[8.0] "[4. 25*] Fantastic spot fest filled with "Oh my god! " moments. Creative way to expose the floor, and I really liked the progression in this match. They both went all out, and I love seeing Darby go up against Goliaths like Brody King. The random stops in pace (which I fully get because they both took so many brutal bumps) kinda slowed down the match for me. It went a bit too long as well."
[8.0] "This was a very good match, the kind of match that AEW specialises in, and having these kinds of matches on TV is pretty damn great. Darby Allin is great, and Brody King really puts on a great show, playing the big man role as well as still moving way more than you'd expect a man his size to. That being said, without sounding ungrateful and like a real sicko about this, it's very good; I don't think this was great. Both men clearly put on a great match, but the psychology from both men was just good, and the moves they were pulling out were good, but considering the Tommaso Ciampa match with Darby a week or so before, as much as comparison is the thief of joy, this match just doesn't come anywhere close to that one. ****"
[8.0] "Darby and Brody always have fantastic matches together, so it's hardly a surprise to see them having another bang. Some of the bumps in this match were nasty (the Cannonball on the barricade made me shiver). Dope stuff, and no more need to be said. (****)."
[9.0] "Just phonemonal man. I love Brody King's offense, one of the best powerhouse in the game right now, every move looks like he's hitting his opponent with a truck, and contrasting with Darby at his most bleeding heart, flailling babyface bumping makes for borderline perfection in terms of ring chemistry. Add on-top of that a finish as brutal as it is defiant and you've got a mat classic for a second title defense."
[8.0] "Freakishly physically grueling match! Considering the action throughout, it's surprising they maintained the relentless pace they kick-started the match with. The David vs. Goliath template was executed so well with Darby using opportunistic momentum shifts, and his 'throwing caution to the wind' approach fitting their dynamic. Brody was great at manhandling Darby and being a monster of a wall for Darby to chip away at, but also his offense portrayed him as an intimidating presence. I found the closing stretch sublime and appropriate at depicting the slaying of a monster. Sick match! ****"
[8.0] "Another great match between Darby Alin and Brody King for the AEW World Title, a very enjoyable TV match of 15min, they always put a great chemistry together. I not a big match of having a World Title defense every week, it's not really my way to view a World Title, but i'm judging here only the match and it's quality and the match is very good. The usual crazy and violent spots, the usual basically for a Darby Alin vs Brody King match."
[10.0] "These two have amazing chemistry and they did not disappoint. I don't know if it's their best match but it was a fantastic one. Nobody is on Darby's level right now."
[8.0] "This match was pretty insane. Very little in ring work, but the stuff on the outside is so brutal. I've seen a lot of people saying this Darby run is great because he's defending it consistently and putting on good matches which is true, but none of these matches do I feel like he is going to lose at all, and they mostly seem thrown together. I seriously don't know how Darby continues doing the stuff he does and his body puts up with it. ****.25"
[8.0] "This was a really fun main event. The type of match you would expect between these two in a big title match like this. Both guys just putting their body's on the line doing crazy stuff. Darby continues on this short but sweet title run, and really making the most out of it, and making it memorable. Really good match, and looking forward to his one against Kevin Knight. Don't think it will be too long before Brody wins a singles title either, the guy always delivers."
[8.0] "Brody and Darby really have chemistry and it didn't disappoint. For once, this wasn't your typical "Darby formula" where he gets manhandled for 10 minutes and comes back in two. Here, they are equal in offense and both guy could shine."
[10.0] "WOW! I'm probably overrating this match a bit, but this thing just worked for me. A truly physical matchup with constant bomb throwing and constant escalation. It's always great when you can fight with friends, because you can beat the shit out of each other and be cool afterwards. Awesome finish too"
[8.0] "Nice match between the two, Brody King is amazing, and Darby is amazing. Some spots are good, but it's nothing and nothing compared to the Ciampa match. This Darby run is looking like one for the ages."
[8.0] "This could potentially be the best match between the two. They're just meant to wrestle each other. Darby Allin being a fighting champion is giving his reign a lot of momentum and having him go against a classic rival like Brody King so early is brave call but a good one. Brody is prepared to give so much for Darby that in between the lines of the carnage you can see a lot of respect. It's rare that Darby isn't the one taking the most damage but Brody takes The Code Red on the announce table, Cannonballs through the guardrail and takes the Powerbomb onto concrete. Of course Darby still throws himself around like a crash test dummy but that's par for the coarse. Darby didn't look like he merely survived King, he beat him and that's exactly what this match needed to do"
[9.0] "[****3/4] Another great match in Darby Allin's so-called 'reign of terror'. Brody is a massive cannonball (that cannonball has me feeling alive again), but Darby's never-give-up attitude carries him through to another dub. Darby can make up for the sheer speed and size advantage by using Brody's momentum and the environment around him in clever ways. Really creative use of the ring padding, going from providing Darby with something to hold onto in an attempt of pure desperation to a weapon Darby could use to conquer his foe. Long may his reign of terror continue!"
[7.0] "****1/4 Very good match, very good defense by Darby although it doesn't come close to the previous one with Ciampa, very good chemistry, a rivalry that has been going on for years and they usually flow well and in this match I like that Darby isn't completely outmatched and manages to gain the upper hand multiple times, very good sequences, very good spots, very good intensity, the match was tough as expected, Darby received hard punishment but Brody also took several hard falls, very good constant pace, and a very good ending, Darby manages to hit a Coffin Drop on Brody who was on the floor unprotected and gets him back into the ring to hit another Coffin Drop, win and retain the world title, now he will defend against Kevin Knight and I hope after that defense he has one against Samoa Joe and another against a different opponent for Darby (preferably one he has never faced before)"
[8.0] "[3.75*] Another incredible match in this super awesome Darby Allin title reign. He is BY FAR the best TV WOTY until now and after the next defenses against Kevin Knight and hopefully RUSH + Joe, he'll have it wrapped up lol. I thought this was a little bit more tryhard than the Ciampa match in the sense where I felt like not everything was naturally perfect like the other one (which's probably a Top 5 MOTY so it's hard to reach the same level). I think this one was more about the specific crazy planner spots than the natural violence and blood, so I ended up enjoying the other more but this was still absolutely incredible. Darby and Brody are awesome dance partners and I just felt alive watching this match. Both matches are better than all of MJF's title defenses except the Darby one btw. I have the utmost respect for these guys because the majority of the bumps here looked GNARLY."
[9.0] "Darby Allin is about to have a generational run as world champion. Killing it every damn week he's had the belt so far. The best match they've had together love how it started as well as the great finish. (****1/2)"
[10.0] "brody king can do no wrong in my eyes these guys have great chemistry and my eyes were glued to the tv darby is a great champ, excited to see what more he's gunna do"
[8.0] "Really enjoyed this one as Darby knocks out these title defenses in what I can only assume will be a title reign that burns twice as bright but lasts half as long. If there's one thing I could have specifically changed about this, it'd have been the ending. I'd have loved to have Darby win this by countout after the coffin drop to the outside. Having Brody beat the count just to get hit with another Coffin Drop immediately felt like putting a hat on a hat for me."
[8.0] "These guys are one of the most consistent pairings in the company and they delivered here once again. It's nothing new but their dynamic is so good that this couldnt help but be great. I enjoyed them switching roles here a bit as Brody is the one who takes all the crazy bumps here instead of Darby, taking a brutal powerbomb onto the floor as well as missing a cannonball through the barricade. The rest of this was pretty typical Darby/Brody stuff but if you're a fan of their other matches then you'll probably like this one. ****"
[9.0] "These are two of my all-time favorite wrestlers having them both immediately take my attention due to their hardcore ethos and raw and aggressive in-ring styles. They mesh together in this match perfectly and Darby Allin has been wrestling at the peak of his game since winning the belt and wrestling Ciampa and now King. The two handshake before the match as a show of respect. Darby connects with the signature missile dropkick to Brody on the steel chair. A brutal chop by Brody sends Darby spilling out of the ring for a chokeslam on the apron. Darby gets in a sleeper hold but Brody drives them both through the announce panel. Brody locks in a sleeper on top of the announce table but Darby escaped and connects with Code Red on top of the table which does not break. Brody chucks Allin hard to ringside taking out a cameraman. Allin gets dragged removing the concrete at ringside. Brody goes for a cannonball but Allin dodges sending King crashing through the barricade. Powerbomb by Darby off the apron sends Brody onto the concrete and Allin connects with a Coffin Drop on the exposed flooring and one more in-ring to retain the title. Rating: ****.5"
[9.0] "An incredible title match between Darby Allin and Brody King. These two wrestlers have faced off many times and always put on a great show and this time, they have even more reason to do so. Honestly, I'm loving Darby's approach to the world title because he does it so differently, and it's really enjoyable to watch. Also, congratulations to Brody because he's establishing himself in much more prominent roles in AEW, and that's thanks to his great work in the company. A very good match."
[8.0] "These two have awesome chemistry based around frankly insane levels of recklessness. This one pinballed wildly between Darby's devil-may-care explosivity and Brody's propensity for a brutal beatdown and there were zero dull moments on the way to a clever and convincing escape for the champ ****"
[8.0] "Darby Allin continues his reign, where the title will be frequently defended. Knight and MJF were watching the match. A good David versus Goliath match. I liked seeing Allin hold the shield on the outside while King literally ripped it off."
[8.0] "[4 Stars] The match was good, but I don't know--I wasn't as hyped for it as I was for the one against Ciampa last week. Plus, on the same show, I preferred Knight vs. MJF."
[7.0] "These two have a history of great matches, with Brody coming out on top more often than not, making for a highly anticipated main event. This started with a great pace, Darby hitting a Code Red before eating a shoulder block from Brody as he attempts a dive to the outside. King landing the senton to Darby's knees and chopping him to the floor put him in firm control of the earlier exchanges, squashing the comeback by throwing himself and Allin through the board. A second Code Red of the match, this time on the announce table, was a tidy little spot but this nor Darby's following dive to the outside were particularly clean. Launching Darby into the cameraman was a fun and unique moment which began an excellent few minutes, the barricade and exposed flooring coming into play and allowing Darby to take control and the victory in quick succession. Great stuff from both men."
[9.0] "The April 29, 2026, war between Brody King and Darby Allin was a harrowing, beautiful spectacle of storytelling through sheer physical punishment, earning a definitive 8.5/10. This was not merely a wrestling match; it was the ultimate realization of the "David vs. Goliath" dynamic, pushed to brutal, compelling limits. The clash of styles was masterful. Brody King utilized his massive size and terrifying power to act as an immovable force of nature, treating Darby as a ragdoll. His chops echoed like gunshots, and his power slams were delivered with malicious intent. Conversely, Darby Allin, the unstoppable object, offered a performance of agonizing beauty. His offense was purely instinctual, involving high-risk, desperate dives and a refusal to stay down that bordered on the supernatural."
[9.0] "That was close, so fucking close to be a ten. The only reason why I didn't gave them that pleasure is because 90% of the ring action happenned outside, not on the inside. That isn't bad, but kinda loses the entire point of doing a world title match, you know? Isn't what I was expecting, and for that specific circunstance, wasn't that good. But besides that boring ass shit I just said, this match is incredible at each single aspect you could think. Brody and Darby had insane chemistry, and see them fighting for a world title is the perfect showing that AEW is, yes, on the right path. I won't even give you who is reading this spoilers, watch them trying to kill each other and pleasure yourself. Darby's style is predictable, but always surprising, I love that son of a bitch."
[6.0] "As much as I enjoyed this for what it really was, I still can't help but feel that it has the same flaw that a lot of Darby matches have. Even if it was a one or two spots it does affect the match; the drop-kick spot from the top corner was kinda weird.. it did cost wayyy more damage to Darby's than his opponent. I get that it's a character thing but it's just so unnatural that it's just naturally unacceptable no matter how enjoyable the match is, it's always that. I liked the idea of the match; felt like a main character in a souls game against one of the toughest bosses. This type of match will always be unique but the flaw speaks, it's a one spot so not a really big deal.. but it did affect the match. Still, Solid TV match. ***"
[8.0] "Good match, Brody loosing 2 times in last 2 months shouldn't be consider as a challenger anymore. I don't know how many matches weekly can Darby survive. It's not 7 minutes aka squash but he wrestles 15-20 minutes. It's probably his peak now. I didn't like his wrestling abilities to much, usually just taking punishment, counter 3 moves and quick win but I hope he can show some clean technical wrestling"
[7.0] "Solid main event with good work outside the ring. I was expecting a bit more from Brody, but overall it was still cool. I'm still skeptical about Darby taking the title, but his weekly title defenses are enjoyable and make me want to see the next one. In-ring quality: 2/4. Stakes: 2/2. Justification: 0.75/1. Card placement: 1/1. Suspense: 0.25/1. Bonus/penalty: none. Total: 7/10. Match watched on MyAEW."
[8.0] "[**** 1/4] Holy shit! That was nuts! Brody is an absolute destroyer, a human being demolisher, and Darby is a fucking psycho killer. Crazy, really fucking hard chops, brutal bumps, and great fucking wrestling. Awesome."
[8.0] "Right from the outset, what I liked about this match is that it gave you something to track, something to think about as it unfolded. The central question hanging over everything was how is Darby Allin going to survive this time? And even more importantly, is he going to survive? That underlying hook is what made the whole thing work. The David vs. Goliath dynamic here is tried and true, but it only continues to be effective as long as it's presented in a believable way. With Darby Allin, that means he has to sell like this stuff actually matters, like he's taking real punishment and if he wins, it has to come across as something he earned rather than something contrived. From that standpoint, the match absolutely delivered. Where things fell short a bit was Brody King. He went through the motions of a powerhouse, hitting the big offense you'd expect, but there was something missing in terms of presence. He didn't quite project that sense of danger, that feeling that he could actually put Darby away at any moment. It never fully clicked in that regard. He didn't feel ruthless enough. And if that edge wasn't going to be there, then you'd at least want to see some kind of internal conflict, some hesitation about whether to completely unleash on a guy like Darby. That could have added another layer to the storytelling and made the match more compelling. As it was, the physical side was there, but the emotional and psychological depth on Brody's end just didn't quite reach the level it needed to."
[9.0] "Another PPV-level match, another match that shows why Darby is the champion, another match where two guys give everything for the company and for the fans they fight for. Huge credit to both of them just like last week, a great match. Very different from last week's, but just as engaging and with tremendous storytelling. It's truly an honor to watch matches like these every week I'm finally being carried by the passion Darby brings to the ring every time he wrestles. Great match that I'd recommend to anyone."
[7.0] "I was pretty cynical about this. I thought, how can we have another 'Darby nearly dies but squeaks out a win' title match? Instead here, they gave Darby loads of breaks during the match where he caught out Brody. It made sense to build his offense rather than just do a surprise roll-up."
[9.0] "Darby Allin once again has an amazing title defense against Brody King, and I must say Darby Allin I alreayd know this reign is going to be a legendary one, with his two title defenses both of them were amazing, and provided a great story in the ring, because in the past we know these two had history but in this match it was simply a Davis vs. Goliath Story. This match felt like a war between two men. Brody King was trying to break Darby Allin as he hit a powerbomb onto the apron, and he was doing everything to weaken down Darby Allin to win his 1st World Title in AEW. But Darby Allin fought back under and hit two Coffin Drops to secure the win, and now next week, Kevin Knight gets his 2nd AEW World Title opportunity as he looks to become a double champion, as in next week's big-time match, Darby Allin 3rd Title Defense is against "The Jet" Kevin Knight."
[10.0] "The David vs. Goliath story in wrestling is usually told in a very linear way--the bigger wrestler dominates most of the match, then the smaller one makes a comeback, and so on. But it's supposed to feel like a war. This match was presented the way I prefer: a fight between two styles, each trying to establish their identity and outdo the other by doing what they do best. Brody looked like he was trying to kill Darby--powerbomb on the apron, a chop off the top rope to the outside, Darby landing on his neck, a swanton onto Darby's knees--and Darby's selling was incredible. Darby delivered an outstanding performance, easily one of the best of the year so far."
[8.0] "I like the idea of Darby defending the title on weekly basis as he's had very good matches with Ciampa and Brody. Perhaps the outcome isn't going to shock anyone, but a world title match on TV is usually a plus. Brody chopped the hell out of Darby and pretty much in control until he got overzealous with throwing his body into Darby and paid the price. A good match, but not the best they've had"
[9.0] "This is shaping up to be quite the epic title run by Darby, even if it only lasts a short amount of time. This was another great match between these 2 who have great chemistry, Brody has become a real star and its great to see. Cant wait for next week with Darby vs Kevin Knight."
[9.0] "I love that the dynamic has become so different between these two. Going all the way back to the first time Darby and Brody went at it in that Rampage Rumble, I've felt like they had great chemistry and tonight was no different. Brody is fantastic at throwing people around. Huge fan of the finish too, I like that it happened in such a flash."
[8.0] "Great main event, Darby and Brody always have had good chemistry and this was no exception. Brody tossed and hit Darby like he was nothing, while Darby's openings for offense came in a way that made sense and led to a believable win for him against Brody"
[9.0] "Darby Allin defies death for the millionth time, it'll never get old. Brody is a soulmate of his in the ring, and he is so good at tossing that little guy around. Somehow finds a way to escalate perfectly when it's insane from the get go. This Darby run is shaping up to be an all timer."
[9.0] "This match was freaking insane. Both these two guys destroyed each other. Brody just kept chopping the ever-loving shit outta Darby. King has a very good showing here and showed he can hang with the top stars in AEW. Darby came out of the gate against Darby, but got caught with a nasty chop from Brody. Both then just went to the second ropes and Darby hit a freaking code red and I thought it was over right then and there but Brody kicked out. Darby went for a suicide dive but Brody immediately stopped it without even doing anything, Darby just bounced off him. Darby was hanging on the ropes, but Brody just chopped the shit outta him, sending Darby crashing to the floor, then immediately grabbed him and slammed him onto the apron. Both got on the table and Brody chopped the shit outta Darby's back and got him in a chokehold, but Darby got out of it and hit a code red onto the table. Darby went for a coffin chop but once again, Brody stopped him and hit brutal chops, just non-stop brutality. Brody hit a cannonball into the corner while Darby was still hanging on the ropes by his legs. Brody hit two brutal clotheslines and somehow Darby still kicked out. Darby hit his own chops, but Brody wasn't fazed and launched Darby to the outside and onto a cameraman. Brody went for another cannonball but Darby got out of the way and sent Brody crashing through the barricade. Brody tried to suplex Darby from the ring onto fucking concrete floor, Darby got out of it thankfully but Brody got power-bombed on the exposed floor and Darby hit a coffin drop onto the floor. Brody got back in the ring and got hit a coffin drop."