[7.0] "This mainly existed to reveal that Takahashi will challenge Fletcher at Forbidden Door and to give him a victory going into that match. That said, this was pretty fun. Definitely the best match on the show, and Takahashi being the challenger at Forbidden Door is cool. I was hoping for Shingo Takagi, but I can't complain about Takahashi whatsoever."
[5.0] "Multi man fatigue sets in big time here as the match is unnecessarily long and has very little of note besides Hologram's dive to the outside and the involvement of Hiromu Takahashi. Kind of disappointing that Takahashi didn't feel like a bigger deal here but I'm excited to see his match against Kyle Fletcher at Forbidden Door."
[9.0] "Great fast paced TV multi-man with a lot of moving parts. I don't really care about the Bucks much in 2025 but even I chuckled at them bitterly bullying Justin Roberts. Alexander, Fletcher, Brody, Hiromu, Hologram, everyone got a nice chance to shine here, this was a great look at some of the awesome talent in AEW right now."
[6.0] "Fun match and good to see Hiromu involved, but besides the Hologram dive to the outside there wasn't a tonne that caught my eye and the finisher was a bit anticlimactic. Good but nothing memorable. ***1/4"
[8.0] "Another great all star tag added to the catalog. They just don't miss. Everyone gets their shine. Everyone looks cool as hell. Consistently awesome TV and this was no different."
[9.0] "Maybe the greatest junior Heavyweight of all time, Hiromu Takahashi revealed as Fletchers opponent is so beast. I'm so excited for that match and this was a brilliant preview of that match with all 8 men being incredible and Hiromu picking up the win and the momentum for himself. Young Bucks are the greatest tag team ever and this on going angle is amazing, best work of their careers. Fletchers TNT Title run has the possibility to be the best ever"
[8.0] "The best match from Dynamite. I liked seeing Hiromu Takahashi teaming up with Brody King, Hologram, and Tomohiro Ishii to take on Josh Alexander and the AEW TNT Champion Kyle Fletcher, with the Young Bucks aligning with them in this all-star tag team matchup. We saw the babyface's team get the win, and The Young Buck is irate as they have been on a downhill spiral since losing at ALL IN Texas."
[8.0] "This match was AEW 8 man tags at their balls to the wall best where I would probably reach the character limit if I wrote about every spot that I enjoyed in this match. Brody King was great as always hitting all of his power moves the fact that man can do a suicide dive is crazy to me he sold the TK driver really well. Ishii is such a dependable hand in multi mans has he can dish out and take big offence as he is a great seller and I love watching him forearm people. Hologram is who this type of match was made for as he can fly around the ring hitting all of his big spots his rope walk dives are great to see. Takahashi looked so good in this match as he always does and the sequence where he cleared the heels from the ring was superb and loved him picking up the win and am so excited to see him in London. The young bucks just don't have bad matches everything they do is so great them super kicking Justin Roberts was great and all of the Tag spots were great as always. Josh Alexander is just like Brody a big man that can move like crazy and hits so many great moves. The protostar was great in this match he is such a good heel and showed it in this match with his great offence and stooging I can't wait to see him in London in his latest form. Overall this matches was fucking great and entertaining as fuck the perfect type of TV match with so many great spots and it set up another great match for FD (****1/4)"
[7.0] "The Young Bucks always do a good job. It was fun to see them show up without music. They were able to get their revenge. The surprise of the match was seeing Takahashi."
[5.0] "These constant multi man tag matches have gotten really old for me, especially when they last forever for no reason. Only fresh thing in this match was the involvement of Hiromu who will be challenging for the belt at the ppv but other than that it's just more of the same."
[6.0] "[3.0*] The "All-Star Tag" bit is starting to be a bit tiring for me specially when some of the names involved are not all-stars at all. For example, if you look at Josh's resume since he came to AEW, is he an all-star? He's below 6th MOTY in my opinion and I love him as a wrestler. Funnily enough, he took the pin. Hiromu isn't my favorite but he looked good and the whole pre-match thing with the Bucks was fucking wonderful, it was probably my favorite thing on the whole show. Amazing storytellers."
[9.0] "UGH this match was so so so so so good live. I'm always biased in favor of anything I see live but I just couldn't help but love this one. I popped hard for Hiromu Takahashi and everyone played their parts really well. AEW just gets how to do these all-star tags and it's so fun to experience every time. Moxley always lobbies to give Cinci a good show and they absolutely gave it this time."
[7.0] "Man, this was a fun match. The young bucks kicking the shit outta Justin was the so unexpected that it killed me. I hated Josh took the pin, I mean why? Why couldn't one of Bucks do it?"
[5.0] "Best match of the evening, but not fantastic. All eight men involved had their time to shine, and Takahashi's pinning gave him the opportunity to face Fletcher in what could be a very good match at Forbidden Door. In-ring quality: 1.5/4. Stakes: 0.5/2. Justification: 1/1. Place on the card: 1/1. Suspense: 0.5/1. Bonuses/penalties: none. Total: 5.5/10. Match seen on AEW Plus."
[6.0] "Hiromu Takahashi wasn't who I was expecting for this but he was a decently fun addition to the match. The Young Bucks are the Young Bucks and do all the classic Young Bucks spots that they do in basically every match, make of that what you will. Another pretty nice heel performance from Fletcher."
[8.0] "Another great all star tag match I've really loved what the Bucks have been doing since All In I hope it leads to them to bringing back the super kick party gimmick back I was hoping for a better opponent for Fletcher at Forbidden Door but the match with Hiromu should be good"
[8.0] "Good but dissapointing if I'm being honest, first thing I was dissapointed was Fletcher facing Hiromu at FD but not Tanahashi, but knowing them and seeing their interactions in this match show me they are probably going to have a sick match but compared to other all-star tag matches we have seen lately and a tag match involving the Young Bucks this was just good not great"
[7.0] "Nice all star tag match with super hard hitting offense. Of course seeing Hiromu Takashi in there was a really cool random surprise as I haven't been paying attention to his current work but always enjoyed seeing him in the ring whenever I did, and he surprisingly got the pin too. Everyone in this match had their own unique offense that added to the match in some way. Kyle Fletcher and the young bucks were very impressive as usual, Hologram's athleticism and Ishii's power is always impressive as well."