DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?

John Bradshaw Layfield vs. John Cena

Match

4​.92
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 257
Number of comments: 53
10.0 0x
9.0 0x
8.0 0x
7.0 13x
6.0 49x
5.0 113x
4.0 70x
3.0 10x
2.0 2x
1.0 0x
0.0 0x
Average rating: 4.92  [257]
Average rating in 2026: 4.60  [43]
Average rating in 2025: 4.85  [62]
Average rating in 2024: 5.00  [53]
Average rating in 2023: 4.96  [50]
Average rating in 2022: 5.28  [25]
Average rating in 2021: 4.90  [20]
Average rating in 2020: 5.50  [4]
Your Options:
Other:
Leo the goat wrote on 13.11.2026:
[5.0] "A strictly average, TV-style 5/10 championship bout that delivered a massive star-making coronation for John Cena despite remarkably uninspiring bell-to-bell action. After months of JBL surviving every challenger on SmackDown through cheap shortcuts and Cabinet interference, the build promised a heated, cathartic war. Instead, they worked a slow, methodical 11-minute match dominated by JBL's heavy-handed punches, sleeper holds, and deliberate pacing--with almost zero high-drama near-falls or wild plunder. Just as Cena finally mounted his trademark comeback, JBL missed a Clothesline from Hell and immediately ate a single FU for the clean three-count, ending JBL's historic nine-month title reign in surprisingly abrupt fashion. Great atmosphere inside the Staples Center for Cena's first world title win, completely forgettable as an actual WrestleMania match."
KSAHZ8 wrote on 24.09.2026:
[5.0] "This match wasn't horrible, it was kind of boring but I think the fact the life had been sucked out of the crowd from the previous match, this suffered from it. A few positive's include the stiffness and Cena's first big crowning moment. But sadly nothing too big really happened, sort of felt like a Smackdown main event. Unoffensive match, slightly boring in comparison to everything else."
Pedram 1384 wrote on 28.05.2026:
[5.0] "It was decent match not as bad as ratings say but it wasn't an instant classic the positive point of this match was the hard hitting"
Raditz Flair wrote on 29.04.2026:
[3.0] "It mostly sucked. The crowd was dead until the obvious Cena win but this is a horrible match for what's supposed to be a crowning moment."
CodyPodlaskowski wrote on 21.04.2026:
[4.0] "Decent match.. it was nothing to go home about but it served its purpose nothing against either John Cena or JBL they had one just get the title on Cena and make Cena look like a million bucks and I feel they accomplished that goal 100%! It wasn't your instant classic but it was a classic that has stood the test of time because of what it ment to the industry and what it stands for... it's the 1st world title win of a man who would become maybe the greatest of all time down the road this match set the tone of what the future was going to look like a WWE with John Cena on top of the mountain and he was there to stay. But as far as match quality it was an average match but memorable."
WG20 wrote on 31.03.2026:
[4.0] "A borefest for Cena's first WWE championship win. The match is basically JBL dominates the whole match Cena makes a comeback Cena wins."
brooksavage2004 wrote on 27.03.2026:
[3.0] "It did have John Cena win his first ever WWE World Title, but this match was pretty bad with weak and by the numbers in ring work and chemistry between each other, and the crowd wasn't into it all that much until Cena wins."
SkyIcons wrote on 02.03.2026:
[5.0] "The most 3 star world title match I've seen in some time. Everything is completely fine and nothing goes wrong. But there's no ambition or real upping of a gear."
TrailsOfPersona wrote on 09.02.2026:
[5.0] "I'm being a little generous and giving this match five points instead of four because it was the crowning moment of one of 'the guys' for WWE. But there really is close to no substance here. It is such a shockingly forgettable match besides the title change. It really is just strikes for 10 minutes with the occasional slam here and there. Neither of them do anything even remotely memorable. This match is worth watching once for historical significance, but it is probably the worst match on the card that is over 5 minutes in length."
EyeBronze8388 wrote on 01.02.2026:
[4.0] "Very underwhelming match. There weren't many nearfalls here. If you're a fan of clotheslines then this was the title match for you! I was surprised by how short it was, but considering the limitations of the workers, it was the right call. It came off like a TV match, though, rather than WrestleMania match for a major title. JBL couldn't have good matches very often and with a bigger guy like Cena it was going to be even more difficult for him. Cena's never been a great worker, but as we'd see over the years he had some good matches in big match situations. This wasn't one of those good matches. This was the first World or WWE title match Cena was in at a WrestleMania. He would go on to wrestle in 7 WWE or World Title matches in a row at WrestleManias after this."
Jonny Dubya wrote on 24.01.2026:
[5.0] "It was a match that made John Cena a megastar that he would become for years in WWE. Props to JBL for doing the job for Cena."
DecentWrestling wrote on 17.12.2025:
[4.0] "This match...probably both their weakest. It just didn't hit. JBL dominated for way too long with too few comebacks for Cena to keep it intriguing. Then Cena supermans up and wins with the F-U. It felt like a 80's Hogan match but lacking the rabid fans which led it to falling a bit flat. Not bad per say, but just lacking given the venom in the story."
Yee I watch wrestlin wrote on 14.12.2025:
[4.0] "The official crowning of John Cena as the guy. Memorable because it is cenas first title run and that's obviously big seeing who he becomes. But it's just him taking heat for 9 mins then coming up to get the win. Not great but not as bad as some say it is. Only thing that matters is the win from cena tho. (**1/4)"
volhexpixels wrote on 08.12.2025:
[5.0] "The only outstanding thing in this is the victory of Cena as WWE Champion, the first of his career, beggining with his main event path that he still has even on our days. But talking about the match, it starts very slow and boring, and starts being more enjoyable in the last minutes (or seconds), but nothing out of the ordinary. This match really need to had more minutes and more action knowing the story behind, that was personal and attractive, just to end in a match that can be transmited in a normal SmackDown"
LK3185 wrote on 24.11.2025:
[4.0] "I wanted to like this more than I did. its the first PPV I got to watch live as it happens, before that it was scramble vision if i was lucky.. Cena and JBL are both guys I really like and they have an awesome title match next month but that is next month and not mania. Felt like their time was cut and that really made the match suffer because you don't get a brawl, you get an ass kicking for like 8 mins and then the finishing stretch. There's no blood and the crowd doesn't really care until the finish. I even heard like audible boring chants."
12psi wrote on 17.11.2025:
[3.0] "This match kind of sucks for a lot of it, and is okay at certain points, but man is that finish tough. Cena coming back like that with no real build makes the insanely boring work by JBL not just boring, but also pointless."
Brye wrote on 03.10.2025:
[4.0] "Very basic match but the finish with Cena winning is cool and very important historically in retrospect. That being said, you could tune in in the last minute of this match and you wouldn't miss anything."
Gravelord wrote on 30.09.2025:
[2.0] "Good lord, I had remembered this as a mostly forgettable affair but upon rewatch I found it to be straight-up atrocious. Cena and Bradshaw turned in utterly unremarkable performances as babyface and heel respectively. The bout was so lifeless and dull that I am already struggling to remember anything about it despite having only finished watching it five minutes ago. Bradshaw spent much of it working over Cena's back using his clubbing offense. Not only was Bradshaw's work on top as paint-by-the-numbers as you'll see, it was ultimately made irrelevant by a finish that saw Cena hulk up after catching Bradshaw coming off of the top rope with a scope slam. Cena didn't really sell the back at all despite Bradshaw wasting ten minutes of my time targeting it, and he simply won after one FU after burning through all of his then signature moves. While the crowd did pop big for Cena's win, those in attendance were noticeably quiet throughout the bout itself. You could definitely hear some heckling on account of how tedious the proceedings were. If it wasn't for the fact that Cena's first world championship win came about because of his victory in this match it would have been forgotten to history as there is otherwise nothing good let alone excellent about it. While there are worse matches, I struggle to think of too many WrestleMania title fights that were as listless and perfunctory as this was. Fortunately, both guys would go on to redeem themselves and then some with their classic 'I Quit' match at Judgement Day two months later. *"
sdenapoli wrote on 24.09.2025:
[5.0] "While this match wasn't terrible or Cena's worst Mania match (No Travis Scott), this was an underwhelming way to crown Cena and end JBL's long reign. While I get they wanted Cena to be an underdog, interference from the Cabinet would've been needed."
EmoForkliftDriver wrote on 03.09.2025:
[5.0] "Lol Cena Wins ass match. I was surprised at how low this match was rated and shockingly it's nothing to do with JBL. Bradshaw isn't the most interesting guy in the ring but as I've grown older I've began to appreciate just how physical this guy worked, he can't carry John Cena to a great match but goddamn he was laying in some stiff strikes this whole match. Cena himself is surprisingly unremarkable in this match. He's sloppy, he gets little to no offence in, he makes no arguments as to why he should be the face of the company in the coming decade. The crowd doesn't even seem behind him, every single thing he does gets a brief pop followed by a chorus of boos which I thought didn't happen until a couple months into his first title reign. They don't do anything wrong here but for a match that is so historically important, it's a struggle to find anything worth talking about"
SoundwaveAU wrote on 02.09.2025:
[5.0] "Such a disappointing ending to JBL's title reign. This is a match that is just so at odds with what JBL's reign has been up until this point. Suddenly instead of a cowardly cheat he's domineering and controlling. His mooks don't get involved once, so all Cena has to overcome is JBL himself, and it's nowhere near as satisfying as it could be."
ahmed wrote on 21.05.2025:
[3.0] "This match did the unforgiveable wrestling sin, it was boring as hell. I like these two wrestlers and they had a great I Quit match, but this was a snooze fest. The wrist holds were unbearable and even tho this was like 11 minutes, it felt like 45. Very important match in History, shame it was crab."
brainbusterrr wrote on 12.05.2025:
[5.0] "So, going into this match, based on the * 1/4 rating from Dave Meltzer, I was expecting some sort of disaster. That isn't really what this is at all! I quite like the fast-paced start to the match. The fellas push a pace before settling into a prolonged heat segment on Cena. The crowd is clearly very bored, as was I. Cena bumps nicely for Bradshaw for a while before a nice comeback that is honestly better than the "5 moves of doom" that we all know today. Some hefty lariats, a big shoulder tackle, a 5 Knuckle Shuffle, and a reversed Clothesline from Hell into an F-U is all it takes to win his first world title. This certainly wasn't a classic by any means, and it isn't even close to what these two would deliver in their next match, but it isn't the disaster I was expecting. ** 1/2"
KKeanel wrote on 26.04.2025:
[4.0] "I wouldn't expect much, however it's still some kind of disappointment. Horrible pace - it's not a proud beginning of Cena's legendary road to 17 titles."
ShaliK wrote on 19.03.2025:
[6.0] "A pretty average match. It was pretty fast-paced and well-executed, but I think it was cut short due to time constraints. A crowd happy to see John Cena win his first world championship. (3*)"
bigredtalk89 wrote on 17.03.2025:
[5.0] "If there ever was a generic title match, this is it. Super formulaic, nothing special at all. JBL beats him up the entire time, no one hits a finisher before the finish, which is just Cena ducking a clothesline and hitting 1 finisher. Underwhelming, and this was back when everyone loved the up and coming Cena, but the crowd was already turning against him in this match."
JLHarman wrote on 31.01.2025:
[6.0] "[3 Stars] A good match, not on the level of a Wrestlemania, especially for the world title, but what we remember most is Cena's first WWE Championship on "the biggest stage in the world" (***)"
Mizzle Assault Ant wrote on 20.11.2024:
[7.0] "This is nothing on their best matches together obviously, but I thought it was reasonably good for the time they got. JBL was hard hitting as usual and fought like he really wanted to keep the title. Cena was pretty much his standard self at this time but the crowd was super happy to see him win."
tsukushimakino wrote on 12.10.2024:
[3.0] "What a weird way to crown Cena. It being 10 minutes isn't a huge deal, but this is just so heatless, and doesn't make Cena look that good even. It's just JBL on offense the entire time till the Cena comback, but it's going thru the motions, there's nothing really interesting, and it doesn't even build towards anything ? The match just kinda ends. Just so uninspired, which is insane to me, given the time and place of it ? Not sure what happended."
JacquesRougeauCanHaveMyWife wrote on 26.06.2024:
[5.0] "Well that was disappointing. It wasn't bad, but it should have felt grander as you were crowning the new young champion. JBL dominates for the most part, then Cena fires up, makes the comeback and the finish comes surprisingly early. It was serviceable, but should have been something much bigger."
RealGrapsThomsen wrote on 02.06.2024:
[5.0] "This was decent enough. JBL worked as the experienced, dominant and cocky heel while Cena worked as an underdog babyface, which would be fine if JBL was such a coward in the build up to this. All that matter is how Cena eventually won the title and it was a pretty big moment given the context."
FakeShemp wrote on 28.02.2024:
[3.0] "This was an incredible misfire with the contrast between how Cena was built up in the pre-match promo package and him just getting dogwalked for 90% of the match being deflating. These two would go on to have some incredible matches with the one at Judgment Day being a top 5 all-time Cena match, but this was just 10 minutes of nothing with a sudden finish."
crs285 wrote on 03.12.2023:
[6.0] "This was about Cena breaking out as the big star and face of the company. The match was a little shorter than expected and didn't build a ton of tension. Match had several repetitive spots. Cena got the win that made his career as this was his first world title."
Ruthless Attitude wrote on 16.11.2023:
[5.0] "This was a very template John Cena match where he gets beaten up at the start, comes back with the five moves of doom and then Cena wins LOL. The match did what it was supposed to where it put Cena at the very top of the company and Cena took the ball and ran with it, but I can also see why at his peak the crowds reactions to him was mixed."
GMS18 wrote on 19.07.2023:
[3.0] "A really nothing match considering it's Cena's coronation, just had no heat or anything interesting going on here. *1/2"
violet011 wrote on 16.03.2023:
[3.0] "Yeah that's how you make a star, have JBL beat him up and then Cena makes a Hogan-like comeback for the finish - *1/2"
Skypellex wrote on 24.04.2022:
[2.0] "A boring and much too quickly dispatched match. Much cited as it was the match that marked the beginning of Cena's rise."
Argylex wrote on 23.04.2022:
[3.0] "Wow, it was really worse than what I remembered. It has a historic significance since it is Cena's first WWE title victory, but other than that, it was just a bad match."
flightaker321 wrote on 13.03.2022:
[5.0] "Very simple match formula JBL dominates Cena, Cena gets in little spurts of offense but it's not much. Cena makes his comeback and wins the title for the first time.**¾"
Geo93 wrote on 17.02.2022:
[6.0] "This wasn't quite a star-making performance from John Cena and it certainly didn't feel like a WrestleMania world title match. However, there were no annoying heel shenanigans in this and it was way too short to ever drag at all. Nobody was sad to see JBL drop the title, either."
4outof5 wrote on 23.01.2022:
[4.0] "Not quite the star-making performance this is hyped as. Cena's first world title win but it would still be some time before he became the defacto #1 guy in WWE. JBL just isn't good enough of a foil to launch a true superstar off of."
RosVer wrote on 05.01.2022:
[7.0] "It was more of a fight than an actual match. The Hogan booking is very strong, but you have to take your mind back in 2005. While we had seen this before, Cena's appeal made it work once again and JBL carried him into a decent match."
Golden Lover wrote on 17.07.2021:
[4.0] "I have absolutely no idea how a crowd can be so dead for a Wrestlemania world title match. This was a dull, run of the mill John Cena match with an absolutely silent crowd. No one was chanting for Cena to make his big comeback, no one cared when he did get his moves in until the very end. Bad, very bad. Can't believe this is a mania world title match."
KingofKings5632 wrote on 02.07.2021:
[6.0] "As a moment, this was pivotal to WWE's growth and ushering into a new era. As a match though, this was pretty bland. JBL is an excellent brawler and can play the dominant champion as well as the cowardly champion equally well. They did neither here, I guess because they didn't want Cena to look weak while also keeping some shine on JBL. This really didn't click, because neither man at that point was strong enough to pull a good match from the other. It was bland, but it wasn't a disaster and the historical significance kind of adds to it when you go back to rewatch."
cactus wrote on 19.05.2021:
[4.0] "I've started to appreciate Bradshaw more as a worker in the last few years. He was great when he was fired up Texan hoss when he was in the APA, and he was completely despicable as JBL. He throws some stiff shots and bullies Cena around, but he's mostly boring when working on top. Cena shows great fire even if his hokey facials need work and leave a lot to be desired. Not a whole lot of interest happens here and the finish comes out of nowhere. The crowd was burnt out, but they came alive for the finish."
pierreMinne wrote on 23.02.2021:
[5.0] "I felt like this match was average all along, it never had a higher moment than another, it was basically a Cena match with a big comeback at the end against a big sloppy heel. It not works with me unfortunately. **3/4"
Brad Garoon wrote on 13.07.2020:
[5.0] "For a WrestleMania Championship match this was very pedestrian. Not bad, but I'll say it's a good thing it wasn't the main event. JBL's boredom is undeterred by the importance (and in hindsight the historical significance) of the moment."