[7.0] "Shoutout to Jon Moxley for waking up from his nap to join the show. Ian explains the Pure Rules and Moxley undercuts him by saying he wasn't listening. Later, Billie burns one of her rope breaks and Moxley realizes he is watching a Pure Rules match. This was a great opener. The women do a lot outside, which is not something I would prefer in Pure Rules. Maybe that's why Jon was confused."
[8.0] "It was a good pure rules fight, Deonna Purrazzo in AEW / ROH is kind of a mystery for me. I had so much hope for her but she didn't deliver in the last 2 years. This match is the first time for the last 2 years that she really did a good job. In pure rules, she can only thrive. Billie Starkz will clearly take over the entire world in a few years. I really liked how the story was built during the match, especially Deonna draining out Starkz's rope breaks before an impressive submission finish."
[9.0] "We probably don't need more titles but at least the Pure title has some unique rules, and at least it's a women's title so we get to see more from a different talent pool. This was a great example of technical wrestling and I was really glad to see Deonna found a place to excel."
[5.0] "Here I see for myself a typical problem of a large number of modern matches in a pure style. This is a regular wrestling match (not the best, to be honest) where there is just a limited number of rope breaks and a timer. I understand that just fighting in a quadrilateral is very difficult for some wrestlers these days, but is it really THAT difficult to do it at least occasionally? Otherwise, Billie seemed to have stopped her development as a wrestler and this bar turned out to be below expectations, while Deonna, on the contrary, has become worse over the past time."
[7.0] "This was a really fun and interesting match that served as a good opener for Final Battle! Deonna Purrazzo especially looked strong, showing clear signs that she's been working on herself and is definitely on the right track to recovering her top form. The match did an excellent job of utilizing the Pure stipulation, building a classic narrative around the rope breaks which successfully got the crowd invested. While Billie Starkz still has a long way to go, she performed well and showed improvement. Ultimately, Purrazzo earned a well-deserved victory via submission in just under 14 minutes, concluding a very enjoyable bout."
[8.0] "These women delivered a much better match than expected, especially Deonna, who was portrayed as the stronger force throughout. For a well-rounded division across ROH/AEW, this title is well-earned to present sleeper matches like this, and Deonna stood herself as an excellent contender for the inaugural champ. 3.75 out of 5 stars!"
[7.0] "An opener which exceeded my expectations and created a great clash of pure-wrestling styles. Deonna absolutely feels like the right person to lead this division, and excelled in the strategic elements of the bout from start to finish, putting in some great submission offence in the process. Filling this out retrospectively, so excuse the lack of detail."
[7.0] "(Grade:C+/***1/4) Very good opening match, Curious to see how The ROH Women's Pure Title will be treated and the upcoming legacy it'll hold. Focusing on the match, it was very technical yet hectic in a good way sort of a balance of Purrazzo's style & Starkz's Style i.e. Billie Starkz hitting a curb stomp to Purrazzo on the ring step or a Alabama slam on the apron compared to Purrazzo who wears down Starkz having her waste her rope-breaks and hitting solid combos. It makes sense having Purrazzo being the inaugural champion as well as her history in ROH so glad to see her get the victory."
[9.0] "I thought this was a pretty damn good opener here with Billie Starkz vs Deonna Purrazzo. I give their Pure Rules match a strong 8.5 out of 10; which means that I am giving this awesome banger a 9 on this site since it's much closer to this number than an 8."
[8.0] "This match was a good reminder of the promise Deonna showed when she first arrived in AEW. The finish was very cool with Deonna kneeing Billie in the head whilst having her in the Venus De Milo. Billie was a great shit heel and bumped like a demon. Excellent first champion for the Women's Pure Division."
[5.0] "This wasn't horrible, but like most Deonna matches since she's debuted in AEW/ROH, I have trouble getting into it much. I really like Billie but her work is far from pristine and typically needs to be in there with someone who's great to have a killer match. Deonna has some nice moments but overall I find her stuff to be pretty sloppy and slow. The finish was pretty lame where the swanton was totally no-sold to go into the submission and the use of pure rules wasn't interesting."
[7.0] "Enjoyable match. My biggest complaint is not that anything in the match was bad, its just that it didn't feel like a "Pure Rules" match. It felt just like a normal singles match, and the dynamics that make a Pure Rules contest so enjoyable were mostly missing. Little mat wrestling, the action didn't focus on the rope breaks, etc. With that being said, I enjoyed the action here, but there was nothing special."
[5.0] "Wasnt really a fan of this. The action here was mostly decent, but outside of the finish i wasnt really drawn in at any point. I did enjoy Deonna's armwork here but Billie's selling of it was pretty lacklustre and took away from the match for me. Didnt hate this but i dont think it was great as an opener honestly. **3/4"
[8.0] "Dope match. Deonna amazes me with her quickness, Billie is a lot better at selling than given credit. Plenty of cool moves, holds, and reversals, but the match psychology and structure and joint selling were the key. Very happy for Deonna winning too, she is well deserving of the Honor (pun intended). 4*"
[7.0] "This was one of the matches i was excited for the most. I do not like pure rules usually. Billie Starkz is so good already, i really see a bright future. Mox is a huge win on commentary. Arm story is told well. Billie getting Deonna up is always a delight and she does it so many times! 7, 5"
[8.0] "Usually I don't watch ROH so that was the first Deonna match I've seen since 2024 I think. She's a beast and she should be in AEW on a regular basis. Billie is also a great prospect, Hope to see both of them in Dynamite or Collision more often."
[7.0] "Interesting match and I'm happy to see Deonna back. She's not yet at the level she used to be, but she's definitely on the right track, and it's pretty clear she's been working on herself. Billie still has a long way to go, but she did well too and she's improving. Not an incredible match, but a good opener for Final Battle, and I'm glad both of them got the opportunity. Now I can't wait for the feud between Deonna and Aminata."
[7.0] "A really fun match with Purrazzo especially looking really good. They used the Pure stipulation well, utilising the rope breaks to build a classic narrative which worked and got the crowd invested. Purrazzo got the win via submission in just shy of 14 minutes, a well deserved victory following an enjoyable bout."
[8.0] "This was a great return to form for Purrazzo, in a spot where she kind of needed to deliver. Watching submission based wrestlers stick to a clear plan that pays off in the end is always a satisfying match structure. She gets pretty nasty in the ways she tries to rip Starkz's arms off as she believably sells the pain. Some big spots in the match with the stairs curbstomp, table leg sweep, and apron Alabama Slam all being spread out nicely to keep the intensity up. Hopefully the booking can allow for this division to continue having high level matches like this. ****"
[8.0] "Really great match! Seeing Deonna in longer and important match made me emotional - she deserves opportunities like this so much and while watching this match i could see why i fell in love with her back in 2020. Purrazzo's technical style is just so good, i love how she will always find a way to get that Fujiwara locked. Starkz also surprised as it was my first match of hers and she did beyond what i expected - her future is bright that's for sure. The closing minutes were INCREDIBLE, you really couldn't tell who's gonna take the belt but in the end it was Deonna and i couldn't be more happy, she needs to be treated as THE top star cause she showed in Impact she is one and this title can help her with that. Queen Aminata came out for a face off with Dee and that match needs to be saved for some big show as the main event - the potential this bout has is so big. Overall it was very good way to open the show and it was definitely great first match for this championship. ***, 75"
[8.0] "I've been a big fan of Deonna for a long time but for whatever reason her AEW run has been a bit underwhelming. Was very happy to see her back on form in her element tonight with this match. Her and Billie both did a great job and it was nice seeing Deonna get that emotional moment where she won the title as you could see it meant a lot to her."
[8.0] "Very solid opener. I have always enjoyed the Pure matches rules. Very happy to see them applied in female matches too. Overall both girls did an amazing job. Happy for Deonna because she seemed a little lost recently but this title could really raise her status."
[6.0] "Interesting match-up for this pairing with their clash of styles. Billie having the more one speed to her pace, throwing her offense in a more head-on fashion. On the other hand, Deonna was technically inclined with her methodical approach when in control, and it made her bigger spots stand out much more, like the Russian leg sweep onto the announce table. I highly enjoyed how Deonna quickly set the tone for how her work would play out, as she immediately made Billie exhaust a rope break by going after the arm, which targeting the arm comes into play for the finish as well. Deonna set her sights on targeting the arm and the back throughout and also had the more detailed work in the smaller details. ***1/4"
[8.0] "This was 100% Deonnas best match in a Tony Kahn owned company, truly her best work so far, dominating early to get Billie through her rope breaks quick including the first one 15 seconds in. Deonna fits the pure rules so well and is 100% the right choice to be the first Women's Pure Champion and I can't wait to see how her reign plays out"
[8.0] "What I want out of a Pure Rules match is graps, graps, and more graps - and yeah, that's what we got with Purrazzo and Starkz. Fantastic match to start this years Final Battle with. Purrazzo was made for Pure Rules, the perfect first champ for this belt."
[7.0] "Really sound match. Deonna was working on the arm throughout and Billie was selling well. Entertaining spots throughout, the russian legsweep on the table stood out. As usual, Billie was bumping her ass off. Deonna deserves it and I'm excited for her match with Aminata."
[8.0] "The best match I've seen Billie Starkz in and it's not that surprising because Deonna is a great technical wrestler. To be fair, Starkz had much better timing in her spots but her strikes still look slow and awkward. At any rate, I'm happy Deonna won."