[1.0] "Another edition of the annual Midcard Mafia battle royal. Battle Royals are usually not my favorites and this was no exception. No real story, suspense or care in the world from the crowd. At least Tazz and Cole seemed to have fun with it resulting in a point."
[4.0] "The start with Simon Dean saying his name and being kicked and eliminated was HILARIOUS. The reunion between Regal and Eugene was nice but so obvious Eugene was waiting for Snitsky to break it up, poor camera work and timing. Crowd was silent up until Viscera humped MNM. Tazz and Cole are fun on commentary, they just sound like they are friends having fun which is refreshing from the corporate advertising voice we hear now. It was an ok battle royal, on the weaker end of things though."
[2.0] "Not great at all. Michael Cole and Taz are pretty bad on commentary here, which is a great shame because I love listening to them on SmackDown. The crowd in the venue didn't care for anything other than Viscera's backshot move. The last like 5 minutes of the match were horrendously slow and boring too."
[1.0] "The WrestleMania 22 pre-show Battle Royale is one of those matches that reminds you why not every wrestler deserves a WrestleMania moment. From start to finish, this match was clunky, directionless, and entirely forgettable -- a chaotic cluster that existed more to fill time than to deliver anything remotely entertaining. You could tell from the very first bell that there was no real structure or story. It was just a random collection of lower-card wrestlers thrown together with no build-up, no stakes, and no reason for the crowd to care. The frustrating thing is that there were actually a few interesting names in the mix -- the kind of talents who could've made the match at least mildly enjoyable. But of course, in typical fashion, those guys were tossed out almost immediately. The likes of Funaki, Simon Dean, and even some mid-carders who had genuine charisma were gone before they could even get a moment to shine. Instead, we were left with the lumbering, awkward wrestlers who couldn't string together a fluid spot to save their lives. Watching them awkwardly stumble through eliminations felt like watching a bad rehearsal that somehow got televised. The pacing was a disaster. At no point did the action feel smooth or coordinated. It was just a mess of bodies bumping into each other, with camera cuts struggling to find anything worth showing. Even the commentary team sounded like they were forcing enthusiasm for something they knew didn't matter. There was no energy, no drama, no sense that anyone watching -- in the arena or at home -- should care who won. The final few minutes were especially painful. The remaining wrestlers looked exhausted, out of sync, and seemingly confused about what spots were supposed to happen next. The finish came off weak and anticlimactic, with zero reaction from the crowd -- and honestly, who could blame them? Nothing in this match earned their investment. It didn't build any future storylines, it didn't elevate anyone, and it didn't even serve as decent filler. In the end, this Battle Royale wasn't just bad -- it was meaningless. A complete waste of time that epitomized the worst kind of pre-show content: filler for filler's sake. Clunky, sloppy, and instantly forgettable, this was a match that shouldn't have made it past"
[4.0] "A nothing battle royale to get people on the card. A few spots here and there but no stakes and its not particularly fun. MNM were the mvps in my opinion, but I wish they could've gotten a tag title defense instead. A proper rematch with the Mexicools would've been way cooler"