[4.0] "A disappointing 4/10 squandered opportunity that worked well enough as a storyline angle but barely qualifies as an actual WrestleMania match. Coming out in full Joker-inspired gear in front of over 72, 000 fans inside Reliant Stadium, Rey Mysterio looked poised for a spirited David vs. Goliath Intercontinental Championship clash--only for JBL to blast him with a cheap pre-bell kick, boast on the microphone, and immediately walk straight into a 619 and a springboard splash for a clean pinfall in just 21 seconds. While the crowd popped huge for Rey capturing the Intercontinental Title and JBL's post-match "I quit! " retirement tantrum gave him a memorable heel exit, the complete absence of competitive wrestling on WWE's biggest stage felt like a letdown--especially given how great their Judgment Day 2006 war had been. Better as a Raw angle than a WrestleMania bout."
[2.0] "Not much to rate but gave it 2 points as it made sense for Layfield to go out this way and it was the best way to do such a short match. I think I'd prefer this over a long match between the two of them. Not every single match has to be 10+ minutes, length does not equal a great quality match."
[0.0] "[N/R] Meh. A Squash Match For Rey mysterio Was Not Expected And JBL's Retirement...also not expected. but 21 seconds is just ass and crazy due to the fact that i wanted them to work a big/small man match."
[9.0] "Hilarious rating. Probably the funniest squash match ever. For what they attempt to accomplish, they literally could not have done it more effectively. JBL was never meant to go out like anyone else."
[7.0] "This match wasn't bad. Clearly, the Intercontinental Champion could have had a better match at WrestleMania, and it wasn't a great retirement for JBL (though arriving at WrestleMania as champion isn't a bad retirement either), but the match itself follows the parameters of professional wrestling very well: JBL as a cowardly and spiteful heel, and Rey as an incredible underdog. Would I recommend it? Yes, if you have five minutes, you can't lose much."
[8.0] "Length isn't everything, you know? This was an absolutely perfect match for what it was, and the ideal way for JBL to end his full time career. He never once in all the years of his big heel run shied away from showing ass when it mattered. He could have had a glad-handing face turn or slipped out of kayfabe for a tearful goodbye, he could have done any number of things, but he went out in the way that perfectly fit his character: a slimy, self righteous, easily embarrassed bully who just couldn't take being one upped so completely by one of his greatest rivals. This ruled for what it was and I'll always look back fondly on it. Plus, a title for Mysterio!"
[4.0] "It was very short but it had great shock value. And I loved it especially in the moment in 2009 it was a pleasant surprise to see Rey win the intercontinental Championship but it was also sad to see JBL go looking back on it"
[1.0] "A difficult one to rate the introductions were very quick so you knew this was going to be a quick match. The entrances are longer than the match."
[4.0] "It's hard to give this a real rating considering the length. Only 21 seconds, gets what needed to be done done as quick as possible. It is weird this is how JBL's career ended."
[7.0] "Just like that! What a stunner this is. Many hate on this, I actually dig this. JBL building himself up with that pre-match heat segment and attacking Rey before the bell even rings only for him to get stunned, lose the title in 21 seconds and quit, while it might be an unceremonious way to go out, makes for a memorable WrestleMania holy sh! t moment. JBL plays it off quite well. The man deserves all the credit in the world. Respect."
[7.0] "This was near perfect and If I was ever a retiring wrestler, this is how I would want to go out. Must have been such a cool moment for JBL. And the cherry on top is the way the fans reacted, which speaks loud of how good JBL was in ring and on the mic, with his characters throughout his career. And to do it at your backyard, wow. Cool moment for Rey as well, with the Joker entrance, and being back the spotlight of Mania after so long and winning the IC title for the first time."
[6.0] "A rare really, really short match that gets to be in the Matchguide and certainly not worth being rated this low just because it's short. This was an angle punctuating a title change and retirement and ultimately an effective one. Rey gets a quick flash pin on the much bigger, much cockier JBL and it just works. The actual action wasn't anything beyond what would be a nearfall or finish in a longer match, but the booking on this was solid. ***"
[2.0] "It's hard to rate a match this short too highly, but considering I've recently rewatched some of the Heel Cole matches, among others, it's kind of nice to see a "heel blowhard gets summarily embarrassed" match that doesn't go on forever and a day. JBL was a loudmouthed blowhard, Rey caught him with a snap win, and we all get to go home a little happier. It's fine."
[4.0] "While this was more of a segment than a match, in my opinion, this was a great way to end the career of JBL, as the man who was a bully his whole career, got humiliated in 21 seconds by Rey in his home state."
[3.0] "Where's JBL's limo? You think he would have a huge entrance for his retirement match at WrestleMania. Rey's Joker gear was pretty cool too. Yes, it's a championship squash but it fits the JBL character to go out this way. As a match, it's nothing at all but as a segment/moment, I felt it did it's job."
[1.0] "Perhaps JBL's back was so beat up he couldn't work a full match anymore. Well, a shocking moment, but also a terrible way for JBL to say goodbye. A massively underrated wrestler in his time"
[5.0] "I'm rating this for what it was: a quick comedy match designed to say goodbye to a hated heel character. It didn't need to be anything more. I'm not going to hate on this match because it was more of a segment than a wrestling match and it was a fine segment for what it was."
[3.0] "I do love that this "match" is the most stressful moment and crisis moment for JBL's career and then he just quits. Otherwise as its like 25 seconds nothing to really talk about"
[0.0] "0 (0.0/10) Hey, everyone at Reliant Stadium was thrilled by Rey beating J.B.L. in 21 seconds. I don't know if that's from J.B.L. hear of from how much the average fan adores Rey Mysterio. Maybe it was the former, because the cheers only grew when Bradshaw quit in front of the whole world to see. Regardless, a wasted spot on the card!"
[0.0] "Even as someone who isn't the biggest JBL fan, this was a terrible last singles match for him with it only being a 21 second squash against Mysterio over the WWE IC Title. This should've been way more for both men especially JBL."
[5.0] "I'll give this squash points for the shocking title change. It's not an amazing moment and it does feel a bit dissapointing to have such a short match, but its a memorable moment with JBL quitting after it. Also Rey's joker gear was pretty cool. I'll take this over the Main Event of this show any day"
[3.0] "This was a face beats heel in seconds match where Rey Mysterio destroys JBL, this would've been an ok match if it was on a random show and it wasn't JBL's retirement, it was a surprise I wasn't expecting though which makes it watchable. I just can't believe JBL went out this way after a career like his..."