausting. And as for the cash-in afterward, I would rather not even get started."
[1.0] "Very poor match, but what do you expect when you put 2 of the worst and most boring women in WWE in that position. I'm so glad Tiffany cashed in, she plays a better heel then a babyface and having her as the champion makes sense. WWE/HHH loves shitting on Chelsea Green."
[5.0] "That was long and pretty mideocre match. Liv was superconfident and Chelsea played ultimate underdog. That story they delivered perfectly and the finish was right. If there was a higher dynamic and it took less time for this, it could be a good match, becuase I didn't see any botches."
[2.0] "There's not much to say about this match... it just highlights the state of WWE's women's division. EMBARRASSING... I just hope they can do better next year. They have an endless amount of talented women they're wasting just to give us this."
[1.0] "The match was: slaps, Codebreaker, slaps, Three Amigos, Codebreaker, slaps, suplex, Codebreaker, slaps, Oblivion, and a roll-up... Tag team or mid-card wrestlers being booked like main eventers... The women's division is having one of its worst years."
[2.0] "I made a joke a few weeks ago about, despite the Houthi rocket attacks, this matchup might've been the greatest act of terrorism to be inflicted upon Riyadh in a hot minute. To be fair, it wasn't terrorism. But dear god, it was still a terrible match. Morgan continues her regression in all facets, and although we all have fond memories of Reklusa, we need to admit to ourselves that Lucha Underground was ten years ago and Chelsea -- like fellow former indie darling Michin, in fact -- is not really where we should be looking in 2026 for a world champion. Slow and plodding during the match, the Judgment Day shenanigans were incredibly boring, and the cash-in itself also derivative of a couple of years ago. Just bad."
[7.0] "This Women's Champion vs. Champion Crown Jewel match between Liv Morgan and Chelsea Green was heavy on character-driven psychological storytelling, but ultimately dragged down by sluggish in-ring execution and an overly predictable post-match angle. The structural story here was actually solid on paper: Liv Morgan leaned heavily into her cocky, mean-spirited heel persona, completely dominating the action and treating Green like an illegitimate paper champion. Chelsea, meanwhile, played the insecure, self-doubting underdog fighting from underneath. When Liv ordered The Judgment Day away from ringside in an act of overconfidence, it opened the door for Green to capitalises on a botched ObLivion attempt and snatch a shock roll-up victory. However, bell-to-bell, the match lacked the workrate and physical intensity required for a high-profile PLE stage. The pacing was noticeably slow, with long stretches of basic heel control that failed to engage a notoriously quiet crowd. To make matters worse, the post-match Money in the Bank cash-in by Tiffany Stratton felt completely telegraphed weeks in advance, undercutting Chelsea's moment of validation before the dust even settled. A decent narrative effort that delivered the right winner, but an undeniably flat TV-style match overall."
[8.0] "I respect Liv's performance in all her matches, as well as the excitement she generates both during and before a match--even when she is a heel. Consider this: on Friday night smackdown they were in New York, and by Saturday night--following a long journey--they were in Saudi Arabia, in middle of the war, yet Liv still delivered a good performance. I like Chelsea, but I'm glad she's no longer the Women's Champion, as she is weak, slow, and unexciting. It was a reasonably good match, but almost all the credit for it goes to Liv's performance. when so many haters with low rating are here, show that Liv does her heel character for the ring, perfectly."
[4.0] "This was as good as it can be when it comes to Liv Morgan's matches. I'm actually happy that WWE gave her extended title run. Now everyone can see how absurdly awful she's when it comes to wrestling. I hope she carry it till people boo her out of the ground. She always amazes me how someone who is there for more than 10 years is still as awful as she was 10 years ago."
[2.0] "Trash, horrible, terrifying... wrestlers who just aren't main event championship material. They are perfect for the mid-card or the tag team division, but there is so much talent better than both of them"
[3.0] "A truly poor match technically, uninteresting, the finish was awful, and then what can be said about Stratton's completely predictable and insignificant cash-in? In short..."
[5.0] "A fairly average match from start to finish. Chelsea attempted a few bursts of offense, but Morgan remained somewhat restrained in her attacks--though she did deliver a decent closing sequence. Ultimately, however, this did little to make these "Crown Jewel" matches any more exciting; I find them quite inconsequential in terms of prestige. In-ring quality: 1.25/5. Stakes: 0.75/2. Justification: 1/1. Placement on the card: 1/1. Suspense: 1/1. Bonus/penalty: none. Total: 5/10. Match viewed on Netflix (FR)."
[5.0] "Not always the smoothest and not in the realm of good, but this was fine. Possibly as good as it could have reasonable been expected to be. Story was solid and crowd played its part, getting behind Chelsea when she couldn't get behind herself. Chelsea gets the win with the stacked pin after dodging the ObLIVion."
[1.0] "The WWE Women's division has hit terrifying new lows in 2026 but it's still early november so there's still time to watch them sink even further into the abyss. This was awful. Chelsea and Liv Morgan as your world champions. This is obvious sabotage of a division that was the lone shining light in 2025. I can't keep watching this anymore. I'm wasting my life."
[3.0] "Terrible match, match construction was stupid, match was stupid, Interventions and roll-up ending made it worse. Match construction was made around Chelsea Green being a weak champion and Liv Morgan being the dominant one, when Chelsea Green was in the build showed to be able to defend herself and her title, which Liv Morgan did not do. JD interventions were stupid, and ending was ridiculous. And I don't even want to talk about the Tiffany Stratton cash-in."
[3.0] "I wasn't shocked when this match didn't live up to the standard some had, because I knew this was going to be very below average. I really wished Stephanie Vaquer was the WWE Women's World Champion and not Liv Morgan. I wasn't amazed by anything. But somehow I had some hope that something could hit for me, but it just didn't. Chelsea Green got the win as she won her 1st WWE Women's Crown Jewel Championship, as we thought, but then what happened next was something we all knew was going to happen eventually. Tiffany Stratton turned heel as she won her 2nd Women's World Title as she's now the WWE Women's Crown Jewel Champion and is the now new WWE Women's Champion."
[7.0] "Geeks on Twitter kept doomposting about this match like 2 months in advance, and yet it didn't turn out to be a disaster AT ALL whatsoever. In fact, both women ended up overdelivering in this match (contrary to the low rating that's pretty much just evident of critics review bombing this contest due to their obvious disdain for both/either women). The match turned out to be really good. I give Liv Morgan vs Chelsea Green a 7.5 out of 10 overall, but I will go with the 7 on here."
[5.0] "I can only be describe this match as 'fine'. It was telegraphed to kingdom come that Chelsea was gonna win this and she did. Cool. Of course the most interesting thing obviously was Tiffy looming, most thought it would be during the match but no, they had Chelsea beat Liv clean as a whistle in a very questionable finish. Most of the match is Liv beating the crap out of Chelsea. My only hope out of this is that the whole thing with Liv telling the JD girls to leave then losing anyway is a meaningful story beat. [**.5]"
[2.0] "I have no idea what this was, but it wasn't good. I hate saying this since I love both Liv and Chelsea, but these two had no in-ring chemistry. Despite a few decent maneuvers and counters, the rest of the match was botchy and slow. I usually like long women's matches, but giving 16 minutes to two women who don't have chemistry was a mistake. "
[1.0] "A legitimate farce to occur on a PPV. No one can execute moves properly, everything feels lightweight and pointless, there's no chemistry, and the finish is laughably bad. Chelsea doesn't even block the oblivion, Liv just falls down and looks like a total jobber just getting rolled up after Chelsea just stares for an entire second. There is no excuse for your women's wrestling and your women's champions to be this bad in the ring in 2026. Who agented this shit?"
[5.0] "I came into this one with really low expectations and they did get surpassed, but this match still isnt good. Green's offense just doesnt look convincing, neither does Morgan's but at least she tries to make it look like a wrestling match. The finish was really abrupt and almost botched. 5"
[5.0] "Very happy that Chelsea got to have her moment for a time. She does belong in the scene with the other talented women on this roster. Unfortunately her and Liv have no chemistry in the ring. I was bored for a majority of this match. But what gave it some weight is that Liv played the great heel throughout the match. Loved Tiffany's cash in if I'm being honest. Thrilled she's back to being a heel."
"Poorly produced and executed. The narrative was Chelsea proving to herself that she deserved to be a champ. Therefore, I would have had Chelsea win clean with her finisher. That's a decisive statement. But having her underneath for the whole match with no sustained heroic comeback and then win by surprise roll-up reinforces the narrative that her championship was a fluke. She didn't prevail, she escaped. A convincing win would have made Tiffany's sudden but inevitable betrayal sting more, too. Perhaps WWE wanted to protect Liv. But why? Liv had nothing at stake. I wanted to root for Chelsea during this championship reign but her ring performances have not delivered. They have instead highlighted a lack of athleticism and poor chemistry with her ring partners. Liv is the same for me. Both are great character workers but marginal ring performers. Tiffany's betrayal was obviously telegraphed yet WWE never produced a plausible explanation for it. The storyline they have given Tiffany since MITB has just made her look like a moron. A heel turn for the sake of a heel turn."
[2.0] "Bad match. The story coming in is that Chelsea is a loser who doubts herself despite being a champion and Liv bullying her. That played into the match with Liv dominating and Chelsea looking helpless. Boring. Flat finish where Liv went for Oblivion but that was blocked and Chelsea rolls her up for the pin. Another unconvincing fluke win for Chelsea that makes her look weak. Predictably, Tiffy cashes in on Chelsea to become the new champion. I'm glad Chelsea's awful pity run is over, the only good thing to come out of this. 2/10"
[4.0] "It's obvious that this match isn't a walk in the park for the viewers. But it's also not the total disaster that some people here would like to make it out to be--not to mention any regression to the Divas era. From ring bell to ring bell, the match isn't great, but it's at least okay. What happens afterwards, however, is a complete mockery. They give Chelsea the biggest triumph of her WWE career with a clean win over Morgan, only to mercilessly shoot her down right after. That's just plain shitty. And Tiffy Time, Version 2.0, now in heel mode, isn't a direction I would have sacrificed Green's current, hard-earned audience acceptance for. But it is what it is--don't even think about getting over unless the office wants you to."
[5.0] "(2.5 stars) To be honest, there's been some improvement - I didn't switch off my TV because of how rubbish they both were, so I'm actually quite proud of myself"
[5.0] "Pretty basic match here, they told the story of the underdog during this match and for weeks in the buildup, so everything was pretty predictable here from Liv dominating to Chelsea rolling her up for the win. The cash-in afterwards wasn't surprising at all, and they didn't even try to make it interesting, the same stupid storyline she had against Nia Jax to a degree, still in disbelief they didn't give Roxanne the briefcase for this. Everything felt super flat in this match and the post-match."
[2.0] "An awful match that suffered from poor execution and a noticeable lack of chemistry, which only confirmed my opinion that this is the worst main roster women's division since the so-called revolution in 2015. Simply boring and forgettable."
[3.0] "Another Power Rangers match this year. An absolute disaster, with an even worse finish. I honestly couldn't even tell if it was a botch or if it was supposed to end differently. Just bizarre. The post-match angle was completely predictable and ended up ruining both the match and all the great mic work that came before it. Absolutely ridiculous. Did we really need Tiffany to turn into a full-blown heel? What was the point? I genuinely don't understand any of this. Maybe they're geniuses and I'm just not seeing the bigger picture, but I seriously have my doubts."
[5.0] "Thought the match flowed well. This was probably both wrestlers best performance in a long time. I thought the match had a lot of intensity and worked well with the story they'd been telling. Chelsea wanted to prove herself and Liv didn't take Chelsea too seriously. Both women sold really well and had the crowd invested. I thought the match was building to an emphatic win for Chelsea so was disappointed with the roll up finish. This will have a good experience for both women and will help them both to have experienced a match of this magnitude and length. Not without its flaws and a better finish would have helped but overall enjoyable."
"from what ive seen this match sucked its great chelsea won but other than that everything about this sucked it was also probably the most predictable cash in oat which made this 100x worse 0.25/5"
"Bad match. Liv beats Chelsea throughout the entire match and at the end, Chelsea just won. She didn't just win , she won in the worst possible way. Also Tifanny's cash-in was so bad. (2/10)"
[3.0] "This match was the most boring one of the entire event. Well, things like that happen, so it can't be helped. But the real issue came after! A cash-in on Chelsea? ! All of Chelsea Green's hard work has gone to waste!"
[6.0] "Good one! I get that people dislike the wrestlers involved and many folks are also complaining about Tiffany's cash-in, which is a part of the experience, but not the match, the bout had already finished for quite a while when it happened, and I've enjoyed the match... the storytelling was very strong, with Liv performing several heel works and dominating Chelsea for a long time, but Chelsea's underdog performance was on point. The whole story of Chelsea being a joke and an inferior wrestler played out really well here, and Liv was having all the actions, completely punishing here, very cocky, but in the end we got the payoff, after Liv tried her finisher, he was surprised by a roll-up and Chelsea managed to satisfyingly steal the match, nice one, that was easy to watch because of the interesting story and dynamic - {**3/4}"
[2.0] "Holy moly this is a shitty match. They have Giulia on Main Event looking at the lights for Nia fucking Jax and this the the kind of women's match WWE is content to shit out. The only difference between this match and a divas era classic is this is 15 minutes longer."
[5.0] "Yeah I don't really know what to make of this one. The story was nice, Chelsea proved herself to be worthy only to get blindsided by Tiffany after the match. Liv lost after a failed ObLivion attempt, this ultimately was kind of a nothing match beyond the narrative of Chelsea needing to prove herself. Liv in particular performed terribly. It was whatever. Rating: 2.5 Stars (**1/2)"
[3.0] "So happy we're back in the divas era! Can't wait for bra and panties matches next. As expected, the match was a nothing burger with no heat and a million code breakers from Liv. The Tiffany cash in was the most obvious thing ever and it was clear by the crowds reaction"
[2.0] "Everything about this was terrible, the match itself, the ending, and the cash-in. Nobody cared when Tiffany cashed in because everyone had already seen it coming. There was absolutely no surprise to it."