[0.0] "When I see fans refer to Melina or any diva from this era as a trailblazer, this is what they think paved the way for current women's wrestling. It's not their fault. I'm certain they didn't ask for these matches but they were in them regardless and they all sucked."
[3.0] "This should of been a bra and panties match or a pillow fight or something. No one wanted to see Ashley have a wrestling match, it was not good at all and just awkward. The lumberjills were pointless, they didn't do anything and nor did we get any camera shots of them! The only fun part was the brawl afterwards but even then it was tame."
[4.0] "Yeah, this was not good at all. Melina's giant swing spot looked great and so did all the ladies at ringside but, that's about it. Ashley Massaro was off her game here (even more so than usual, evidenced by having a broken foot) before the match if I remember correctly, and we all knew what happened to Massaro's life years after this but, even then the match wasn't all that great. Only giving it a 4 because Melina DID mention, the match almost wasn't even on the card to begin with. And honestly? I think there's quite a few Divas matches (at least 10+) I can think that are worse than this. At least Melina's entrance was also fun to watch."
[2.0] "This wasn't awful. Ashley threw a few good forearms, and Melina doing a swing was cool. The lumberjill gimmick didn't really add anything to this though."
[1.0] "1/4* (0.5/10) Melina/Ashley could have been a straightup singles match, but I'm sure Vince convinced himself that making this a Lumberjill match was a compliment to the women's division. He thought wrong. The memory of Mania 23 would have been better off without this preceding the main-event (or, being on the show whatsoever)."
[0.0] "Terrible match between both women with really horrible in ring action and psychology, it was cut way short and the lumberjack stipulation had little to no purpose during the actual match other than a brawl between all the women around the brawling post match."
[1.0] "Gets 1 point for being short. Pretty dreadful match with the womens division in dire straits at this time with Trish and Lita gone, and Mickie James bizarrely being used as a lumberjill with Victoria. I guess Melina tried her best?"
[1.0] "Pretty much a total nothing match, which is unfortunate for a championship bout but there wasn't much here. Melina was pretty capable, Ashley was not. It felt like Trish, Lita and Mickie were doing big things to get the women's division over but it was always one step forward and five steps back during this era."
[2.0] "Even if the match + post match brawl is an absolute piss break, girls just played their roles in unbeneficial circumstances for women's wrestling. RIP Ashley."
[0.0] "A match that doesn't even feel like a full segment for a PPV. Melina was way better than this and Ashley (R.I.P) should've been given more of a chance to improve. Worst thing in the card, and its great that we're past this era of women's booking at least"