[8.0] "Easily the best match of the night right here. Ídolo being presented as more of a top guy than his first run with the company is super cool to see. It was definitely a bit surprising to see him take the win here when watching this live, but a really nice surprise at that."
[6.0] "The commentary is so bad in this company. Some actual character work happens as they throw to break with Andrade and a woman in the crowd and it is silence. No one said anything. Even the ref said something about it. They are either muted and laughing or laying out for some quick commercial sound. They are an embarrassment multiple times a week out there. The tag match earlier had a loud crowd and guys slapping the shit out of each other and Excalibur just calmly reads dates and times of shows you don't care about."
[8.0] "This was a good match. Swerve and Andrade had their working boots on for this one cause this was both best match in a while. Swerve was having some meh matches and when since returning, Andrade has had long squash matches. This was just fun to watch and that house-call from mid-air was a great counter. Shocked Andrade won. {wrote on 30.01.2026}"
[9.0] "As someone fairly new to wrestling, I could see Andrade had something else in the tank, and this AEW run seems to be what I saw. What a match, a fantastic showcase of both guys, and while Swerve is hitting all his moves, Andrade works with them and does his own thing. For the most part, this felt like a smooth match where both guys were actually fighting, and despite there being some long faffing with the outside count, this still felt really fun. As the match went on, things got better, and then that final sequence of near falls drew me in, and I was hooked. The previous two Andrade pins on Strickland got me. I'm OK with a slightly cheating finish, especially with Don Callis on commentary. Great match, very watchable with a fantastic final sequence. ****1/2"
[5.0] "I was willing to halfway ignore the prolonged period of time spent on the outside in favor of "referee's discretion due to the necessity of having a winner" and I was also willing to ignore the cooperative acrobatics. However I can not ignore the no-selling in the final sequence of the match. A match that I enjoyed mostly because of Andrade's offence. Andrade also happens to be the one whose no-selling annoyed me the most."
[6.0] "Better than I expected from these two. I'm a fan of both but their worst instincts are front and center whenever they wrestler someone who will not seek to limit the cool 50/50 video game sequences. Despite that, it came of well in the context of the match. Surprisingly grittier and physical than these two are known for as well."
[7.0] "[3.5*] A great main event that was filled with what'd you expect, some cool spots, some spots that looked way too choreographed, and a screwy finish, all in under 15. Still, Andrade and Swerve are both phenomenal, and i really enjoyed this one."
[6.0] "**** A good match, good chemistry, they worked well together although I think they can have a better match in the future, good sequences, good steady pace but without a noticeable escalation towards the end, good intensity and a good finish, Andrade wins after a low blow and connecting with his DM"
[6.0] "[3.0*] I deeply love this shit lmao. no seriously, and despite Andrade's Cringey gimmick with the fans, he's really one of the best in the American wrestling scene right now, and this was a solid main-event for this disappointing episode of AEW dynamite. This shit Rocks and sometime it just feels like it's there' so here's that."
[6.0] "Big win for Andrade and a nice performance altogether, Swerve still not doing what I wish he would, except for the Death Valley Driver in the apron, that was sick. Still, a pretty cool match with awesome spots and strikes, not particularly my favorite of the night but worth the watch."
[8.0] "As for a weekly show awesome match. Barricade hit was fire and overall chemistry of the guys involved is great! Brutal as non gimmick match can be with blend of technical and highflying style. Top turnbuckle spot <3"
[8.0] "What a triumphant return for Andrade, what he's doing in the US and Japan is really good, I'm having trouble seeing where they want to steer Swerve in all this though."
[8.0] "Match of the night right here, by far. I still think that Swerve Strickland still didn't knew which is the best way to connect his strikes and quick pacing with his strengh, but he will figure out sooner, he is a pretty good wrestler for that. Andrade is getting the chance of his life, never in the american TV he got so over with the crowd and audience, finally he made his talent able to work as a draw for AEW. Beat Swerve, even not being clean, is a hell of a victory."
[8.0] "Two great in-ring guys with a lot of charisma, they fully delivered as a main event match. The sequence on the ropes that ended with the hurricanrana was awesome and I'd love to see these two can come up with in a rematch. I would have loved to see Omega vs Swerve, but getting Andrade a rub right away is smart and leaves more options for Swerve going forward anyway. Plus Kenny still has unfinished business after Andrade attacked him when he first returned. The main event scene right now is on fire and there's so many great options."
[7.0] "This was undoubtedly going to be a banger but I'd be lying if I said this fully delivered. I don't know if it's because the rivalry here doesn't feel well established or Andrade El Idolo is more focused on reintroducing himself but the chemistry felt like it really need a little bit to fully click. Some of the early back and forth while impressive felt a bit off in the tightness and urgency. Luckily they found their footing pretty quick and Andrade looked just as good as he did before he left the company. Swerve Strickland also felt like he clicked with the story the more the match went on, feeling a lot more desperate than in his match last week with Kevin Knight. The dirty finish was a nice ouch as well as it keeps this match up open for redemption"
[8.0] "8.0 - The crowd was already hot before anyone even came out with loud "AEW, AEW, AEW" chants, and when Swerve's music hit the fans started swaying before popping even harder once he appeared and was formally introduced by Justin Roberts, while Andrade also had clear support on his entrance with fans waving a Mexican flag and holding up some very random big cat head signs. As soon as the bell rang the building exploded into nonstop "Whose house? Swerve's house! " chants that genuinely never stopped, along with repeated "AEW, " "Holy Shit, " and "This Is Awesome" chants, plus a bizarre but memorable sight of a man dressed as Jesus watching the match and another fan holding an RIP Lou Spicoli sign. My favorite moment came when Swerve went for a piledriver on the guardrail only for Andrade to counter with a back body drop that sent Swerve crashing onto the rail while Andrade crotched himself in the process, which was excellent, and the match ultimately ended when Andrade hit a low blow on Swerve followed by the D.M. for the win. The opening stretch was loaded with slick counters, including both men flipping out of hurricanranas, and Andrade mixed in his newer character work with his classic offense, hitting a springboard tornillo to the floor, his signature moonsault fake-out into a standing moonsault, and his missed big boot into a brutal back elbow, while both wrestlers came across as true main-event level performers. Standout sequences included Andrade baiting Swerve into a double stomp only for Swerve to stop short and pull him up into a springboard hurricanrana, Swerve kicking out of an avalanche poisonrana, a running double knee and a short-arm scissor DDT, and Swerve countering Andrade's double knees in mid-air with a House Call for a huge near fall. The only real knock for me was the finish, as I would have preferred Andrade simply beat Swerve clean, even though it clearly sets up a future payback moment and likely a larger multi-man number one contender situation down the line."
[8.0] "The quick pose pin attempt making werve so angry was great. Sick starting sequence. SO many good moves! Andrade gimmick is perfect. Match is building very slowly and it feels great. Match kicks into higer gear and is very nice and captivating."
[7.0] "High-energy, thoroughly entertaining match that opened sharply and never let up, immediately showcasing both men's agility and chemistry. The main body of the bout delivered on nearly every level, with standout sequences, crisp execution, and strong pacing that kept the audience invested throughout, even if some psychology leaned on spectacle over subtlety. The finish was clean and decisive, and both men committed fully to their characters, selling the tension and elevating the stakes in a way that made the match feel significant."
[7.0] "A good main event and the second best match of the night. Some good bombs in this and a very good Andrade performance here as well as one of Swerve's better singles performances in a while. I do think he needs to re work some of his offence though because some of the parts early in the match where he was trying to move like a cruiserweight didnt look the best. Other than that though, this was a pretty entertaining match and im super excited for Andrade/Kenny next week. ***1/2"
[9.0] "Big singles matches really bring the best out of Andrade and, after an underwhelming return to the ring in both NJPW and AEW so far, he and Swerve put on a quality main event. Two incredibly diverse competitors, agile as they are powerful, performing at their best in pursuit of the championship with the result an incredibly difficult one to predict. The closing minutes were nuts: the spinning back elbow and the House Call were absolutely sensational strikes, the avalanche poison-rana, the DDT near-fall, the finish. Magnificent. This will be a TV MOTY contender come December. Although it doesn't contribute to my match rating, it's worth also mentioning that the show close was absolute cinema."
[10.0] "Well Andrade is back in AEW, this time for real and no fooling with draconian contract clauses, so thank god for that. Andrade has his faults, his difficulty with remaining in one place and the drama he causes will surely hold him back from the very top level. However he's a damn talented wrestler and I'm just glad he's able to wrestle in a high profile place, at least until he throws it all in the trash can again. In the meantime we get to see him have great first time match against Shane Strickland, a man who showed talent for many years but whose star has exploded into brilliance in the last several years. I thought this was a damn great TV match, one of the best AEW has put out this month. There were small hiccups perhaps, I didn't love the dodge-fu Ospreay style exchange early on but hey, it popped the crowd so what do I know? The more they got down to it, the more I liked this, I felt a lot of quick chemistry springing up here. Great pacing, fast but not so fast that the flow of the action was disregarded, and they built up to a great finishing stretch. Even with some well crafted nearfalls I never expected Andrade to walk away with the victory but I'm not mad about it all, something unpredictable on AEW is a good thing in this case. Crowd was digging it and they took some big swings, that nasty back bump on the rail for one, and it all paid off really well. My #9 match of this very young year."
[8.0] "This is the most locked in Andrade has looked in years. We all know when Andrade is motivated he is a demon in the ring. But after his very underwhelming second WWE run which had a mix of poor booking and a firing he defiantly has something to prove. He hasn't looked this motivated since the C2 tournament. Its incredible that he spent nearly 2 years in WWE struggling to get reactions and in less than a month in AEW he is over and fans love him. Him and Swerve had impeccable chemistry here and they could certainly run this again on PPV with more time. Swerve is back to his best after injury and Andrade legitimately looks like a main eventer and world champion contender."
[9.0] "Swerve is back into the groove of things, another great match and performance from him. Andrade was also great here. The athletics, strikes, and moves were all done well. Incredible main event."
[8.0] "[4 Stars] What Andrade is offering us this January is just excellent. He is the best wrestler to follow this year, along with AJ Styles for now."
[9.0] "What a way to solidify Andrade as a top contender early on. A fantastic match, a strong showing for both. You can truly say Andrade had his number today but that on another day it would be different. Honestly this is how he should have been booked before and I think they are correcting for that past mistake beautifully."
[7.0] "[3.5*] Great TV Main Event, this was the MOTN in my opinion. Although I think Swerve really needs to rethink about some of his "move-set" because now he's a proper Heavyweight and he really should be adapting some of his high-flying stuff, I thought the match-up with Andrade worked really well here, even if he looked funny with some bits at the beginning. Talking about Andrade, what a star this man is, wow. Absolutely fantastic showing. He has just immense charisma and I'm really happy TK did the right decision by making him win. He is a superstar and his current gimmick rocks. He kinda stole it from Soberano Jr but whatever, he does it perfectly for the north-american TV. The nearfalls at the ending stretch were awesome, btw."
[8.0] "This was a hell of a TV main event. Both guys were clearly motivated here, with Andrade especially making a statement in his big AEW return. Nice to see a bit of a surprise ending, too. ****"
[6.0] "A solid match in the ring, with a steadily increasing pace and good offense from both sides. And another very nice House Call. While of high quality, I'm still surprised that this match closed the show, given all the other title matches. In-ring quality: 2.25/4. Stakes: 0.5/2. Justification: 0.75/1. Placement on the card: 0.5/1. Suspense: 1/1. Bonus/penalty: none. Total: 6/10. Match watched on Triller TV."
[6.0] "I don't really follow wrestling nowadays, just watch matches, so I have no idea why Andrade can't hold down a job. I'm also out of the loop with AEW, but it does seem really stale right now with a ton of chatty complication around who might be facing whom and why. This was a videogame set to supercute mode, where a low blow across the guard rail does nowt, but in the ring it's more effective than an avalanche poison rana followed by a finisher ***"
[7.0] "Andrade is looking a lot better ever since his return, definitely a big improvement from his first run in the company. I could do without the cringe ringside fan interaction gimmick but other than that he has a lot more momentum this time around and I think it'd be a lot better if he beats Kenny after beating Swerve. Just ride the wave for once."
[8.0] "Absolutely fantastic match. We don't give Swerve anywhere NEAR enough credit, he is one of the best in the game. That being said, Andrade looks like a superstar right now. He's in great shape, is presenting himself with confidence. His ring work in this match was outstanding, he looks completely locked in. I hope he stays that way because this was excellent."
[7.0] "Pretty much in line with what I expected. Loses the details Swerve gave last week & loses the absolute coolness Andrade had last week too. It wasn't super strong narratively, but it was very entertaining. As much as I do like both guys I think I have to come to grips with the fact that they're going to do these spots where things seem obvious or too cliche to work. A lot of what they do here is just pop the crowd. I mainly enjoyed this one because of that, but I also didn't enjoy it because of the effects of that. I am glad Andrade won and am excited for him & Omega. [***.5]"
[8.0] "A little stat before the match: both men were undefeated this year. We had two good wrestlers, each with a good manager capable of working the crowd. A fun moment was the barricade spot where Andrade took a picture with a fan. The ending shows that Andrade is a strategist ready to do anything to win. I also really liked the post-match because it shows that MJF, the champion, has serious competition around him. We can clearly have many good matches and storylines surrounding the title."
[6.0] "(***) It's fine. Not a bad match, but just not my cuppa tea. It went a lil too long (7 minute overrun. God in Heaven! ) and relied heavily on near-fall after near-fall in the final stretch. It was surprisingly cold for a TV main event too. They're both gunning for the belt and this match COULD get them SOMEWHAT closer to a title shot. They don't exactly hate each other either. Swerve's big angle earlier on the program didn't even have anything to do with Andrade! He was interrupting Kenny and Hangman's confrontation. Andrade is doing good work but of all the guys vying for the World Title, Andrade is the guy I buy the least as a contender. This is his first match on Dynamite since resigning for God's sake! They went hard but in the words of the wise Kazuchika Okada, I don't "feel" anything."
[8.0] "I was pretty excited when I heard this would be main-eventing, and it really delivered with a sometimes somewhat ridiculous but consistently fun outing. Andrade is one of my top names to watch for 2026 after reflecting on some of his best matches across his CMLL, WWE and AEW tenures, and he delivered a really vicious and exciting performance here. Swerve Strickland sold really well as well as dishing out some really brutal offence in a brilliant final 5 minutes. Andrade won with a low blow into The Message/DM, was the cheating really necessary? Probably not, but it did solidify Andrade as a clever and ruthless heel. This was a great match overall, a bit shy of some of the best of 2026 so far, but still a really enjoyable watch which is worth seeking out."
[8.0] "Somebody get this man a title! Andrade is the truth and I am so glad he is back in AEW. Props to TK and Swerve for putting him over here. The main event scene in AEW is hot right now and both go these guys are legitimate contenders and clearly have a ton of chemistry but in a different way than say Swerve and Page do. All the work here was PPV main event quality. The build throughout the match, the big spots and counters and the overall urgency that both of them had the whole match. The finish was creative and they pulled it off well which doesn't happen all the time with refs in AEW."
[7.0] "Why is Andrade glowing like this? I might've made some unholy demonic noises while he made his entrance. Undeniably the best match on the card, this came across like a high-flyers heavyweight clash with its dynamic action with some physicality sprinkled in. Chemistry was GREAT here! The plants for Andrade are offering a fantastic touch to his El Ídolo moniker. ***1/2"
[9.0] "This match was cooool. It had a strong reason to happen, both wreslters have their own stories happening so there were so many potential outcomes. Swerve still being the favourite and Andrade being the underdog actually worked so well as it gave Andrade the chance to really stamp that he's a proper threat. Which he is. And he's cool. There were some great spots, that damn guard rail spot made me cringe so hard. The two seemed to have fun as well as they both have kinda similar moves or at least athleticism. Very fun match...and the right winner!"
[8.0] "I was not expecting Andrade to win this match but I was surprised! A really great match to make Andrade look like a future main eventer especially with this new character he's put on. These two had some great chemistry with one another and I thought the ending was very clever! [****.15]"
[9.0] "Awesome match. Andrade already feels bigger and better than he did during the entirety of his first run. The crowd chants, the interactions with the fans, the smoothness of his movement (he no longer feels hindered physically by the big pants) and he's showing off in ring what I saw in him during his all-time NXT run. Please don't do anything stupid Andrade and reach the potential that's always been there in a major American company. Swerve was great too, and he's been so selfless lately, hope he gets another title run soon."
[9.0] "A phenomenal match! It's January, so this next statement is truly hyperbolic but this was the TV match of the new year. The next 11 months of TV wrestling matches has the bar Swerve & Andrade set tonight to clear. These two are so similar in physical stature and look, it went beyond that and felt they were just mirroring each other's energies in there. Another hard hitting match on the card, with the right guy winning, and everyone being protected and elevated in the process. Andrade just reinserted himself into the main event picture and I believe we're looking at the start of a "Wrestler of the Year" type run. I was worried about Swerve over the last few matches, shaking off some rust and finding it again in the ring. He did it. He's back. I am so hyped for everything coming up for both."
[8.0] "The match of the night for me. Andrade picks up the win which I like, and him vs Kenny next week will be great. PPV level match on tv and I love all of these guys fighting for a shot at the world title. Good chemistry between the two and another match down the line would work wonders."
[10.0] "Basically one of the best matches of the month of January , clearly a PPV quality match of two of the best talents of the AEW World scene, the last 6 minutes were angelical, full of false finishers and more of an incredible chemestry of two wrestlers could be main eventing one of the futures PPV's of this year or a rematch in the CC"
[8.0] "This was such a great surprise. I had known Andrade was signed to AEW but it seemed he wasn't going to actually wrestle until this happened, as this was his debut since returning. Andrade looked to be in fantastic shape as he showed off his technical skills with Swerve. This match was full of great spots and ended with a cheap low blow before the DM finish. Great showing for Andrade and Swerve always delivers."