DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?

Finlay vs. John Bradshaw Layfield

Match

6.71
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 237
Number of comments: 41
10.0 0x
9.0 3x
8.0 43x
7.0 102x
6.0 60x
5.0 29x
4.0 0x
3.0 0x
2.0 0x
1.0 0x
0.0 0x
Average rating: 6.71  [237]
Average rating in 2026: 6.67  [48]
Average rating in 2025: 6.63  [68]
Average rating in 2024: 7.08  [39]
Average rating in 2023: 6.76  [42]
Average rating in 2022: 6.48  [23]
Average rating in 2021: 6.50  [14]
Average rating in 2020: 6.33  [3]
Your Options:
Other:
Leo the goat wrote on 13.11.2026:
[6.0] "A fun, stiff, hard-hitting 6/10 WrestleMania opener that delivered exactly what you want from two rugged veterans beating the hell out of each other for ten minutes. Stepping out into the Orlando sunlight to kick off WrestleMania XXIV, Finlay and JBL skipped the filler and went straight to snug forearms, trash can lids, kendo sticks, and nasty ringside bumps. Finlay brought tremendous babyface fire while fighting to avenge JBL's brutal attacks on Hornswoggle, and JBL played the arrogant, punishing bully to perfection--highlighted by that wicked spot where JBL hurled a steel trash can at a diving Finlay mid-air. Hornswoggle's brief involvement with the shillelagh was kept short and sweet before JBL blasted Finlay's knee with a kendo stick and nailed a decisive Clothesline from Hell for the clean pinfall. Nothing deep or epic, just a brisk, physical curtain-jerker that warmed up the Citrus Bowl crowd nicely."
DecentWrestling wrote on 04.11.2026:
[7.0] "Hard hitting and fun brawl. Great choice for an opening match. JBL smashing Hornswoggle with the trash can was hilarious and Finlay's suicide dive being stopped looked painful. Solid finish to give JBL momentum going into his next feud. Good stuff all around."
EvieSonicFan124 wrote on 15.07.2026:
[8.0] "[3.75*] If You Loved The ECW Short Matches With The Hardcore Stuff, Then This Match Is A Go-Go A Go Go. Finlay Is My Favorite Hardcore Wrestlers Ever, That Shileigh {don't know how to pronounce the weapon} is a beautiful weapon and i enjoyed it. JBL, This Man Was Chanelling His ECW Days With This, I'm Impressed That I Remembered Him Being In ECW. {If That Says Or Mentioned In SVR 2008 Or Others}"
jumtackthack wrote on 05.04.2026:
[9.0] "Amazing brawl! Expectedly underrated. A very wwe style brawl, no blood and not the most hard hitting or brutal but it was so much fun and they definitely had a couple spots that made me cringe. Loved a lot of the hornswoggle stuff here. Really good opener"
WG20 wrote on 01.04.2026:
[5.0] "It was a fine match to open the show. Some okay spots with the weapons nothing memorable. In the end JBL won"
SkyIcons wrote on 14.03.2026:
[6.0] "It's a WWE brawl, not too extreme, though I popped for the trash cans to the head (at least the first few times). Outside of the stipulation it was a well worked match as you'd expect from these 2 vets."
Smi-48 wrote on 20.02.2026:
[5.0] "A typical WWE Brawl of that era, which focuses more on pretense than substance. The hits with the accessories look partly impressive, partly implausible, and the accompanying storyline is pure absurdity. Although the match isn't fundamentally bad, it feels like a shame that Finlay wasn't let off the leash against the bully Bradshaw."
EyeBronze8388 wrote on 01.02.2026:
[5.0] "Interesting choice for an opener because they were two veterans that were known as hard hitters. Sometimes you want an exciting match in this spot, but they opted for more of a physical brawl."
Hitman26 wrote on 29.01.2026:
[6.0] "A fun brawl match to open WrestleMania, two veterans collide and have a fun match with many objects being used. Finlay got hornswaggle with him too but despite that JBL got the win."
WhatIsLooveee wrote on 18.01.2026:
[7.0] "Putting this match first in the card, I think, was a good decision. They didn't have a chance to steal the show, but given both of their abilities as good brawlers, they couldn't make a bad match with such rules. A very entertaining tough fight between two veterans, 7 points."
CAMERONQPR93 wrote on 07.10.2025:
[7.0] "This is a chaotic weapon-filled sprint. Two experienced brawlers throwing everything at each other (literally) turned out to be a great choice to open up a WrestleMania."
InfiniteWick wrote on 05.09.2025:
[7.0] "Very crazy, even in 2008, WWE had a somewhat out of shape, old Irish guy with a son who looks maybe 10 years younger open up a WrestleMania. What's crazier is that Finlay, after everything in his career, can still perform at a high level. Its a scrappy brawl, intense, and has a good level of intensity. I think pacing wise, its very good. No dead spots. However, in terms of evolving the match and getting more or less intense or crazy over time, it just never really does. It kind of stays consistently kind of violent. But, still good. It opens hot, and it continues to be hot for most of the match. Finlay takes an incredible headshot with the trashcan lid off a suicide dive and this popped me incredibly. Its an insane thing to time and take, but they deliver. Even the Hornswoggle bits are pretty tolerable. It added to the story. It just doesn't evolve much from what it began as. It maybe goes too long, even though I'm very glad that these two old folks got to open WrestleMania, and were given time. Its clear they were trying to fit a lot in in a short time too, so if it was shorter, they'd likely be rushing even more. It never got boring, and it was a very nice brawl. Good Mania opener. [***.25]"
sdenapoli wrote on 26.08.2025:
[6.0] "A fun and violent brawl to open Wrestlemania. While the storyline and winner may have been interesting, the match itself had 2 veterans who know how to fight. ***1/4"
Thenxt observer wrote on 24.05.2025:
[6.0] "*** (06/10) No video package for 24's first match, so, we know Vince didn't care too much about JBL/Finlay, despite having a part in the build. Barely under nine minutes given, but the two made the best of their brief time by knocking the slob off each other's faces in a quick but modestly fun opener."
WrestleRaveNick wrote on 19.05.2025:
"Two veteran brawlers going at and silly story aside; these guys had a fun physical matchup that set the tone of the night! Give this one a watch!"
KKeanel wrote on 25.04.2025:
[7.0] "Badass opener. Entertaining brawl with an obvious winner, however it doesn't lowers a general reception."
bigredtalk89 wrote on 16.04.2025:
[7.0] "Fun brawl and an underrated WM opener, IMO the wrong guy went over but you can't win em all, JBL gets the win despite the story being about Finlay's son being beaten up by JBL, I don't think the good guy always has to win but this one could have easily gone to Finlay and it would have felt a little better"
CommisarRobe wrote on 11.04.2025:
[8.0] "What a great opener! A no frills straight fight between two guys who hate each other. This is a short match but fits plenty of great spots as well as some really gnarly bumps. A great way to get the blood pumping for Mania."
Ajay00329 wrote on 02.04.2025:
[7.0] "Honeslty a great brawl involving an awesome hardcore spots. Everyone took a nice beating to make this match great. A fun opener overall"
Wrestlingfan0808 wrote on 31.03.2025:
[8.0] "This was a hoot. One of the most underrated wrestlemania matches ever. Jbl ruled and so did finlay. This ruled. ****"
Erdrick wrote on 31.03.2025:
[5.0] "Finlay, a man who carries a shillelagh with him everywhere, immediately discards his weapon to go digging around under the ring in search of trash cans and kendo sticks. What ensues is a bog standard and fairly slow WWE-style hardcore match with the hated heel abusing a midget until he wins, ending the first match of the evening on a down note for the crowd."
PhillyHarden wrote on 31.03.2025:
[7.0] "Kinda a crazy banger? Wish it was like 3-4 minutes longer. Lots of nasty shots and stiff hits. Surprised me a lot"
MaskDeMasque wrote on 24.03.2025:
[7.0] "I remember this match fondly. It was my first time watching WrestleMania and didn't expect this as the opener. Real fun brawl."
KA10 Meltzer wrote on 17.02.2025:
[7.0] "This was a really good opener for Mania, no the storyline wasn't great but this was still a hard-hitting fun match. JBL was playing his role perfectly and Hornswoggle also had a great spot with JBL throwing the trash can lid at him."
fablezzzz wrote on 14.02.2025:
[8.0] "This match is simply awesome. Hard-hitting, personal fun. JBL and Finlay are two tough shooters that knew how to get the match over and play to their strengths. Probably my 2nd favorite WM opener of all time."
eltetechori wrote on 11.01.2025:
[7.0] "A decent wrestling match that followed a bit of an absurd storyline, but hey, a match that could be perfectly seen on a weekly show, but they decided to put it on WrestleMania, something interesting that without the stipulation would be no big deal."
brooksavage2004 wrote on 12.09.2024:
[8.0] "The story around this match was really silly, but the match itself is pretty good and the action was entertaining too."
JacquesRougeauCanHaveMyWife wrote on 27.07.2024:
[6.0] "A fine way to open the show. The build was stupid, they got Finlay and Hornswoggle over so they got a decent reaction from the crowd here. Both guys were working stiff which added a lot to the match as there was no place for blood here and it didn't go for too long."
Mizzle Assault Ant wrote on 27.05.2024:
[9.0] "Fantastically fun match and one of my favorite Wrestlemania openers ever. These two threw everything at each other, stiff as hell with some fun moments thrown in to boot. Hard to believe not everyone loves this one as much as I do, really. Awesome stuff."
Heartbreakkid2003 wrote on 01.04.2024:
[7.0] "Fun opener. A pretty short fun hardcore match. Bradshaw and Finley got good chemistry and there are some entertaining moments in here. I enjoyed this 3.5/5"
TrailsOfPersona wrote on 19.01.2024:
[5.0] "I was pretty close to giving this match 6 points, but the wrong man won, so I lowered to 5 points. See, this is a match that I think maybe you don't want to book, because it hurts either guy to lose unless booked very carefully. Finlay and Hornswaggle were getting REALLY over at this point. They got a GREAT pop, and you could tell every time Finlay started to come back that they were dying for him to beat JBL. I think a big win here could have kept his momentum strong, and maybe he could have built up to a U.S./IC title run. At the same time, though, JBL is still on the fresher side of his return to in ring action. So if you want him to feeling like a world title contender, it might not have been wise to beat him at such a big stage either. At the end of the day, though, I think it hurt Finlay more to lose this one than JBL. They could have done a finish where JBL was looking to win, but Hornswaggle comes in for the save which let FInlay catch JBL, and kept JBL sort of strong. The match itself was Finlay showing what an underrated worker he was along with fantastic heel work from JBL. The dive to the outside into the trash can lid was spectacular. This one really reminded me of some of the older Attitude-era Hardcore matches with all of the weapons and debris flying around. A solid match, and a good opening, but I stand by my statement that the wrong man won, and that hurt this match overall."
BigDave123 wrote on 24.07.2023:
[9.0] "Guilty pleasure as I totally loved this match. JBL was being an absolute douche throughout and the action was hard hitting and fun."
Prince Osborne wrote on 29.03.2023:
[7.0] "The story sounds so lame to be in WrestleMania, but the action was chaotic, fast-paced and most importantly entertaining! Both men worked at a breakneck pace surprisingly with most of the moves being almost perfect. Finlay is one of the underappreciated wrestlers of all-time as well as JBL who excelled as a character much better than inside the ring. 3.5 out of 5 stars!"
zachattack2023 wrote on 12.03.2023:
[7.0] "This was a very fun brawl and a great start to wrestlemania this was a hard hitting match with some cool weapon spots and just a enjoyable match.***1/2"
flightaker321 wrote on 20.03.2022:
[6.0] "Nice brawl to open the show, we got a ton of garbage can use, JBL throwing a garbage can into Hornswoggle was hilarious. JBL finishes off Finlay with a clothesline from hell.***1/4"
cactus wrote on 19.05.2021:
[7.0] "Another year, another Wrestlemania featuring Hornswoggle getting abused. This time JBL lobs a trash can violent at poor 'ol Swoggle. This felt like a more cohesive early 2000's hardcore match with the added ruggedness of JBL and Finlay throwing potatoes at each other. After all the usual spots you can expect in WWE hardcore match (cookie sheets, trash cans, and the obligatory table spot), JBL puts Finlay away with a Clothesline From Hell. The storyline going into this was awful, but the match was strong enough to make this worthwhile."
GulakBusick wrote on 31.03.2021:
[8.0] "I love this match. They absolutely wallop each other. Great, unique opener to one of the best Manias of all. ****"
Mudshow Idol wrote on 31.08.2020:
[5.0] "Pretty average brawl with a few good bumps. I liked the topee into the garbage can lid and the clothesline from hell was pretty stiff this time."
HC7 wrote on 28.07.2020:
[7.0] "This was good but somewhat underwhelming considering the two participants in this match. Not as much of a all out piss beating brawl that you'd expect between Finlay and Bradshaw in a street fight. Still a fun brawl to open Mania"
Bigdawgwrestlerbaby wrote on 15.07.2020:
[7.0] "This was a really fun opener, i enjoyed it. The crowd likes weapons being used, so whenever they hit eachother with weapons the response was generally a favorable one. They are two veteran wrestlers that worked hard and put on a good, physical brawl. Good gimmick match ***1/4"