[6.0] "A good stipulation for this feud but it overall wasn't really great. The wrestling part was good but story wise it was not. Bianca had a huge role in this and didn't do anything. Naomi should have won because she lost the WM match but they failed that. Not my favourite."
"Wanted to like this and no offense to these women, but this match needed that big breakaway wall from NXT. Haha It might be more over than these wrestlers. This reminded me of the bad stuff Jade did in AEW."
[7.0] "This was probably one of Cargill's better singles matches. I loved the finish to the match with Jade hitting her Jaded slam through the table for the win. You don't see that kind of match ending very often, so it felt like a big deal to see Jade hit a huge move like that. I expected Jade to win since she's in the WWE Women's Title match at SummerSlam, so it's the right move to give her momentum. Naomi was terrific in the match as the crazy heel who was on offense for a lot of it."
[4.0] "This was by far the worst match on the card and frankly the only bad match. Naomi and Jade's work , to put it bluntly, sucks. Everything they do is so obviously rehearsed and full of cooperation that I was actively cringing every few minutes. Jade is obviously still green but somehow Naomi was the one that dragged this match down especially with that stupid spot where she adjusted the trash can on herself when it was slipping off. And speaking of trash, I hate the spot (that is very common nowadays) where a wrestler decides to focus on throwing "weapons" in the ring and leave their opponent to have a f**king picnic. It's stupid. With that being said, all three women did try to make this feel like the end of their story. Naomi and Jade exhibited some viciousness that felt right for this match. And there were a couple of decent spots. But yeah I did not like this match. Their first one (although average) was better."
[7.0] "It seemed they were going for a classic brawl, but Cargill is way too slow to keep up with Naomi. So, while the match was good, it could have been better had Cargill puts some cardio in and not moved at the pace of a turtle. Probably Cargill's best match in the WWE so far as of 2025."
[4.0] "Imagine putting Naomi and Jade Cargill together in a fight. Obviously, you're going to end up with the worst fight of the night by far. Slow, with no good spots, and extremely boring. Bianca tried to add a bit of drama, but even then, it wasn't enough. For me, it's the only blemish on this event, which in my opinion was easily in the top 5 of the year in WWE."
[7.0] "A pretty solid No Disqualification Match that was probably one of Cargill's best matches ever. I was thinking this would go a bit longer, considering the history between these two. However, I don't know that I need to watch a 15-20+ minute Cargill match."
"I think the match was ok, nothing really fancy, despite the fact that it was a "No Holds Barred" type of match. It didn't went hardcore at all, as expected. But there was some good spot anyway, can't deny it."
[7.0] "Mostly a spot fest but a very fun spot fest. What I disliked about this match is how Bianca Belair didn't do anything to make it more exciting and by the end of the match I had forgotten that she was the referee completely."
[7.0] "Maybe I disliked Jade always winning and getting tired of this feud. But I admit I enjoyed this one, way better than their mania encounter. I liked the weapon usage from both sides, it felt sick and told a very good and effective story. That Jaded finisher from top on the table is so perfect, reminding me of the moment that Beth Phoenix glamslam on Eve Torres at Survivor Series 2011, so I gotta give Jade strong credit for this one, even the entire match is led by Naomi. [***1/2]"
[7.0] "This was a fun match it was a a bit too short tho wish they would've got more time but for the time given i thought they did a good job. Naomi has been killing it with this new character and Jade continues to improve i don't think she's as bad as ppl try to make her out to be."
[7.0] "Bianca as special guest ref didn't have much purpose being there from an actual storytelling standpoint, but this was still a solid brawl between both women with really decent action, spots and psychology between each other throughout it all, it was a step up from their WWE WrestleMania 41 (2025) match and it was a nice enough way to finally end their feud."
[7.0] "They deserve to get more time because for the 11 minutes match was just normal. Activity and extreme moments was good, but I feel like potential of that story a higher. Bianca almost do nothing and I don't understand why she is here."
[3.0] "The weakest match of the show by far. Jade, look-wise, is probably the perfect wrestler. But that's it. This match, along with many others, highlighted that just she doens't look comfortable inside the ring, as you can see the many times she seems lost on what to do next. Bianca as referee also added nothing to the match, so I don't really understood the reason for it also. The good part of the match was that they did some interesting spots, to say the least, like the dropkick to the announcer table and the camera spot. But the match never evolved from this, just going from isolated spot that looks cool to another till the underwhelming ending; both didn't even try to hit a move besides the occasional hit to keep the other stunned as they set up another spot with a weapon. As Naomi just threw everything at Jade, for her to counter and win of one move, this was easily one of the most dull and poor No DQ matches I've seen."
[5.0] "[2.5*] Unfotunately the 2nd worst match of the night while I was expecting it to be a MOTN Contender. I think at this point Jade will never get it 100% and honestly? That's fine for her aspirations. The only good thing about this match was the planned big spots but it lacked heat and rage."
[6.0] "This was a decent match but it was nothing too special at all. I didn't like how Naomi was destroying Jade throughout the entire match, only for Jade to hit her finisher through a table with no comeback at all to win. 3/5"
[5.0] "The night's weakest match to this point, overly relying on set-pieces after a chaotic angle the night prior. That aggression is traded in for plunder arrangement and such, hurting the match's pace and rhythm. Naomi's performance is good though, keeping this on track and getting things over the line safely. **1/2"
[7.0] "naomi is on fire. Not only is she the best heel in the wwe women's division but i'm safe in saying she may be the best heel in the entire industry today. This also is the best singles match in jades wwe career. But jade is also no where near where she is being placed on the roster right now. We are less then a month away from this women possibly being the wwe women's champion. That is a world i'm not ready to live in. 3.50 stars"
[7.0] "I've been loving Naomi's new heel persona following MITB, and this was a great showcase of that. Smartly cutting off the powerhouse offence of Jade at every corner delivering some brutal spots of her own. Enjoyed Bianca as guest referee, called it down the middle."
[4.0] "Well it was underwhelming knowing this was No Hold Barred. It will suffer, and for a good reason, to the no DQ match of 2018's Evolution match. And with this comparison, the match was really poor and bad. Very few violent spots, the pace was not there... I did not like it."
[6.0] "This was...good? No, good is a impressive word and this actually not deserve this. I can say this was entertaining, for sure. Jade Cargill using a fucking camera was funny, Naomi heel work has been great in ring and even better outside. Some stuff still annoyed me, like the poor selling of Cargill during the entire match. Also, why Bianca was the referee exactly? She didn't had any contact with the wrestlers here, really useless."
[7.0] "Very good, physical match that allowed both women to show their best qualities. Jade very much looked like a powerhouse here, and Naomi was wonderful as the scheming villain cutting her down at every corner. The spots were quite fun here, with the most notably being the fun explosion stunt with the monitor, and I also really enjoyed the finish... despite the camera work leaving a bit to be desired with everything they showed. Overall, I really liked this match, and it is probably Jade's best match for me to date."
[4.0] "This match didn't deliver the spots. Compared to the last Evolution's No DQ match, this failed miserably. We need more spots outside the ring, in the crowd, it'd be really fun like what Iyo & Rhea did."
[8.0] "I thought the match between these two at Mania was Jade's best to date - this one edges it out. Kudos to Naomi taking that finish, face first through the table looked gnarly. Jade took some bumps too. These two have good chemistry and when Naomi is champ, I expect them to run it back."
[6.0] "It was a match that had interesting spots and that knew how to use Jade's strengths well. if it had been longer than 15 or 20 minutes, it would have been better."
[4.0] "**3/4 decent match, one of Cargill's best 1 vs 1 matches, it could have been worse but the stipulation helped them hide their weaknesses, simple pace, they never got going well because they were constantly slow, simple spots, nothing unusual or complex, the only interesting one was Naomi's dropkick to Jade towards the table monitor, there were some slight botches and some lack of fluidity, normal ending with Jaded from the third to the table, Jade is not a champion material and no one can take me down from there."
[8.0] "I jumped when Naomi kicked the TV and it sparked all over the place. They beat the hell out of each other and that's all I ask for in these matches."
[3.0] "Honestly it was really not good for a No Holds Barred match, not enough physicality, very few violent spots, the addition of Bianca as referee did not bring anything to the match, we don't even have the impression that there was a real rivalry between the two it's a shame"
[4.0] ""It seems like the match wasn't held as a regular one to cover up the in-ring shortcomings of both competitors, but even so, their lack of performance was noticeable. Traditionally in pro wrestling, repeated head shots with weapons are portrayed as causing significant damage, but that wasn't the case in this match. Even Bianca's role as the special referee didn't feel particularly impactful."
[6.0] "Bit of a spot fest but for 10 minutes of throwaway carnage it was perfectly servicable. Naomi ate the pin and got her win back later in the night so both women came out of Evolution pretty well. Special referee once again proving to be an awful gimmick. Either Bianca gets involved in which case it's telegraphed or she doesn't and you wonder what the point of having her there was and tonight it was the latter. Guess it got her on the show?"
[7.0] "It was a good match. I expected Naomi to win, but that was okay because she made history later that night. I expected more from this match; I wanted to see what Bianca was going to do, especially with Jade. Overall, it was a 3.5"
[7.0] "Good match, better than their Mania match. Good addition to the rivalry. Felt it took a minute to get going, but it closed strong. Almost wish they had a few more minutes to capitalize on the place they got to down the stretch. With Jade having a title match next month and Naomi having MITB doesn't seem like we're done with these two, and I'm all for seeing more. 3.5 stars."
[6.0] "Well this was better than their mania match which was I did not enjoy. I mean it still was not great by any stretch of the imagination.Iit was entertaining don't get me wrong with some half way decent spots but it is a plunder match so is automatically somewhat interesting. This still was not that great though as bit slow and plodding at times. What was the point of the special guest ref as it added nothing to the match other than getting Bianca on the show. The finish was clunky as well and looked so awkward but it was a top rope face buster through a table so it was still cool. Overall all not the best thing I have ever seen definitely the weakest match on the card so far but a decent match if you compare it to the rest of Cargills work over the last couple years. (***)"
[6.0] "Thought this was a solid match. Bianca didn't add anything but I guess they wanted her on the show so whatever. My main problem with this is how slow everything was, in a NHB match things should feel rushed and like 2 people are actually trying to hurt each other and that just didn't come across here."
[7.0] "Naomi seems to be able to get the best out of Jade. Bianca being the special guest ref seemed to just be a way to get her on the show. Overall the match was a fun hard hitting plunder fest. Had its clunky moments but overall exceeded my expectations."
[6.0] "This was a decently fun no DQ match. I'm not a huge fan of Jade Cargill but I do love Naomi so it evened out. Jade got her ass kicked for most of it and then got the win which maybe should be the blueprint for her big matches."
[5.0] "Somewhat disappointed by this one, but still good with what we got here. The closing spot was R O U G H for Naomi. Bianca being there was mostly pointless. Decent enough overall."
[6.0] "This was solid. Better than their match at WrestleMania, the no holds barred stipulation allowed for more creativity and to cover up the in-ring weaknesses of Jade. Bianca being the special guest referee had no impact whatsoever, she wasn't needed here. It's a typical WWE style plunder match with some weapons being used along with a couple of table spots. Naomi got a lot of offense in, dominating Jade who to her credit took some rough looking bumps. Jade wins with a Jaded off the top rope through a table, which looked good. 6/10"
[7.0] "A solid match thanks to Naomi because Jade once again did nothing during 85% of the match except take the bump and woke up at end to make her finisher and win."
[6.0] "Maybe this rating is too harsh but this was definitely the worst match of the night. Naomi did her best to make this match feel extreme with some interesting spots like when she drove the leg of the chair into jades eye. This match needed 5 more minutes and some bigger spots. Still not convinced of Jade as a performer, very much a one trick pony. Biancas involvement felt unnecessarily minimal for someone who was introduced as referee in a big way on SNME."
[5.0] "I think Naomi is pretty good and Jade has unlimited potential, but this match just didn't hit in my opinion. The finish was cool, but the stipulation didn't add much. They utilized the stipulation, but it didn't do much for me. I think Jade has a lot of work to do, but she does seem to look better each match."
[8.0] "I am shocked that this match is being rated relatively lower on the scale from others. I thought that this was the second best match on a stacked PLE behind only the main event. I thought that the spots were great. The moves felt personal. The monitor spot was great and looked scary. I did feel the ending was kind of abrupt and that Bianca did not do much as the special guest referee other than some looks of concern, but other than that I thought this was a great match."
[6.0] "I think this match especially initially was treated too harshly. There were some cool spots here and Naomi shined pretty well, but I do feel like if this match ever had a fault it lies in the emotions behind it feeling way too one sided for a blood feud no holds barred match. Naomi kind of held all the emotion and the finish left me feeling a lot left to be desired, which is unfortunate because I was really really looking forward to this match but in the end it was okay. Nothing wrong with. I swear some people act like Jade Cargill is the worst wrestler of all time. While I agree that she may be pushed too soon into the main event scene, she is nowhere near the 1-3/10s thrown at her often"
[6.0] "Creative match, but probably the worst of the night. A bit slow and some spots weren't that impressing. They both did ok, but the finissh where we can see Naomi talking to Jade threw me off. A good match to solidify Jade even more, though I'm not sure if she's completely ready."
[4.0] "The stipulation helped to hide some of both women's shortcomings, but still was not a good match. A very slow-paced spotfest, with many spots especially the finisher looking too choreographed with Naomi stepping up to the top rope while talking to Jade."
[7.0] "[3, 5 Stars] It was better than at Wrestlemania, but I found the match a little too short, and the end spot was a little less impressive than expected. (***, 5)."
[7.0] "Thought this was good from Jade, i would have thought a Ambulande match would have been better given the story, and now that Naomi just cashed it, its just like Seth Rollins cashing in on Wrestlemania, this was good, and Jade for me has been improving and improving each week."
[6.0] "I think this match had the potential to be either the best match of Jade Cargill's career or a total disaster, and it happens that stayed on the middle ground, neither here or there, but it was a good match, clearly not so violent as you can naturally expect from a No Holds Barred, but some spots were cool, like the tables breaking and the commentary desk exploding. The ending was really good, a typical Jade Cargill finish, all of the sudden but impactful, with the Jaded from the top rope through the table, that made she win the match, overall a positive one - {**3/4}"
"7.5, the match were fun and great. I loved seeing Bianca there doing the sideeyes and than getting emotive on some spot and i wondered if she would strike one of them. Jade is probably the best IT Factor wrestling in the business i'd love her to do more POWER MOVES, Naomi have a great gimmick and fun to watch in ring."
1x
1x
24x
156x
179x
71x
27x
4x
1x
0x
0x