[8.0] "What a good match. But I do have a few tiny critiques; those being Kyle's leg slaps, and the way his matches usually go 5-7 minutes, (or longer) than they should. (I'd also prefer if he used the Top Rope Brainbuster as a big match finisher, rather than his main, which he actually does do in this match, I started my review too early lol) But overall a fun first title defense where they just throw absolute bombs at each other for 16 minutes."
[8.0] "Really good opener for the show. Fletcher's first title defense right here and the reign is already off to a great start. Ishii, as he usually is, was great here. He came with a strong height "disadvantage" and still looked like a threat to Fletcher's reign. Very happy with how this turned out."
[8.0] "Honestly? If Ishii is gonna have another AEW Summer the next year, I want him to be a champion. Let him hold the TNT title for like 2 months and give him weekly defenses. He's always putting on bangers and I think he deserves a reward in the form of gold. That being said, this Fletcher reign has just started and it has been already the most interesting reign since Christian. That is obvious a bad sign for this title, that has had a lot of champions that didnt land the opportunity given, but with just two weeks this title feels important again. The wrestler makes the belt, always, and this is a perfect example."
[8.0] "This was a great match. Kyle Fletcher has really found himself in the past year as a heel. His in ring work has excelled and his character work is top notch. Tomohiro Ishii is always great and can bring the fight to almost anyone. He was also the Strong Openweight Champion, so we had a champion vs champion match here. This was a fun bout, with Ishii giving Fletcher the heavy blows, but Fletcher was able to give back some heavy blows of his own. There was a brainbuster that Fletcher gave Ishii on the ring apron, which had to suck for him to take. After a powerbomb and a series of kicks to the corner, despite a clothesline from Ishii, Fletcher was able to get him up for another brainbuster to win the match. ****"
[5.0] "Pretty disappointing. Given the hot run Fletcher is on as a stooge heel, this match feels like a departure from that style of performance and it is worse for it. Instead of cowering and being cheap in the ways he gains control, he endures Ishii's bombs and comes back with some of his own. There'sa bit of great selling form Kyle (when Fletcher seems knocked loopy) and some meanness (like in the brain buster on the apron of the ring), even a piece of stalling. But it seems like Fletcher is wrestling an Ishii match instead of mixing his style in a complementary way with that of the Stone Pitbull."
[7.0] "This was a really good but somewhat prototypical Ishii match. Kyle Fletcher moves really quick and injected some speed and really solid selling to create a bit more tension than you usually get from an Ishii bout. Kyle Fletcher picked up the win with a Brainbuster after a really solid showing from both men. Worth a watch but maybe not one to seek out unless you particularly love the Ishii formula."
[8.0] "Excellent match as expected. Strangely I thought I'd like it a bit more even, but Fletcher kind of went back to his Ospreay-lite routine at times instead of the more fun heel character he has developed, but ultimately he hit a balance that still worked well for me. Ishii did as well as ever."
[8.0] "Terrific stuff, you can take Ishii out of the G1, but he still manages to have a prime G1 match elsewhere as Fletcher has an outstanding defense. ****."
[8.0] "Outstanding. From start to finish, this was nonstop physicality between two of the best wrestlers in the world. A New Japan Pro Wrestling style match in front of a hot AEW crowd. Tomohiro Ishii is nearly twice Kyle Fletcher's age, yet these two moved at a simultaneous breakneck speed in an absolutely THRILLING encounter. Professional wrestling in fine form. 4.25 stars, 8.5 out of 10."
[7.0] "Very good overall, though I wouldn't call it great. Felt a little long at times and I think having seen the Ishii formula a million times it doesn't hit for me as hard as others less used to him in New Japan. ***3/4"
[9.0] "Ishii is a timeless wonder. Kyle Fletchers rise to the top of AEW over the last few years has been unbelievable. Just an absolute slugfest of a match the brain buster on the apron to Ishii in particular was brutal. ****1/4"
[9.0] "First defense for Fletcher is a fucking banger. If this is a sign to come for this one, this is so fucking good. A banger with good signs to come"
[6.0] "Good first title defense. Despite the size difference, the offenses seemed credible, and the two styles worked well together. No suspense, but a decent performance to start the reign and the show. In-ring quality: 2/4. Stakes: 1.5/2. Justification: 1/1. Place on the card: 1/1. Suspense: 0/1. Bonuses/penalties: none. Total: 6.5/10. Match seen on AEW Plus."
[7.0] "Rock solid TV bout that probably could've done with being a tad more succinct. For every red-hot exchange there was either a dead spell or some tacky fighting spirit no-sell bullshit stinking the place up. Still Ishii's best singles outing of the year ***1/2"
[7.0] "(Grade:C+/***1/4) A very good opening match for Collison and Kyle Fletcher's 1st title defense against Tomohiro Ishii. Fletcher planting Ishii on the apron w/ a sheer-drop brain buster was gnarly and followed by a sweet diving elbow drop and Ishii kicked out at 2 was impressive. the last few moments of the match could've been shaved off but it good that both Fletcher looked strong against the stone pitbull. bonus goes for Paul Walter Hauser on commentary during this match."
[9.0] "Awesome TV match here, one of the best this year. A great story was told and the crowd was very heated for it. Fletcher is the best TV wrestler in the world."
[7.0] "[3.5*] Really good match. Yeah, they probably should've built Ishii a little bit better for this title match because even if the TNT Championship is an open-challenge belt, he only loses which makes his matches very predictable and "nonsense" kayfabe wise, specially the more competitive ones. If you ignore all of that, it's a very cool back-and-forth 50/50 match, with the classic fighting spirit puro spots that popped the crowd hugely. Tons of Brainbusters, Suplexes and all of that."
[9.0] "This match was fucking unbelievable Kyle was in his bag as was Big tom. This match was stiff as most people expected with so many big spots. It started with an excellent forearm battle with neither man giving an inch as they battered each other and it set the tone for the rest of the match as it was a true battle . Fletcher looked immense once again he really is becoming one of the best in the world the way he paces matches his look, the presence in the ring are all top tier. Big Tom looked great and was the best match he has had in an AEW ring for a long time (since the match with Hangman after all in last year) with some great strikes, headbutts and suplexs fighting from underneath against the younger Fletcher. The spot of the match was easily the Brain buster on the apron as it looked fucking brutal. The finish was great with Ishii refusing to give in as Kyle hit multiple running bots in the corner before finally getting the brain buster for the 3. Overall just a brilliant hard hitting match exactly what collision is all about with top performances from both men. Its an Ishii Summer. (****1/2)"
[7.0] "A good first defence for Kyle. I wish the crowd were more into this one but the work done here was still relatively good. Ishii works his style and Kyle sort of plays into it but also injects some of his great stooging and heel antics into the mix that have made him so fun to watch over the past 9 months. Not the greatest match stylistically, but still enjoyable nonetheless. ***1/2"
[6.0] "I'm so tired of Ishii's overall presence on aew shows but this match was definitely good. Fletcher has shown he can definitely bring much needed prestige to the tnt title with what looks to be an awesome title reigng. That title has been in hell for the longest time and we'll see what this reign does for it as we're off to a pretty promising start."
[7.0] "The main draw back of this match is Ishii has been beaten like a drum in AEW so why would I believe he is anything but a very talented job guy? Despite that significant draw back the match they had to get to inevitable result was very good."
[8.0] "Banger. Kyle Fletcher faced off against Tomohiro Ishii on collision for the first time around this time last and what a difference a year makes. Fletcher is so much more intense this time around and his believablilty is at an all time high. Ishii was firing in all cylinders and gave The Protostar some great moments. Already off a great start for Fletchers TNT title reign and I'm very excited to see who they're gonna put him up against at Forbidden Door. I'm hoping it's a certain legend on his retirement tour."
[9.0] "Wow, I thought this was gonna suck, but this was a great match. I'm starting to understand why people love Kyle Fletcher. Both of these guys were going nuts in this opening match."
[8.0] "Gotta give it a 8 because of rewatchability, probably a 8.5 this is better than a regular 8, enjoyed the hell out of it. Fletcher is great and has the best facial expressions in the game. Ishii is amazing."
[9.0] "Ishii doing what he does best, have great matches while making his opponents look like a million bucks. Ishii is the go to for solid title defenses and for Fletcher this is the second legend in a row he's faced win a great match."
[9.0] "I saw a comment on Twitter tonight, "every year Ishii wrestles a G1 match, no matter if he's in the tournament or not". And whereas his summer vacation last year was fun (such as the Gale match at RevPro), this was even better than the meeting the two lads had last year. What a way to kick off Fletcher as a fighting champion. The TNT championship has lost a bit of shine in comparison to the International as of late, but the Protostar with the gold (and hopefully soon, also pink) is going a long way to rehabilitating the belt."
[9.0] "Yet again, Ishii puts on a terrific TV match for AEW. His and Fletcher's styles meshed perfectly. They beat the hell out of each other, took a couple crazy bumps, and fired up at the perfect moments. That's also two weeks in a row of an awesome Kyle Fletcher title bout on Collision. It's crazy how versatile he is, as his performance in this match was completely different from his one against Dustin. Instead of playing the domineering heel, he tapped into a more sports-oriented style through his brawling with Ishii, all while seamlessly incorporating his quickness and striking. A terrific start to his title run ****1/2"
[9.0] "Fletcher vs. Ishii is a match where Kyle initially fails to control, at least not in the first half. They begin with an exchange of strikes, followed by lariats and counterattacks. It's interesting because this is the style Ishii dominates, but he gradually becomes overwhelmed by Fletcher, who manages to gain the advantage in the second half of the match thanks to his explosiveness. Excellent defense, the crowd created a good atmosphere"
[9.0] "Amazing match. This match was initially swayed toward Ishii. We saw a very strong style, some chops, lariats, suplexes, and plenty of kicks. Fletcher would then lead him into his territory, using his speed to his advantage. This really could be Ishii's best match in AEW, and surely one of the best defenses of the TNT Championship."
[8.0] "Great match and I'd even argue that this was Ishii's best match in AEW so far. Riding off the momentum of the Dustin match, Kyle Fletcher looked like an absolute star here and I think this is going to be the reign that sets the TNT Championship back on track."