[6.0] "While I do prefer both Hayter & Aminata as wrestlers, Sisters of Sin definitely should have advanced here, seeing as how they're a much more established team. I'm not typically a fan of a makeshift team randomly running through multiple established teams (not inherently opposed to the idea, though), so I'm good with this result."
[3.0] "Yet another fine match dragged down by the involvement of Julia Hart. I can't say I'm surprised at all. The ending is a complete mess. It's good at times but also very bad and 100% the worst part of the night imo."
[6.0] "I like all four individuals in this match, but I got to say, it wasn't that great. This should've been a big and important match, both by the stakes and the fierce rivalry between them, but didn't achieve this level at all. It followed the same formula (a good formula, btw) but with pretty much nothing new. Skye and Julia are still getting better and that process can expose their flaws sometimes. The same can be said about their strengths, and that is their teamwork. I am not bothered by the result, it is the most logical thing to do whether you like it or not, the actual established team won and thanks to an outside interference as well. The final act of the match is a huge upgrade and gets a few extra points for the rating that the camera work was desperate to take off."
[5.0] "Everything related and connected with that match went super strange. Like, the chemistry between the tags looked kinda off, the ring action was fine but not great, Julia Hart looked awful at most of the exectuions he did during the match, and the interference was kinda useless. I mean, everyone gets hyped with Aminata and Hayter as a tag and you make them be eliminated at the first round? If this isn't the best way to describe bad booking, I don't know what it is."
[3.0] "Between the uninspired layout of the bout and the less than stellar attention to production, it all ends up being a bit of a mess. You don't get to see the interference that leads to the finish and the whole way getting there is formulaic choreographed spots in stereo that are not that thought out as to come off organically."
[5.0] "The thing that will make-or-break this tournament for me is whether the already-established teams can go the distance and feel like prominent figures. With that considered, the result is pleasing, but the manner of it is not. An established tag-team, at this point in the new emergence of the division, shouldn't require outside interference to overcome a relatively thrown-together team. The match itself requires little discussion; decent, nothing more, nothing less. All things considered, rating this straight down the middle feels appropriate."
[5.0] "I want to get behind this tournament, because I'm all for a Women's tag division, especially if it gives younger talent more screentime / chance to develop. However, this is not a good start on so many levels. Firstly, why did Aminata and Hayter constantly tag in and out at the start to do one move, then switch again. Surely the point is to tag to buy yourself a five count to double team an opponent, or to keep them off-guard - This achieved neither of those things and was pointless. Secondly, the pacing was slow and never really picked up. I thought Hayter and Skye Blue looked decent at best. Lastly, the ending. Thekla slid out from under the ring (I assume? ) as it was completely missed by the camera crew. It was then called on commentary as being Julia Hart, yet the camera then cut back to the ring, where Hart and Blue were double teaming Aminata for the finish. And to add icing on the cake, when we did get a replay, Thekla was clearly prone on the ground in clear view of Hayter, who then ran right towards her. So many issues, but I still have hope things will pick up, especially with the Bayne promo that followed."
[5.0] "Women's tag: not a bad match by any means, and the younger members of the group are developing well, but this was no classic. Decent in patches, tough in patches but basically fine. 5/10"
[3.0] "Same criticism as last week in that 3 out of 4 of these women shouldn't be on television but in a developmental system. Especially Julia Hart who showed much promise early in her career hasn't improved and possibly gotten worse. Over the past years it's become clear wrestlers won't learn anything in this place. The problems were a little less apparent here because this was at least a normal 2 on 2 tag match. What hurt the match even more was the finish. Thekla's interference, a really simple thing, was botched in every way possible. The camera didn't catch it and Excalibur even mistook her for Julia Hart, which was weird. This women's tag tournament (jeesh, how many tournaments can you have? ) is already a fail."
[6.0] "While I was initially excited about the introduction of the women's tag team title, I'm a little disappointed by the start of the tournament. Hart is really plateauing, if not regressing, and the match's pace never really took off. Thekla's interference was somewhat predictable, but the production made it even less impactful. A rocky start, but having more at stake in the women's midcard is still a welcome addition. In-ring quality: 1.25/4. Stakes: 0.75/2. Justification: 1/1. Card placement: 1/1. Suspense: 0.75/1. Bonus/penalty: none. Total: 5.75/10. Match watched on Triller TV."
[5.0] "This match left me feeling disappointed. Mainly because it was one of the featured matches of the first round of the tournament, and it was quite slow, unsynchronized, and lacked chemistry between all the wrestlers involved. The only positive was Tekla's interference, which helped further her rivalry with Hayter, but the rest was quite poor and one of the show's biggest disappointments. 5/10."
[6.0] "I thought the actual match was quite good, I'm just baffled by the decision to have Hayter and Aminata lose. They are so cool together and I really hope this isn't the last time we see them as a tag team. (***1/4)"
[6.0] "Honestly this march was much better than I actually expected it to be mainly because of how good Jamie and Aminata are. I thought they really carried this match with their great hard hitting offence and having long control segments which meant they were able To hide the weakness Julia and Skye have as they're both still pretty green and it worked well for most of the match. But I'll give Julia and Skye their flowers this was probably the smoothest I've seen them look as a team in AEW with all of their offence looking pretty good throughout the match and even the time they were in control of the match being pretty good to watch. My only gripe with this match is as much as I love the Sisters of Sin I've been robbed of the greatest women's tag match match in AEW history of Mercedes and Athena vs Jamie and Aminata but as it's to build towards B&G I'll accept it. Overall a really solid match which definitely exceeded my expectations. (***1/4)"
[5.0] "For the most part a "just fine" match, but laced with some memorable moments of sloppiness. There were a couple too many moments for my liking which felt entirely unnatural in their set-up, and sadly I do think Julia has regressed. Regardless of the fact that it is building to Blood & Guts, I detest the outcome of this one."
[4.0] "I didn't aspect that Jamie hayter and queen aminata already lost and also I don't think Skye blue and Julia Hart are goods. The match is boring and with a stupid finish"
[4.0] "Not a good match and the result was just stupid. Not sure what the direction for Aminata and Jamie is after this or why TK feels the need to constantly push someone as bad as Julia Hart. Only thing I can really see is that Shida comes back to ally with Aminata and Jamie to feud with Triangle of Madness"
[4.0] "A pretty boring match with a terrible result. I have no idea what Tony continues to see in Skye and Julia but there's absolutely no reason why they should be advancing in this tournament over Jamie and Aminata who are actually, y'know, good wrestlers. The action here was mostly boring and Skye and Julia's heel work was painfully dull. It does pick up a bit towards the end with a cool Aminata hot tag but it doesn't do enough to undo the previous 5 minutes where nothing of note happens. Very dull match overall with a result that basically killed all hope i had for this tournament. **1/4"
[2.0] "What was the point of having Jamie Hayter and Queen Aminata go over last week, presumably to give them some credibility as a tag team heading into the tournament, only to then job them out in the first round? This match could've just been announced, like all the others, without the goofy stipulation of last week's match. If they wanted to get some heat on the heels then have Thekla attack them after the bell. Fans wanted to see the Head Butt/Hayterade finisher again. (Penelope sold that thing like death last week; really made it look awesome.) It goes without saying that Hayter and Aminata had the nearly impossible task of trying to make Julia Hart seem credible as a wrestler. They did their best, but that wasn't good enough. Skye Blue was fine. But...this was bad booking, boring action and lame finish."
[4.0] "[**1/4] A disappointing start to the women's tag tournament and introduction to these new titles. The angle between these four women took priority over delivering a strong match, which may understandable given this will also play into the women's Blood & Guts match. However, this lacked the heat of a fued that is actually working and the finish was flat."
[7.0] "Good match. Not happy with the result, but the tag team work in this match was too good too ignore despite of it. Don't get the pushback this match is receiving tbh"
[4.0] "Julia Hart is one of the worst active members of the roster. She talked through this whole match, and all of her offense sucked. QA and Jamie losing is the wrong call, unless a lot more feuding is gonna be done between them and Thekla. But please don't let Julia Hart go deep in this tournament."
[4.0] "Julia Hart is a rough watch and Skye Blue is barely better. Thankful for Hayter and Aminata because I can only deal with some much performative pillow feather offense. The submission Aminata did to Blue was cool. Classic AEW camera crew missing the Tekla spot. I thought the finish was meh."
[6.0] "I thought it could be better but still decent match. Sisters of Sin winning which personally I thought wont happen, still would prefer to see Jamie and Aminata in semis losing due to interference there, it would give us better match. But Skye and Julia also keep getting better and I see them with this titles even if not inaugural Champions."
[7.0] "This was a decent match with actually a shocking outcome. I think most people would have Jamie and Aminata advancing so it was surprising to see the upset"