[0.0] "This is terrible for a multitude of reasons. Not one has anything to do with Butterbean's boxing career. He didn't beat untrained fights. He wasn't Kimbo Slice. He fought professional fighters. He simply wasn't fighting in the high ranks. Making fun of his appearance, (from a wrestling fan no less), doesn't bolster one's opinion. It's weak."
[0.0] "I am genuinely offended by this match. A shoot boxing match on a wrestling show with an untrained wrestler and a half slob with a clear weight advantage who has made a career out of hurting untrained idiots. I can't stress how much I hate this."
"Funny that we can leave comments here. I will just say that 2026 had a Brawl 4 All moment of it's own. Jake Hager, formerly Jack Swagger of WWE, participated in some slap fight promotion where you just get hit as hard as possible in the face. He was KOed, of course, but it completely devalues him for this pro wrestling business. Some people say Bart Gunn was never seen again..."
[0.0] "What was the point of having this here? Again with mistakes from the past, like in WrestleMania 2 where a whole boxing match takes place, and here it was more like a segment, this is wrestling, not boxing even though I also like boxing. 0/10 [DUD]"
[1.0] "The last ever of the awful Brawl for All matches. They held that whole tournament and got absolutely nothing out of it outside of injuring much of their roster."
[0.0] "A total joke. Enough has been said about what a brain fart the Brawl For All was and this was the culmination. Much speculation that Bart Gunn was being punished for daring to win the tournament."
[7.0] "Don't know much about Bart Gunn or how this impacted his career but my goodness what a knockout! Can't believe this was actually allowed to take place here."
[0.0] "Unfortunately, this killed Bart Gunn's career for a while. He actually had to go to Japan and change his name to resurrect his career. I don't think this match is in any way Bart's fault. And it is in no way a hindrance or a knock on his talent."
[6.0] "Look, maybe Bart Gunn was supposed to be a huge star and this killed it, idk anything about him. So from my standpoint this is hilarious, and about as enjoyable as a 35 second match can be."
[0.0] "[True Rating -5/10] Without a doubt the worst celebrity match ever at a WrestleMania and a completely unjustified career killing of Bart Gunn who was buried here all because he didn't let Dr. Death beat him up in a legitimate fight that should never have been booked in the first place! The Brawl 4 All concept was just an all around terrible idea where absolutely nobody who took part in it benefited."
[1.0] "This match is pure cruelty. Bart Gunn came in with momentum, looking sharp, but Butterbean ended it in less than a minute, landing a clean, brutal KO. It's shocking to watch and shows just how big the gap was between a tough guy and a real golden gloves champion. Entertaining in the "holy crap" sense, but it's impossible to enjoy knowing it was basically a career death sentence for Bart. The Brawl 4 All concept peaked here in stupidity."
[0.0] "One of the more embarrassing moments in pro wrestling history, really. This never should have happened, nothing Brawl for All should have, but this was frankly cruel and petty. Lawler-Cole is still the worst Wrestlemania match for being endless and terrible, but this was just an ugly black eye - if you'll excuse me - on the sport as a whole."
[1.0] "Culmination of the Brawl for All. Vince Russo, please go suck a dick. This was unnecessary and stupid to put Bart Gunn in the path of Butterbean to ruin his career."
[0.0] "Match exist only for burying Bart Gunn. Vince Russo should be proud of himself how he detroy carrer of may wrestlers who's involved in infaomus "Brawl for all""
[0.0] "Such an atrocious and colossal waste of time this was, it's just Butterbean knocking out Bart cold within seconds of the first round, that's literally it."
[0.0] "The conclusion to one of the worst things the WWF put on TV. They ran a shoot fight tournament and when a guy that they didn't like won it fair and square they decide to feed him to the wolves. An absolute waste of time. Poor bart"