DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?

Bret Hart vs. Shawn Michaels

Match

Match Data
Date:
31.03.1996
WON rating:
****1/4
Match type:
7​.97
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 491
Number of comments: 169
10.0 83x
9.0 127x
8.0 131x
7.0 80x
6.0 35x
5.0 11x
4.0 11x
3.0 7x
2.0 1x
1.0 2x
0.0 3x
Average rating: 7.97  [491]
Average rating in 2026: 7.65  [62]
Average rating in 2025: 7.86  [77]
Average rating in 2024: 8.25  [73]
Average rating in 2023: 7.84  [58]
Average rating in 2022: 7.95  [42]
Average rating in 2021: 8.05  [37]
Average rating in 2020: 7.53  [19]
Average rating in 2019: 7.57  [14]
Average rating in 2018: 8.83  [18]
Average rating in 2017: 7.80  [10]
Average rating in 2016: 7.94  [18]
Average rating in 2015: 8.56  [9]
Average rating in 2014: 8.91  [11]
Average rating in 2013: 8.17  [6]
Average rating in 2012: 7.00  [1]
Average rating in 2011: 8.00  [3]
Average rating in 2010: 9.25  [8]
Average rating in 2009: 7.33  [6]
Average rating in 2008: 7.63  [19]
Your Options:
Other:
vanoodie wrote on 15.10.2026:
[5.0] "the last 30 minutes or so was pretty ok, but the lead up was a bit too long and boring. some pinfalls wouldve made this a bit more exciting even tho itll lose its "unique" status of being a "pinfall-less" 60 minute iron man match."
Jamildo2 wrote on 25.09.2026:
[7.0] "Being honest, I'm really struggling to rate this one. As a piece of work, as a piece of wrestling lore, I can see why people love it.The match feels ahead of its time in a lot of ways. BUT... for large parts this was a little boring. The first half an hour was a slog where Shawn and Bret seemed to be playing for time, the final third picked up a little but the decision to not have any falls at all feels a little strange in hindsight. Half of this match wasn't telling a story, it was just a string of rest holds and rests on the outside. I'm being negative and I don't want to be, because it was good. But 5 star good? Not for me. 7.5/10"
PhillyHarden wrote on 13.08.2026:
[10.0] "Genius. A legitimate bell-to-bell masterpiece, like having four or five great matches in one. If professional wrestling is the art form of two men telling a story using only their bodies as instruments, then this is the equivalent to Beethoven's Ninth or Moby Dick. You may not hang on every note or word, but something happens on every page to keep you deeply invested. It's almost something you can't put words to. For one hour (plus) in Anaheim, two of the very best made magic. Like if you could sit over the shoulder of the author writing the first great American novel. Every great match from this point onward took elements from this."
Benzo92 wrote on 31.07.2026:
[3.0] "An absolute slog with no drama for 95% of it. If the match was wrestled the exact same way between two guys who don't have the (well earned) reputations that Shawn and Bret do people would unanimously shit all over it. I was so excited to watch this back in the day having been told it's a classic - it isn't. I've watched it several times over the years to see if my mind changes and it's somehow more dull every time, each rest hold seems to last a little longer each time too. It holds up particularly poorly with Iron Man's like Lesnar/Angle and MJF/Danielson being in a different stratosphere in terms of quality but it wasn't good for its time either, there's a reason why people have never been able to settle on whether it's any good or not. And in my opinion it very, very much isn't, probably my least favourite big match from either guy and by far the most overrated match ever (by those who actually rate it highly)."
EvieSonicFan124 wrote on 06.07.2026:
[10.0] "[5.0*] 5 stars. if you haven't look at the story of shawn michaels' redemption, check this out. shawn had a hell of a 1995. he failed to win the world title form his best friend diesel at the wrestlemania after winning the royal rumble at #1, then he was the choice to become king of the ring 1995, but failed to do it due to a time limit draw. then won the intercontinental championship for the third time after beating jeff jarrett in a damn classic ic title match. then summerslam, he beated razor ramon in a epic sequel ladder match at summerslam! then reunited with diesel to win tag titles, then...shawn got attacked in a bar. then shawn won his second royal rumble by eliminating his own best friend diesel, then put his contendership on the line against owen hart to get to wrestlemania. 1 HOUR OF FULL MADNESS, you could feel the emotion, the desperation in this match thorough, then he finally did it! SWEET CHIN MUSIC! THE BOYHOOD DREAM HAS COME TRUE! it took shawn a year to get to this gold after setbacks in 1995. this match will forever be the night: wrestlemania 12 that the heartbreak kid would live up to shawn michaels' name."
tall4life wrote on 25.05.2026:
[8.0] "What a hard match to rate. Saying it's 20 minutes of rest holds and headlocks is understating it, its close to 45 minutes. There is a nice story told throughout of HBK trying to prove that he can mat wrestle just as well as Bret can, leading to some surprising counters and turnarounds. Once that last 15-20 minutes hit all hell breaks loose and suddenly the offense is frenetic enough to build tremendously well to the tie finish into overtime. Suffering through the rest holds is rough, but if you can make it past that, you are rewarded very well."
WrestleChaos wrote on 16.05.2026:
[10.0] "Amazing match. They got through it without losing a bit, no botvhes, and amazing storytelling. I mean, they told the story perfectly, and I loved that none scored a pinfall untill the end, telling that they were so equal, and knew each other so well. Amazing."
DaWay wrote on 30.03.2026:
[4.0] "Technically the first ever iron man match, and I can see why a lot of people love it. A chance to show everyone the storytelling potential of this brand-new stipulation! ....so why did neither of them gain a single fall within the hour? A brilliant final five minutes, and a wonderful sudden death with Shawn Michaels completing the boyhood dream, but for these two, a shocking dud. A lot of people go into this match with the idea that we've got Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels, two phenomenal workers who deservingly get all their flowers, wrestling for 60 minutes, which, on paper, HUZZAH! But on execution, gang, I'm sorry, but it's just so boring. **"
DrewVogelaar1 wrote on 28.03.2026:
[8.0] "I do agree with the sentiment that maybe we could have had a pinfall or two apiece from both competitors during the match. On the other hand, having Piper announce there has to be a winner and getting more wrestling out of two fantastic wrestlers is pretty freaking cool. Both guys sell the hell out of this match, Shawn flies a few times, and Bret takes some serious bumps. I also don't know if it was planned, but as Bret walks off, somebody perfectly throws a Canadien flag on him, and it's actually hilarious cause he seems to be pissed. This match is also a significant improvement over the previous five WrestleMania main events."
goldenbasket wrote on 25.03.2026:
[6.0] "Some very great moments and to wrestle for 60 minutes is incredible. There are just too many skipable parts which lower the rating of this match. Also having only 1 fall in an iron match makes no sense"
Rhasta wrote on 22.03.2026:
[3.0] "Speaking in kayfabe, how shit are these 2 guys that they can't beat a single person in a whole freaking hour? Either they're incompetent or so good that you need an hour to beat them, which buries the entire roster who lose in 5-20 minutes. Outside of kayface, it's just not a compelling match. It's an hour boring slog to sit through. Having only 1 pinfall the entire match was a colossal mistake and a big reason why this match sucks."
WG20 wrote on 21.03.2026:
[6.0] "Whilst I understand the importance of this match the fact they wrestled for an hour with no pinfalls or submissions was an odd choice, given the 2 individuals involved. This match was fine too much stalling in parts I am in the boat of this match being overrated."
Sweet Fighter V wrote on 10.03.2026:
[9.0] "As if a WrestleMania main event between Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels for the WWF title wasn't already special, they decide to make it extra special by having them in the first ever (televised) Iron Man match. On top of that, you get Shawn's iconic zip line entrance, so yeah; EXTRA special. Even something as simple as the referee giving instructions puts the importance of the match over significantly. Putting together such a match is such a bold decision knowing how daring the stipulation can be. But if anyone could ever make it work, it's most definitely these two. Of course it tends to drag a bit, but they manage to maintain a certain sense of urgency that keeps the match alive throughout. It's a masterful piece of psychology and methodical pacing with excellent mat work, flawless execution, good impact, great drama. The selling of the limb work is a bit spotty, but they sell the grueling nature of the match better than any other 60-minute match I have ever seen. This, along with the two going the distance with neither man being able to pin or submit the other, therefore forcing a sudden death overtime, is perfection. Bret locking in the Sharpshooter with 30 seconds remaining makes for an utterly brilliant false finish. Him going right back after Shawn's back in overtime only for Shawn to hit a Sweet Chin Music out of nowhere before hitting another one for the win is glorious. This is unlike anything the company ever produced before, and it's indeed special. ****1/2"
Sadagious wrote on 03.03.2026:
[9.0] "Historical match. Shawn Michaels' entrance is one of the most iconic entrances of all time. This is a WrestleMania Moment. Bret says he knows all of Shawn's weaknesses and that he will be on him at the first mistake he makes, placing the traumatic pressure of the loss at Survivor Series 1992 onto Shawn. Bret's arrogance makes him think Shawn is still the rookie he defeated 4 years ago, but from the very first minutes Shawn establishes superiority over Bret in a mat game and proves to him that he is no longer the same man, that he has climbed the mountain step by step. Shawn throwing Bret to the outside with a headscissors and Bret's self-frustrated reaction is the moment he realizes Shawn is not the old Shawn. Yet, Bret is still the one who throws the first punch. This also shows that Bret cannot establish superiority over Shawn purely through technique and strategy, so he seeks an alternative path; the physiological & psychological superiority Shawn builds pushes Bret to act almost like a heel, to perform increasingly desperate german suplexes, belly to belly suplexes and even a suicide dive. Every gained move is determined by a slight difference in speed or power. Learned psychology is an extraordinarily effective narrative tool in the match; Bret applies a headlock, Shawn escapes with a headscissors, Bret applies a headscissors again and when Shawn tries it once more Bret moves his head away. Or when Shawn applies a sleeper, Bret backs him into the corner; Shawn applies the sleeper again, and when Bret backs up again Shawn drives his head into the corner. Shawn's concentration on not making mistakes throughout the match is visible when he crawls to the ropes as Bret tries to lock in the Sharpshooter. Shawn, falling into the same psychology Bret once did, performs moves not in his repertoire like a gutwrench suplex and hurricanrana, and in the last minute he loses his composure so much that, just like Survivor Series 1992, he leaps and gets caught in the Sharpshooter, but time runs out... restart, a very logical finish under these conditions. Masterclass storytelling, psychology and details. As a result, a WrestleMania Main Event I once disliked, but now find wonderful especially for its narrative texture and psychological foundation. ****"
Raditz Flair wrote on 19.02.2026:
[6.0] "It's shockingly slow and plodding, even for a match slated for an hour. Flair and Steamboat did 55 minutes 2 out of 3 falls and there was never a slow moment. Don't get me wrong, Bret and Shawn are amazing but Flair and Steamboat are 2 of 2 and superior workers because they had better psychology. Someone else pointed out the limb work and it meant nothing later on. The way the match was structured was flawed too. For some reason they split 30 minutes between Shawn and Bret dictating the pace instead of back and forth. Not terrible but not underrated either."
SebasDiaz wrote on 19.02.2026:
[10.0] "This match is badly underrated by most of the fans I feel like this is a match that shows how great Bret and Shawn were and why they were the biggest in the New Generation Era, no one on that era in all WWF could've done this match, starting low and preparing in Low fire to what came later, Shawn and Bret didn't stop for an hour, after knowing Bret and Shawn planned all this in some minutes, and the crowd also putting in the atmosphere for the ending, sudden Death and Shawn new champion, Amazing. 10/10 [*****]"
SkyIcons wrote on 15.12.2025:
[3.0] "I am on the side of people who think this match is overrated. 60 minutes of nothing. I can deal with long matches, but the talents have to do things to keep me invested, and these 2 fail to do that. Shocking lack of psychology on display. The 25+ minutes of limb work don't affect a single thing. Nothing feels consequential. The moves and whatnot aren't the problem, of course it's all executed well, it's everything else. Best part about this is the call from Vince after Shawn wins. The boyhood dream did indeed come true, even if it happened in a pretty bad match."
TrailsOfPersona wrote on 04.12.2025:
[4.0] "Easily one of the most overrated matches of all time. In my opinion, the only way to watch this match is to watch it at double speed. Either that, or you need to have the flexibility to do a lot of fast-forwarding. They really only had enough material for a 20 minute match. 30 at best. The first 5 minutes establishes it with some good wrestling. The following 25 are extended rest holds. So about half the match can be tossed away just like that. A little after the 30 minute mark they start breaking out some of the better spots of the match, and the bout gets good for 10-15 minutes. Then we go back to rest holds until about the final 10 minutes where it goes back to being very good. This is an iron man match surely out of pretentiousness. It's not downright abysmal, but it's easily the worst match these two had against each other. It's one of the worst Wrestlemania matches both of them have ever had too. Probably not the worst for either, but close. A bloated snore of a match that can't measure up comparative to ANY of the all time great matches they both had past and future."
DexterMorgan wrote on 20.11.2025:
[10.0] "One of the best iron man matches of all time between shawn and Bret . Great match , great chemistry, great performance and great moments. {*****}."
Anorak wrote on 06.10.2025:
[6.0] "I didn't find this boring or tedious, but I did find it ridiculously underwhelming and also somewhat frustrating. Be it the lack of selling the earlier limb work, the hilariously convoluted ways both men avoided using their finishers and worse still the really underwhelming finish. It doesn't help when Lawler calls both men idiots when they go to the outside to break 10 counts. Only mid 90s Vince could get two of the all time greats and give them a stipulation which makes them both look poor to the viewer, I totally get that having zero falls may give the illusion to the viewer that both men are strong, but the only takeaway I had was that Shawn was lucky and Bret was a moron...not really selling either of your top two guys imo."
Ajay00329 wrote on 22.09.2025:
[8.0] "Well many people do have mix feelings and I understand that. The big issue of this match is that the match provides multiple falls yet this match has a single fall in 61 minutes, both Shawn and Bret have made this match work, but it would have been better if there were falls involved, like atleast 3-3 before Michaels wins in overtime. But yeah this shows the capability of both men that they can wrestle 60 minutes, pure Wrestling without any bullshit like weapons, interference or anything and the ending is forever a pure wrestlemania moment. But still I wish this match had multiple falls involved. Still a great match"
Oniquon wrote on 31.07.2025:
"So egregiously overrated. The only good thing about this match is the end. Very boring for the first 60 minutes."
atayguitar wrote on 09.06.2025:
[7.0] "I have some issues with the pacing, which was predictable due to the length of the match. I certainly award it points for not putting me to sleep as a large part of the match is deliberate, strategic technical moves and wearing out of limbs. But it's done superbly well. I think they did a pretty good job with the imperfect idea of the Iron Man match."
ksr31 wrote on 07.06.2025:
[6.0] "Very overrated match. These two had better matches together. This match went long just for the sake of going long. Going zero pinfalls for an hour hurt this match. Michaels worked for 20 min on bret's arm with bret no selling it immediately with a shoulder tackle that sends Michaels outside. Good thing was Shawn Michaels entrance in the match."
Causeahazard wrote on 30.04.2025:
[5.0] "Cutting the 30 minutes of submissions and rest holds out of it a pretty decent match minus Shawn's decision to go after Hart's arm for 15 minutes for no pay-off. Definitely needed a fall or two to keep the crowd in it cause they just looked bored as hell. The scale and build of this match cannot be overlooked because it was incredible and that might be the greatest Wrestlemania entrance ever. ** 3/4"
KKeanel wrote on 25.04.2025:
[7.0] "The way how they spread their cardio boundaries through the whole match was pretty disappointing. Two third of the bout was just forgettable because of endless locks on head or legs. Finally after "Sudden death" rule activation whole action aqccuired some emotions and intense, what eventually gave Michaels a W."
niclaswrestling wrote on 16.04.2025:
[8.0] "Bret Hart vs Shawn Michaels for the WWF Championship in a 60 Minute Iron Man Match: WOAH. What a special match on paper. In reality? A polarising match with special moments... But also weaknesses. Look, what both of these men were able to achieve here deserves all kind of applause. Wrestling for over an hour straight? Amazing! But that doesn't change the fact that this match is reeeally difficult to sit through without getting bored here and there. The first half hour especially drags on FOREVER. Rest hold after rest hold after rest hold. You were watching and hoping for an out of nowhere pinfall, but that just simply didn't happen. Yes, the match picked up steam as it went on, and The Finale with the Sudden Death and crowning moment for Michaels was INCREDIBLE. Was the idea to have only one pinfall and that all the way at the end both good and bad? Definitely, as you weren't able to use pinfalls for tensions throughout the match, while keeping that one pinfall till the end made it that much more special. At the end of the day, this is without a doubt a very well worked match between two all time greats, and easily one of the best closing moments of any Wrestlemania in history. But its also clear that the match did NOT need to go one hour, and it would have benefited everybody to just make this a 30 Minute Iron Man Match instead. That way you can cut out a lot of the filler, and only focus on the magic. With all that being said, this remains an INCREDIBLE Main Event that deserves recognition despite its weaknesses. It's not perfect, and less would have been more, but it's still something special, and without a doubt the best Wrestlemania Main Event at that point in history! (8/10)"
RPMX123 wrote on 12.04.2025:
[6.0] "i get it, it's the first of its kind, pacing yourself for an hour is probably the hardest thing a pro wrestler can do, but they could've thought this out a little better. why the hell would you have no pinfalls or submissions at all in the FIRST iron man match, surely you'd want to use that stipulation's potential to the fullest. have shawn win a fall by sweet chin music, give them both 2 or 3 minutes to sell, then get back to it. have bret tap out shawn, another 2 minutes of selling. it would give the crowd SOMETHING to pop for. that woulda been better than fuckin 25 minutes of rest holds. the memorable spots are good like shawn kicking the timekeeper, the dive to bret on the outside, the piledriver i guess, shawn getting yeeted into the steel steps and the ending sharpshooter spot but that's only about 5 minutes of action in a 60 minute fucking match. i'll give it ***3/4 as a match but 6 for personal enjoyment"
new era lover wrote on 11.04.2025:
[6.0] "30 minutes of the match were absolutely atrocious like so bad, nothing happened at all bro. Second part was decent stuff but who makes an iron match with 0 pinfalls like common man what the f am i watching here for an hour. Although i think Shawn is pretty good in the ring"
li0nsault wrote on 07.04.2025:
[8.0] "I finally gave this one a try! To say that the first 30 minutes are not for everyone would be an understatement, as you only see holds. They manage to do different ones every time, but this lasts half an hour... I can see this being a masterclass for wrestlers, but the majority of fans won't enjoy this, and I admit I was bored at times. Action is faster during the next 20 minutes, quite good match, but I dare to say nothing crazy. There were some fun spots like Shawn kicking someone at ringside, and Jose Lothario taking some bumps, but that's pretty much it. The final 10 minutes are the most exciting part of the match, some good nearfalls and so. The match ends in a time limit draw, but continues anyway (sudden death), and you close the show with HBK finally winning the big one, historic moment definitely. Is there any problem? We got 0 falls during the whole 60 minutes, and that's a BIG letdown for the first iron man match in history... I wouldn't give this one 5 stars, but I respect the work, and it was nowhere near bad. But yeah, it had some serious booking mistakes that will make this even unwatchable for some people."
IsThisWrestling wrote on 05.04.2025:
[6.0] "Ultimately this is not a great match by any stretch of the imagination. It's not bad at all either, but beyond the historical significance, this match doesn't bring that much to the table. The crowd is largely uninterested. 60 minutes without a fall in the "first-ever" Iron Man match is obnoxious. It's just OKAY, but it could have been so much better. Vince is sucking HBK off sooooo hard on commentary that it becomes comical. There was no attempt made to hide that Shawn would leave with the belt. Bret is treated like an afterthought. The idea that an hour long wrestling match was in any way unique or revolutionary is such a Vince-brain way of thinking. Very far from "five stars"."
Gravelord wrote on 04.04.2025:
[7.0] "I've seen it called the most overrated match of all time and I've seen it called the underrated overrated match of all time. The point is, this is definitely one of the more polarizing matches in WWE history. I myself fall somewhere in the middle; it wasn't bad, but it wasn't good either. I'd probably call it decent and disappointing. The first because it does have its moments, particularly during the second half of the matches. And I'd call it the latter because it could have been much better had it been laid out differently. The biggest problem I had was the first thirty minutes; simply put, they were not at all interesting and if the match continued at that glacial pace I'd have come away thinking it was a very bad match. I understand the psychology of starting out slow, but they could have at least thrown some more exciting spots and sequences to keep things from being so dull. The story of Michaels trying to beat Bret at his own game by out-wrestling him was interesting on paper, but nothing ultimately amounted from it so I came away feeling like my time had been wasted for the first thirty. HBK relentless targeted Bret's left arm, but it went nowhere as it gets dropped in the second half of the match and Bret simply stops selling it. Had they actually had some falls throughout the match, it could have worked better with Michaels capturing a fall off of a submission on the left arm. Things did pick-up in the second half once Bret began to take control of the bout; the two exchanged nearfalls during the thirty-to-twenty minute mark before Bret was able to capture the advantage after Irish whipping Michaels over the top right turnbuckle, leading to him 'injuring' his back. Bret's work on the back was much more satisfying to watch than was Shawn's earlier targeting of the arm as Bret is just much better at isolating parts. He really goes to work on it using a combination of moves, but gives Michaels enough hope spots to stop things from ever feeling dull. The pace gradually quickened during the last ten minutes before the time expired as Bret seemed poised to win with his signature Sharpshooter. Gorilla Monsoon then screws Bret by ordering the match to restart under sudden death rules after Bret had already released the Sharpshooter. Seriously, this was supposed to come off as a big babyface triumph by HBK but he just came off as having got lucky to me as Bret clearly had him beat if it wasn't for the time expiring. Anyway, to cut a long story short, this would have been better had both guys managed to score one or two falls on the other. You could have still done sudden death to make both guys appear as evenly matched, but it would have allowed for the limb work to ultimately mean more and reward my investment as a viewer if it lead to a decision either way. Overall, a pretty good bout that will continue to elicit a wide variety of opinions but one worth watching just because of its importance in the career of two of the most influential wrestlers of all time. ***1/4"
fantoy wrote on 04.04.2025:
[5.0] "The match is not a great success, it is long, slow, no chemistry between two wrestlers who hate each other. Shawn Michaels is clearly inferior to Bret Hart from a technical point of view but this was the case for practically all wrestlers and the vast majority of times Bret was good enough that it did not show and even managed to make his opponent look better than he was. This is not the case here, Bret spends his match belittling Michaels and making him look much worse than he was. Michaels is not in the shape of his life, and is not capable of raising his level while in other moments of his career he could. The end of the match, if it has the merit of "protecting" Bret, is not a great booking. In the end, this match is rather the symbol and the true beginning of the demotion of the WWF in favor of WCW. Shawn wasn't ready to be champion, he should never have been, he had too many problems at that time...Bret was able to put over almost single-handedly (even if Vince McMahon's work should not be neglected) Stone Cold Steve Austin who would become the real big star of the federation."
Wrestlingfan0808 wrote on 15.03.2025:
[9.0] "A pretty ambitious match at the time involving to of your best workers in the company at the time. There a lot of bright spots in this match, primarily the closing stretch. But to do an iron man match where no one takes a pin fall? A bit much. Wasn't ideal having Bret work a match like this either since he isn't your typical moves kind of wrestler which is also fine like I said, not ideal for him in this setting. No idea what the general consensus is regarding this match but I still like it quite a bit because of daring this match for the time they did it. Doesn't hurt seeing one of your favs achieve his ultimate goal by becoming the champ either. ****1/4"
AndyUK wrote on 09.03.2025:
[8.0] "It's good with some great moments rather than great. Shawn's title win is an epic moment though. I don't think I'd ever give it less than an 8 but on the flip side I find hour long matches to often be a contrived attempt at creating an epic anyway where there are numerous spots designed to waste time and it takes me out of it a little. I think the Iron Man stipulation was designed to make that feel a bit more natural as you can have the breather in between falls, but because fo the lack of falls in this it's more like the former. Still good though."
fablezzzz wrote on 14.02.2025:
[9.0] "I was told by British youtubers that this match is too long, boring, not good, and overrated. They are blatantly lying to your face and circle jerking the narrative to the community. I find Bret Hart to be the most overrated wrestler in the history of the industry, yet I thought this was a masterful match, despite it going 0 falls for an hour. It's incredible. Shawn Michaels and Bret Hart truly did something special that night and I appreciate it so much for what it is. [4.75]"
CMFunk007 wrote on 13.02.2025:
[9.0] "At the time, this was a fresh new idea. They still don't have a ton of iron man matches. Usually just 1 hour Kenny Omega draws. But Bret and Shawn couldn't have a bad match together if they tried. I'm not sure I liked the no falls within an hour, because why an iron man match? You could have had the same result in a regular match. This si also around the time that Vince McMahon started his obnoxious, "1-2-3 and he got him! No! " commentary. But I still enjoyed this clinic they put on."
igskillfart wrote on 12.02.2025:
[3.0] "(2.75* Yeah this just didnt click with me, the first 10 minutes of the match was pretty good, very technical, Brets attack on the head and Shawns work on the arm was smartly done, however the way they delivered it was terrible, first off Shawns arm work was pretty awkward, Shawn also stopped selling the head damage Bret has did, and we cant forget the most obvious is that Bret no selling the arm work Shawn was working, this match was just boring, everything felt rushed and no emotion what so ever, it was just like a ok lets go to this spot, sell and lets go to the next, Especially during the last 5 minutes what Shawn was doing, the 0-0 score was stupid, the first pinfall should have been where Bret hit the piledriver on Michaels, but they decided to keep on going and I can see why fans were leaving, a very rushed and boring match and two of the best wrestlers couldn't even pull off a good match, a disappointment that should not be rewatched even if its nostalgic."
Luna100 wrote on 09.02.2025:
[3.0] "Sorry to say but I found this to be really long and dull match with to little of a peak, it also feels like a waste of a stipulation since it ends in a fall less draw, and just ends in sudden death, just very anti-climatic. I do not recommend this match really, their ambition just doesn't come off and is disappointing. Writing this review of the match is quite annoying as I do not have a large amount of things to say about this match, but I also want an accurate review. But yeah don't watch *1/2"
charlierosegold wrote on 07.02.2025:
[7.0] "Sometimes I think about what these guys could have accomplished together if they didn't hate each other, or maybe even if the company they were employed under didn't exacerbate that hatred for what one would assume would be for profit (even though the hatred might have lost them money long term). Even in the extreme short scale of this match, could we have had a 1-1 tie instead of a 0-0? As it stands, this is the best wrestled boring match possible. A feat of the era, and dull as hell. My hot transgender wife (fat) was pretty into this as she didn't know the results, but by the end she was pretty mad at the format. Oh well, last ninety seconds rules, boyhood dream or whatever, still excellent."
Spitora wrote on 23.12.2024:
[4.0] "I don't think this ages well at all tbh. It felt like it didn't need to be 60 minutes long and that there was a lot of fluff and filler that dragged because they needed to fill in the void of the entire 60 minutes. It also doesn't help that there were no pin fall victory for the entirety of the iron man match. I understand that you can say they're trying to tell a story, but the story for me unfortunately was boring and dull. I don't think I'd be able to rewatch this match and if I were to recommend someone this match, I'd just tell them to skip to like the final 2 minutes or so since I feel like everything before that didn't matter too much."
SweetGuyEddie wrote on 20.07.2024:
"I like iron-man matches, I love Bret, and I haven't seen many Shawn Michaels matches, but I like what I have seen. I wanted to love this match, and I honestly kinda did until I thought about it some more. The match was well worked and I was engaged for most of it, though it does have a lot of time filling spots in it. That alone won't drop my opinion of the match though. What makes me go from potentially loving the match to just liking it is that I think it failed to capitalize on its format. I didn't buy most, if any, of the pin attempts by Bret or Shawn, and, with no pins in the iron-man portion, the match just does not have the key elements of an iron-man match. There are no surprise pins, there is no tension from watching the gap between scores fluctuate, and I didn't really feel like either Bret or Shawn came across as desperate until the very end. All the things that give iron-man matches a sense of suspense are not really in this match. It honestly felt like they were more focused on having a sixty minute match, and didn't care about the iron-man stipulation, but it doesn't make for the most compelling sixty minute draw either. Even the sudden death portion didn't light me on fire, and the finish didn't really do anything for me. Still, I liked the story they were telling in the match, and the actual wrestling was good throughout. If that's all you need, I think this match is a success. For me, it's a good match, but one that I think could have been far better if they really played into the stipulation they were given."
Johan wrote on 30.06.2024:
[10.0] "Probably the most divisive match of all time, I'm in the opinion it's an all time classic, these two tried to achieve what Ric Flair did every other month and you know what? they failed! but I turn they achieved something else, the classic technical match, the concept of two faces being completely lost in a match and putting on a generational classic in my eyes, they achieved something that was greater in my eyes and that was making wrestling feel like a legitmate sport, an all time classic in my eyes [*****]"
ReedPryorNY wrote on 26.06.2024:
[8.0] "Really important match that represented a grassroots evolution for the company. In a smaller arena, at a time when the WWF was struggling, Shawn Michaels and Bret Hart put themselves out there for 1 hour for the fans to see. There were obvious potshots, from Vince McMahon on commentary (isnt it ironic), and with Shawns attitude throughout the match. However, having seen the match again last night, I found myself focusing on how beautiful the story was leading into the finish. It was a Bret Hart match through and through, capped off with the final climatic minute in the Sharpshooter when everyone in the arena got to their feet. With the sudden death overtime, the finish could have been cheapened, but these two rose above it to leave you on a cliffhanger that sadly, never got answered in 1997. Still, as a feat of athleticism and going against the grain of quick hit satisfaction, this match does stand the test of time. Worth a revisit for fans who love this time in the business, and the arch of these two artists. ****1/2"
RealGrapsThomsen wrote on 21.05.2024:
[8.0] "This was a pretty good match. The in ring work was amazing and the psychology was spot on. My only complaint with this is how neither man tried to pin the other for the first half hour! It was rest hold after rest hold after rest hold, leading to a time limit draw. That last few minutes of Sudden Death was amazing however, had me on the edge of my seat, and Shawn got his crowning moment."
muchomichaelmike wrote on 21.05.2024:
[9.0] "****3/4 / It wasn't slow it was methodical, and with two of the most methodical/dramatic wrestlers we've ever seen it was bound to be a classic. I agree with the sentiment that having the time limit run out is a little pointless but the crowd was engaged from bell to bell, and bell to bell again. I would've liked some more in overtime but after an hour of as grueling a match as they had you kind of just have to take what you're given at face value. This is/was an instant classic that will be remembered forever."
leonconnelly652 wrote on 09.05.2024:
[5.0] "Shame these two never had that great match this just isn't it, lots of dull time wasting holds. Imagine if these two had 30 minutes to just go all out in this match this would have been an all time classic. Whoevers decision it was to go an hour without a fall needed to be fired like that ruins the whole premise of the match what's the point if you not gonna go back and forth with who's winning you may as well have just had a normal match. There's still some good stuff you could edit this match into a nice highlight reel as wwe constantly does"
MarkMcMarkington2 wrote on 05.05.2024:
[7.0] "I can see why many people love this match but it just feels like a drag to me. Not one Im in a rush to rewatch anytime soon."
JCC001 wrote on 03.05.2024:
[5.0] "If youre gonna do a 60 minute 0-0 at least they chose two of the best ever to pull it off. Despite this its a bit of a slog to get through, only starts to pick up around half an hour in which isnt great, the ending is exciting when they actually decide to do some spots instead of just sit in rest holds and run the clock down. In my opinion it wouldve been so much better if they were trading falls and neither man was able to properly gain an advantage for long, but Im sure there was some form of politicking involved which prevented a certain someone from taking any pins"
RegularGonzalez wrote on 30.04.2024:
[6.0] "This match just goes on, and on, and on. The technical work in is done really well, but the overall story is really boring. With no falls for the entire first hour, what was the point of even making this an iron-man match? I love both Bret & Shawn, but this is a match that honestly I've only been able to watch fully through like 3 times. That being said, Shawn KILLED the timekeeper with that Superkick"