[6.0] "I really like this format, as it allows new wrestlers to come in and be showcased right away with a match for such an important title as the United States Championship. El Hijo de Dr. Wagner Jr. was the perfect opponent for that. I hope he was able to gain the visibility he deserves thanks to a performance that was highly satisfying against a Carmelo Hayes who is always at the top of his game."
[6.0] "A decent match, but not very exciting and quite predictable. It feels like it's mainly there to bring in a AAA wrestler to create a fresh card and move on. In-ring quality: 1.25/4. Stakes: 1.5/2. Justification: 0.75/1. Card placement: 1/1. Suspense: 0.25/1. Bonus/penalty: none. Total: 5.75/10. Match watched on Netflix (FR)."
[5.0] "(Grade:C-/**3/4) Thoguth it was a fine US Title defense. Having El Hijo Dr.Wagner Jr. step up to accept the championship opportunity with a lukewarm response for the fan but as the action continued they eventual warmed up to him. Hayes continues to put on solid-work with the championship and hopefully it'll elevate him to the main event scene."
[5.0] "Pretty sterile stuff. They gave the challenger, largely unfamiliar to the audience, plenty of shine and a couple of low jeopardy moments before the face champion just hit his finish and secured the win. Your bog standard TV fayre."
[6.0] "Good match, but without a soul. I'm tired of this open challenges and not inrested on it anymore. WWE trying to do something intresting, adding AAA wrestlers, but that not worked. I hope that on WrestleMania we will get something bigger for the US championship."
[7.0] "I thought this was pretty fun. I will say, I hope Carmelo ends the open challenges soon because I'd like to see him in a feud for WrestleMania with Ilja or Trick. I definitely wasn't expecting Dr Wagner to answer but this was still pretty fun. Carmelo is yet to have a bad match since winning the US title."
[8.0] "(4.00) An Underrated match -i think because of how the show went- A mix High-Flying/Technical, i think Melo should've taking the match slower than he did if dose it like the Gunther's match it will end up being much better, i really liked the False Finish i knew Wagner won't win but they made me believe he might !"
[7.0] "This was pretty good, but nothing very special. Wagner Jr. just doesn't really have the same kind of juice as a workrate wrestler like Melo and it showed here, with a few disjointed moments that were held together largley by Melo. Still cool to see an AAA man on smackdown."
[6.0] "Solid match for the US title. Wagner being the open challenger is definitely a surprise since the AAA wrestlers rarely appear in WWE. This was a nice showcase for Wagner in a competitive match though him winning was never going to happen. Carmelo retains. 6/10"
[6.0] "This was the match of the night for me, as we had a very uneventful episode. But Carmelo Hayes, who has been a bright spot on this show, had an unexpected challenger from AAA: the AAA Latin American Champion, El Hijo de Dr. Wagner Jr., who answered the challenge as he aimed to be a double champion. This match could've been a lot better, as there were noticeable miscues and moments where they botched a few situations. But the match's closing moments were very solid, as Carmelo Hayes retained his WWE United States Title in a strong battle, also nice touch to see the sign of respect from both men after the match. We had people from AAA and TNA answering Carmelo Hayes. This is what the open challenge should be. I would like someone from NOAH to answer Carmelo Hayes, if possible."
[6.0] "Good match here, good showcase for the AAA stars with having their Latin American Champion coming over for a shot, nothing much really happened, just a good match."
[7.0] "As a match in itself, it was enjoyable, and quite different from the other title defenses. A more lucha libre style with a mix of power moves introduced by El Hijo del Wagner Jr. Initially the pace was strange but it recovered quickly. A very solid match with a good demonstration by Wagner Jr. to the American audience. Expected reaction from the audience present, demonstrating once again that they don't care about wrestling outside of WWE."
[7.0] "A good match. Really confused why this random Mexican is there however... they have such a large roster and yet they have to bring AAA wrestlers to wrestle a TV match? This didn't help Carmelo Hayes at all."
[6.0] "It's heading back toward an open challenge for the US title, so that's okay. The Mexican is an unexpected and welcome challenger, and although the match isn't groundbreaking, it's pretty okay."
[6.0] "This was a really solid match. Decent pacing, well worked. Not a bad introduction to Wagner Jnr as well. Maybe not meeting the high standards of the banger belt but I still enjoyed it."
[7.0] "The highlight of this episode of WWE Smackdown was once again the United States Championship match. This time, the open challenge was presented by the excellent El Hijo de Dr. Wagner Jr., one of the top stars on the current AAA roster. It was a good match, and I'd gladly see them meet again on some PLE or weekly episode."
[6.0] "Well it was good but far from great. The 7 would very generous because of personal enjoyment but it just does not reach that level for me. Melo is really amazing by himself, so is El Hijo del Dr. Wagner Jr.. Always good to see them on tv but the match was pretty tame."
[7.0] "[***1/2] This was, as expected a solid match. Wagner is a unit and Carmelo can work well with just about anyone. What we get is a good clash of styles, and this match really only left me wishing we got 15 minutes instead of 10. Wagner works a very good powerhouse style, while Carmelo continues his hot momentum. Please give us another Ilja vs Carmelo match, they always hit."
[7.0] "The best match of the night and most likely the only good match of this show. I was surprised by El Hijo Del Wagner Jr' showing up but he gave us a good match here. I enjoyed a lot of this match with these two gliding with each other. I think EHD Wagner Jr. impressed the fans here. Overall, another good US Open Challenge. [***.5]"