[7.0] "This match is not bad in a vacuum, the pace is pretty good and the action quite solid. The booking however, is a much more mixed bag. WXHy did Ruaka need to stay that long a gets eliminated on a rollup ? Why did Rina the 5STAR GP winner gets pinned cleanly ? BEside there is no advancement in any storyline, we already know Kamitani and Hayashishita have issues that need t be adressed."
[3.0] "Boring, exceedingly difficult to follow, and basically a pointless endeavor designed to stick as many women on the card as possible while pushing Hanan. This was way too incoherent to glean anything out of."
[8.0] "This was the big, messy, chaotic, 8v8 nonsense that you expect from something like this. It was extremely fun, with a lot of good sequences and spots throught. I thought the structure of the match was good, and basically the "Correct" way to do one of these, as the lower card talents like Yuria, Waka and Matoi were thinned out early to give HATE a huge numbers advantage for Stars to overcome. I was quite surprised Rina was out so soon, though, considering the massive spotligth that had been on her ages. I thought the likes of Ruaka and Priestley might have been shipped off before her, but I was perhaps more surprised with how little fanfare her elimination received. Speaking of, Priestley was absent for a lot of this match, her stretch was noticably shorter than a lot of other peoples, but I think she did some solid work when she was in it. I think the spotlight for me was the Momo/Saya double elimination, felt like a really well executed spot and a great way to swing thing back in STARS favour. I thought HATE's interference was really well handled here, too. It threw the match into jeopardy and caused some eliminations, which drew some ire from the crowd, while not completely overrunning the match. I think they did a good job of taking the heat on the heels, and turning it into support for the babyfaces. A lot of people got quite a nice showcase here, and as expected, it came down to the two faction leaders, who I thought really stepped up to the occasion, and worked really nicely together to create a strong finish. Bridging germans can be a bit hit or miss for me as a finisher, but I thought Hanan absolutely nailed it here. All in all, not a perfect match, but I thoroughly enjoyed this. I think the lack of stakes was always going to make it fall behind a bit compared to some other similar matches, but for what it was, as a big blow off feud between these two teams and a climax to STARS latest recruits joining the faction, I thought it was very well done."
[8.0] "They don't do em much but the faction elimination tags are fun super party matches, all action all spots and full of drama and suspense with the over-the-top rope rule and no touch tag rule. With the composition of STARS it also helped tell an easy story of the babyfaces falling in a hole early and having to climb back out of it. It's also cool, now that they got a new song and everything, they've established the reborn STARS squad with Hanan at the top and Maika and Utami as her lieutenants."
[6.0] "[3*] A decent match overall, some fun moments here and there, but I really don't see what the reason in this match was. Maika looked strong here and I liked that - Maika fan. Also got some Utami and Kamitani crumbs here where Utami tries facing off with Kamitani but she constantly ignored Utami."
[7.0] "Kind of exciting, but suffers from typical Stardom elimination match issue of people constantly acting stupidly when they could try to win the match."
[3.0] "This seemed like a way to cram a lot of people onto the show. Everything about this was forgettable. None of it was really bad. But the match seemed to have rules for no real reason. Instead of using graphics to display the rules, they should have used graphics to help the viewer keep track of who was eliminated... not that eliminations mattered much either as people continued to participate after the eliminations. Very clustery."
[6.0] "Work is solid and what isn't is masked by chaos. Iida and Konami were the most standout. The order of eliminations was increasingly confusing, and felt made this match feel ultimately pointless. Hanan wins lol."
[7.0] "Originally I gave this a 6, as I was comparing it to the outstanding Queens Quest vs Oedotai wars in the past. Where the story was built over months and they had big stakes. (Loser leaves faction etc) Here though, the build was barely a month and it felt like there were no stakes in this match at all. But the match itself was fine, it got better after the first couple of eliminations and it focused on the Veterans and the old QQ members. But there some eliminations were just quick and there was no urgency to break them up either. But it did pick up towards the end, with some nice moments with RIna looking strong. The Iida and Konami moment, Utami taking out Momo and Saya after Saya tried to swerve her and attacked Hanan. Maika pinning Rina felt odd since she just won the 5 Star. (Especially with how the show ended) Bea cleaning house was interesting and pinning Utami was a choice. They've really made her look strong here. Eventually Hanan and Tora were the last 2 standing, and after some help from Stars, Hanan pins Tora and wins. A decent match, honestly too many people and no real stakes meant this didn't hit the heights the previous Oedo/Stars/QQ matches have. Commentary saying that HATE was defeated and the reign is over was odd too. As this didn't feel like very final or that important either. I'm still not sold on Hanan leading this group either, especially when Maika and Utami are leagues over her in star power and former World champions."
[7.0] "The match is entertaining, but as an elimination match it falls short. Most of the eliminations were abrupt and without any impact on the match. Utami eliminates Kamitani and Momo only to be eliminated herself a minute later, diminishing the significance of Utami's elimination of Kamitani. Hanan is being booked very poorly; everything related to her feels so forced that in the end you don't care about her at all."
[7.0] "Good elimination match. Honestly better than I expected. I dont get why people are deciding to turn on Hanan, her reign is clearly a step above whatever Konami was doing with the belt, and it surely feels more important on Hanan. People just love to complain."
[8.0] "Way better than i expected, the in-ring action was really good throughout with everyone doing something memorable or at least meaningful. We had some rivalries renewals (Maika/Tora, Konami/Iida, Kamitani/Hayashishita, Hanan/Priestly etc) Utamu eliminated both Saya and Momo so i'm guessing we're getting closer to the most anticipated match that STARDOM can book which is obviously Saya vs. Utami. Hanan and STARS in general winning this feels weird, Hanan's booking is just ridiculous at this point, i totally don't get what Okada sees in her + STARS as a whole feels so random and unnecessary. Overall it was great but i don't have that feeling it did much to push any feud forward. ****"
[7.0] "I actually quite enjoyed this one. It was fun, chaotic, funny in some places, and destined to be, at the very least, just a fine match considering all the talent involved. I'm sure they're still building towards an eventual HATE implosion, as well as the Kamitani/Utami singles match, so this more-than-likely was a way of pushing towards that outcome. I will say that some of the earlier eliminations (such as Konami, Rina, Azusa, Momo and Kamitani) perplexed me, especially with Bea Priestley sticking around towards the end, but that's more of a personal nitpick. This was solid. [***]"
[7.0] "I had fun with this match. It was of couse a bit chaotic, but in a good way. Rinas elimination was interesting but it makes sence if you follow her story and path."
[5.0] "Your usual chaotic multi man that was overbooked to fuck and had all the wrong priorities booking wise. The whole feud feels very manufactured just like the Hanan push in general and the one true organic feud that nearly everyone wants to see (Utami/Saya) felt like a sideshow in this match so they can kick the can down the road even more with that and instead keep making Utami look like a geek, at least she eliminated Saya here still and it looks like they might do something with it. There was some cool sequences especially where Maika was involved but other than that it felt heatless and forced with the elimination orders being baffling to say the least"
[8.0] "Over booked, over blown and utterly ridiculous at times, but I absolutely loved it as a roller coaster ride. Obviously the quality varied depending on who was in the ring, but the section which started with Iida and Konami through to Saya and Momo's double elimination and peaking with Maika eliminating Bea was pretty fantastic. Some incredibly well put together spots (the blinded headbutt, the rocket launcher double elimination, Saya's spin kick and the AIR RAID CRASH LARIAT INTO A DESTROYER! ), but also some house of torture stuff towards the end."
[2.0] "This was as bad bell to bell as it was pointless bell to bell. The Hulk Hanan push needs to be studied as i don't know a single real human being asking for Hanan to get the rocket strapped to her in place of all the actual feuds this match could have and should have produced. The only thing i despise more than a bad match is a bad match that wastes your time. Stars vs HATE is a waste of everyone's time."
[8.0] "The good part of having so many people take part in an elimination match is that you're constantly on the edge of your seat. Saya Iida was the unexpected gem of this bout and moved like a comet."
[8.0] "Stardom are really good at this type of match and this was indeed excellent. I will say they have also done this quite a but better in the past still an excellent match though."
[4.0] "The big STARS vs HATE elimination match that didn't have much heat coming in but maybe coming out there would be things to build from. Wrong. It's a mess to have 16 women out there, it's way too much and was nothing more than getting as many people on the card as possible. If this were the top five from each group facing off it would have been a lot better. The match went around 25 minutes and the eliminations were happening so often that there was such little time for anything to settle in. There also wasn't much to care about so this didn't need to drag on forever, either. This match was stuck between telling stories but going too long and telling no story but rushing through everything. Utami eliminating Momo and Saya was the only meaningful thing while the rest was random because they had to get people out. The final two of the leaders Hanan and Natsuko, entirely predictable, had a couple of minutes of bland wrestling before Hanan wins it for STARS. In the end, there wasn't any point. 4/10"